True Refuge wrote:Debate Proxy 1 wrote:No, I haven't actually read that one. Do you have a link?
As for socialist Native Americans, it is my understanding that Marx got the basis of his ideas about it from Ancient Society, a book by an American anthropologist describing the society of the Iroquois and other tribes. They did own property in common.
It starts talking about capital relations in section 5. Sections 1-4 are a bit of historical context.
Marx also distinguished "primitive communism", a.k.a tribal mutual aid, from post-capitalist communist society. They have some limited similarities, but the way they form isn't really comparable.
Mainly because of what Marx called "the tyranny of the machine." Industries run on their own schedules, and it has to be timed perfectly to function.