Original debate: viewtopic.php?f=9&t=531499
I have adopted parts of Wallenburg's argument here in draft 2 as per Wallenburg's message below. Wallenburg is now attributed as a co-author.
Insta-repeal Draft 2
Expressing its disgust in activities cited in the target resolution, namely the distribution of "revenge pornography", "upskirting" and "downblousing";
Acknowledging the purported intent of the target resolution to "challenge" such activities;
However, dismayed that the resolution contains significant loopholes that impede implementing this resolution, and, in some cases, potentially impeding anyone seeking redress for such activities;
In particular, aghast that operating clause two's very specifically wording requiring all WA states to "to outlaw... wilful distribution of, and threats to distribute [said] recordings" and the very narrow exception "where their distribution occurs in a judicial or policing context and is necessary to help convict a person of an offence defined in this Article" means that:
- evidence drawn from such recordings cannot be used in other criminal cases (outside of those "defined in this Article"), even if the cases more serious in nature, such as, merely as examples, domestic abuse or murder;
- the aforesaid evidence also cannot be used in settings such as administrative procedures, arbitration and mediation proceedings, and also cannot be used in civil proceedings in court (such as, merely as examples, civil cases for recovering damages for emotional distress and trauma), thus defeating much the purpose of this resolution;
Looking forward to a well-written resolution to address this topic in due course;
Hereby repeals the target resolution, "Challenging Sexually Exploitative Recordings".
Co-author: Wallenburg
Draft 1
Expressing its disgust in activities cited in the target resolution, namely the distribution of "revenge pornography", "upskirting" and "downblousing";
Acknowledging the intent of the target resolution to restrict such activities;
However, dismayed that the resolution contains various loopholes that prevent the effective implementation of this resolution, and, in some cases, potentially impeding anyone seeking redress for the aforesaid activities, such as:
- Operative clause two's mandate to "outlaw the making of, wilful distribution of, and threats to distribute" creates a grey area as to whether it retroactively becomes illegal on the part of the creator to create these recordings if they were originally created with the consent of the participants but then later distributed without consent;
- Operative clause two's very specifically worded exception of "where their distribution occurs in a judicial or policing context and is necessary to help convict a person of an offence" means that evidence of sexually exploitative records cannot be used in settings such as administrative procedures, arbitration and mediation proceedings, and also cannot be used in civil proceedings in court (merely as an example, such as civil cases for recovering damages for emotional distress and trauma), thus defeating much of the purpose of this resolution;
Looking forward to an improved resolution on this topic in due course;
Hereby repeals the target resolution, "Challenging Sexually Exploitative Recordings".






