NATION

PASSWORD

[Passed] Repeal Challenging Sexually Exploit've Recordings

A record of historical World Assembly debates.
User avatar
Simone Republic
Minister
 
Posts: 2772
Founded: Jul 09, 2019
Capitalizt

[Passed] Repeal Challenging Sexually Exploit've Recordings

Postby Simone Republic » Mon Aug 28, 2023 3:01 am

Submitted.

Original debate: viewtopic.php?f=9&t=531499

I have adopted parts of Wallenburg's argument here in draft 2 as per Wallenburg's message below. Wallenburg is now attributed as a co-author.

Insta-repeal Draft 2

Expressing its disgust in activities cited in the target resolution, namely the distribution of "revenge pornography", "upskirting" and "downblousing";

Acknowledging the purported intent of the target resolution to "challenge" such activities;

However, dismayed that the resolution contains significant loopholes that impede implementing this resolution, and, in some cases, potentially impeding anyone seeking redress for such activities;

In particular, aghast that operating clause two's very specifically wording requiring all WA states to "to outlaw... wilful distribution of, and threats to distribute [said] recordings" and the very narrow exception "where their distribution occurs in a judicial or policing context and is necessary to help convict a person of an offence defined in this Article" means that:

  1. evidence drawn from such recordings cannot be used in other criminal cases (outside of those "defined in this Article"), even if the cases more serious in nature, such as, merely as examples, domestic abuse or murder;
  2. the aforesaid evidence also cannot be used in settings such as administrative procedures, arbitration and mediation proceedings, and also cannot be used in civil proceedings in court (such as, merely as examples, civil cases for recovering damages for emotional distress and trauma), thus defeating much the purpose of this resolution;

Looking forward to a well-written resolution to address this topic in due course;

Hereby repeals the target resolution, "Challenging Sexually Exploitative Recordings".

Co-author: Wallenburg




Draft 1
Expressing its disgust in activities cited in the target resolution, namely the distribution of "revenge pornography", "upskirting" and "downblousing";

Acknowledging the intent of the target resolution to restrict such activities;

However, dismayed that the resolution contains various loopholes that prevent the effective implementation of this resolution, and, in some cases, potentially impeding anyone seeking redress for the aforesaid activities, such as:

  1. Operative clause two's mandate to "outlaw the making of, wilful distribution of, and threats to distribute" creates a grey area as to whether it retroactively becomes illegal on the part of the creator to create these recordings if they were originally created with the consent of the participants but then later distributed without consent;
  2. Operative clause two's very specifically worded exception of "where their distribution occurs in a judicial or policing context and is necessary to help convict a person of an offence" means that evidence of sexually exploitative records cannot be used in settings such as administrative procedures, arbitration and mediation proceedings, and also cannot be used in civil proceedings in court (merely as an example, such as civil cases for recovering damages for emotional distress and trauma), thus defeating much of the purpose of this resolution;

Looking forward to an improved resolution on this topic in due course;

Hereby repeals the target resolution, "Challenging Sexually Exploitative Recordings".
Last edited by Goobergunchia on Mon Sep 25, 2023 9:01 am, edited 15 times in total.

User avatar
The Ice States
Senator
 
Posts: 4474
Founded: Jun 23, 2022
Ex-Nation

Postby The Ice States » Mon Aug 28, 2023 12:44 pm

"This is certainly an...interesting proposal, Ambassador. Nonetheless, this makes arguments which do not particularly persuade us to support a repeal of the target. Specifically, we strongly disagree with the first argument as written. The definition of 'sexually exploitative recordings' explicitly applies where they are 'made or otherwise distributed without that person's consent'. The use of 'or' makes it quite clear whether something indeed falls under the definition if it was distributed, but not created, without their consent. Opposed."

~Robert Desak,
World Assembly Ambassador,
The Eternal Union of Devonia and the Ice States.


Ooc: As mentioned on Discord, do you have Wallenburg's permission to copy his comments (link for posterity) near-verbatim into the draft?
Last edited by The Ice States on Mon Aug 28, 2023 12:48 pm, edited 2 times in total.
Old GA Stat Effects · Style Guide · WA Authorship

"Petty tyrant", "antithetical to a better future for the WA".

User avatar
Arawi
Secretary
 
Posts: 31
Founded: Jun 22, 2020
Ex-Nation

Postby Arawi » Mon Aug 28, 2023 12:56 pm

The Ice States wrote:"This is certainly an...interesting proposal, Ambassador. Nonetheless, this makes arguments which do not particularly persuade us to support a repeal of the target. Specifically, we strongly disagree with the first argument as written. The definition of 'sexually exploitative recordings' explicitly applies where they are 'made or otherwise distributed without that person's consent'. The use of 'or' makes it quite clear whether something indeed falls under the definition if it was distributed, but not created, without their consent. Opposed."

~Robert Desak,
World Assembly Ambassador,
The Eternal Union of Devonia and the Ice States.



I believe the author was questioning whether the creator would explicitly be at fault if the distribution was carried out without the participants’ consent. The creator is not responsible for the distribution, therefore should not be prosecuted for a distribution that does not have the consent of the participants.

Benjamin Brophy

Minister for the World Assembly
Ministry of Foreign Affairs

The Real Democratic Dictatorship of Arawi

User avatar
Wallenburg
Postmaster of the Fleet
 
Posts: 23195
Founded: Jan 30, 2015
Ex-Nation

Postby Wallenburg » Mon Aug 28, 2023 1:25 pm

I'd appreciate a co-author credit if you want to use my language. That said, I leave it to Simone to decide whether the language is close enough to my own to merit that. In my opinion, there is enough deviation not to count as plagiarism. The second argument is equally if not more strong, I think, so I am quite happy to support the repeal as written. It might benefit, though, from mentioning that these recordings cannot be used in criminal cases, either, unless the case is specifically on the charge of creating or distributing revenge porn.
Last edited by Wallenburg on Mon Aug 28, 2023 1:30 pm, edited 1 time in total.
GREX LUDENTIUM DELENDUS EST
King of Snark, Real Piece of Work, Metabolizer of Oxygen, Despotic Hegemon, Old Man from The East Pacific, by the Malevolence of Her Infinite Terribleness Catherine Gratwick the Sole and True Claimant to the Bears Armed Vacancy

User avatar
The Ice States
Senator
 
Posts: 4474
Founded: Jun 23, 2022
Ex-Nation

Postby The Ice States » Mon Aug 28, 2023 1:51 pm

Arawi wrote:I believe the author was questioning whether the creator would explicitly be at fault if the distribution was carried out without the participants’ consent. The creator is not responsible for the distribution, therefore should not be prosecuted for a distribution that does not have the consent of the participants.

Benjamin Brophy

Minister for the World Assembly
Ministry of Foreign Affairs

The Real Democratic Dictatorship of Arawi

"Then they were not 'sexually exploitative recordings' when they were made, and therefore it does not fall under 'the making of...sexually exploitative recordings'. That does not preclude it from falling under, say, 'wilful distribution of'."

~Robert Desak,
World Assembly Ambassador,
The Eternal Union of Devonia and the Ice States.
Old GA Stat Effects · Style Guide · WA Authorship

"Petty tyrant", "antithetical to a better future for the WA".

User avatar
Imperium Anglorum
Postmaster-General
 
Posts: 13180
Founded: Aug 26, 2013
Inoffensive Centrist Democracy

Postby Imperium Anglorum » Mon Aug 28, 2023 3:27 pm

Elsie Mortimer Wellesley. The argument related to evidentiary process is very strong. I would focus on it almost entirely.

Author: 1 SC and 59+ GA resolutions
Maintainer: GA Passed Resolutions
Developer: Communiqué and InfoEurope
GenSec (24 Dec 2021 – 25 May 2025); posts not official unless so indicated
Delegate for Europe
Publius Clodius Thrasea Paetus (previously)
Ideological Bulwark 285, WALL delegate
Twice-commended toxic villainous globalist kittehs

User avatar
Simone Republic
Minister
 
Posts: 2772
Founded: Jul 09, 2019
Capitalizt

Postby Simone Republic » Mon Aug 28, 2023 8:04 pm

Imperium Anglorum wrote:Elsie Mortimer Wellesley. The argument related to evidentiary process is very strong. I would focus on it almost entirely.


Wallenburg wrote:The second argument is equally if not more strong, I think, so I am quite happy to support the repeal as written. It might benefit, though, from mentioning that these recordings cannot be used in criminal cases, either, unless the case is specifically on the charge of creating or distributing revenge porn.


I have written draft 2 which uses entirely the evidentiary process argument and removing the more complex grey area argument. Actually I missed the point that because it said "offence" that other criminal cases are specifically on the charge of creating or distributing revenge porn and added emphasis.

I have credited Wallenburg as a co-author.

The Ice States wrote:
Arawi wrote:I believe the author was questioning whether the creator would explicitly be at fault if the distribution was carried out without the participants’ consent. The creator is not responsible for the distribution, therefore should not be prosecuted for a distribution that does not have the consent of the participants.

Benjamin Brophy

Minister for the World Assembly
Ministry of Foreign Affairs

The Real Democratic Dictatorship of Arawi

"Then they were not 'sexually exploitative recordings' when they were made, and therefore it does not fall under 'the making of...sexually exploitative recordings'. That does not preclude it from falling under, say, 'wilful distribution of'."

~Robert Desak,
World Assembly Ambassador,
The Eternal Union of Devonia and the Ice States.


If I use 2 as the final, it removes a more complex argument and simply relies on the fact that the resolution strips "sexually exploitative recordings" from being used in other criminal cases or in civil cases (victims suing for damage) as the ground for repeal.

To be honest, probably easier to digest for the GA as a whole. If no changes, it will be submitted as soon as the original passes.
Last edited by Simone Republic on Wed Aug 30, 2023 1:37 am, edited 6 times in total.

User avatar
Namwenia
Envoy
 
Posts: 267
Founded: Aug 08, 2022
Democratic Socialists

Postby Namwenia » Tue Aug 29, 2023 5:35 am

"If the at vote in the World Assembly passes, we are open to supporting this repeal effort.

The Ambassador wonders if it is worthwhile to include a discussion of clause (a) and statement on materials as '...made with the intention that any other person should view them for their own sexual pleasure or to humiliate that person'. Our Ambassador believes that the intent of the making of such materials is irrelevant to whether or not it should constitute as a sexually exploitative material and for that reason, this line, unfortunately, weakens the proposal at vote.

We will continue to watch as this repeal draft is prepared."
-Usagi Lenin
Chief of Staff of World Assembly Ambassador Statler Miyamoto
The United Socialist States of Namwenia
The United Socialist States of Namwenia
Retired Account, Residing in the Region of Namwenia
See Moduland for Questions

User avatar
Simone Republic
Minister
 
Posts: 2772
Founded: Jul 09, 2019
Capitalizt

Postby Simone Republic » Thu Aug 31, 2023 9:34 pm

This has been submitted now that the original resolution has passed.

User avatar
Cessarea
Minister
 
Posts: 2220
Founded: Jul 02, 2023
New York Times Democracy

Postby Cessarea » Fri Sep 01, 2023 12:14 am

Supported. I'm quite miffed at how suddenly the target resolution was submitted and approved, when there were still some ongoing debates surrounding it. I hope voter fatigue and the hesitancy of those who don't read its contents do not impede this repeal.
Last edited by Cessarea on Fri Sep 01, 2023 12:20 am, edited 2 times in total.
⠀The Ministerial Council of Cessarea⠀
Local GAer | Q&A
She/they transfem.
Ask me about non-monogamy.
A nation with a history as old as time. Or so it claims.
Home to Artificials - thin machine beings who do not yet fully understand themselves.
World Assembly Diplomats
Currently in hibernation.
Logical Stimulus wrote:Every person in Starlight is the exact same to me. I can barely tell you anyone’s name except Cessarea’s. They’re all just Cessarea.
Sedgistan wrote:You are my favourite person to interact with on the NSGP server.

User avatar
Juansonia
Minister
 
Posts: 2459
Founded: Apr 01, 2022
Scandinavian Liberal Paradise

Postby Juansonia » Tue Sep 05, 2023 12:55 pm

Support.
Hatsune Miku > Most "modern" music.
IC: MT if you ignore some stuff(mostly flavor), stats are not canon. Embassy link.
OOC: No longer active on NationStates.
> Taxation is theft. <
Sorry, I broke my signature quote spoiler.
Brits mistake Miku for their Anthem

User avatar
IstoWalker
Secretary
 
Posts: 40
Founded: Apr 05, 2023
Ex-Nation

Postby IstoWalker » Fri Sep 08, 2023 6:24 am

I am in full support of this resolution. On President Ink Forest's behalf, it is believed that this resolution would be extremely useful in creating a more ethical society.

General Winter
Head of Government
IstoWalker
Unified Nations BEST VERSION

User avatar
Imperium Anglorum
Postmaster-General
 
Posts: 13180
Founded: Aug 26, 2013
Inoffensive Centrist Democracy

Postby Imperium Anglorum » Thu Sep 21, 2023 5:51 am

Fullest support.

Author: 1 SC and 59+ GA resolutions
Maintainer: GA Passed Resolutions
Developer: Communiqué and InfoEurope
GenSec (24 Dec 2021 – 25 May 2025); posts not official unless so indicated
Delegate for Europe
Publius Clodius Thrasea Paetus (previously)
Ideological Bulwark 285, WALL delegate
Twice-commended toxic villainous globalist kittehs

User avatar
Juansonia
Minister
 
Posts: 2459
Founded: Apr 01, 2022
Scandinavian Liberal Paradise

Postby Juansonia » Thu Sep 21, 2023 10:09 am

I’m surprised that this is winning by so much, given how common it is to violate GA#122
Hatsune Miku > Most "modern" music.
IC: MT if you ignore some stuff(mostly flavor), stats are not canon. Embassy link.
OOC: No longer active on NationStates.
> Taxation is theft. <
Sorry, I broke my signature quote spoiler.
Brits mistake Miku for their Anthem

User avatar
Cessarea
Minister
 
Posts: 2220
Founded: Jul 02, 2023
New York Times Democracy

Postby Cessarea » Thu Sep 21, 2023 11:15 am

Juansonia wrote:I’m surprised that this is winning by so much, given how common it is to violate GA#122

We should repeal 122 :p
⠀The Ministerial Council of Cessarea⠀
Local GAer | Q&A
She/they transfem.
Ask me about non-monogamy.
A nation with a history as old as time. Or so it claims.
Home to Artificials - thin machine beings who do not yet fully understand themselves.
World Assembly Diplomats
Currently in hibernation.
Logical Stimulus wrote:Every person in Starlight is the exact same to me. I can barely tell you anyone’s name except Cessarea’s. They’re all just Cessarea.
Sedgistan wrote:You are my favourite person to interact with on the NSGP server.

User avatar
FDRussa
Civilian
 
Posts: 1
Founded: Sep 17, 2023
Ex-Nation

Respuesta a la resolución

Postby FDRussa » Sun Sep 24, 2023 10:44 pm

Good morning everyone, I believe and think that we must all be against sexual exploitation, all nations must come to an agreement and support each other on this issue. It may be difficult but I know that with effort we can against sexual exploitation.

User avatar
Tinhampton
Post Marshal
 
Posts: 16285
Founded: Oct 05, 2016
Civil Rights Lovefest

Postby Tinhampton » Mon Sep 25, 2023 4:46 am

Repeal "Challenging Sexually Exploitative Recordings" was passed 11,029 votes to 1,080. (91.08% support)

After the SEFI and FCR repeals, this is the most popular resolution of 2023. I, ermmmm... was not expecting this particular accolade.

(Against, of course, but no Sophia IFV: conflict of interest plus no other takers.)
Last edited by Tinhampton on Mon Sep 25, 2023 5:28 am, edited 1 time in total.
The Self-Administrative City of TINHAMPTON (pop. 329,537): Saffron Howard, Mayor (UCP); Lydia Anderson, WA Delegate-Ambassador

Authorships & co-authorships: SC#250, SC#251, Issue #1115, SC#267, LGA#484, LGA#491, LGA#533, LGA#540, LGA#549, SC#356, LGA#559, LGA#562, LGA#567, LGA#578, SC#374, LGA#582, SC#375, LGA#589, LGA#590, SC#382, SC#385, LGA#597, LGA#607, SC#415, LGA#647, LGA#656, LGA#664, LGA#671, LGA#674, LGA#675, LGA#677, LGA#680, Issue #1580, LGA#682, LGA#683, LGA#684, LGA#692, LGA#693, LGA#715, LGA#757, SC#526, LGA#763, LGA#788, LGA#791, LGA#792, LGA#798, LGA#799, LGA#800, LGA#807, LGA#814, LGA#817
The rest of my CV: Cup of Harmony 73 champions; Torchbearer of Aeternum; fourth-most-prolific WA author of all time; proclaimer of WZTC's move to Palmetto
Tinhampton the player: 51yo Tory woman w/Asperger's; Cambridge graduate; currently reading nothing (I'm too busy)


Advertisement

Remove ads

Return to WA Archives

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: No registered users

Advertisement

Remove ads