NATION

PASSWORD

[ISSUES CONTEST] Artificially Intelligent

A place to spoil daily issues for those who haven't had them yet, snigger at typos, and discuss ideas for new ones.
User avatar
Palikit
Lobbyist
 
Posts: 19
Founded: Oct 20, 2022
Ex-Nation

[ISSUES CONTEST] Artificially Intelligent

Postby Palikit » Wed Apr 26, 2023 5:22 pm

This is my first attempt at an issue, so it may be terrible. It's based on some recent real-world events.

Title: Artificially Intelligent

Validity: Invalid for nations with low scientific advancement or no public education

Description: Following record-setting scores across schools in all of @@NAME@@ throughout the last school year, teachers have discovered that an easily accessible AI known as TalkABC may be the cause. TalkABC is a new technology that can write and respond to questions, and its effect on the school systems has raised questions about government interference with AI. As you make your way to a meeting with your Minister of Education, you are bombarded with opinions on the issue.

Option 1: "AI is stopping young @@DENONYM@@s from getting a sufficient education!" declares high school teacher @@RANDOM NAME@@ as you climb the stairs to your meeting. "Children are using this TalkABC to write their papers and aren't learning the material. The stupid AI is wrong half the time anyway. Kids may seem to be getting smarter, but they're just getting dumber and lazier. We must ban TalkABC, and all AI, from schools for the good of education!"

Effect: Students are punished for owning smartwatches

Option 2: "Hey, just because some people can't keep up with the times doesn't mean they have to hold everyone back," explains TalkABC programmer @@RANDOMNAME@@, flying a drone with a megaphone to be heard above the crowd. "AI is the future. If kids aren't learning, so what? TalkABC can do more than any random kid, and they'll all just end up relying on AI anyway. You should let AI grow to its fullest potential!"

Effect: AI is terminating the competition

Option 3: "Maybe a compromise?" inquires your Minister of Education as you finally make your way into the meeting. "It does seem to be a problem that AI is doing work for students, but it does have many new and interesting ideas. Banning it completely will just cause students in secret, and they won't learn anything at all if we fully allow it. I say we provide students with TalkABC and allow it to help students spark ideas and generally chat with them. However, we can give teachers the ability to check all student assignments to see if they were done by TalkABC. That way, we still get the future through AI without having stupid children!"

Effect: Teachers spend hours checking kindergartener's drawings for the use of AI

Option 4: "Why are we allowing this godforsaken abomination into classrooms!?" cries @@RANDOMNAME@@, principal of @@CAPTAL@@'s largest religious private school, interrupting your meeting. "This obscenity as well as all of this so-called "modern technology" must be purged from @@NAME@@ before it corrupts the minds of any more impressionable young @@DEMONYM@@s!"

Effect: Talking to AI is talking to the devil

Title: Artificially Intelligent

Validity: Invalid for nations with low scientific advancement or no public education

Description: Following record-setting scores across schools in all of @@NAME@@ throughout the last school year, teachers have discovered that an easily accessible AI known as TalkABC may be the cause. TalkABC is a new technology that can write and respond to questions, and its effect on the school systems has raised questions about government interference with AI. A meeting has been called for those involved to voice their opinions.

Option 1: "AI is stopping young @@DENONYMPLURAL@@ from getting a sufficient education!" declares high school teacher @@RANDOM NAME@@. "Children are using this TalkABC to write their papers and aren't learning the material. AI may know so many things, but it doesn't have a human perception of the world. Letting AI influence our children is dangerous, as it will never be able to truly be human. We shouldn't allow our youth to become reliant on it. I propose implementing an age requirement of 18 to use AIs like TalkABC. Protect our youth!"

Effect: high schoolers are regularly arrested for talking to video game NPCs

Option 2: "Hey, just because some people can't keep up with the times doesn't mean they have to hold everyone back," explains TalkABC programmer @@RANDOMNAME@@, video calling into the meeting rather than physically coming. "AI is the future. Students are still learning, just differently than they were before. AI knows so much more about math, science, writing, and history than any dumb human, and can cater to each child's unique needs. We should do away with stupid humans educating our children and allow AI to help the world to its fullest potential."

Effect: AI is terminating teacher's jobs

Option 3: "Maybe a compromise?" inquires your Minister of Education. "It does seem to be a problem that AI is doing work for students, but it does have many new and interesting ideas. Banning it completely will just cause students in secret, and they won't learn anything at all if we fully allow it. I say we provide students with TalkABC and allow it to help students spark ideas and generally chat with them. However, we can give teachers the ability to check all student assignments to see if they were done by TalkABC. That way, we still get the future through AI without having stupid children!"

Effect: teachers spend hours checking preschooler's drawings for the use of AI

Option 4: "Why are we allowing this godforsaken abomination into classrooms!?" cries @@RANDOMNAME@@, principal of @@CAPTAL@@'s largest religious private school, barging into the meeting uninvited. "This obscenity as well as all of this so-called "modern technology" must be purged from @@NAME@@ before it corrupts the minds of any more impressionable young @@DEMONYMPLURAL@@!"

Effect: TalkABC is talking to the devil


Title: Artificially Intelligent

Validity: Invalid for nations with low scientific advancement or no public education

Description: Following record-setting scores across schools in all of @@NAME@@ throughout the last school year, teachers have discovered that an easily accessible AI known as TalkABC may be the cause. TalkABC is a new technology that can write and respond to questions, and its effect on the school systems has raised questions about government interference with AI. A meeting has been called for those involved to voice their opinions.

Option 1: "AI is stopping young @@DENONYMPLURAL@@ from getting a sufficient education!" declares high school teacher @@RANDOM NAME@@. "Children are using this TalkABC to write their papers and aren't learning the material. AI may know so many things, but it doesn't have a human perception of the world. Letting AI influence our children is dangerous, as it will never be able to truly be human. We shouldn't allow our youth to become reliant on it. I propose requiring identification to use AI chatbots like TalkABC, and not allowing those under the age of 18 or who are university students to use them. Protect our education system!"

Effect: video game sales are down as it is illegal for students to speak with NPCs

Option 2: "Hey, just because some people can't keep up with the times doesn't mean they have to hold everyone back," explains TalkABC programmer @@RANDOMNAME@@, video calling into the meeting rather than physically coming. "AI is the future. Students are still learning, just differently than they were before. AI knows so much more about math, science, writing, and history than any dumb human, and can cater to each child's unique needs. We should do away with stupid humans educating our children and allow AI to help the world to it's fullest potential."

Effect: AI is terminating teacher's jobs

Option 3: "Maybe a compromise?" inquires your Minister of Education. "It does seem to be a problem that AI is doing work for students, but it does have many new and interesting ideas. Banning it completely will just cause students in secret, and they won't learn anything at all if we fully allow it. I say we provide students with TalkABC and allow it to help students spark ideas and generally chat with them. However, we can give teachers the ability to check all student assignments to see if they were done by TalkABC. That way, we still get the future through AI without having stupid children!"

Effect: teachers spend hours checking preschooler's drawings for the use of AI

Option 4: "Why are we allowing this godforsaken abomination into classrooms!?" cries @@RANDOMNAME@@, principal of @@CAPTAL@@'s largest religious private school, barging into the meeting uninvited. "This obscenity as well as all of this so-called "modern technology" must be purged from @@NAME@@ before it corrupts the minds of any more impressionable young @@DEMONYMPLURAL@@!"

Effect: TalkABC is talking to the devil


Title: Artificially Intelligent

Validity: Invalid for nations with low scientific advancement or no public education

Description: Following record-setting scores across schools in all of @@NAME@@ throughout the last school year, teachers have discovered that an easily accessible AI known as TalkABC may be the cause. TalkABC is a new technology that can write and respond to questions, and its effect on the school systems has raised questions about the use of AI in education. A meeting has been called for those involved to voice their opinions.

Option 1: "AI is stopping young @@DENONYMPLURAL@@ from getting a sufficient education!" declares high school teacher @@RANDOM NAME@@. "Children are using this TalkABC to write their papers and aren't learning the material. AI may know so many things, but it doesn't have a human perception of the world. Letting AI influence our children is dangerous, as it will never be able to truly be human. We shouldn't allow our youth to become reliant on it. I propose requiring identification to use AI chatbots like TalkABC and not allowing those under the age of 18 to use them. Protect our education system!"

Effect: video game sales are down as it is illegal for students to speak with NPCs

Option 2: "Hey, just because some people can't keep up with the times doesn't mean they have to hold everyone back," explains TalkABC programmer @@RANDOMNAME@@, video calling into the meeting rather than physically coming. "AI is the future. Students are still learning, just differently than they were before. AI knows so much more about math, science, writing, and history than any dumb human, and can cater to each child's unique needs. We should do away with dumb humans educating our children and allow AI to help the world to it's fullest potential."

Effect: AI is terminating teacher's jobs

Option 3: "Maybe a compromise?" inquires your Minister of Education. "It does seem to be a problem that AI is doing work for students, but it does have many new and interesting ideas. If we ban it, kids can find ways to use it illegally, and they won't learn anything if we fully allow it. I say we provide students with TalkABC and allow it to help students spark ideas and generally chat with them. However, we can give teachers the ability to check all student assignments to see if they were done by TalkABC. That way, we still get the future through AI without having stupid children!"

Effect: teachers spend hours checking preschooler's drawings for the use of AI

Option 4: "Why are we allowing this godforsaken abomination into classrooms!?" cries @@RANDOMNAME@@, principal of @@CAPTAL@@'s largest religious private school, barging into the meeting uninvited. "This obscenity as well as all of this so-called "modern technology" must be purged from @@NAME@@ before it corrupts the minds of any more impressionable young @@DEMONYMPLURAL@@!"

Effect: TalkABC is talking to the devil


Title: Artificially Intelligent
Validity: Invalid for nations with low scientific advancement or no public education

Description: An easily accessible AI known as TalkABC that can write essays, answer questions, and have conversations has raised concerns among teachers about its effect on student’s writing ability.

Option 1: "Young @@DENONYMPLURAL@@ are forgetting how to write!" declares high school English teacher @@RANDOM NAME@@, waving an encyclopedia in your face. "Children are using this ‘TalkABC’ to write their papers and aren't learning the material or developing their writing skills. If we continue to allow this method of cheating in our classrooms, our youth will not be intelligent or well educated. It has become necessary to require identification to use AI chatbots like TalkABC and not allow those in the education system or who are under the age of 18 to use them,” @@HE@@ proclaims, angrily smashing your secretary’s laptop with the encyclopedia.

Effect: the government claims a recent decrease in test scores to be a sign of intelligence

Option 2: "Hey, a few old-timers don’t have to hold everyone back," robotically refutes TalkABC programmer @@RANDOMNAME@@, reading a speech likely written by TalkABC off @@HIS@@ laptop. "AI is the future. Students are still learning, just differently than they were before. Normal teachers only have so much time, and are often overworked and underpaid. They aren’t giving our children an optimal education. If AI were to teach children, it could cater to each child’s individual needs and give a personalized education with all the tools of the internet. We should do away with tired and overworked teachers inefficiently educating our children and allow AI to help @@NAME@@ to its fullest potential."

Effect: citizens wonder if @@LEADER@@ is the brains behind their speeches

Option 3: "Maybe a compromise?" inquires your Minister of Education. "It does seem to be a problem that AI is doing work for students, but it does have many new and interesting ideas. If we ban it, kids can find ways to use it illegally, and they won't learn anything if we fully allow it. I say we provide students with TalkABC and allow it to help students spark ideas and generally chat with them, allowing AI to prosper as a tool of innovation without decreasing intelligence. TalkABC even has a feature where it can be given an essay and asked ‘Did you write this?’ We can stop abuse by simply forcing teachers to ask TalkABC whether or not it did every student’s work.”

Effect: teachers spend hours checking preschooler's drawings for the use of AI

Option 4: "Why are we allowing this godforsaken abomination into classrooms!?" cries @@RANDOMNAME@@, principal of @@CAPTAL@@'s largest religious private school, barging into the meeting uninvited. "This obscenity as well as all of this so-called ‘modern technology' must be purged from @@NAME@@ before it corrupts the minds of any more impressionable young @@DEMONYMPLURAL@@!" @@HE@@ howls, hurling the mangled corpse of your secretary’s laptop out the window in anger.

Effect: chatting with chatbots is chatting with the devil

Draft #6

Title: Artificially Intelligent

Validity: Invalid for nations with low scientific advancement, no public education, and no AI personhood/planning

Description: An easily accessible chatbot known as TalkABC that can write essays and have conversations has raised concerns among teachers about its effect on student’s writing ability.

Option 1: "Young @@DENONYMPLURAL@@ are forgetting how to write!" declares high school English teacher @@RANDOM NAME@@, waving an encyclopedia in your face. "Children are using this ‘TalkABC’ to write their papers and aren't learning the material or developing their writing skills. The chatbot isn't even perfect as it often struggles with complex concepts. If we continue to allow this method of cheating in our classrooms, our youth will not be well educated. It has become necessary to require identification to use chatbots like TalkABC and not allow those in the education system or who are under the age of 18 to use them,” @@HE@@ proclaims, angrily smashing your secretary’s laptop with the encyclopedia.

Effect: the government claims a recent decrease in test scores to be a sign of a good education system

Option 2: "Hey, a few old-timers don’t have to hold everyone back," robotically refutes TalkABC programmer @@RANDOMNAME@@, reading a speech likely written by TalkABC off @@HIS@@ laptop. "AI is the future. Students are still learning, just differently than they were before. Normal teachers are often overworked and underpaid. They aren’t giving our children an optimal education. If you throw some more funding our way, TalkABC can advance beyond simply being a chatbot and become a person capable of teaching. If AI were to teach children, it could cater to each child’s individual needs and give a personalized education with all the tools of the internet. We should do away with overworked teachers inefficiently educating our children and allow AI to help @@NAME@@ to its fullest potential."

Effect: citizens wonder if @@LEADER@@ is the brains behind their speeches

Option 3: "Maybe a compromise?" inquires your Minister of Education. "It does seem to be a problem that a chatbot is doing work for students, but it does have many new and interesting ideas. Fully banning it won’t allow us to access all the interesting ideas it has, and students won't learn anything if we fully allow it. I say we provide students with TalkABC and allow it to help students spark ideas and generally chat with them, allowing chatbots and AI to prosper as tools of innovation without ruining our education system. TalkABC even has a feature where it can be given an essay and asked ‘Did you write this?’ We can stop abuse by simply forcing teachers to ask TalkABC whether or not it did every student’s work.”

Effect: teachers spend hours checking preschooler's drawings for the use of AI

Option 4: "Why are we allowing this godforsaken abomination into classrooms!?" cries @@RANDOMNAME@@, principal of @@CAPTAL@@'s largest religious private school, barging into the meeting uninvited. "This obscenity as well as all of this so-called ‘modern technology' must be purged from @@NAME@@ before it corrupts the minds of any more impressionable young @@DEMONYMPLURAL@@!" @@HE@@ howls, hurling the mangled corpse of your secretary’s laptop out the window in anger.

Effect: chatting with chatbots is chatting with the devil

Any thoughts?
Last edited by Palikit on Mon Jun 26, 2023 10:24 am, edited 11 times in total.

User avatar
Australian rePublic
Post Czar
 
Posts: 32236
Founded: Mar 18, 2013
Inoffensive Centrist Democracy

Postby Australian rePublic » Thu Apr 27, 2023 7:05 am

Option 1- How?
NationStates' resident cockroach. I've been around forever, I'm a pest. I'm everywhere and you can't get rid of me
All in-character posts are fictional and have no actual connection to any real governments
Greek Australian----Orthodox Christian
Issues and WA Proposals Written By Me |Issue Ideas You Can Steal
My countryball, courtesy of Recaxa https://i.imgur.com/SPUTpra.png

User avatar
Trotterdam
Postmaster-General
 
Posts: 11324
Founded: Jan 12, 2012
Left-Leaning College State

Postby Trotterdam » Thu Apr 27, 2023 12:32 pm

Palikit wrote:"Children are using this TalkABC to write their papers and aren't learning the material. The stupid AI is wrong half the time anyway."
If the AI is wrong half the time, then why is it such a problem?

Teachers should fail kids who give wrong answers on half of their exam questions anyway, regardless of whether they wrote those wrong answers themselves or not.

User avatar
Socio Polor
Ambassador
 
Posts: 1240
Founded: Nov 28, 2015
Ex-Nation

Postby Socio Polor » Thu Apr 27, 2023 2:10 pm

Hey there, welcome to GI! As someone with an interest in the area of AI, I love the concept! Let's see how I can help:

Title: Artificially Intelligent

First off, try to see if you can come up with a catchier or eye-catching title. I wasn't the best at titles myself, so completely understand if you might struggle here :p

"AI is stopping young @@DENONYM@@s from getting a sufficient education!"

Consider using the @@DEMONYMPLURAL@@ macro here

"Hey, just because some people can't keep up with the times doesn't mean they have to hold everyone back," explains TalkABC programmer @@RANDOMNAME@@, flying a drone with a megaphone to be heard above the crowd. "AI is the future. If kids aren't learning, so what? TalkABC can do more than any random kid, and they'll all just end up relying on AI anyway. You should let AI grow to its fullest potential!"

I don't know, I feel like this option is missing more. They say to let AI grow to its full potential, but in what way? Shall they replace all teachers with AI chatbots? Do away with school altogether and have kids learn from the AI completely? A number of possibilities to add to this

inquires your Minister of Education as you finally make your way into the meeting.

Question, how exactly did @@leader@@ hear the first two options if they're not even in the room? I was under the assumption they were already there. Just a small detail you may want to consider addressing. Honestly, it might not even matter, though worth considering, nonetheless :p

Lastly, same as the title, try and see if you can come up with slightly better effect lines, maybe a comedic punchline or shot of irony or two in some of them. Also, effect lines shouldn't be capitalized

Overall, not a bad first attempt imo. I like the ChatGPT-inspired theme here! Good Luck!
Last edited by Socio Polor on Thu Apr 27, 2023 2:12 pm, edited 1 time in total.

User avatar
Palikit
Lobbyist
 
Posts: 19
Founded: Oct 20, 2022
Ex-Nation

Postby Palikit » Thu Apr 27, 2023 7:26 pm

Thanks for the feedback! I corrected some errors and followed many of the suggestions for the second draft. I fixed the problem with the first option saying that AI doesn't work and gave the first option more of a solution. I also reworked the second option into leaning towards AI teachers and being more extreme about the possibilities of AI. I fixed up the story of how everyone gets their opinions to leader, and I tried to improve the effect lines. For the title, I'm still not entirely sure what to do. Would "Artificial Intelligence Making Students Less Intelligent" work better? Titles do seem to be hard for me. Again, I appreciate the suggestions and hope for more.

User avatar
Australian rePublic
Post Czar
 
Posts: 32236
Founded: Mar 18, 2013
Inoffensive Centrist Democracy

Postby Australian rePublic » Fri Apr 28, 2023 2:55 am

How do you plan to stop kids from using AI? I mean, if kids are going to use it to cheat, I don't think they're gonna take heed to any laws. Also, what about university students, who could be as old as in their 80s?
NationStates' resident cockroach. I've been around forever, I'm a pest. I'm everywhere and you can't get rid of me
All in-character posts are fictional and have no actual connection to any real governments
Greek Australian----Orthodox Christian
Issues and WA Proposals Written By Me |Issue Ideas You Can Steal
My countryball, courtesy of Recaxa https://i.imgur.com/SPUTpra.png

User avatar
Palikit
Lobbyist
 
Posts: 19
Founded: Oct 20, 2022
Ex-Nation

Postby Palikit » Fri Apr 28, 2023 3:08 pm

Australian rePublic wrote:How do you plan to stop kids from using AI? I mean, if kids are going to use it to cheat, I don't think they're gonna take heed to any laws. Also, what about university students, who could be as old as in their 80s?


I tried to remedy this by requiring registration to use the AI. That way, students won't be able to easily avoid the law, and university students also won't be able to use the AI. Thanks for the help!

User avatar
Australian rePublic
Post Czar
 
Posts: 32236
Founded: Mar 18, 2013
Inoffensive Centrist Democracy

Postby Australian rePublic » Fri Apr 28, 2023 5:55 pm

Palikit wrote:
Australian rePublic wrote:How do you plan to stop kids from using AI? I mean, if kids are going to use it to cheat, I don't think they're gonna take heed to any laws. Also, what about university students, who could be as old as in their 80s?


I tried to remedy this by requiring registration to use the AI. That way, students won't be able to easily avoid the law, and university students also won't be able to use the AI. Thanks for the help!

Wait? What? What if uni students want to use for reasons unrelated to their studies? And how do you prove that you're not a uni student when registering? And what if you register and become one later? It's one thing to prevent children from using AI and an other thing entirely to prevent certain groups of adults
NationStates' resident cockroach. I've been around forever, I'm a pest. I'm everywhere and you can't get rid of me
All in-character posts are fictional and have no actual connection to any real governments
Greek Australian----Orthodox Christian
Issues and WA Proposals Written By Me |Issue Ideas You Can Steal
My countryball, courtesy of Recaxa https://i.imgur.com/SPUTpra.png

User avatar
Palikit
Lobbyist
 
Posts: 19
Founded: Oct 20, 2022
Ex-Nation

Postby Palikit » Sat Apr 29, 2023 5:43 am

Australian rePublic wrote:Wait? What? What if uni students want to use for reasons unrelated to their studies? And how do you prove that you're not a uni student when registering? And what if you register and become one later? It's one thing to prevent children from using AI and an other thing entirely to prevent certain groups of adults


Ok, I certainly messed up that option a few times. I think the best route is to only ban it for those under 18 and allow university students access, especially because the rest of the issue is focused on AI's effect on children. University students will be expected to use AI responsibly as adults. I think this option finally kind of works, let me know if there are still problems. Again, thanks for the feedback.

User avatar
Soldierlandia
Attaché
 
Posts: 71
Founded: Apr 28, 2023
Ex-Nation

Postby Soldierlandia » Mon May 01, 2023 9:54 am

This is cool I like it
Hi, I’m Soldierlandia, I made my home in Hellhole. I’m a simple joke nation, but I’m most active here, on the forums! It became one of my main accounts at my school.

Name of Nation: Soldierlandia
Tier: 9
Type: 9
Class: 0.77777777777

User avatar
Palikit
Lobbyist
 
Posts: 19
Founded: Oct 20, 2022
Ex-Nation

Postby Palikit » Tue May 02, 2023 3:38 pm

I've made a few general improvements, and I hope that this is getting better. I was wondering if I should change the title, as it was pointed out above that my title isn't very strong. Does anyone think "Artificial Intelligence Making Students Less Intelligent?" works better? I appreciate all feedback!
Last edited by Palikit on Tue May 02, 2023 3:38 pm, edited 1 time in total.

User avatar
Australian rePublic
Post Czar
 
Posts: 32236
Founded: Mar 18, 2013
Inoffensive Centrist Democracy

Postby Australian rePublic » Wed May 03, 2023 3:36 am

Palikit wrote:
Australian rePublic wrote:Wait? What? What if uni students want to use for reasons unrelated to their studies? And how do you prove that you're not a uni student when registering? And what if you register and become one later? It's one thing to prevent children from using AI and an other thing entirely to prevent certain groups of adults


Ok, I certainly messed up that option a few times. I think the best route is to only ban it for those under 18 and allow university students access, especially because the rest of the issue is focused on AI's effect on children. University students will be expected to use AI responsibly as adults. I think this option finally kind of works, let me know if there are still problems. Again, thanks for the feedback.

I suppose it does, I guess
NationStates' resident cockroach. I've been around forever, I'm a pest. I'm everywhere and you can't get rid of me
All in-character posts are fictional and have no actual connection to any real governments
Greek Australian----Orthodox Christian
Issues and WA Proposals Written By Me |Issue Ideas You Can Steal
My countryball, courtesy of Recaxa https://i.imgur.com/SPUTpra.png

User avatar
Palikit
Lobbyist
 
Posts: 19
Founded: Oct 20, 2022
Ex-Nation

Postby Palikit » Mon May 08, 2023 4:55 am

I'm hoping for some more feedback on this. I feel like I've improved it, but it still needs a lot more before I can submit it. Any thoughts on what I can improve?

User avatar
Palikit
Lobbyist
 
Posts: 19
Founded: Oct 20, 2022
Ex-Nation

Postby Palikit » Fri May 19, 2023 1:44 pm

I'm bumping this for some more feedback.

User avatar
Palikit
Lobbyist
 
Posts: 19
Founded: Oct 20, 2022
Ex-Nation

Postby Palikit » Fri Jun 02, 2023 12:54 pm

I might try to use this for the issues contest, but I'd like to improve it a bit first. Does anyone have any thoughts/criticisms about it currently?
I haven't done anything important enough to put here.

User avatar
Newer Zealand
Lobbyist
 
Posts: 15
Founded: Oct 22, 2022
Scandinavian Liberal Paradise

Postby Newer Zealand » Sat Jun 03, 2023 8:49 am

Palikit wrote:I might try to use this for the issues contest, but I'd like to improve it a bit first. Does anyone have any thoughts/criticisms about it currently?

looks good. i would submit, but i'm not good at writing issues. still submit it.
Socialism :3 The Leftist Assembly FOREVER RAAAAAAAAAAH
LGBTQQIA+ RIGHTS!!!

User avatar
Electrum
Issues Editor
 
Posts: 4670
Founded: Jan 20, 2013
Left-Leaning College State

Postby Electrum » Sun Jun 04, 2023 1:39 am

I think this is a strong start for an issue. I think however that it can definitely be written better. There's a lot of lines that are not doing much like 'A meeting has been called for those involved to voice their opinions', 'Protect our education system!' and 'AI is stopping young @@DENONYMPLURAL@@ from getting a sufficient education'.

For example you can rewrite the description to something like:

Teachers are concerned that an easily accessible AI known as TalkABC, which can write essays and respond to questions, are affecting student's writing ability.

For option 1 - 'AI may know so many things, but it doesn't have a human perception of the world' is not really the strongest argument. It seems like the teacher is complaining more that children are being reliant on an AI that doesn't understand what it's like to be a human instead of the fact that students are cheating / not learning the proper way to write / etc. Also what about university students?

Option 2 - An AI developer would not say these things. They wouldn't say 'AI knows so much more about math, science, writing, and history than any dumb human' because TalkABC (or ChatGPT) is a language model. It doesn't know anything. It only predicts what comes next given a prompt. Replacing teachers with AI is definitely an intriguing concept though. A more convincing argument is that an AI would be better able to give personalised feedback to students and cater lessons to each student whereas a teacher has only so much time to teach a class.

Option 3 - I don't think it's possible (right now) to 'check student assignments' for AI but definitely the core of the option that helping students spark ideas is a great concept and should be expanded.

In general the options don't have much characterisation. And the characters all sound the same with 'dumb human' and 'stupid children'. You might want to read the most recently submitted issues to see what that's like. Also probably all but the third effect lines need some work. Interested to see what you come up with next.
Last edited by Electrum on Sun Jun 04, 2023 1:40 am, edited 1 time in total.

User avatar
Palikit
Lobbyist
 
Posts: 19
Founded: Oct 20, 2022
Ex-Nation

Postby Palikit » Mon Jun 05, 2023 4:27 pm

Electrum wrote:I think this is a strong start for an issue. I think however that it can definitely be written better. There's a lot of lines that are not doing much like 'A meeting has been called for those involved to voice their opinions', 'Protect our education system!' and 'AI is stopping young @@DENONYMPLURAL@@ from getting a sufficient education'.

For example you can rewrite the description to something like:

Teachers are concerned that an easily accessible AI known as TalkABC, which can write essays and respond to questions, are affecting student's writing ability.

For option 1 - 'AI may know so many things, but it doesn't have a human perception of the world' is not really the strongest argument. It seems like the teacher is complaining more that children are being reliant on an AI that doesn't understand what it's like to be a human instead of the fact that students are cheating / not learning the proper way to write / etc. Also what about university students?

Option 2 - An AI developer would not say these things. They wouldn't say 'AI knows so much more about math, science, writing, and history than any dumb human' because TalkABC (or ChatGPT) is a language model. It doesn't know anything. It only predicts what comes next given a prompt. Replacing teachers with AI is definitely an intriguing concept though. A more convincing argument is that an AI would be better able to give personalised feedback to students and cater lessons to each student whereas a teacher has only so much time to teach a class.

Option 3 - I don't think it's possible (right now) to 'check student assignments' for AI but definitely the core of the option that helping students spark ideas is a great concept and should be expanded.

In general the options don't have much characterisation. And the characters all sound the same with 'dumb human' and 'stupid children'. You might want to read the most recently submitted issues to see what that's like. Also probably all but the third effect lines need some work. Interested to see what you come up with next.


Thanks a lot for the feedback! I think I've addressed everything. I shortened the description and generally tried to remove fluff from the issue.
For option 1, I changed the argument to focus more on the fact that the students won't learn/get a proper education if AI is just doing all their work for them.
Similarly, I edited the argument in option 2 to focus more on the potential AI has to improve the education system through personal feedback.
For option 3, I believe it is currently possible to put text into ChatGPT/TalkABC and ask "Did you write this?" The option will require teachers to do that for every single assignment. I did elaborate on how exactly this works.
Finally, I tried to add characterization and improve the effect lines. I added some actions by the characters and tried to give their speech a bit more personality, and I changed the effect lines for options 1, 2, and 4.
Thanks!
I haven't done anything important enough to put here.

User avatar
South West Rhodesia
Secretary
 
Posts: 33
Founded: Jun 01, 2023
Ex-Nation

Postby South West Rhodesia » Mon Jun 05, 2023 8:29 pm

In SWR, we like to pride ourselves as being the 'problem paradigm' in absolutely everything imaginable...
so...
AI options
AI is considered by thems as know these things as only 'a possible possibility sometime in the future'. You are referring to algorithm based machine intelligence as AI- but AI ain't a thing yet. Given the false narrative of brain/machine linguistic/poetic metaphors, and the moronic assumptions of Kurzweil's 'Singularity' innate to the "more algorithms = AI" method; it probably never will be. Scamming for dodgy investment hype however is very real, and has been for millenia. Hence an alternative response option:

"Treat this media narrative about AI, and the spivs selling it with the contempt they deserve, just as one would do with any similar politician's disengenous pronouncements, policies or other prattle". Well- jazz it up a bit for the site!

Or change the question to 'Oligarchs planning to go to Mars?', and use exactly the same response!

User avatar
Verdant Haven
Senator
 
Posts: 3613
Founded: Feb 26, 2013
Left-wing Utopia

Postby Verdant Haven » Tue Jun 06, 2023 8:26 am

- One of the tricks with the current surge of ChatGPT-inspired issues is that ChatGPT is not an actual AI (nor anything even close to it), it's merely a predictive text engine. It's very hard to talk about the non-existence of actual AI though, because in NationStates there is actual AI! Some nations have AI sufficiently advanced that it has citizenship, can replace humans in extremely complex knowledge-based positions, and has the same full range of rights and troubles as any biological human. As such, we would basically need to have issues based on real-world "AI" assigned only to nations that don't have NationStates AI, as the entire dilemma wouldn't make sense if actual Ais are a thing. Blarg.

- The above being said... I think one of the stronger arguments the teacher in option 1 could use is the fact that predictive text engines like ChatGPT (TalkABC) frequently write like crap, and are terrible at checking their sources. It's not just that students aren't learning to write, but they also aren't learning anything at all, as the chatbot is giving them pure dross as an output.

- Also in light of the first point, speaker 2 might be a place where somebody asks for funding to develop the actual Ais that are possible in NS, or to pitch the idea that their AI is *not* just a chatbot, but is in fact a living person deserving of citizenship, which brings in different questions about plagiarism, civil rights, whether the AI wants to be spending its time writing essays for cheating children, etc.

- In options 1 and 3, careful about conflating intelligence and education. Lack of education doesn't mean somebody is unintelligent, but it definitely can contribute to ignorance.

User avatar
Trotterdam
Postmaster-General
 
Posts: 11324
Founded: Jan 12, 2012
Left-Leaning College State

Postby Trotterdam » Tue Jun 06, 2023 8:45 am

Verdant Haven wrote:As such, we would basically need to have issues based on real-world "AI" assigned only to nations that don't have NationStates AI, as the entire dilemma wouldn't make sense if actual Ais are a thing.
Problem is, NationStates AIs still exist even in nations without AI citizenship, since the technology is still there. Some nations might ban AI technology, but even then there might be criminally-made examples. Other nations would have enslaved AIs.

Or since we're talking about online chatbots, someone could easily access one being hosted in a different nation.

Verdant Haven wrote:- The above being said... I think one of the stronger arguments the teacher in option 1 could use is the fact that predictive text engines like ChatGPT (TalkABC) frequently write like crap, and are terrible at checking their sources. It's not just that students aren't learning to write, but they also aren't learning anything at all, as the chatbot is giving them pure dross as an output.
An earlier version of the draft did mention that, but it ran afoul of my comment here:
Trotterdam wrote:If the AI is wrong half the time, then why is it such a problem?

Teachers should fail kids who give wrong answers on half of their exam questions anyway, regardless of whether they wrote those wrong answers themselves or not.
And the author decided it was easier to sweep it under the carpet than properly address it.

User avatar
Palikit
Lobbyist
 
Posts: 19
Founded: Oct 20, 2022
Ex-Nation

Postby Palikit » Sat Jun 17, 2023 7:22 pm

Ok, I've been really busy irl and I've only recently found the time to work on this. A few things I changed:

I changed the validity to add that nations that already have AI planning/personhood won't receive the issue as they obviously already have full AI.

I mostly changed the term "AI" to "chatbot" to better represent what ChatGPT/TalkABC actually is. I tried to more accurately represent it as being a tool that predicts words rather than a functioning AI. I still left it as AI for parts of the second option, as that option is focusing on the eventual possibilities of chatbots/AIs.

I added a request for more funding in option 2 to support the AI teachers. ChatGPT/TalkABC would definitely need more work before it can act as a teacher, and the option is trying to introduce this more advanced AI already found in NS.

For Option 1, I added that the current chatbot is not perfect, and that it struggles with complex problems. I understand that ChatGPT currently has issues with writing total crap, but Google's chatbot, Bard, has access to the internet and seems to be able to fact-check itself and not be simply wrong about things. Chatbots exist that doesn't really have the issues with writing complete crap and. While it still struggles with understanding complex topics, this chatbot is assumed to have a decent amount of intelligence.

Finally, I changed the statements about the intelligence of the nation to instead focus on its education level.

Thanks a lot to everyone who has given feedback, I hope this has gotten better.
Last edited by Palikit on Mon Jun 26, 2023 10:23 am, edited 1 time in total.
I haven't done anything important enough to put here.

User avatar
Palikit
Lobbyist
 
Posts: 19
Founded: Oct 20, 2022
Ex-Nation

Postby Palikit » Mon Jun 26, 2023 10:27 am

The issues contest ends soon, and I would like to submit this for the contest if I can. I'm honestly not sure if this is any good or not, so I would appreciate any feedback.
I haven't done anything important enough to put here.


Advertisement

Remove ads

Return to Got Issues?

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: Corridors Under Mandate, Lupinern

Advertisement

Remove ads