Draft #6
Title: Artificially Intelligent
Validity: Invalid for nations with low scientific advancement, no public education, and no AI personhood/planning
Description: An easily accessible chatbot known as TalkABC that can write essays and have conversations has raised concerns among teachers about its effect on student’s writing ability.
Option 1: "Young @@DENONYMPLURAL@@ are forgetting how to write!" declares high school English teacher @@RANDOM NAME@@, waving an encyclopedia in your face. "Children are using this ‘TalkABC’ to write their papers and aren't learning the material or developing their writing skills. The chatbot isn't even perfect as it often struggles with complex concepts. If we continue to allow this method of cheating in our classrooms, our youth will not be well educated. It has become necessary to require identification to use chatbots like TalkABC and not allow those in the education system or who are under the age of 18 to use them,” @@HE@@ proclaims, angrily smashing your secretary’s laptop with the encyclopedia.
Effect: the government claims a recent decrease in test scores to be a sign of a good education system
Option 2: "Hey, a few old-timers don’t have to hold everyone back," robotically refutes TalkABC programmer @@RANDOMNAME@@, reading a speech likely written by TalkABC off @@HIS@@ laptop. "AI is the future. Students are still learning, just differently than they were before. Normal teachers are often overworked and underpaid. They aren’t giving our children an optimal education. If you throw some more funding our way, TalkABC can advance beyond simply being a chatbot and become a person capable of teaching. If AI were to teach children, it could cater to each child’s individual needs and give a personalized education with all the tools of the internet. We should do away with overworked teachers inefficiently educating our children and allow AI to help @@NAME@@ to its fullest potential."
Effect: citizens wonder if @@LEADER@@ is the brains behind their speeches
Option 3: "Maybe a compromise?" inquires your Minister of Education. "It does seem to be a problem that a chatbot is doing work for students, but it does have many new and interesting ideas. Fully banning it won’t allow us to access all the interesting ideas it has, and students won't learn anything if we fully allow it. I say we provide students with TalkABC and allow it to help students spark ideas and generally chat with them, allowing chatbots and AI to prosper as tools of innovation without ruining our education system. TalkABC even has a feature where it can be given an essay and asked ‘Did you write this?’ We can stop abuse by simply forcing teachers to ask TalkABC whether or not it did every student’s work.”
Effect: teachers spend hours checking preschooler's drawings for the use of AI
Option 4: "Why are we allowing this godforsaken abomination into classrooms!?" cries @@RANDOMNAME@@, principal of @@CAPTAL@@'s largest religious private school, barging into the meeting uninvited. "This obscenity as well as all of this so-called ‘modern technology' must be purged from @@NAME@@ before it corrupts the minds of any more impressionable young @@DEMONYMPLURAL@@!" @@HE@@ howls, hurling the mangled corpse of your secretary’s laptop out the window in anger.
Effect: chatting with chatbots is chatting with the devil
Any thoughts?






