Illegal GA Proposals 2nd edition

[Juansonia]

General Assembly Resolution #611 “End Collective Punishment” (Category: Civil Rights; Strength: Significant) shall be struck out and rendered null and void.

Believing that collective punishment is grossly unfair, as it purposefully targets the innocent, and therefore a serious violation of sapient rights; and

Observing that collective punishment is a favoured tool of authoritarian regimes to suppress opposition;

Hereby, within the confines of past, standing World Assembly law:

Bans member states from purposefully punishing, convicting, or otherwise targetting for punishment, any individual for:

Any act they did not personally commit or knowingly conspire, suppress evidence of, encourage, or facilitate; or

Connection or relationship to an individual, on the basis that that individual has committed a punishable or unlawful act;

Demands that all past convictions contravening this resolution by member states be fully rescinded; and

Clarifies that this resolution does not ban member states from purposefully punishing, convicting, or otherwise retaliating against persons for:

Membership in a proscribed organisation; or

A punishable act unambiguously committed under their authority

tries to legislate in a repeal

[Umbratellus]

https://www.nationstates.net/page=UN_view_proposal/id=mixtikal_1653366031
Category: Civil Rights

Strength: Significant

Proposed by: MIXTIKAL

Believing that collective punishment is grossly unfair, as it purposefully targets the innocent, and therefore a serious violation of sapient rights; and

Observing that collective punishment is a favoured tool of authoritarian regimes to suppress opposition;

Hereby, within the confines of past, standing World Assembly law:

Bans member states from purposefully punishing, convicting, or otherwise targetting for punishment, any individual for:

Any act they did not personally commit or knowingly conspire, suppress evidence of, encourage, or facilitate; or

Connection or relationship to an individual, on the basis that that individual has committed a punishable or unlawful act;

Demands that all past convictions contravening this resolution by member states be fully rescinded; and

Clarifies that this resolution does not ban member states from purposefully punishing, convicting, or otherwise retaliating against persons for:

Membership in a proscribed organisation; or

A punishable act unambiguously committed under their authority

Pretty sure this is just a copy-paste of end collective punishment.

[Bears Armed]

It is, and it's accordingly been marked as illegal.

[Dexterra]

Basics.

https://www.nationstates.net/page=UN_view_proposal/id=krisward_1653392200
ID: krisward_1653392200
Title: Repeal: “End Collective Punishment”
Category: Repeal
Target: GA#611
Proposed by: KrisWard

General Assembly Resolution #611 “End Collective Punishment” (Category: Civil Rights; Strength: Significant) shall be struck out and rendered null and void.

It makes No sense prisoners should be repealed as Collective Punishment is an effective way to govern.

https://www.nationstates.net/page=UN_view_proposal/id=meerduan_1653405028
ID: meerduan_1653405028
Title: Repeal: “End Collective Punishment”
Category: Repeal
Target: GA#611
Proposed by: Meerduan

General Assembly Resolution #611 “End Collective Punishment” (Category: Civil Rights; Strength: Significant) shall be struck out and rendered null and void.

This is one of, if not the biggest known deterrents. We need this to hold back unruly citizens with social and personal punishments.

[Fachumonn]

Also, those both don't address the contents of what it's repealing.

[Bears Armed]

Also, those both don't address the contents of what it's repealing.

One of my colleagues got both of them.

[Juansonia]

General Assembly Proposal
ID: lemona_1653566658

Repeal: “Limiting Animal Pathogens”
A resolution to repeal previously passed legislation.

Category: Repeal

Resolution: GA#609

Proposed by: Lemona

General Assembly Resolution #609 “Limiting Animal Pathogens” (Category: Environmental; Industry Affected: Agriculture) shall be struck out and rendered null and void.

The World Assembly,

The damage done by limiting animal pathogens was large, leaving many nations with a agriculture in the top 5% that are in the WA no crops. In hundreds of states this further caused unemployment issues.

I would wish to repeal this and heal the damage done, and also recognize that zoonotic diseases are of no harm to the agriculture sector.

1. Definitions
In this resolution:
1. the "WHA" is the World Health Authority;
3. a "zoonotic disease" is any disease which:
a. is caused by a pathogen; and
b. is capable of being transmitted from a nonsapient being to a sapient being.
2. Recognize

Zoonotic diseases are old problems:
1. Zoonotic diseases no longer are a problem to the international community and means nothing is needed to stop it.
3. Import and export.

Each member nation shall stop:

1. testing every animal intended for import to or export from such nation for any zoonotic disease which:
2. has been determined by the WHA or local health authorities to pose a substantial danger to sapient wellbeing; and
3. denying entry or exit to, treat, euthanize, or isolate, any animal which tests positive for any such disease until such animal tests negative for the same zoonotic disease.

tries to legislate in a repeal, metagaming

[Juansonia]

General Assembly Proposal
ID: alphawolf32_1653693660

Green Energy Initiative
A resolution to increase the quality of the world's environment, at the expense of industry.

Category: Environmental

Industry Affected: Mining

Proposed by: Alphawolf32

limit the amount of green house gasses in the enviorment .
limit mining producrion.
increase use of green energies

Proposal basics: no active clause, not from WA perspective

[Bears Armed]

Adopt Rick Roll As World National Anthem
A resolution to enact uniform standards that protect workers, consumers, and the general public.

Category: Regulation
Area of Effect: Consumer Protection
Proposed by: Lashyr

Honestly guys, have you felt that anthems are boring? We can spend hours and hours listening to other countries anthems, but our heads will be in our hands and we'll be groaning because all we hear are trumpets. Sure, some can sound good, but wouldn't it be better if we all could have some more fun with anthems. What better than the Rick Roll?

1. Rick Roll anthems are a great way to unify the world. Having the same anthem will eliminate all the moaning and groaning people feel when the listen to anthems. And guess what? No one will have to hate on any nations anthems because they're all the same!

2. Anyone else hate trumpets? Yeah...BRING IN THE DRUMS Y'ALL! A nice guitar is a good way to bring the world together. It's just what we need.

3. I know all nations are different, but adopting the Rick Roll as the world's national anthem brings us all together. It's something we can all enjoy together instead of being sour toward each other.

Nations of the world, I'm calling on you to adopt the Rick Roll as the national anthem of the world. It would be my great honor to present this proposition so we can perhaps be one step closer to world peace.

- Stay Safe out there. It's a big world. With love, Lashyr

Approvals: 1 (Nordfert)

GenSec Status: ILLEGAL — HELD
Illegal (1): Bears Armed
Seconds ago: Bears Armed: Illegal — JOKE PROPOSAL. Also: Category Incorrect (There is NO correct Category for this...); Proposal Basics (Not written as a law; Not written from the perspective of the W.A. as a whole); Branding (in this case, both use of first person singular "I" and inclusion of a nation's name in the text); RL Reference.

Status: Lacking Support (requires 63 more approvals)
Voting Ends: in 3 days 1 hour

[Juansonia]

General Assembly Proposal
ID: lemona_1653963734

Access To Better Education
A resolution to promote funding and the development of education and the arts.

Category: Education and Creativity

Area of Effect: Educational

Proposed by: Lemona

The General Assembly,

In these days of age, many people, despite having access to the internet, are becoming dumber. This is a resolution to increasing funding in education and to educate society.

1. Welfare and funding for schools worldwide to be increased, along with your more jobs for teachers
2. Make sure all students are up to the standard

A. Any student that is below standard, make sure they get the proper education and even tutors to push them up
3. Abolish Homework as a regular assignment. Homework increases stress in students making it harder for them to learn and for them to have emotional issues. This would make all homework a punishment instead or something for the student to choose if they want to do.
4. Give students the right to choose their schedule.

A. This will be regulated as students can not just not do any subjects, but this should make them feel more comfortable with what they are doing.
5. Increase inclusiveness in schools and promote anti bullying. This will be increased by helping a student who is having trouble with a school-welfare program. LGBT students and students in a minority shall not be hurt or discriminated against. This goes for any minority in any Nation.

By this the education system across the world shall become greater and make students more comfortable.

Not written from WA perspective, duplicates 603, probably contradicts something else, no active clause

[Juansonia]

General Assembly Proposal
ID: meowstona_1654068122

The Black Cats Protection Law
A resolution to improve worldwide human and civil rights.

Category: Civil Rights

Strength: Strong

Proposed by: Meowstona

General Assembly,
As you know cats are greatly appreciated. However, not all cats are treated the same. Some cats may be neglected or overlooked.

To prevent this from happening we should,

1. Provide educational resources to ‘clear the air’ around the black cat myth

2. Create black cat only shelters to promote the adoption of these loving felines.

3. Make ‘black cat murders’ a crime no matter the motive (e: religion)

Together we can end the stigma around black cats and adopting them. Happy pride month!

No active clause(should), not WA perspective (written TO the GA, not BY the GA),

[Juansonia]

General Assembly Proposal
ID: greater_new_rhodesia_and_nyasaland_1654092832

A Proposal To Legalize Assisted Suicide
A resolution to modify universal standards of healthcare.

Category: Health

Area of Effect: Healthcare

Proposed by: Greater New Rhodesia and Nyasaland

WHEREAS, this General assembly presently assembled does propose to all man the right to decide for himself his fate; therefore we prepose to make the following law:

Article I. Definitions
I. Man in this article refers to any person who is apart of the species known as 'homo sapiens'.
II. In this article 'assisted suicide' refers to suicide effected with the assistance of another person, especially the taking of lethal drugs provided by a doctor for the purpose by a patient suffering from a terminal illness or incurable condition.

Article II. What would this do?
This bill would allow terminally ill, mentally capable adults to have the option of accelerating their deaths with medical assistance.

It is based on assisted dying laws that have been in place in IRL places for years. Too many dying people suffer against their wishes at the end of life in this country and our current law fails to protect dying people, who often feel they have no option but to seek help overseas or take matters into their own hands at home. Many hundreds of terminally ill people take their own lives in this country in distressing circumstances. Even with the very best care, thousands of people in the world every year will die without adequate pain relief or with unmanageable and distressing symptoms, despite the very best palliative care.

This law would help a small but significant number of dying people avoid unwanted suffering at the end of life but would also provide protection and reassurance to those living with a terminal illness that this option will be available to them if the worst should happen. Assisted dying would not be a substitute for palliative care, but an additional option alongside it; dying people need excellent palliative care and the option of assisted dying in the event that they find their suffering unbearable.

Openly admits to RL references

[Juansonia]

General Assembly Proposal
ID: meowstona_1654118949

The Gun Safety Act
A resolution to enact uniform standards that protect workers, consumers, and the general public.

Category: Regulation

Area of Effect: Safety

Proposed by: Meowstona

General Assembly,
Gun violence has gotten out of control and we need to take action to prevent more violence in the future.

To do this we shall,

1. Raise the eligible age to purchase a gun to 25. This will lower school shootings and ensure that the person purchasing a gun understands the importance of gun safety and how serious purchasing a firearm is.

2. Prohibit sales of automatic rifles. This will decrease and prevent more deaths from guns, specifically automatic rifles. We should do this because automatic rifles are very dangerous, even more dangerous compared to their handgun counterparts.

3. Make it illegal for a person to run in office if they receive money from any gun organization and or company.

4. Install metal detectors in government buildings such as schools. This will ensure that nobody can come in a building with a gun or weapon of any type.

Proposal basics (not WA perspective), contradicts existing resolution (the one which includes a blocker on internal weapon policy)

edit: another one:

General Assembly Proposal
ID: lile_ulie_islands_1654121759

The Firearm Regulation Act
A resolution to reduce income inequality and increase basic welfare.

Category: Social Justice

Strength: Strong

Proposed by: Lile Ulie Islands

Committed to improving the world, one resolution at a time,

Cognizant of the fact that some individuals believe that a firearm is a source of “protection,”

Determining this issue of gun violence to be struck down,

Ensuring that the world shall be a safer place with less grief due to the loss of a person by gun violence,

Hereby,

Mandates that all nations must comply the following,

(a) All assault rifles shall be outlawed
(b) More intensive and extensive background checks shall be placed on individuals when buying a firearm
(c) Ensuring mental health and wellness programs for those with mental issues and a owning a firearm is a risk to others
(d) A license or ID must be shown when purchasing a firearm
(e) Firearms shall not be purchased through the internet
(f) One with the intent to harm shall not be subject to a firearm

Ensuring that all nations around the world maintain decent civil rights, while establishing safety, peace, and justice.

Co-author: Yifm

This one's WA perspective, but category's more wrong, and it contradicts the blocker.

[Bears Armed]

The last five proposals reported in this thread have now all been marked as Illegal, as have two other new ones.

[Umbratellus]

https://www.nationstates.net/page=UN_view_proposal/id=slevilia_1654876649

Category: Advancement of Industry

Area of Effect: Labor Deregulation

Proposed by: Slevilia

It hurts me how the weirdest things are not the same around the world so I gonna change that starting with measurement systems. When people move, if we only have one measurement system than it wouldn't be confusing. think About it, the world in measurement systems is almost unified why not finish the job https://drive.google.com/file/d/18yGxuY ... p=drivesdk

For starters; wrong category, has nothing to do with deregulating labor. Clear format issue with the majority being contained in a dubious link. Branding and not written from the perspective of the WA.

[Bananaistan]

https://www.nationstates.net/page=UN_view_proposal/id=slevilia_1654876649

Category: Advancement of Industry

Area of Effect: Labor Deregulation

Proposed by: Slevilia

It hurts me how the weirdest things are not the same around the world so I gonna change that starting with measurement systems. When people move, if we only have one measurement system than it wouldn't be confusing. think About it, the world in measurement systems is almost unified why not finish the job https://drive.google.com/file/d/18yGxuY ... p=drivesdk

For starters; wrong category, has nothing to do with deregulating labor. Clear format issue with the majority being contained in a dubious link. Branding and not written from the perspective of the WA.

**Coughs**

If an illegal proposal already has its own thread elsewhere in this forum, please don't post it in this thread as well. Post your comments in the proposal's existing thread; that will bump it near enough to the top to be noticed. Joke or silly proposals can be posted in its dedicated thread.

[Umbratellus]

https://www.nationstates.net/page=UN_view_proposal/id=slevilia_1654876649

Category: Advancement of Industry

Area of Effect: Labor Deregulation

Proposed by: Slevilia

It hurts me how the weirdest things are not the same around the world so I gonna change that starting with measurement systems. When people move, if we only have one measurement system than it wouldn't be confusing. think About it, the world in measurement systems is almost unified why not finish the job https://drive.google.com/file/d/18yGxuY ... p=drivesdk

For starters; wrong category, has nothing to do with deregulating labor. Clear format issue with the majority being contained in a dubious link. Branding and not written from the perspective of the WA.

**Coughs**

If an illegal proposal already has its own thread elsewhere in this forum, please don't post it in this thread as well. Post your comments in the proposal's existing thread; that will bump it near enough to the top to be noticed. Joke or silly proposals can be posted in its dedicated thread.

My apologies, I did not see that it had a thread of it's own.

[Juansonia]

General Assembly Proposal
ID: ism_aslamistan_1654957902

Removal Of The Krasnayan Region
A resolution to increase democratic freedoms.

Category: Furtherment of Democracy

Strength: Mild

Proposed by: Ism Aslamistan

The Krasnayan Region is renowned for its bad treatment of new comers as well as its frequent colonisation of Newly formed states. This Proposal states that the nations signing must remove all diplomatic ties with Krasnaya and sanction them, this will support those who have been ill treated by the Krasnayan Dictatorship

Proposal basics: GA proposals cannot target specific nations or regions(that's the SC's job)
Category violation
Game mechanics: Neither the GA nor the SC may compel WA members to cease diplomatic ties

[Magecastle Embassy Building A5]

As every week on every calendar contains a day called Tuesday, and
Tacos are not only a tasty treat, but a staple of happiness and joy, and
The combining of Taco consumption with the week day of Tuesday is, in essence, a natural, and
The celebration that is derived from participating in Taco Tuesday promotes social, mental, and economic upward trends, and
Therefore, it is proposed that Taco Tuesday be recognized as a World Wide Event each week.

Participation is voluntary.

"Tuesday" seems to be a real world reference, no enacting clause ("it is proposed"), optionality ("participation is voluntary")

[Spiderman]

Title: The Privacy Act
ID: we_hate_all_of_you_1658202277
Category/effect: Regulation - Safety
Authored by: WE HATE ALL OF YOU

Companies need to respect user privacy. see companies like poopybooks have been selling user data to the black market and to Chinese companies like onecent. this needs to change 1; companies obviously cant sell user data.:2 Companies have to show users their data every week. 3: companies like pear have this option called block tracking well ALL PHONES COMPUTERS TABLETS NEED TO HAVE THE FEATURE. overall we need to do more things for privacy so here's our chance

Duplicates GA resolution 481, RL references ('Chinese companies like onecent,' 'companies like pear'), not written from WA perspective - possibly more.

[Tinhampton]

General Assembly Proposal
ID: emus_and_papayas_1659321930

Repealing the Right to hunt or kill emus
A resolution to restrict civil freedoms in the interest of moral decency.

Category: Moral Decency

Strength: Mild

Proposed by: Emus and Papayas

---

This proposal/law/bill/etc. will lead to the following after being passed.

A. Emus are recognized as a protected species

B. Emus, (as a protected species) cannot be killed, hunted, etc.

C. The killing of emus will proceed to a court as animal abuse, felony, or murder, (depending on the government)

D. Emus can no longer be used for supplements. Such as “Emu Oil” as a example.

E. Emus can no longer be used for meat for any reasons.

F. After being passed, this law will allow countries with high animal rights to allow emus to be recognized as citizens of the state including the rights that come with citizenship of said nation.

G. Countries with low animal rights are allowed to use other animals as meat or supplements according to already in-use laws, and/or religious beliefs. However, emus must be considered as a protected species by all.

Marked legal by Sierra Lyricalia. Arguably illegal due to Article B, which contradicts Article 1 of GA#267 "Sensible Limits on Hunting," which itself reserves to member states whether to outright ban the hunting of emus (or any other animal).

[Tinhampton]

General Assembly Proposal
ID: united_nation_of_science_1659476813

Automotive Revolution
A resolution to increase the quality of the world's environment, at the expense of industry.

Category: Environmental

Category: Automotive

Proposed by: United Nation Of Science

---

1. All Autombels must be emition free.
2. All Automotive factories must be emition free.
3. Governments will not pay for the changes the companies will.
4. All Charging stations must also be emition free all through the process of making them and charching them.
5. People will be given a $5,000 check for help buying a new car that will comply with the new standers and regulation.
6. If you do not use the money to help buy the car your entire family will face 10 year in state prison in in seperate jail cells.
7. After out of jail, each memeber of the family will be forced to pay back the $5,000 working for the government doing what ever the government wants.
8. If family dose to comply with paying the money back, the entire family will be jailed for life in seperate jail cells.

Illegal for containing Real-World References and contradicting Article 7 of GA#598 "Access To Euthanasia Services". Please bear with me:

1. Article 7 of Automotive Revolution ("AR") is at issue; however, it cannot be understood without reference to Articles 5 and 6 of AR.
   
   1. Article 5 of AR requires that every person be given $5,000 to spend on "a new car that will comply with the new standers and regulation."
   2. Article 6 of AR requires that any person who improperly uses Article 5 grants be imprisoned with their family.
   3. Article 7 requires that everybody imprisoned pursuant to Article 6 and subsequently released "will be forced to pay back the $5,000 working for the government doing what ever the government wants."
2. Work prescribed pursuant to Article 7 of AR can be "what ever the government wants," without the possibility of independently choosing or leaving the assigned job. This can include working as a medical professional who conducts assisted suicide procedures, which Article 2 of GA#598 requires all member states to offer.
3. Article 7 of GA#598 declares that "A medical professional expressing a bona fide objection against performing assisted suicide may not be required to perform assisted suicide, as long as that professional directs patients seeking assisted suicide to easily, readily, and locally accessible assisted suicide services."
4. Medical professionals who conscientiously object to conducting assisted suicide - even if they offer the direction to other assisted suicide sites prescribed in GA#598 - may nonetheless be required to conduct it if their government says so, in contradiction of GA#598, so long as they are only serving in that role because their government assigned it to them pursuant to Article 7 of AR.
5. In addition, Articles 5 and 7 of AR prescribe a dollar amount of compensation. Citing such values in dollars, or any other real world currency, is - by tradition - a violation of the RWR rule.

[WayNeacTia]

General Assembly Proposal
ID: united_nation_of_science_1659476813
(Image)
Automotive Revolution
A resolution to increase the quality of the world's environment, at the expense of industry.

Category: Environmental

Category: Automotive

Proposed by: Emus and Papayas

---

1. All Autombels must be emition free.
2. All Automotive factories must be emition free.
3. Governments will not pay for the changes the companies will.
4. All Charging stations must also be emition free all through the process of making them and charching them.
5. People will be given a $5,000 check for help buying a new car that will comply with the new standers and regulation.
6. If you do not use the money to help buy the car your entire family will face 10 year in state prison in in seperate jail cells.
7. After out of jail, each memeber of the family will be forced to pay back the $5,000 working for the government doing what ever the government wants.
8. If family dose to comply with paying the money back, the entire family will be jailed for life in seperate jail cells.

Illegal for containing Real-World References and contradicting Article 7 of GA#598 "Access To Euthanasia Services". Please bear with me:

1. Article 7 of Automotive Revolution ("AR") is at issue; however, it cannot be understood without reference to Articles 5 and 6 of AR.
   
   1. Article 5 of AR requires that every person be given $5,000 to spend on "a new car that will comply with the new standers and regulation."
   2. Article 6 of AR requires that any person who improperly uses Article 5 grants be imprisoned with their family.
   3. Article 7 requires that everybody imprisoned pursuant to Article 6 and subsequently released "will be forced to pay back the $5,000 working for the government doing what ever the government wants."
2. Work prescribed pursuant to Article 7 of AR can be "what ever the government wants," without the possibility of independently choosing or leaving the assigned job. This can include working as a medical professional who conducts assisted suicide procedures, which Article 2 of GA#598 requires all member states to offer.
3. Article 7 of GA#598 declares that "A medical professional expressing a bona fide objection against performing assisted suicide may not be required to perform assisted suicide, as long as that professional directs patients seeking assisted suicide to easily, readily, and locally accessible assisted suicide services."
4. Medical professionals who conscientiously object to conducting assisted suicide - even if they offer the direction to other assisted suicide sites prescribed in GA#598 - may nonetheless be required to conduct it if their government says so, in contradiction of GA#598, so long as they are only serving in that role because their government assigned it to them pursuant to Article 7 of AR.
5. In addition, Articles 5 and 7 of AR prescribe a dollar amount of compensation. Citing such values in dollars, or any other real world currency, is - by tradition - a violation of the RWR rule.

Not seeing a real world reference here Tin.....

[Outer Sparta]

General Assembly Proposal
ID: united_nation_of_science_1659476813
(Image)
Automotive Revolution
A resolution to increase the quality of the world's environment, at the expense of industry.

Category: Environmental

Category: Automotive

Proposed by: Emus and Papayas

---

1. All Autombels must be emition free.
2. All Automotive factories must be emition free.
3. Governments will not pay for the changes the companies will.
4. All Charging stations must also be emition free all through the process of making them and charching them.
5. People will be given a $5,000 check for help buying a new car that will comply with the new standers and regulation.
6. If you do not use the money to help buy the car your entire family will face 10 year in state prison in in seperate jail cells.
7. After out of jail, each memeber of the family will be forced to pay back the $5,000 working for the government doing what ever the government wants.
8. If family dose to comply with paying the money back, the entire family will be jailed for life in seperate jail cells.

Illegal for containing Real-World References and contradicting Article 7 of GA#598 "Access To Euthanasia Services". Please bear with me:

1. Article 7 of Automotive Revolution ("AR") is at issue; however, it cannot be understood without reference to Articles 5 and 6 of AR.
   
   1. Article 5 of AR requires that every person be given $5,000 to spend on "a new car that will comply with the new standers and regulation."
   2. Article 6 of AR requires that any person who improperly uses Article 5 grants be imprisoned with their family.
   3. Article 7 requires that everybody imprisoned pursuant to Article 6 and subsequently released "will be forced to pay back the $5,000 working for the government doing what ever the government wants."
2. Work prescribed pursuant to Article 7 of AR can be "what ever the government wants," without the possibility of independently choosing or leaving the assigned job. This can include working as a medical professional who conducts assisted suicide procedures, which Article 2 of GA#598 requires all member states to offer.
3. Article 7 of GA#598 declares that "A medical professional expressing a bona fide objection against performing assisted suicide may not be required to perform assisted suicide, as long as that professional directs patients seeking assisted suicide to easily, readily, and locally accessible assisted suicide services."
4. Medical professionals who conscientiously object to conducting assisted suicide - even if they offer the direction to other assisted suicide sites prescribed in GA#598 - may nonetheless be required to conduct it if their government says so, in contradiction of GA#598, so long as they are only serving in that role because their government assigned it to them pursuant to Article 7 of AR.
5. In addition, Articles 5 and 7 of AR prescribe a dollar amount of compensation. Citing such values in dollars, or any other real world currency, is - by tradition - a violation of the RWR rule.

Not seeing a real world reference here Tin.....

Isn't using real-world currency (such as $) already a violation of the RWR rule?

[Imperium Anglorum]

I don't know why this sudden idea has emerged that anything that like exists in the real world is a RLR. The use of dollars isn't a specific real world reference even as much as mere reference of "Catholic", "Muslim", or "January" are. "Traditionally", whatever that means, both have been held to be legal.

Oh wait, I don't need to rely on nebulous and unsupported terms like "traditionally". I can just rely on direct citation. Novel Writers Appreciation Month (2010) 1 IAM 7; Repeal "For the Detained and Convicted" (2009) 2 IAM 2.