NATION

PASSWORD

White Privilege

For discussion and debate about anything. (Not a roleplay related forum; out-of-character commentary only.)

Advertisement

Remove ads

Is white privilege real?

1-Yes
96
23%
2-No
217
52%
3-Sort of
68
16%
4-Oh come on, OP! Devils food cake is black, Angel food cake is white, the evidence is there!
16
4%
5-The cake is a lie(Ugh, painful pun)
10
2%
6-I read Nationstates for the articles, I swear!
13
3%
 
Total votes : 420

User avatar
Herskerstad
Postmaster-General
 
Posts: 10258
Founded: Dec 14, 2009
Ex-Nation

Postby Herskerstad » Sun Aug 20, 2017 5:35 am

Privilege is, and always has been relative.

As far as the state is concerned aside from immediate calamities, they should give increased aid to three classes that actually matters. The poor, the disabled and the unfortunate.
Although the stars do not speak, even in being silent they cry out. - John Calvin

User avatar
Ramune and Chocolate
Spokesperson
 
Posts: 144
Founded: Aug 08, 2017
Ex-Nation

Postby Ramune and Chocolate » Sun Aug 20, 2017 6:28 am

Donut section wrote:Found the guy who white guilts the hardest.

An intelligent and thoughtful response. Internet SJWs totally btfo cannot recover send help.
Shofercia wrote:Ok, so those of you that think that "White Privilege" exists - name a single part of White Privilege that isn't a Right enshrined in the Bill of Rights, or in the Convention of Social Rights. If you mean that White Privilege means that whites get to use the Bill of Rights and minorities don't, that's sort of right; minorities should be able to use the Bill of Rights, and so should the poor whites, but I wouldn't call that a privilege. For me a privilege is something like driving; a Right to Free Speech is a Right, not a privilege. The Right not to be racially profiled is a Right, not a privilege.

I suppose the definition of privilege used is a different one. For example, if a society permits a certain religious group greater freedom of worship and belief while other religious groups are suppressed and denied basic rights, then it is safe to say that the former religion is granted a privileged position in the eye of the society.
Last edited by Ramune and Chocolate on Sun Aug 20, 2017 6:28 am, edited 1 time in total.
Left-libertarian, free market anarchist.
Free market anti-capitalism?
Music

User avatar
Zottistan
Postmaster-General
 
Posts: 14887
Founded: Nov 26, 2011
Ex-Nation

Postby Zottistan » Sun Aug 20, 2017 6:59 am

Every social group has its own set of privileges granted to and denied from it. That's what characterizes it as a distinct group. There are privileges that white people have and that black people don't, and equally there are privileges that black people have and that white people don't. You can make the argument that any of these specific privileges are unfair or wrong, and in a lot of cases you'd be making a valid argument, but breaking down every second political issue to the vague, undefinable notion of white privilege and institutional white supremacy is a huge mistake. Take every issue as it is; sometimes there is racism, usually there is not. There is no cultural architecture intrinsically designed to favor white people over others, only individual privileges that the two groups have over eachother.
Ireland, BCL and LLM, Training Barrister, Cismale Bi Dude and Gym-Bro, Generally Boring Socdem Eurocuck

User avatar
Cottony
Envoy
 
Posts: 335
Founded: Apr 13, 2017
Democratic Socialists

Postby Cottony » Sun Aug 20, 2017 7:04 am

What's that?

User avatar
Dylar
Negotiator
 
Posts: 7071
Founded: Jan 07, 2016
Ex-Nation

Postby Dylar » Sun Aug 20, 2017 7:30 am

Cottony wrote:What's that?

What's what?
St. Albert the Great wrote:"Natural science does not consist in ratifying what others have said, but in seeking the causes of phenomena."
Franko Tildon wrote:Fire washes the skin off the bone and the sin off the soul. It cleans away the dirt. And my momma didn't raise herself no dirty boy.

Pro: Life, Catholic, religious freedom, guns
Against: gun control, abortion, militant atheism
Interests: Video Games, Military History, Catholic theology, Sci-Fi, and Table-Top Miniatures games
Favorite music genres: Metal, Drinking songs, Polka, Military Marches, Hardbass, and Movie/Video Game soundtracks

User avatar
Sovaal
Postmaster-General
 
Posts: 13695
Founded: Mar 17, 2017
Ex-Nation

Postby Sovaal » Sun Aug 20, 2017 9:28 am

Dylar wrote:
Cottony wrote:What's that?

What's what?

What? I can't hear you!
Most of the time I have no idea what the hell I'm doing or talking about.

”Many forms of government have been tried and will be tried in this world of sin and woe.
No one pretends that democracy is perfect or all wise. Indeed, it has been said that democracy is
the worst form of government, except for all the others that have been tried from time to time." -
Winston Churchill, 1947.

"Rifles, muskets, long-bows and hand-grenades are inherently democratic weapons. A complex weapon makes the strong stronger, while a simple weapon – so long as there is no answer to it – gives claws to the weak.” - George Orwell

User avatar
Thermodolia
Post Kaiser
 
Posts: 79496
Founded: Oct 07, 2011
Anarchy

Postby Thermodolia » Sun Aug 20, 2017 10:00 am

Borovan4 wrote:It's real. If a business hires who do they hire? If a customer uses a service who do they prefer? Even if it's subconscious it's there.

As a consumer I prefer the cheaper option, race doesn't play a factor
Last edited by Thermodolia on Sun Aug 20, 2017 10:20 am, edited 1 time in total.
Male, Jewish, lives somewhere in AZ, Disabled US Military Veteran, Oorah!, I'm GAY!
I'm agent #69 in the Gaystapo!
>The Sons of Adam: I'd crown myself monarch... cuz why not?
>>Dumb Ideologies: Why not turn yourself into a penguin and build an igloo at the centre of the Earth?
Click for Da Funies

RIP Dya

User avatar
Shofercia
Post Czar
 
Posts: 31341
Founded: Feb 22, 2008
Ex-Nation

Postby Shofercia » Sun Aug 20, 2017 10:10 am

Ramune and Chocolate wrote:
Shofercia wrote:Ok, so those of you that think that "White Privilege" exists - name a single part of White Privilege that isn't a Right enshrined in the Bill of Rights, or in the Convention of Social Rights. If you mean that White Privilege means that whites get to use the Bill of Rights and minorities don't, that's sort of right; minorities should be able to use the Bill of Rights, and so should the poor whites, but I wouldn't call that a privilege. For me a privilege is something like driving; a Right to Free Speech is a Right, not a privilege. The Right not to be racially profiled is a Right, not a privilege.


I suppose the definition of privilege used is a different one. For example, if a society permits a certain religious group greater freedom of worship and belief while other religious groups are suppressed and denied basic rights, then it is safe to say that the former religion is granted a privileged position in the eye of the society.


The problem here is that could discourage said group from fighting for the Rights of other groups.

First they came for the Socialists, and I did not speak out—
Because I was not a Socialist.

Then they came for the Trade Unionists, and I did not speak out—
Because I was not a Trade Unionist.

Then they came for the Jews, and I did not speak out—
Because I was not a Jew.

Then they came for me—and there was no one left to speak for me.


When Kelo lost her house, the property owners bonded together and eminent domain is now much less effective as a result, at least in most states. When the pipeline violated Native American land, we, as property owners, did nothing. Do you think the latter act encouraged or discouraged giant corporations from attacking our Property Rights? Now imagine for a second if we called it the "Property Privileges" - see the point?

What you're saying is correct from a grammatical standpoint, and it has merit. The atrocious treatment of minorities and the poor by the police force is certainly an issue. Some US Citizens get deported for not looking white enough, and that's fucked up. I have no doubts about it. But the way that it's presented also weakens the fight against injustice, by sinking basic Human Rights to the mere level of privileges.
Come, learn about Russian Culture! Bring Vodka and Ushanka. Interested in Slavic Culture? Fill this out.
Stonk Power! (North) Kosovo is (a de facto part of) Serbia and Crimea is (a de facto part of) Russia
I used pronouns until the mods made using wrong pronouns warnable, so I use names instead; if you see malice there, that's entirely on you, and if pronouns are no longer warnable, I'll go back to using them

User avatar
Dylar
Negotiator
 
Posts: 7071
Founded: Jan 07, 2016
Ex-Nation

Postby Dylar » Sun Aug 20, 2017 12:00 pm

Sovaal wrote:
Dylar wrote:What's what?

What? I can't hear you!

Wait, what? You don't need to be able to hear on the Internet.
St. Albert the Great wrote:"Natural science does not consist in ratifying what others have said, but in seeking the causes of phenomena."
Franko Tildon wrote:Fire washes the skin off the bone and the sin off the soul. It cleans away the dirt. And my momma didn't raise herself no dirty boy.

Pro: Life, Catholic, religious freedom, guns
Against: gun control, abortion, militant atheism
Interests: Video Games, Military History, Catholic theology, Sci-Fi, and Table-Top Miniatures games
Favorite music genres: Metal, Drinking songs, Polka, Military Marches, Hardbass, and Movie/Video Game soundtracks

User avatar
Nexus of All Realities
Diplomat
 
Posts: 567
Founded: Jun 18, 2017
Ex-Nation

Postby Nexus of All Realities » Sun Aug 20, 2017 12:25 pm

Mine never was.
Not a Nazi!
Whatever happened to ordinary people?

User avatar
SD_Film Artists
Postmaster-General
 
Posts: 13400
Founded: Jun 10, 2009
Ex-Nation

Postby SD_Film Artists » Sun Aug 20, 2017 1:33 pm

Longweather wrote:
SD_Film Artists wrote:"Privilege" does exist in the form of entrenched power in society, however the concept of "white privilege" is often exaggerated and abused by the ctrl-left who use it as an excuse to be misandrist and racist towards white people.

To paraphrase Maajid Nawaz: "Sorry Diane Abbot MP [wealthy black woman], if you think that you can walk into a council estate and tell a white, working class boy that he has more power than you and that's why you can be sexist and racist towards him, then that's a load of rubbish."


First, thank you for using Ctrl-Left. It's nice to know some people still use the term. Second, where did you get that quote/paraphrased statement? I would love to listen/read wherever it came from.


Here: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Dm8Wx-OzPdI
Lurking NSG since 2005
Economic Left/Right: -2.62, Social Libertarian/Authoritarian: 0.67

When anybody preaches disunity, tries to pit one of us against each other through class warfare, race hatred, or religious intolerance, you know that person seeks to rob us of our freedom and destroy our very lives.

User avatar
Dread Lady Nathicana
Retired Moderator
 
Posts: 26052
Founded: Antiquity
Ex-Nation

Postby Dread Lady Nathicana » Sun Aug 20, 2017 1:43 pm

Trotskylvania wrote:You have to be completely, militantly ignorant about reality to pretend that white privilege doesn't exist.

There's no point being nice or mincing words about this. You are so sensitive to the very idea that maybe, just maybe, you got a leg up from some one and your self-narrative about how self-reliant and special you are might not be entirely accurate, you demand that everyone tip-toe around you and coddle your precious feelings.

There is definitely identity politics at play here. It's the identity politics of whiteness.

If your self-esteem is so fragile that it is threatened by accepting the clear sociological fact that there is an enduring institutional legacy of racism in the United States, then perhaps you should do some soul searching, and not demand that we ignore that in sociological terms, you were born on third-base, nor demand that we pretend you hit a triple.

The sociological evidence is clear. To deny it is the same as being a flat earther. Non-whites in America, with few exceptions, are live in poorer communities. They have less access to education, or to health care. They have been for decades pushed to the margins of society, and only within living memory did they even begin to achieve the legal recognition of equality.

Things might be improving, but it would be insanity to pretend that means that racism is not a problem. But like any hierarchical society, our society conflates questions of social status with moral status, and so in a knee-jerk reaction you consider the very notion of an unearned privilege connected to your skin-color to be an attack on your moral status. White privilege has nothing to do with such moral sanctimony.

It's not a just world. Moral status has nothing to do with social status. White privilege doesn't mean you're bad people for being white. To assume that it does, however, requires a hidden assumption of the basest form of racial collectivism, the zero-sum thinking that races represent real biological categories locked in competition with one another, and the elevation of one requires the subjugation of another. Please let go of such petty tribalisms. Let's talk about the basic facts.

The facts are simple. The legacy of Jim Crow and slavery aren't over yet. Blacks have had a uniquely subjugated position in American society due to this historical legacy, a legacy of institutional racism that has not just left black communities impoverished or terrorized, but also culturally maladapted for success within society. Liberals are plenty guilty of indulging in infantilizing marginalized groups, treating them as poor noble savages. The truth is more complicated. The experience of suffering doesn't make people better, it is very good at making people variously tribal, defensive, angry, defeated, prone to lashing out, and ensuring that shit rolls down hill (as the tradition of black feminist struggles can surely attest to).

But do you know what is the most fundamental white privilege? Getting to be an individual.

If a white person fucks up, you don't get a chorus of voices in the commentariat sanctimoniously shaking their heads, and talking about how the offender is a disappointment to white community. Successful whites are never asked to be moral examplars or paragons that wide-eyed young white boys and girls look up to as a credit to their race. That old attitude has never left us, we just use different verbiage, and with often misdirected intentions well-meaning people, black and white, pillory black celebrities for failing to be a credit to their race.

Black parents are constantly called to the bar to answer for their children being fuck ups in a way that whites never have to. White kids getting into trouble is dismissed as the exuberance of youth, kids being young and dumb. Black kids getting into trouble is always treated as a failure of the black community and black parents.

If it sounds stupid, that's because it fucking is. Because who gets to have the privileges of whiteness has changed dramatically. I'm a Polish-American, from a little town in northern Michigan that's almost entirely peopled by Poles and other peoples from Eastern/Central Europe. They didn't all settle there because of some mythical Slavic feeling of brotherhood, they all pretty much fucking hated each other. Even within Poland, we had regional animosities going back centuries. Being Polish only mattered more than, say, being from Gdansk or being from Warszawa, when they got off the boat from the Old Country, and realized that in America, they're all Polacks and in the prevailing hierarchy of late 19th/early 20th century America, they're one step above blacks. So no matter how much they hated each other, they settled with other Poles because at least they had that shared otherness.

Fast forward a hundred years, and we get to be in the White club. The only people who tell Polack jokes are the Polacks of my father's generation or older, an old habit to armor themselves against the racism they experienced for not being an Anglo-Saxon Protestant.

Whiteness isn't really about skin color, it's always been a social club. And only in the post Jim Crow era have all Europeans been invited to that club. Maybe I'll live to see the day when being of African descent will be the same as my own Polish descent in our culture. I'd certainly like to live to see it. But if you really think there's no such thing as white privilege, ponder this:

When I get verbally abused by little shits on the internet, say on Xbox Live voice chat, they don't call me a Polack. They don't even call me any number of slurs for white people, like cracker or honky. They call me a n-word, because the most hurtful thing you can say to someone is to call them black.

Brief note:

Whites aren't 'allowed' to use race in any descriptor, as we are immediately accused of racism if we do - there are generally two sides to any one given story, and this is the unspoken part of the narrative you gave - which does not, btw, invalidate what you said, because problems DO exist. All this does is explain another part of the story.

Stupid kids on the internet use all sorts of names to call - f****t and cunt and the like being about as prevalent, if not moreso. Stupid people gonna stupid, whatchagonnadoaboutit. So no, /the/ most hurtful thing varies from person to person. Have heard, and seen, my fair share of it. Not to invalidate the claim that people use 'n-word' as an insult - they do. But they are not the only people who have who and what they are used as a pejorative by assholes.

There have been various groups throughout history condemned - here and elsewhere. The Irish, the Catholics, the Mormons (standing extermination order in Missouri against them all the way into the 80's if you care to look into Gov. Boggs), the Chinese, the Mexicans, LGBT+, Women ... once again, this does not invalidate the problem blacks have had, and continue to have. This simply adds to the overall narrative that people are ignorant asshats, and it needs to stop. Don't particularly care how it gets sorted (aside from 'peaceably' where at all possible), so long as it does get sorted, sooner rather than later. With as little misguided finger-pointing and blame-gaming as we can manage, please and thank you.

User avatar
Mushet
Post Marshal
 
Posts: 16565
Founded: Apr 29, 2008
Ex-Nation

Postby Mushet » Sun Aug 20, 2017 3:48 pm

Dread Lady Nathicana wrote:
Trotskylvania wrote:You have to be completely, militantly ignorant about reality to pretend that white privilege doesn't exist.

There's no point being nice or mincing words about this. You are so sensitive to the very idea that maybe, just maybe, you got a leg up from some one and your self-narrative about how self-reliant and special you are might not be entirely accurate, you demand that everyone tip-toe around you and coddle your precious feelings.

There is definitely identity politics at play here. It's the identity politics of whiteness.

If your self-esteem is so fragile that it is threatened by accepting the clear sociological fact that there is an enduring institutional legacy of racism in the United States, then perhaps you should do some soul searching, and not demand that we ignore that in sociological terms, you were born on third-base, nor demand that we pretend you hit a triple.

The sociological evidence is clear. To deny it is the same as being a flat earther. Non-whites in America, with few exceptions, are live in poorer communities. They have less access to education, or to health care. They have been for decades pushed to the margins of society, and only within living memory did they even begin to achieve the legal recognition of equality.

Things might be improving, but it would be insanity to pretend that means that racism is not a problem. But like any hierarchical society, our society conflates questions of social status with moral status, and so in a knee-jerk reaction you consider the very notion of an unearned privilege connected to your skin-color to be an attack on your moral status. White privilege has nothing to do with such moral sanctimony.

It's not a just world. Moral status has nothing to do with social status. White privilege doesn't mean you're bad people for being white. To assume that it does, however, requires a hidden assumption of the basest form of racial collectivism, the zero-sum thinking that races represent real biological categories locked in competition with one another, and the elevation of one requires the subjugation of another. Please let go of such petty tribalisms. Let's talk about the basic facts.

The facts are simple. The legacy of Jim Crow and slavery aren't over yet. Blacks have had a uniquely subjugated position in American society due to this historical legacy, a legacy of institutional racism that has not just left black communities impoverished or terrorized, but also culturally maladapted for success within society. Liberals are plenty guilty of indulging in infantilizing marginalized groups, treating them as poor noble savages. The truth is more complicated. The experience of suffering doesn't make people better, it is very good at making people variously tribal, defensive, angry, defeated, prone to lashing out, and ensuring that shit rolls down hill (as the tradition of black feminist struggles can surely attest to).

But do you know what is the most fundamental white privilege? Getting to be an individual.

If a white person fucks up, you don't get a chorus of voices in the commentariat sanctimoniously shaking their heads, and talking about how the offender is a disappointment to white community. Successful whites are never asked to be moral examplars or paragons that wide-eyed young white boys and girls look up to as a credit to their race. That old attitude has never left us, we just use different verbiage, and with often misdirected intentions well-meaning people, black and white, pillory black celebrities for failing to be a credit to their race.

Black parents are constantly called to the bar to answer for their children being fuck ups in a way that whites never have to. White kids getting into trouble is dismissed as the exuberance of youth, kids being young and dumb. Black kids getting into trouble is always treated as a failure of the black community and black parents.

If it sounds stupid, that's because it fucking is. Because who gets to have the privileges of whiteness has changed dramatically. I'm a Polish-American, from a little town in northern Michigan that's almost entirely peopled by Poles and other peoples from Eastern/Central Europe. They didn't all settle there because of some mythical Slavic feeling of brotherhood, they all pretty much fucking hated each other. Even within Poland, we had regional animosities going back centuries. Being Polish only mattered more than, say, being from Gdansk or being from Warszawa, when they got off the boat from the Old Country, and realized that in America, they're all Polacks and in the prevailing hierarchy of late 19th/early 20th century America, they're one step above blacks. So no matter how much they hated each other, they settled with other Poles because at least they had that shared otherness.

Fast forward a hundred years, and we get to be in the White club. The only people who tell Polack jokes are the Polacks of my father's generation or older, an old habit to armor themselves against the racism they experienced for not being an Anglo-Saxon Protestant.

Whiteness isn't really about skin color, it's always been a social club. And only in the post Jim Crow era have all Europeans been invited to that club. Maybe I'll live to see the day when being of African descent will be the same as my own Polish descent in our culture. I'd certainly like to live to see it. But if you really think there's no such thing as white privilege, ponder this:

When I get verbally abused by little shits on the internet, say on Xbox Live voice chat, they don't call me a Polack. They don't even call me any number of slurs for white people, like cracker or honky. They call me a n-word, because the most hurtful thing you can say to someone is to call them black.

Brief note:

Whites aren't 'allowed' to use race in any descriptor, as we are immediately accused of racism if we do - there are generally two sides to any one given story, and this is the unspoken part of the narrative you gave - which does not, btw, invalidate what you said, because problems DO exist. All this does is explain another part of the story.

Stupid kids on the internet use all sorts of names to call - f****t and cunt and the like being about as prevalent, if not moreso. Stupid people gonna stupid, whatchagonnadoaboutit. So no, /the/ most hurtful thing varies from person to person. Have heard, and seen, my fair share of it. Not to invalidate the claim that people use 'n-word' as an insult - they do. But they are not the only people who have who and what they are used as a pejorative by assholes.

There have been various groups throughout history condemned - here and elsewhere. The Irish, the Catholics, the Mormons (standing extermination order in Missouri against them all the way into the 80's if you care to look into Gov. Boggs), the Chinese, the Mexicans, LGBT+, Women ... once again, this does not invalidate the problem blacks have had, and continue to have. This simply adds to the overall narrative that people are ignorant asshats, and it needs to stop. Don't particularly care how it gets sorted (aside from 'peaceably' where at all possible), so long as it does get sorted, sooner rather than later. With as little misguided finger-pointing and blame-gaming as we can manage, please and thank you.

Quite a bold assertion, I think I've seen this happen without accusations of racism, I'm not sure because it doesn't seem too noteworthy to remember, though I'll admit my interaction with white people is rather limited.
"what I believe is like a box, and we’re taking the energy of our thinking and putting into a box of beliefs, pretending that we’re thinking...I’ve gone through most of my life not believing anything. Either I know or I don’t know, or I think." - John Trudell

Gun control is, and always has been, a tool of white supremacy.

Puppet: E-City ranked #1 in the world for Highest Drug Use on 5/25/2015
Puppet Sacred Heart Church ranked #2 in the world for Nudest 2/25/2010
OP of a 5 page archived thread The Forum Seven Tit Museum
Previous Official King of Forum 7 (2010-2012/13), relinquished own title
First person to get AQ'd Quote was funnier in 2011, you had to have been there
Celebrating over a decade on Nationstates!

User avatar
Dread Lady Nathicana
Retired Moderator
 
Posts: 26052
Founded: Antiquity
Ex-Nation

Postby Dread Lady Nathicana » Sun Aug 20, 2017 4:42 pm

Mushet wrote:Quite a bold assertion, I think I've seen this happen without accusations of racism, I'm not sure because it doesn't seem too noteworthy to remember, though I'll admit my interaction with white people is rather limited.

Wouldn't say it's bold - just a simple thing that we've had too many negatives attached to the idea of 'white_thing' - especially when used as a prideful sort of deal. Honestly, can anyone here really see the words 'white pride' and think of anything not racist, evil-minded, wrong, or at the very least, bad? Stands to reason that a white person being called a 'credit to the white community' would be viewed with the same optics. Pretty damn sure it has, and usually for that very reason. We are told repeatedly we cannot have pride marches, while any other color should and can - which is not to say that I'm for them. Because I am not. (See recent, ye gods almighty, no.) That 'whites don't have culture' - which is wrong, especially given all the various nationalities involved, but hey. Totally grant that a good part of that has been the spread of European empires all over, the whole 'noble savage' and supposed 'responsibility of civil whites' to bring some sort of order, enlightenment, and all that bullshit to our supposedly uncivil brown brethren. Point is, people can and have been awful. But due to the much more recent (in the scope of history) slavery issues here in this country, the ongoing racial tensions, and the very real racial hate issues that continue to plague us, there are some also very real points that probably ought to be recognized.

We can't, as whites, use the same parallels in many cases - be it on account of history, commonly-accepted usage, or what have you. Simple fact. And that's really all there is to it. Was answering the 'why don't we see the same of whites as we do blacks when commenting on their respective communities'. No, don't feel particularly picked on due to that fact, do realize that the various sectors are viewed with different optics whether they should or not (why isn't this or that community doing something about the community members who are doing wrong, or are to blame - fill in your racial blank there, it does tend to be the minorities blamed whereas the individual is more often blamed when they're white - or at least it certainly seems that way).

User avatar
36 Camera Perspective
Minister
 
Posts: 2887
Founded: Jul 18, 2016
Ex-Nation

Postby 36 Camera Perspective » Sun Aug 20, 2017 4:45 pm

Shofercia wrote:Ok, so those of you that think that "White Privilege" exists - name a single part of White Privilege that isn't a Right enshrined in the Bill of Rights, or in the Convention of Social Rights. If you mean that White Privilege means that whites get to use the Bill of Rights and minorities don't, that's sort of right; minorities should be able to use the Bill of Rights, and so should the poor whites, but I wouldn't call that a privilege. For me a privilege is something like driving; a Right to Free Speech is a Right, not a privilege. The Right not to be racially profiled is a Right, not a privilege.

The Convention of Social Rights views access to education and healthcare as Rights, not privileges. Being an individual is a Right, not a privilege. Here's the thing: once you pretend that something is a mere privilege, rather than a Right, it's much easier to not give said privilege to minorities, and to take said privilege away from whites. After all, it's only a privilege, not a Right. That's why I am very much against the term "White Privilege".


Studies have shown that if you take two job applicants with the same exact qualifications, and the only difference between them is that one has a white name and one has a black name, the white names are more likely to get hired. That's the definition of white privilege.
Power, power, the law of the land
Those living for death
Will die by their own hand

User avatar
Bakery Hill
Postmaster-General
 
Posts: 11973
Founded: Jul 03, 2016
Ex-Nation

Postby Bakery Hill » Sun Aug 20, 2017 4:46 pm

Dread Lady Nathicana wrote:Whites aren't 'allowed' to use race in any descriptor, as we are immediately accused of racism if we do - there are generally two sides to any one given story, and this is the unspoken part of the narrative you gave - which does not, btw, invalidate what you said, because problems DO exist. All this does is explain another part of the story.

Yeah nah, that's not true.
Founder of the Committee for Proletarian Morality - Winner of Best Communist Award 2018 - Godfather of NSG Syndicalism

User avatar
Bakery Hill
Postmaster-General
 
Posts: 11973
Founded: Jul 03, 2016
Ex-Nation

Postby Bakery Hill » Sun Aug 20, 2017 4:52 pm

Dread Lady Nathicana wrote:
Mushet wrote:Quite a bold assertion, I think I've seen this happen without accusations of racism, I'm not sure because it doesn't seem too noteworthy to remember, though I'll admit my interaction with white people is rather limited.

Wouldn't say it's bold - just a simple thing that we've had too many negatives attached to the idea of 'white_thing' - especially when used as a prideful sort of deal. Honestly, can anyone here really see the words 'white pride' and think of anything not racist, evil-minded, wrong, or at the very least, bad? Stands to reason that a white person being called a 'credit to the white community' would be viewed with the same optics. Pretty damn sure it has, and usually for that very reason. We are told repeatedly we cannot have pride marches, while any other color should and can - which is not to say that I'm for them. Because I am not. (See recent, ye gods almighty, no.) That 'whites don't have culture' - which is wrong, especially given all the various nationalities involved, but hey.

Sort of true in a sense. White pan-culture is more defined, as Trotskylvania said, as a social club. And that social club is defined by being empowered at the expense of other groupings. There's a difference between St Patrick's Day and a KKK march. One is a celebration of cultural practice, religion and even a historic endurance of hardship (also a fuckload of booze). What does a KKK White Pride March celebrate? Dominance.
Last edited by Bakery Hill on Sun Aug 20, 2017 4:52 pm, edited 1 time in total.
Founder of the Committee for Proletarian Morality - Winner of Best Communist Award 2018 - Godfather of NSG Syndicalism

User avatar
36 Camera Perspective
Minister
 
Posts: 2887
Founded: Jul 18, 2016
Ex-Nation

Postby 36 Camera Perspective » Sun Aug 20, 2017 4:52 pm

Shofercia wrote:"White Privilege" was designed as a bullshit argument to deny minorities Basic American Rights that white people enjoy, by labeling these Rights as a "privilege",


That's ridiculous. White privilege emerged because many felt that whites enjoyed unearned social benefits as a result of their race, meaning that minorities are facing racial injustice. It had nothing to do with denying rights to minorities. It had everything to do with making sure that, in practice, minorities and whites have the same rights. It's literally the exact opposite of how you characterized it. Nobody is trying to say that the rights we have are actually a privilege. We should all have the same rights under the constitution. The 'privilege' part is that, in practice, we are all not treated as if we have the same rights, and in many cases, these differences occur across racial lines.

and to eventually take these Rights away from white people. For example:

"White people get treated respectfully by cops - white privilege!"
Bill of Rights implies: "all people must be treated respectfully by cops!"


It's not that white people being treated well by cops is white privilege. It's "All other things being equal, a white person is less likely to face police brutality than a black person."

That's the privilege. My brand of social justice doesn't want to take rights away from white people. White people have the right to be free from police brutality. It's just that black people do too, but unfortunately, are often treated like they don't.
Last edited by 36 Camera Perspective on Sun Aug 20, 2017 4:54 pm, edited 1 time in total.
Power, power, the law of the land
Those living for death
Will die by their own hand

User avatar
Geilinor
Post Czar
 
Posts: 41328
Founded: Feb 20, 2010
Ex-Nation

Postby Geilinor » Sun Aug 20, 2017 4:54 pm

Bakery Hill wrote:
Dread Lady Nathicana wrote:Wouldn't say it's bold - just a simple thing that we've had too many negatives attached to the idea of 'white_thing' - especially when used as a prideful sort of deal. Honestly, can anyone here really see the words 'white pride' and think of anything not racist, evil-minded, wrong, or at the very least, bad? Stands to reason that a white person being called a 'credit to the white community' would be viewed with the same optics. Pretty damn sure it has, and usually for that very reason. We are told repeatedly we cannot have pride marches, while any other color should and can - which is not to say that I'm for them. Because I am not. (See recent, ye gods almighty, no.) That 'whites don't have culture' - which is wrong, especially given all the various nationalities involved, but hey.

Sort of true in a sense. White pan-culture is more defined, as Trotskylvania said, as a social club. And that social club is defined by being empowered at the expense of other groupings. There's a difference between St Patrick's Day and a KKK march. One is a celebration of cultural practice, religion and even a historic endurance of hardship (also a fuckload of booze). What does a KKK White Pride March celebrate? Dominance.

It's worth asking the question. Why is white people being proud automatically associated with the KKK?
Member of the Free Democratic Party. Not left. Not right. Forward.
Economic Left/Right: -1.13
Social Libertarian/Authoritarian: -2.41

User avatar
36 Camera Perspective
Minister
 
Posts: 2887
Founded: Jul 18, 2016
Ex-Nation

Postby 36 Camera Perspective » Sun Aug 20, 2017 4:55 pm

Bakery Hill wrote:
Dread Lady Nathicana wrote:Whites aren't 'allowed' to use race in any descriptor, as we are immediately accused of racism if we do - there are generally two sides to any one given story, and this is the unspoken part of the narrative you gave - which does not, btw, invalidate what you said, because problems DO exist. All this does is explain another part of the story.

Yeah nah, that's not true.


Ross Perot was reamed because he went in front of an audience of mostly black people and said "you people", so yeah, it seems pretty true.
Power, power, the law of the land
Those living for death
Will die by their own hand

User avatar
Dread Lady Nathicana
Retired Moderator
 
Posts: 26052
Founded: Antiquity
Ex-Nation

Postby Dread Lady Nathicana » Sun Aug 20, 2017 4:55 pm

Bakery Hill wrote:Sort of true in a sense. White pan-culture is more defined, as Trotskylvania said, as a social club. And that social club is defined by being empowered at the expense of other groupings. There's a difference between St Patrick's Day and a KKK march. One is a celebration of cultural practice, religion and even a historic endurance of hardship (also a fuckload of booze). What does a KKK White Pride March celebrate? Dominance.

Eh. Cut the pick and choose and read the rest of the two posts you're questioning there. One does explain one's reasoning more fully. Please be aware, am not challenging St Paddy's vs Klan hoedown here. Am challenging the idea that without a non-white color descriptor, 'culture' isn't a thing. We all have various cultures that have contributed to who and what we are. Some are born of tradition, and some have devolved from ignorance. There's your difference, right there - regardless of skin color.

User avatar
Bakery Hill
Postmaster-General
 
Posts: 11973
Founded: Jul 03, 2016
Ex-Nation

Postby Bakery Hill » Sun Aug 20, 2017 4:56 pm

Geilinor wrote:
Bakery Hill wrote:Sort of true in a sense. White pan-culture is more defined, as Trotskylvania said, as a social club. And that social club is defined by being empowered at the expense of other groupings. There's a difference between St Patrick's Day and a KKK march. One is a celebration of cultural practice, religion and even a historic endurance of hardship (also a fuckload of booze). What does a KKK White Pride March celebrate? Dominance.

It's worth asking the question. Why is white people being proud automatically associated with the KKK?

It is a question worth asking. It's one I felt I answered, and Trots answered better than me.

Being "white" isn't really an ethnicity, it's a weird pan-culture based on dominance. If you are proud of being white, all too often it can be associated with being proud of that dominance and wanting to uphold it.
Founder of the Committee for Proletarian Morality - Winner of Best Communist Award 2018 - Godfather of NSG Syndicalism

User avatar
Shofercia
Post Czar
 
Posts: 31341
Founded: Feb 22, 2008
Ex-Nation

Postby Shofercia » Sun Aug 20, 2017 4:57 pm

36 Camera Perspective wrote:
Shofercia wrote:Ok, so those of you that think that "White Privilege" exists - name a single part of White Privilege that isn't a Right enshrined in the Bill of Rights, or in the Convention of Social Rights. If you mean that White Privilege means that whites get to use the Bill of Rights and minorities don't, that's sort of right; minorities should be able to use the Bill of Rights, and so should the poor whites, but I wouldn't call that a privilege. For me a privilege is something like driving; a Right to Free Speech is a Right, not a privilege. The Right not to be racially profiled is a Right, not a privilege.

The Convention of Social Rights views access to education and healthcare as Rights, not privileges. Being an individual is a Right, not a privilege. Here's the thing: once you pretend that something is a mere privilege, rather than a Right, it's much easier to not give said privilege to minorities, and to take said privilege away from whites. After all, it's only a privilege, not a Right. That's why I am very much against the term "White Privilege".


Studies have shown that if you take two job applicants with the same exact qualifications, and the only difference between them is that one has a white name and one has a black name, the white names are more likely to get hired. That's the definition of white privilege.


There's no such thing as two candidates with the exact same qualifications; also, William Smith is a white name, and he don't look white.
Come, learn about Russian Culture! Bring Vodka and Ushanka. Interested in Slavic Culture? Fill this out.
Stonk Power! (North) Kosovo is (a de facto part of) Serbia and Crimea is (a de facto part of) Russia
I used pronouns until the mods made using wrong pronouns warnable, so I use names instead; if you see malice there, that's entirely on you, and if pronouns are no longer warnable, I'll go back to using them

User avatar
36 Camera Perspective
Minister
 
Posts: 2887
Founded: Jul 18, 2016
Ex-Nation

Postby 36 Camera Perspective » Sun Aug 20, 2017 4:58 pm

Shofercia wrote:
36 Camera Perspective wrote:
Studies have shown that if you take two job applicants with the same exact qualifications, and the only difference between them is that one has a white name and one has a black name, the white names are more likely to get hired. That's the definition of white privilege.


There's no such thing as two candidates with the exact same qualifications; also, William Smith is a white name, and he don't look white.


There is when you're designing a study where the applicants are the exact same except for their names. :eyebrow: I don't think you understand the research if that's your objection. Also, "Will Smith" wasn't a name used in the study, so again.
Last edited by 36 Camera Perspective on Sun Aug 20, 2017 4:58 pm, edited 1 time in total.
Power, power, the law of the land
Those living for death
Will die by their own hand

User avatar
Bakery Hill
Postmaster-General
 
Posts: 11973
Founded: Jul 03, 2016
Ex-Nation

Postby Bakery Hill » Sun Aug 20, 2017 4:58 pm

Dread Lady Nathicana wrote:
Bakery Hill wrote:Sort of true in a sense. White pan-culture is more defined, as Trotskylvania said, as a social club. And that social club is defined by being empowered at the expense of other groupings. There's a difference between St Patrick's Day and a KKK march. One is a celebration of cultural practice, religion and even a historic endurance of hardship (also a fuckload of booze). What does a KKK White Pride March celebrate? Dominance.

Eh. Cut the pick and choose and read the rest of the two posts you're questioning there. One does explain one's reasoning more fully. Please be aware, am not challenging St Paddy's vs Klan hoedown here. Am challenging the idea that without a non-white color descriptor, 'culture' isn't a thing. We all have various cultures that have contributed to who and what we are. Some are born of tradition, and some have devolved from ignorance. There's your difference, right there - regardless of skin color.

White culture is a thing. It's just shit culture. Irish, Polish, English and Italian culture are pretty great though. Though going back through the history of the United States, for a long time only one of those were considered white.
Founder of the Committee for Proletarian Morality - Winner of Best Communist Award 2018 - Godfather of NSG Syndicalism

PreviousNext

Advertisement

Remove ads

Return to General

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: Cerespasia, Ifreann, Kogure, Slembana, The Huskar Social Union, The Notorious Mad Jack, United Paradisia, Vassenor, Voxija, Washington Resistance Army

Advertisement

Remove ads