NATION

PASSWORD

[R] Personal Attack

Who needs it, who got it, who hands it out and why.
User avatar
The V O I D
Post Marshal
 
Posts: 16406
Founded: Apr 13, 2014
Father Knows Best State

[R] Personal Attack

Postby The V O I D » Sat Oct 22, 2016 11:00 am

Aelex wrote:Then you aren't welcome on this R.P and will be ignored by everyone for acting like the petulant and cheating child that you are.


Emphasis mine.

Already foe'd Aelex but they continued responding to me, I just decided to ignore their posts or brief read them and not respond.

And then this happens.

User avatar
The Archregimancy
Senior Game Moderator
 
Posts: 35002
Founded: Aug 01, 2005
Democratic Socialists

Postby The Archregimancy » Sat Oct 22, 2016 12:58 pm

After careful consideration of the individual's record, appropriate action has been taken.

That it wasn't even his RP, but was rather started by a third party, played a part in the decision; but it wasn't the only factor.

User avatar
Aellex
Senator
 
Posts: 4635
Founded: Apr 23, 2016
Ex-Nation

Postby Aellex » Sat Oct 22, 2016 2:39 pm

Considering this comment was made after more than three pages that were spent by a lot of the people participating in this R.P to try to explain to VOID that his behavior, namely powergaming and refusing to ascribe by the same rule of realism as the rest of us were, was inappropriate.
Considering Void was putting in jeopardy the entire R.P, having pushed one of the member to quit it already.
Considering what a mentor had said previously to VOID :
G-Tech Corporation wrote:If you don't respect your peers enough to consider their opinions, especially when the preponderance of opinions I've seen expressed in this thread seem somewhat dubious about your stated nation, why write with them? I haven't seen anyone forcing you to be a third world nation, merely raising what seem to be valid concerns about the practicality and logic behind your creation.

(a comment which was met by even more stubbornness from VOID.)
Considering Void's language to me and the rest of the other posters had been far from polite.
Considering his foeing was not so much a way to resolve peacefully the situation but rather one to try to enforce his behavior on the rest of us :
The V O I D wrote:I bow for no man.

I'm just going to stick with my lore/nation and what it is in factual land. You guys can pretend it exists in another state, if you wish, but that won't change factland. When the IC goes up, if China and I decide to invade Britannia, I'm going to do it according to my nation's lore and actual military strength and such. Nobody in this thread except for me, myself, I and my brain control my nation, its lore, its capabilities, etc.

If people ignore me on the IC, i'll just keep posting like they didn't. And if they lose territory because they refused to acknowledge me? Oh well, not my problem.

Considering, also, that this report was made as a way to shut an ongoing discussion in which VOID was involved for the previously mentioned reasons and to get a cheap shot at me for opposing him in said discussion.

I would like to, on this ground, complain about the deletion of my nation without any formal sentence nor message informing me of said deletion nor of its reasons and to officially dispute this ruling as well as to ask for a second opinion flare.
I would like to know, especially, if during the careful consideration that preceded my deletion Arch took the time to consult with G-Tech Corporation, the mentor who had been siding with the rest of us during this problem with VOID, or to merely read the last few pages of the thread that leaded to this post before making this unilateral judgement.
Because, while my ad-hominem was an ill move it was in no way something I see meriting unilateral action, to which, if proven so, would see me want my old nation back.
I could have entirely understood an ominous looming from the mods to resolve the situation but a DEAT, and especially a DEAT without any warning nor explanation, was, in my opinion at least, quite overkill.
Citoyen Français. Disillusioned Gaulliste. Catholique.

Tombé au champ d'honneur, add 11400 posts.

Member of the Committee
for Proletarian Morality


RIP Balk, you were too good a shitposter for this site.

User avatar
United Marxist Nations
Post Czar
 
Posts: 33804
Founded: Dec 02, 2011
Ex-Nation

Postby United Marxist Nations » Sat Oct 22, 2016 2:45 pm

I'd also like to come in, as the OP of the thread, to say that I was resolving the issue, and was coming down closer on the side of Aelex than of VOID. And that is partly because VOID directly undermined my authority as OP here:

The V O I D wrote:
United Marxist Nations wrote:They have shitty third world colonies and a rural tundra. You are trying to ignore the consequences of 15-20% of your GDP being in the military. You are not trying to be the same as us, you are trying to be unreasonably strong.


:roll: I'm just gonna continue my existence, as I said.



The problem had already been on the way to being solved when moderation got involved, which just reopened the wound unnecessarily, and undermined my authority on the thread.

Moreover, Aelex and I have similar opinions on this issue, and was quick to come to a compromise, showing that he was of one opinion with me on the matter.
Last edited by United Marxist Nations on Sat Oct 22, 2016 2:57 pm, edited 1 time in total.
The Kievan People wrote: United Marxist Nations: A prayer for every soul, a plan for every economy and a waifu for every man. Solid.

Eastern Orthodox Catechumen. Religious communitarian with Sorelian, Marxist, and Traditionalist influences. Sympathies toward Sunni Islam. All flags/avatars are chosen for aesthetic or humor purposes only
An open mind is like a fortress with its gates unbarred and unguarded.
St. John Chrysostom wrote:A comprehended God is no God.

User avatar
The V O I D
Post Marshal
 
Posts: 16406
Founded: Apr 13, 2014
Father Knows Best State

Postby The V O I D » Sat Oct 22, 2016 3:19 pm

I'd just like to take this moment to inform moderation that while I was a bit impolite, yes, I do not believe I engaged in any direct attacks on anyone, nor any serious rulebreaking behavior. I'd also like to point out that I was mostly acting defensive in that thread argument (which has since been resolved, I believe).

User avatar
G-Tech Corporation
Khan of Spam
 
Posts: 69036
Founded: Feb 03, 2010
Corrupt Dictatorship

Postby G-Tech Corporation » Sat Oct 22, 2016 3:42 pm

It should be noted that, having no connection to the thread, I do not explicitly endorse the views of either side; I was merely illustrating a point relating to cooperation within the realm of P2TM RPing. Knowing that the levels of experience with RPing conventions within the group were variable, I endeavors to clarify the fact that P2TM RPing is by its nature done by consensus, and by convention dictates by the Opening Poster within reasons; ignoring one or the other facets of collaborative RPing is generally detrimental to the enjoyment of all writers involved.

As such, I would note that the degree to which the acrimony in the thread had escalated should perhaps be reassessed when considering actions towards those transgressions reported.
Quite the unofficial fellow. Former P2TM Mentor specializing in faction and nation RPs, as well as RPGs. Always happy to help.

User avatar
Lady Scylla
Post Marshal
 
Posts: 16205
Founded: Nov 22, 2015
Civil Rights Lovefest

Postby Lady Scylla » Sat Oct 22, 2016 3:55 pm

G-Tech Corporation wrote:It should be noted that, having no connection to the thread, I do not explicitly endorse the views of either side; I was merely illustrating a point relating to cooperation within the realm of P2TM RPing. Knowing that the levels of experience with RPing conventions within the group were variable, I endeavors to clarify the fact that P2TM RPing is by its nature done by consensus, and by convention dictates by the Opening Poster within reasons; ignoring one or the other facets of collaborative RPing is generally detrimental to the enjoyment of all writers involved.

As such, I would note that the degree to which the acrimony in the thread had escalated should perhaps be reassessed when considering actions towards those transgressions reported.


Not sure if redundant, if so, apologies -- G-Tech was there on my request for some intervention since they're a Mentor, and I was hoping they could mediate the situation.
~ --- ~ The Queen of Sass ~ --- ~
~BisexualBaddie~
RIP Dyakovo </3


All that is gold does not glitter, not all those who wander are lost; The old that is strong does not wither, deep roots are not reached by the frost.

User avatar
Kyrusia
Retired Moderator
 
Posts: 10140
Founded: Nov 12, 2007
Ex-Nation

Postby Kyrusia » Sat Oct 22, 2016 4:35 pm

This is being reviewed. Everyone's patience is appreciated at this time.
[KYRU]
old. roleplayer. the goat your parents warned you about.

User avatar
Kyrusia
Retired Moderator
 
Posts: 10140
Founded: Nov 12, 2007
Ex-Nation

Postby Kyrusia » Sat Oct 22, 2016 5:04 pm

United Marxist Nations wrote:I'd also like to come in, as the OP of the thread, to say that I was resolving the issue, and was coming down closer on the side of Aelex than of VOID. And that is partly because VOID directly undermined my authority as OP here:

The V O I D wrote:
:roll: I'm just gonna continue my existence, as I said.



The problem had already been on the way to being solved when moderation got involved, which just reopened the wound unnecessarily, and undermined my authority on the thread.

Moreover, Aelex and I have similar opinions on this issue, and was quick to come to a compromise, showing that he was of one opinion with me on the matter.

First and foremost, there are no real means to "undermine" your authority as OP. As OP, in your thread, in boards where thread ownership applies - including Portal to the Multiverse - you are god. You can ban a player from your thread for any reason - including no reason at all. While I understand your attempts to resolve disputes among your own thread, if ever it comes to a point where you feel a player in your thread is no longer willing to approach the table of compromise, you can utilize the powers entitled to you by thread ownership to prohibit them from further participation in your thread. If they continue posting, report this to Moderation and appropriate action will be taken. Of course, these powers entitled by thread ownership are ultimately superseded by Moderation's role of ensuring the rules are followed.

Aellex wrote:Considering this comment was made after more than three pages that were spent by a lot of the people participating in this R.P to try to explain to VOID that his behavior, namely powergaming and refusing to ascribe by the same rule of realism as the rest of us were, was inappropriate.
Considering Void was putting in jeopardy the entire R.P, having pushed one of the member to quit it already.
Considering what a mentor had said previously to VOID :
G-Tech Corporation wrote:If you don't respect your peers enough to consider their opinions, especially when the preponderance of opinions I've seen expressed in this thread seem somewhat dubious about your stated nation, why write with them? I haven't seen anyone forcing you to be a third world nation, merely raising what seem to be valid concerns about the practicality and logic behind your creation.

(a comment which was met by even more stubbornness from VOID.)
Considering Void's language to me and the rest of the other posters had been far from polite.
Considering his foeing was not so much a way to resolve peacefully the situation but rather one to try to enforce his behavior on the rest of us :
The V O I D wrote:I bow for no man.

I'm just going to stick with my lore/nation and what it is in factual land. You guys can pretend it exists in another state, if you wish, but that won't change factland. When the IC goes up, if China and I decide to invade Britannia, I'm going to do it according to my nation's lore and actual military strength and such. Nobody in this thread except for me, myself, I and my brain control my nation, its lore, its capabilities, etc.

If people ignore me on the IC, i'll just keep posting like they didn't. And if they lose territory because they refused to acknowledge me? Oh well, not my problem.

Considering, also, that this report was made as a way to shut an ongoing discussion in which VOID was involved for the previously mentioned reasons and to get a cheap shot at me for opposing him in said discussion.

I would like to, on this ground, complain about the deletion of my nation without any formal sentence nor message informing me of said deletion nor of its reasons and to officially dispute this ruling as well as to ask for a second opinion flare.
I would like to know, especially, if during the careful consideration that preceded my deletion Arch took the time to consult with G-Tech Corporation, the mentor who had been siding with the rest of us during this problem with VOID, or to merely read the last few pages of the thread that leaded to this post before making this unilateral judgement.
Because, while my ad-hominem was an ill move it was in no way something I see meriting unilateral action, to which, if proven so, would see me want my old nation back.
I could have entirely understood an ominous looming from the mods to resolve the situation but a DEAT, and especially a DEAT without any warning nor explanation, was, in my opinion at least, quite overkill.

Mentors are not Moderators, let us get that out of the way. That being said, it is acceptable for them to become involved in a thread and assist in dispute resolution if requested - typically with permission or yield granted by the OP. They cannot, however, force a player to adhere to the consensus of a thread, nor can they force other players to abide by player conventions. They are there, first and foremost, to educate with regards to them and help provide players with tools as to making a judgment as to their own involvement.

"Stubbornness" is not a rule violation; it can be frustrating, as a roleplayer, but it is not a rule violation. Likewise, what may or may not be poor player conduct is, also, not necessarily a rule violation; players are entitled to ignore other players, even in roleplaying threads where they themselves are active. It is up to the players in that given thread to decide how to reconcile this or, in the event no reconciliation can be reached, it is up to the thread OP to take the appropriate action insofar as nothing is otherwise actionable. In short, in events like this, it is up to the OP, not you.

To be blunt here, your record is not spotless. That being said, in this specific instance, your appeal will be granted, in part. Your deletion will be momentarily overturned and your nation restored. Even so, as you yourself acknowledge, your insult was entirely unnecessary and, as you stated, "an ill move." For that, taking into account your record, you will receive a *** 7-day ban for flaming ***. Please note: this applies to you, the player, not simply your current account nor the one that will momentarily be restored.
Last edited by Kyrusia on Sat Oct 22, 2016 5:40 pm, edited 2 times in total.
Reason: Typo.
[KYRU]
old. roleplayer. the goat your parents warned you about.


Advertisement

Remove ads

Return to Moderation

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: Yellowgrass Creek

Advertisement

Remove ads