NATION

PASSWORD

Anarcho-Primitivism: Is the future stuck in the stones?

For discussion and debate about anything. (Not a roleplay related forum; out-of-character commentary only.)

Advertisement

Remove ads

Do you agree with Anarcho-primitivism/green anarchism?

Yes, I do!
9
6%
No, I have a different ideology.
124
78%
Neutral or unsure of a stance.
5
3%
I am a server rack, actually!
15
9%
I have not heard of this before.
5
3%
 
Total votes : 158

User avatar
The Alexanderians
Postmaster-General
 
Posts: 12121
Founded: Oct 03, 2010
Ex-Nation

Postby The Alexanderians » Sun Jul 31, 2016 8:32 pm

Merizoc wrote:
Jute wrote:That would be green anarchism, then. Primitivism is explicitly against most technologies as well.

Technology is so vague. Primitivism is a critique of agriculture and civilization (a byproduct of agriculture), not "technology". A bow is technology. A spear is technology. It's not a term that's relevant to the conversation.

Civilization is kinda required for the VAST majority of technology and infrastructure. Never mind RETAINING that on a cultural and societal level,
Galloism wrote:Or we can go with feminism doesn't exist. We all imagined it. Collectively.
You can't fight the friction
Women belong in the kitchen
Men belong in the kitchen
Everyone belongs in the kitchen
Kitchen has food
I have brought dishonor to my gaming clan
Achesia wrote:Threads like this is why I need to stop coming to NSG....

Marethian Lupanar of Teladre wrote:A bright and cheerful mountain village of chapel-goers~

The Archregimancy wrote:
Hagia Sophia is best church.

Major-Tom wrote:Why am I full of apathy?

I'm just here to be the peanut gallery
уσυ нανєи'т gσт тнє fυℓℓ єffє¢т

User avatar
The New Sea Territory
Post Marshal
 
Posts: 16644
Founded: Dec 13, 2012
Ex-Nation

Postby The New Sea Territory » Sun Jul 31, 2016 9:07 pm

The Alexanderians wrote:
Merizoc wrote:Technology is so vague. Primitivism is a critique of agriculture and civilization (a byproduct of agriculture), not "technology". A bow is technology. A spear is technology. It's not a term that's relevant to the conversation.

Civilization is kinda required for the VAST majority of technology and infrastructure. Never mind RETAINING that on a cultural and societal level,


Define "civilization". Depending on your definition, I might agree.
| Ⓐ ☭ | Anarchist Communist | Heideggerian Marxist | Vegetarian | Bisexual | Stirnerite | Slavic/Germanic Pagan | ᚨ ᛟ |
Solntsa Roshcha --- Postmodern Poyltheist
"Christianity had brutally planted the poisoned blade in the healthy, quivering flesh of all humanity; it had goaded a cold wave
of darkness with mystically brutal fury to dim the serene and festive exultation of the dionysian spirit of our pagan ancestors."
-Renzo Novatore, Verso il Nulla Creatore

User avatar
MERIZoC
Postmaster of the Fleet
 
Posts: 23693
Founded: Dec 05, 2013
Left-wing Utopia

Postby MERIZoC » Sun Jul 31, 2016 9:22 pm

The Alexanderians wrote:
Merizoc wrote:Technology is so vague. Primitivism is a critique of agriculture and civilization (a byproduct of agriculture), not "technology". A bow is technology. A spear is technology. It's not a term that's relevant to the conversation.

Civilization is kinda required for the VAST majority of technology and infrastructure. Never mind RETAINING that on a cultural and societal level,

Sure.
The fact remains that primitivism is not a criticism of "technology" because that wouldn't make any sense.

User avatar
Roskian Federation
Diplomat
 
Posts: 717
Founded: Jul 13, 2016
Ex-Nation

Postby Roskian Federation » Sun Jul 31, 2016 9:25 pm

Merizoc wrote:
The Alexanderians wrote:Civilization is kinda required for the VAST majority of technology and infrastructure. Never mind RETAINING that on a cultural and societal level,

Sure.
The fact remains that primitivism is not a criticism of "technology" because that wouldn't make any sense.


Sorry for butting in, but primitivism is a criticism of technology, or is primitive (synonomous with inferior) technology a social construct???
RIP ROSKI, UNJUSTLY DELETED on 12 JULY 2016 +15,601 posts

RSS Madenska set to fully activate on October 15th
Yugoslovenski and Maldania reaffirm the Central States Alliance

User avatar
MERIZoC
Postmaster of the Fleet
 
Posts: 23693
Founded: Dec 05, 2013
Left-wing Utopia

Postby MERIZoC » Sun Jul 31, 2016 9:27 pm

Roskian Federation wrote:
Merizoc wrote:Sure.
The fact remains that primitivism is not a criticism of "technology" because that wouldn't make any sense.


Sorry for butting in, but primitivism is a criticism of technology, or is primitive (synonomous with inferior) technology a social construct???

What

User avatar
Prosocial
Spokesperson
 
Posts: 171
Founded: May 09, 2016
Ex-Nation

Postby Prosocial » Sun Jul 31, 2016 9:55 pm

Out of the set of all the things I disagree with, it's the one I'm closest to agreeing with.

User avatar
The Alexanderians
Postmaster-General
 
Posts: 12121
Founded: Oct 03, 2010
Ex-Nation

Postby The Alexanderians » Sun Jul 31, 2016 9:55 pm

The New Sea Territory wrote:
The Alexanderians wrote:Civilization is kinda required for the VAST majority of technology and infrastructure. Never mind RETAINING that on a cultural and societal level,


Define "civilization". Depending on your definition, I might agree.

Organization and socialization of human interactions and efforts.

I also got an official one:
civ·i·li·za·tion
ˌsivələˈzāSH(ə)n/
noun
the stage of human social development and organization that is considered most advanced.
"they equated the railroad with progress and civilization"
synonyms: human development, advancement, progress, enlightenment, culture, refinement, sophistication
"a higher stage of civilization"
the process by which a society or place reaches an advanced stage of social development and organization.
the society, culture, and way of life of a particular area.
plural noun: civilizations; plural noun: civilisations
"the great books of Western civilization"
synonyms: culture, society, nation, people
"ancient civilizations"


As a means of pure survival by any and all definitions of Anarcho-Primitivism I find myself opposed on the fact I rather enjoy living. I'm not talking survival odds here. Without tech which is based on large amounts of infrastructure, I have literally zero chance of surviving past a few weeks at best.
Galloism wrote:Or we can go with feminism doesn't exist. We all imagined it. Collectively.
You can't fight the friction
Women belong in the kitchen
Men belong in the kitchen
Everyone belongs in the kitchen
Kitchen has food
I have brought dishonor to my gaming clan
Achesia wrote:Threads like this is why I need to stop coming to NSG....

Marethian Lupanar of Teladre wrote:A bright and cheerful mountain village of chapel-goers~

The Archregimancy wrote:
Hagia Sophia is best church.

Major-Tom wrote:Why am I full of apathy?

I'm just here to be the peanut gallery
уσυ нανєи'т gσт тнє fυℓℓ єffє¢т

User avatar
Dagashi
Envoy
 
Posts: 246
Founded: Jul 26, 2016
Ex-Nation

Postby Dagashi » Mon Aug 01, 2016 7:41 am

Threlizdun wrote:recognize much of what was lost through our separation from nature,


"Lost."

Getting separated from nature was one of the best things to ever happen to us.
Embrace your inner Girliness.

User avatar
Community Values
Minister
 
Posts: 2880
Founded: Nov 14, 2015
Ex-Nation

Postby Community Values » Mon Aug 01, 2016 7:48 am

Who would stop people from progressing technologically? The rain gods?
"Corrupted by wealth and power, your government is like a restaurant with only one dish. They've got a set of Republican waiters on one side and a set of Democratic waiters on the other side. But no matter which set of waiters brings you the dish, the legislative grub is all prepared in the same Wall Street kitchen."
-Huey Long

User avatar
The Alexanderians
Postmaster-General
 
Posts: 12121
Founded: Oct 03, 2010
Ex-Nation

Postby The Alexanderians » Mon Aug 01, 2016 7:49 am

Community Values wrote:Who would stop people from progressing technologically? The rain gods?

Shhh don't anger them, we need rain for our grain fields and to make beer! Oh wait...that requires agriculture and civilization.
Galloism wrote:Or we can go with feminism doesn't exist. We all imagined it. Collectively.
You can't fight the friction
Women belong in the kitchen
Men belong in the kitchen
Everyone belongs in the kitchen
Kitchen has food
I have brought dishonor to my gaming clan
Achesia wrote:Threads like this is why I need to stop coming to NSG....

Marethian Lupanar of Teladre wrote:A bright and cheerful mountain village of chapel-goers~

The Archregimancy wrote:
Hagia Sophia is best church.

Major-Tom wrote:Why am I full of apathy?

I'm just here to be the peanut gallery
уσυ нανєи'т gσт тнє fυℓℓ єffє¢т

User avatar
The Life Planets Union
Spokesperson
 
Posts: 100
Founded: Nov 06, 2009
Ex-Nation

Postby The Life Planets Union » Mon Aug 01, 2016 7:51 am

You're telling me there's enough wild food to sustain seven billion people- or that you didn't think about that far enough- or that you don't care.
Either way, fuck this shit. Any other form of anarchism is preferable.
Community Values wrote:Who would stop people from progressing technologically? The rain gods?

Mobs.
Or what happens after the first apocalypse in A Canticle for Leibowitz.
Back from the grave. The monument to all my sins, and Selena's future.
Wallenburg wrote:
unless it is for science or to appease the gods and goddesses I am pro life

...

What the fuck.

User avatar
Khadgar
Postmaster-General
 
Posts: 11414
Founded: Antiquity
Ex-Nation

Postby Khadgar » Mon Aug 01, 2016 7:51 am

Anarco-primitivism is such an idiotic ideology, particularly on the internet.

User avatar
The Life Planets Union
Spokesperson
 
Posts: 100
Founded: Nov 06, 2009
Ex-Nation

Postby The Life Planets Union » Mon Aug 01, 2016 7:52 am

The Alexanderians wrote:
Community Values wrote:Who would stop people from progressing technologically? The rain gods?

Shhh don't anger them, we need rain for our grain fields and to make beer! Oh wait...that requires agriculture and civilization.

aka 200,000 years of luck.
300 generations from now your children will have beer and bread again. Until then, it's various types of berries and roots. Meat is a luxury for every other generation.
Back from the grave. The monument to all my sins, and Selena's future.
Wallenburg wrote:
unless it is for science or to appease the gods and goddesses I am pro life

...

What the fuck.

User avatar
Alvecia
Postmaster of the Fleet
 
Posts: 20487
Founded: Aug 17, 2015
Democratic Socialists

Postby Alvecia » Mon Aug 01, 2016 7:55 am

Khadgar wrote:Anarco-primitivism is such an idiotic ideology, particularly on the internet.

This gave me the giggles.
It's like advocating for the amish or luddite over the internet.

User avatar
The Alexanderians
Postmaster-General
 
Posts: 12121
Founded: Oct 03, 2010
Ex-Nation

Postby The Alexanderians » Mon Aug 01, 2016 7:56 am

Alvecia wrote:
Khadgar wrote:Anarco-primitivism is such an idiotic ideology, particularly on the internet.

This gave me the giggles.
It's like advocating for the amish or luddite over the internet.

I advocate for the amish.
Their bread is fantastic.
Galloism wrote:Or we can go with feminism doesn't exist. We all imagined it. Collectively.
You can't fight the friction
Women belong in the kitchen
Men belong in the kitchen
Everyone belongs in the kitchen
Kitchen has food
I have brought dishonor to my gaming clan
Achesia wrote:Threads like this is why I need to stop coming to NSG....

Marethian Lupanar of Teladre wrote:A bright and cheerful mountain village of chapel-goers~

The Archregimancy wrote:
Hagia Sophia is best church.

Major-Tom wrote:Why am I full of apathy?

I'm just here to be the peanut gallery
уσυ нανєи'т gσт тнє fυℓℓ єffє¢т

User avatar
Kilobugya
Negotiator
 
Posts: 6878
Founded: Apr 05, 2005
Left-wing Utopia

Postby Kilobugya » Mon Aug 01, 2016 8:03 am

It's not just wrong - it's actually criminal. It would call for massive genocide of at least 90% of world population. It has many other fatal flaws, but just that would be enough to completely and utterly reject it, and stop considering seriously anyone advocating it. The only "good" point of it is that primitivists have actually no chance to achieve their stated goal, the only for such a massive collapse of civilization to happen would be through a world war, dinosaur-killer asteroid, or something similar that is completely out of their reach, so while their ideology is criminal lunacy, they are actually harmless.
Secular humanist and trans-humanist, rationalist, democratic socialist, pacifist, dreaming very high to not perform too low.
Economic Left/Right: -9.50 - Social Libertarian/Authoritarian: -7.69

User avatar
Diopolis
Post Marshal
 
Posts: 17733
Founded: May 15, 2012
Ex-Nation

Postby Diopolis » Mon Aug 01, 2016 8:07 am

There are ideologies that tend to end in mass murder because they're not well thought out, but one that needs to begin with mass murder is a special kind of awful.
Texas nationalist, right-wing technocrat, radical social conservative, post-liberal.

User avatar
Jute
Postmaster-General
 
Posts: 13734
Founded: Jan 28, 2014
Democratic Socialists

Postby Jute » Mon Aug 01, 2016 8:22 am

Ashkera wrote:
Jute wrote:Transhumanism? There's absolutely no need for any opposition of that to be in conflict with support for live-saving surgery.

It's not necessarily within the normal bundle of human enhancement technologies, since it would only enhance healthspan and not increase strength, speed, intelligence, etc beyond the natural peaks for that individual.

For Anarcho-Primitivists, the decision not to conduct surgery with tech from after the year 1900 would be fairly consistent. They're against all the technologies and necessary supply chains.

For non-AnPrims, they are already willing to defy the natural order to extend lifespan. They're even willing to do this with aging, causing the dying process to be drawn out and expensive. Aging involves senility, frailty, and multiple organ failure. Can you imagine what an enormous amount of money a society which had life extension technology but then had people die of aging normally and patched them up during the process would be wasting?

You didn't clarify what you meant with "extending lifespan". Do you mean transhumanistic cyborg enhancements, or just the use or improvement of what we already have now?
Carl Sagan, astrophysicist and atheist wrote:"Science is not only compatible with spirituality; it is a profound source of spirituality.
When we recognize our place in an immensity of light-years and in the passage of ages,
when we grasp the intricacy, beauty, and subtlety of life, then that soaring feeling,
that sense of elation and humility combined, is surely spiritual...
The notion that science and spirituality are somehow mutually exclusive does a disservice to both."
Italios wrote:Jute's probably some sort of Robin Hood-type outlaw
"Boys and girls so happy, young and gay / Don't let false worldly joy carry your hearts away."

See the Jutean language! Talk to me about all. Avian air force flag (via) Is Religion Dangerous?

User avatar
Lady Scylla
Post Marshal
 
Posts: 16195
Founded: Nov 22, 2015
Civil Rights Lovefest

Postby Lady Scylla » Mon Aug 01, 2016 9:04 am

Dagashi wrote:
Threlizdun wrote:recognize much of what was lost through our separation from nature,


"Lost."

Getting separated from nature was one of the best things to ever happen to us.


We're apart of nature, we've hardly separated from it. Being so, anything we do technologically is essentially 'natural'.
~ --- ~ The Queen of Sass ~ --- ~
~BisexualBaddie~
RIP Dyakovo </3


All that is gold does not glitter, not all those who wander are lost; The old that is strong does not wither, deep roots are not reached by the frost.

User avatar
Jello Biafra
Negotiator
 
Posts: 6402
Founded: Antiquity
Left-wing Utopia

Postby Jello Biafra » Mon Aug 01, 2016 9:35 am

There are some good critiques that primitivists make about civilization and society, but ultimately their solutions are worse than the problems they seek to solve.

User avatar
Ashlak
Diplomat
 
Posts: 846
Founded: Oct 29, 2008
Left-wing Utopia

Postby Ashlak » Mon Aug 01, 2016 9:43 am

Lady Scylla wrote:
Dagashi wrote:
"Lost."

Getting separated from nature was one of the best things to ever happen to us.


We're apart of nature, we've hardly separated from it. Being so, anything we do technologically is essentially 'natural'.


This. Humans building skyscrapers are no more unnatural than beavers building dams.

---

Primitivism is absolutely repugnant to me. I don't want to give up civilization and all the wonderful things humanity has accomplished because of it, just because some extremists over romanticize hunter gatherer societies.
I am a girl of the transgender variety


User avatar
Ashkera
Minister
 
Posts: 2516
Founded: May 14, 2015
Ex-Nation

Postby Ashkera » Mon Aug 01, 2016 10:00 am

Jute wrote:You didn't clarify what you meant with "extending lifespan". Do you mean transhumanistic cyborg enhancements, or just the use or improvement of what we already have now?

I am Transhumanist, so obtaining an immortal machine body is not a moral problem for me.

For non Transhumanists, in biological bodies, it would require changes to the genetic code and possibly body transplant operations.
第五大黒森帝国
Practice. Virtue. Harmony. Prosperity.

A secretive Dominant-Party Technocracy located in the southwest of the Pacific Ocean
Factbook: The Fifth Empire of Ashkera [2018/2030] (updated 18.04.29) / Questions
Roaming squads of state-sponsored body-builders teach nerds to lift. "Fifth generation" cruise ships come equipped with naval reactors. Insurance inspectors are more feared than tax auditors. Turbine-powered "super interceptor" police cruisers patrol high-speed highways.

User avatar
Benuty
Post Czar
 
Posts: 39228
Founded: Jan 21, 2013
Ex-Nation

Postby Benuty » Mon Aug 01, 2016 11:40 am

Ashkera wrote:
Jute wrote:You didn't clarify what you meant with "extending lifespan". Do you mean transhumanistic cyborg enhancements, or just the use or improvement of what we already have now?

I am Transhumanist, so obtaining an immortal machine body is not a moral problem for me.

For non Transhumanists, in biological bodies, it would require changes to the genetic code and possibly body transplant operations.

Immortal machines?

The very idea is heresy just look at the C'tan, and see how well being an immortal machine turned out for the necrontyr.
Last edited by Hashem 13.8 billion years ago
King of Madness in the Right Wing Discussion Thread. Winner of 2016 Posters Award for Insanity. My posts in NSG, and P2TM are separate. Participated in the former Roleplay Groups: Varsity Row, Thought Cafe, and the Pub. Supporter of a Free Tibet Christian Pacifist Christian Vegetarian

User avatar
Ashkera
Minister
 
Posts: 2516
Founded: May 14, 2015
Ex-Nation

Postby Ashkera » Mon Aug 01, 2016 11:50 am

Benuty wrote:
Ashkera wrote:I am Transhumanist, so obtaining an immortal machine body is not a moral problem for me.

For non Transhumanists, in biological bodies, it would require changes to the genetic code and possibly body transplant operations.

Immortal machines?

The very idea is heresy just look at the C'tan, and see how well being an immortal machine turned out for the necrontyr.

I don't think the court will take Warhammer 40,000 into evidence. Also didn't you say there was going to be a collapse?
第五大黒森帝国
Practice. Virtue. Harmony. Prosperity.

A secretive Dominant-Party Technocracy located in the southwest of the Pacific Ocean
Factbook: The Fifth Empire of Ashkera [2018/2030] (updated 18.04.29) / Questions
Roaming squads of state-sponsored body-builders teach nerds to lift. "Fifth generation" cruise ships come equipped with naval reactors. Insurance inspectors are more feared than tax auditors. Turbine-powered "super interceptor" police cruisers patrol high-speed highways.

User avatar
Saiwania
Postmaster of the Fleet
 
Posts: 22269
Founded: Jun 30, 2008
Ex-Nation

Postby Saiwania » Mon Aug 01, 2016 11:57 am

Kilobugya wrote:The only "good" point of it is that primitivists have actually no chance to achieve their stated goal, the only for such a massive collapse of civilization to happen would be through a world war, dinosaur-killer asteroid, or something similar that is completely out of their reach, so while their ideology is criminal lunacy, they are actually harmless.


It is easy enough in my view. Humans keep adding carbon dioxide to the atmosphere and so much heat is trapped gradually that life becomes increasingly hard on Earth, to the point where most of civilization collapses, if humans don't go extinct altogether.

There is technology to remove greenhouse gases from the atmosphere, but there are many cost and scaling challenges to actually implementing it on a large enough scale to actually cause CO2 levels to fall back towards normal once again, instead of constantly increasing to where plants and the wider ecosystem can't keep up. A clean up will take many decades of capturing carbon and pumping it into the ground but it can be done.

If humans die out before then, the planet will be hot for centuries but will gradually repair itself and eventually flourish in our absence. People disappearing would technically speaking, be the best possible change for the environment. Our species is almost exactly akin to a virus that constantly expands, destroys, changes everything in our path in an unsustainable fashion. Most of what we do ends up harming our host- which is this planet.
Last edited by Saiwania on Mon Aug 01, 2016 12:00 pm, edited 2 times in total.
Sith Acolyte
Peace is a lie, there is only passion. Through passion, I gain strength. Through strength, I gain power. Through power, I gain victory. Through victory, my chains are broken!

PreviousNext

Advertisement

Remove ads

Return to General

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: -Astoria-, American Legionaries, DutchFormosa, Eahland, Elejamie, Great Lakes Municipalities, Ifreann, Maple Islands, Myrensis, Nu Elysium, Sanctified Hellas, The Archregimancy, The Desperate Bisexual, The Matthew Islands, Valrifell, Vassenor, Zurkerx

Advertisement

Remove ads