NATION

PASSWORD

Condemnations - Perhaps a new Rule #5?

A chamber dedicated to the dissemination of inter-regional peace and goodwill, via force if necessary.
User avatar
A mean old man
Senator
 
Posts: 4444
Founded: Jun 27, 2008
Iron Fist Consumerists

Condemnations - Perhaps a new Rule #5?

Postby A mean old man » Thu May 13, 2010 4:43 pm

Alright; we're having a downwards spike in the quality of condemnations lately, mainly revolving around those being condemned and the reasons for condemning them, and I think we need to step back again and take a look at what's going on and perhaps set a few more basic standards for our WASC proposals.

Some of the specific resolutions I've got in mind here are (but are not limited to):
Condemn Mukkanism
Condemn Valbara
...and numerous failed proposals that have still gotten some disturbingly high approval counts in the queue.

Back while Condemn Greater Tezdrian was being drafted, I remember, very early on, QuoD having a complaint about the mention of the nation violating the terms of a certain standing WAGA resolution within the condemnation's wording. Unibot prudently removed it from the resolution.

However, we're having quite a few ugly encounters with violation of GA resolutions being cited in WASC condemnations nowadays, and it's proving to be, for proposal authors, a lazy way out of actually finding someone worthy of condemnation and a way of avoiding doing some serious work and research to discover what they have done that is truly condemnable.

I believe the argument that JURSIDICTIONS against has made against condemning nations for disobeying the terms of GA legislation in the thread for "Condemn Mukkanism" is absolutely perfect for those who like to think in a very technical fashion:


JURISDICTIONS wrote:It has been tradition that laws of the GA are automatically followed; no nation may even be capable of breaking such laws. However, I pose this question.

Can citizens of said nations break WA law? If true; Then this means that government officials can break laws. If government officials can break laws, then the nation in effect can ignore such laws. If this is true; then it brings the WA to the same fate as the "Real World United Nations" which never gets anything done.

This now makes the WAGA a mockery because laws can be put into place but ignored by governments if the question above is true.

This SC proposal should be illegal, in that... General Assembly Law cannot (meaning "totally impossible by all standards") be violated.



Sure, it's possible for us to disobey WAGA legislation in roleplaying; anyone can do anything when roleplaying. But when it comes to the real game mechanics, we're not really capable of doing what we do in roleplaying. So why allow what is utterly impossible in the roleplaying of the WAGA into the roleplaying of the WASC?

So please - before anyone writes up any more condemnations of random newbies who have defied laws set by the GA and gets their condemnations dangerously close to passing (and may I remind you that it takes little to no effort to defy GA laws - in the case of Mukkanism, with the posting of a single message, and that it takes little to no effort, apparently, to write a condemnation of these people and pull the heartstrings of proud WA delegates in order to get them to quorum ... and what the hell is a "chain-axe," anyway?), can we please think about installing a few basic rules on whether this is actually worthy of a WASC condemnation or not?

I'm all for condemning someone for evil acts in roleplaying, but citing their involvement in the WAGA and basing a proposal around their violation of a GA law seems to have an absurdly strong affect on delegates and will make them approve nearly anything, whether the condemnation is really all that deserved or not.

We could still condemn people without having to state outright in the proposal that it is for their disobedience of GA proposals, right? We could still condemn Mukkanism for cutting apart commies (though I certainly wouldn't, and I'm sure the delegates wouldn't, since they might actually notice how silly the reason for his condemnation was when it's not hidden behind an overly patriotic cry for retribution for the disrespect of GA resolutions) without having to say he was defying GA legislation, couldn't we? For all we know, Mukkanism might not have been a part of the WA when they hacked apart a few communists.

So please - consider a new rule for WASC proposals that prevents people from stating that nations were violating the terms of GA resolutions in their condemnations. From what I've seen, it's only been a detriment to the quality of WASC condemnations. Random nonentities are being condemned for utterly noobish forum posts and half-assed condemnation proposals are reaching quorum and nearly passing. All we need now is for someone with the preaching capabilities of Sedge (that was a compliment, Sedge ;) ) to sit back for ten minutes and write one of these condemnations, and it'll sit in the WASC's history for eternity.


A mean old man wrote:From Corporate's Poll in the forums, which is currently unanimously against this resolution:

A mean old man wrote:Against. I feel a bit guilty opposing it, as the delegate of the author's region asked me for Corporate's delegate's approval for that proposal while it was in the queue (this was during Aven's last days as delegate) in return for his approval of my "Commend The Joint Systems Alliance" and I slightly unwillingly obliged; however, the proposal should've been thought through a bit more during its writing. I'm also getting very sick of condemnations based off of nations' roleplayed decisions to violate the terms of GA resolutions, and fear that, if people readily accept this as a reason to condemn a nation and don't look into the evidence or history of a nation's decisions to disobey GA resolutions, any old newbie roleplayer who decides they want a condemnation badge can simply go violate as many GA resolutions as they like in the roleplaying forums until they attract attention. It doesn't take any work or thought, and complete nonentities like "Mukkanism" will wind up getting condemnation badges and sitting in the history of the WASC for eternity.

No. That is a precedent which must not be set. In fact, I think I'll take that to the WASC forums as a serious complaint. A nation should not be condemned entirely for disobeying GA legislation.


As of right now, Mukkanism has made only 34 posts.

Never before have I heard of this "Mukkanism." Of course, there are plenty of prominent influences in the NationStates world which I have never heard of before, however, after observing this nation and its posting history in the forums, I have confirmed my suspicions that it is a total nonentity.

...so why is such a nonentity being condemned? Well, it's because he disobeyed the terms of WAGA resolutions. So what? Any newbie roleplayer can do that. Does that mean we should be condemning them?

I think the author certainly has potential to write good WASC legislation and certainly has an appealing writing style (otherwise this proposal would not have climbed to where it is now) and should certainly stick around in the WASC forums in the future, but condemning a newbie simply for ignoring WAGA legislation in roleplay is not practical. I can't imagine the long line of poor-quality WASC resolutions which would be passed should this become a popular precedent here.
A: SC#16 - Repeal "Liberate The Security Council"
A: SC#26 - Commend The Joint Systems Alliance
A: SC#30 - Commend 10000 Islands
A: SC#37 - Condemn NAZI EUROPE
A: SC#38 - Repeal "Condemn NAZI EUROPE"
A: GA#149 - On Expiration Dates
C: SC#58 - Repeal "Commend Sedgistan"
A: SC#62 - Repeal "Condemn Swarmlandia"
C: SC#63 - Commend Ballotonia
A: SC#65 - Condemn Punk Reloaded
C: GA#163 - Repeal "Law of the Sea"
A: SC#72 - Repeal "Commend Mikeswill"
C: SC#74 - Condemn Lone Wolves United
C: SC#76 - Repeal "Condemn Thatcherton"
A: SC#81 - Repeal "Condemn Anthony Delasanta"
C: SC#83 - Condemn Automagfreek
C: SC#84 - Repeal "Liberate Islam"
C: SC#111 - Commend Krulltopia ← please forget

User avatar
Unibotian WASC Mission
Diplomat
 
Posts: 729
Founded: Oct 27, 2009
Ex-Nation

Postby Unibotian WASC Mission » Thu May 13, 2010 8:23 pm

QuoD having a complaint about the mention of the nation violating the terms of a certain standing WAGA resolution within the condemnation's wording. Unibot prudently removed it from the resolution.


I removed it, because I respect QuoD's wishes, and I think he's the last person in the univerise who wants a SC resolution with his work represented in it. I agree with Kryo's ruling that the house of cards fallacy should not exist in SC resolutions.

One should not base their entire argument on compliance to particular laws, the key phrase being "should not". Because a repeal could negate your argument, and make your condemnation a likely candidate for a condemnation.

Maybe the rule could be that non-compliance to all or some of WA rules cannot be the sole justification for a resolution. Expressing why such non-compliance is bad, is much better. When someone just lists all of the resolutions that a nominee doesn't obey, it's like white noise to me, I like rhetoric.
Last edited by Unibotian WASC Mission on Thu May 13, 2010 8:26 pm, edited 1 time in total.

User avatar
A mean old man
Senator
 
Posts: 4444
Founded: Jun 27, 2008
Iron Fist Consumerists

Postby A mean old man » Thu May 13, 2010 8:28 pm

The vagueness there worries me, though; what with the power this sort of WA propaganda has in getting condemnations to quorum, I fear what would be your average, quorum-missing, pretty lame proposal could be popped up over the cap and voted on rather often with a little slightly misleading embellishment.

Though I certainly understand your point of view.

However, since IC suddenly seems to be taking over the WASC, I'd expect this new SC to follow IC etiquette as well, right? Even if that isn't the case, the IC side of the SC should be following the proper IC etiquette...
Last edited by A mean old man on Thu May 13, 2010 8:29 pm, edited 2 times in total.
A: SC#16 - Repeal "Liberate The Security Council"
A: SC#26 - Commend The Joint Systems Alliance
A: SC#30 - Commend 10000 Islands
A: SC#37 - Condemn NAZI EUROPE
A: SC#38 - Repeal "Condemn NAZI EUROPE"
A: GA#149 - On Expiration Dates
C: SC#58 - Repeal "Commend Sedgistan"
A: SC#62 - Repeal "Condemn Swarmlandia"
C: SC#63 - Commend Ballotonia
A: SC#65 - Condemn Punk Reloaded
C: GA#163 - Repeal "Law of the Sea"
A: SC#72 - Repeal "Commend Mikeswill"
C: SC#74 - Condemn Lone Wolves United
C: SC#76 - Repeal "Condemn Thatcherton"
A: SC#81 - Repeal "Condemn Anthony Delasanta"
C: SC#83 - Condemn Automagfreek
C: SC#84 - Repeal "Liberate Islam"
C: SC#111 - Commend Krulltopia ← please forget

User avatar
JURISDICTIONS
Chargé d'Affaires
 
Posts: 360
Founded: Nov 03, 2008
Ex-Nation

Proposal For rule change

Postby JURISDICTIONS » Fri May 14, 2010 9:20 am

This is what I posted in the C&C thingy asking for a rule change. And why.

JURISDICTIONS wrote:The At Vote is the SC is concerning.

[AT VOTE] Condemn Mukkanism

Jurisdictions wrote:
It has been tradition that laws of the GA are automatically followed; no nation may even be capable of breaking such laws. However, I pose this question.

Can citizens of said nations break WA law? If true; Then this means that government officials can break laws. If government officials can break laws, then the nation in effect can ignore such laws. If this is true; then it brings the WA to the same fate as the "Real World United Nations" which never gets anything done.

This now makes the WAGA a mockery because laws can be put into place but ignored by governments if the question above is true.

This SC proposal should be illegal, in that... General Assembly Law cannot (meaning "totally impossible by all standards") be violated.

Thank you.

-An OCC/IC speech from the Representative from Jurisdictions


I am going to follow up on what I said, and why we should have this changed.

According to the FAQ:
NationStates FAQ wrote:The World Assembly is the world's governing body. It's your chance to mold the world to your vision, by voting for resolutions you like and scuttling the rest. However, it's a double-edged sword, because your nation will be affected by any resolutions that pass. (Unfortunately you can't obey the resolutions you like and ignore the rest, like real nations.) In other words, it's a hot-bed of political intrigue and double-dealing.


According to the resolution above, a nation's government officials can ignore WA law. If citizens of nations (which includes the officials who govern them) can ignore/break the law of the General Assembly. It will make a mockery of the WA as a whole. And turn the WA into the "UNnamed organization" which by the way gets nothing done because nations and the citizens do not follow the law.

According to NS tradition, GA resolutions are impossible to break. If this resolution passes, the WA will become a mockery of its self.

I push for this rule:

Proposed Rule: / wrote:
Security Council resolutions may not condemn or commend nations for violation of General Assembly resolutions; as General Assembly resolutions are impossible to violate.
You can call me "Juris" for short. Also, you don't have to type my nation name in all caps either.
Last edited by Max Barry on Mon Jan 01, 0001 12:01 am. Edited 000000000000 times in total.
Takaram wrote:Irony. Rule 4 prevents a repeal based on Rule 4 violations, meaning that Rule 4 does not comply with Rule 4. It should be struck down.
Kingdom of Great Britain - Lord Chief Justice
The East Pacific - Viceroy (Chief Justice) and Viceroy Designee (Asst. Chief Justice)
Osiris - Elder (Justice)

User avatar
Oh my Days
Diplomat
 
Posts: 637
Founded: Nov 20, 2008
Ex-Nation

Postby Oh my Days » Fri May 14, 2010 10:54 am

That's good, I'd also like to have:

In Character proposals must be for In Character reasons; e.g. you can't condemn someone for godmodding and claim it is "fraud" or a similar euphemism.


A nation or player can only be Condemned for excelling in a field that has negative consequences for others; e.g. Brutally murdering people in a fantastically efficient way, not for being a rubbish roleplayer, or annoying player etc.


Every proposal that doesn't fit those guidelines has been crap. This would stop the recent, very poor IC C&Cs.
Citizen of The East Pacific and Osiris

User avatar
JURISDICTIONS
Chargé d'Affaires
 
Posts: 360
Founded: Nov 03, 2008
Ex-Nation

We Petition for these rules to be put in place for the SC

Postby JURISDICTIONS » Fri May 14, 2010 11:08 am

These rules NEED to be in place.

Jurisdictions wrote:Security Council resolutions may not condemn or commend nations for violation of General Assembly resolutions; as General Assembly resolutions are impossible to violate.


Oh my days wrote:In Character proposals must be for In Character reasons; e.g. you can't condemn someone for godmodding and claim it is "fraud" or a similar euphemism.


Oh my days wrote:A nation or player can only be Condemned for excelling in a field that has negative consequences for others; e.g. Brutally murdering people in a fantastically efficient way, not for being a rubbish roleplayer, or annoying player etc.
You can call me "Juris" for short. Also, you don't have to type my nation name in all caps either.
Last edited by Max Barry on Mon Jan 01, 0001 12:01 am. Edited 000000000000 times in total.
Takaram wrote:Irony. Rule 4 prevents a repeal based on Rule 4 violations, meaning that Rule 4 does not comply with Rule 4. It should be struck down.
Kingdom of Great Britain - Lord Chief Justice
The East Pacific - Viceroy (Chief Justice) and Viceroy Designee (Asst. Chief Justice)
Osiris - Elder (Justice)

User avatar
Oh my Days
Diplomat
 
Posts: 637
Founded: Nov 20, 2008
Ex-Nation

Postby Oh my Days » Fri May 14, 2010 12:47 pm

JURISDICTIONS wrote:These rules NEED to be in place.

Jurisdictions wrote:Security Council resolutions may not condemn or commend nations for violation of General Assembly resolutions; as General Assembly resolutions are impossible to violate.


Oh my days wrote:In Character proposals must be for In Character reasons; e.g. you can't condemn someone for godmodding and claim it is "fraud" or a similar euphemism.


Oh my days wrote:A nation or player can only be Condemned for excelling in a field that has negative consequences for others; e.g. Brutally murdering people in a fantastically efficient way, not for being a rubbish roleplayer, or annoying player etc.


Agreed absolutely, it would also do away with any need for rule 4, seeing as the proposals that flame would be much better covered by this ruleset.
Citizen of The East Pacific and Osiris

User avatar
JURISDICTIONS
Chargé d'Affaires
 
Posts: 360
Founded: Nov 03, 2008
Ex-Nation

Postby JURISDICTIONS » Fri May 14, 2010 1:02 pm

Yes. Ard needs to see this, the mods need to see this. Can someone get a hold of Ard?
You can call me "Juris" for short. Also, you don't have to type my nation name in all caps either.
Last edited by Max Barry on Mon Jan 01, 0001 12:01 am. Edited 000000000000 times in total.
Takaram wrote:Irony. Rule 4 prevents a repeal based on Rule 4 violations, meaning that Rule 4 does not comply with Rule 4. It should be struck down.
Kingdom of Great Britain - Lord Chief Justice
The East Pacific - Viceroy (Chief Justice) and Viceroy Designee (Asst. Chief Justice)
Osiris - Elder (Justice)

User avatar
Oh my Days
Diplomat
 
Posts: 637
Founded: Nov 20, 2008
Ex-Nation

Postby Oh my Days » Fri May 14, 2010 1:27 pm

She'll see it in good time, she has always been good at answering our concerns and has never shirked the responsibility she was landed with after the creation of the SC. Ard said in the thread on Rule 4 that she's busy with tax returns at the moment, so she may still be doing that.
Citizen of The East Pacific and Osiris

User avatar
A mean old man
Senator
 
Posts: 4444
Founded: Jun 27, 2008
Iron Fist Consumerists

Postby A mean old man » Fri May 14, 2010 1:37 pm

JURISDICTIONS wrote:
Proposed Rule: / wrote:
Security Council resolutions may not condemn or commend nations for violation of General Assembly resolutions; as General Assembly resolutions are impossible to violate.


A nice, short way of putting it.

Oh my Days wrote:That's good, I'd also like to have:

In Character proposals must be for In Character reasons; e.g. you can't condemn someone for godmodding and claim it is "fraud" or a similar euphemism.


A nation or player can only be Condemned for excelling in a field that has negative consequences for others; e.g. Brutally murdering people in a fantastically efficient way, not for being a rubbish roleplayer, or annoying player etc.


Every proposal that doesn't fit those guidelines has been crap. This would stop the recent, very poor IC C&Cs.


That would get rid of miserably silly proposals like "Condemn Kalasparata" and prevent things like one of the few (if not the only?) INSTA-REPEALED resolutions the WA has ever seen, Condemn Ninja pirate awesome town, from passing.
Though the mods would certainly need to be somewhat lenient with rules like these, as there could be proposals made that are actually decent that might slightly infringe upon them in some way.
A: SC#16 - Repeal "Liberate The Security Council"
A: SC#26 - Commend The Joint Systems Alliance
A: SC#30 - Commend 10000 Islands
A: SC#37 - Condemn NAZI EUROPE
A: SC#38 - Repeal "Condemn NAZI EUROPE"
A: GA#149 - On Expiration Dates
C: SC#58 - Repeal "Commend Sedgistan"
A: SC#62 - Repeal "Condemn Swarmlandia"
C: SC#63 - Commend Ballotonia
A: SC#65 - Condemn Punk Reloaded
C: GA#163 - Repeal "Law of the Sea"
A: SC#72 - Repeal "Commend Mikeswill"
C: SC#74 - Condemn Lone Wolves United
C: SC#76 - Repeal "Condemn Thatcherton"
A: SC#81 - Repeal "Condemn Anthony Delasanta"
C: SC#83 - Condemn Automagfreek
C: SC#84 - Repeal "Liberate Islam"
C: SC#111 - Commend Krulltopia ← please forget

User avatar
Oh my Days
Diplomat
 
Posts: 637
Founded: Nov 20, 2008
Ex-Nation

Postby Oh my Days » Fri May 14, 2010 1:45 pm

A mean old man wrote:That would get rid of miserably silly proposals like "Condemn Kalasparata" and prevent things like one of the few (if not the only?) INSTA-REPEALED resolutions the WA has ever seen, Condemn Ninja pirate awesome town, from passing.
Though the mods would certainly need to be somewhat lenient with rules like these, as there could be proposals made that are actually decent that might slightly infringe upon them in some way.


I've been trying to think of what good proposals it could rule out, can you think of anything specific?
Citizen of The East Pacific and Osiris

User avatar
Naivetry
Ambassador
 
Posts: 1294
Founded: Aug 02, 2006
Liberal Democratic Socialists

Postby Naivetry » Mon May 17, 2010 10:44 am

I can't.

I like the suggestions so far, with one caveat (which QoD pointed out when I was ranting about this):

In Character proposals must be for In Character reasons; e.g. you can't condemn someone for godmodding and claim it is "fraud" or a similar euphemism.


We can't get at their motivations if they choose to conceal them. We can (and, I think, should) make this a recommendation, but we could never really enforce it as a rule. What would you think about, instead, requiring that all Condemnations written for RP reasons be debated entirely RP-In Character? That would at least get the miserable 'yeah, he's a noob, I hate him, he's going down' posts out of the SC.

(On the flip side of this, I don't particularly care if people post RP-IC in Gameplay threads. It ranges from rude to hilarious, depending on who's doing it, and I wouldn't want to rob people of their fun.)

User avatar
A mean old man
Senator
 
Posts: 4444
Founded: Jun 27, 2008
Iron Fist Consumerists

Postby A mean old man » Mon May 17, 2010 2:21 pm

Naivetry wrote:We can't get at their motivations if they choose to conceal them. We can (and, I think, should) make this a recommendation, but we could never really enforce it as a rule. What would you think about, instead, requiring that all Condemnations written for RP reasons be debated entirely RP-In Character? That would at least get the miserable 'yeah, he's a noob, I hate him, he's going down' posts out of the SC.


Although I can't imagine how that would be enforced. Quite a few people draw a very thin and wiggly line between IC and OOC as well. This particular idea might be a bit of a pipe dream.
A: SC#16 - Repeal "Liberate The Security Council"
A: SC#26 - Commend The Joint Systems Alliance
A: SC#30 - Commend 10000 Islands
A: SC#37 - Condemn NAZI EUROPE
A: SC#38 - Repeal "Condemn NAZI EUROPE"
A: GA#149 - On Expiration Dates
C: SC#58 - Repeal "Commend Sedgistan"
A: SC#62 - Repeal "Condemn Swarmlandia"
C: SC#63 - Commend Ballotonia
A: SC#65 - Condemn Punk Reloaded
C: GA#163 - Repeal "Law of the Sea"
A: SC#72 - Repeal "Commend Mikeswill"
C: SC#74 - Condemn Lone Wolves United
C: SC#76 - Repeal "Condemn Thatcherton"
A: SC#81 - Repeal "Condemn Anthony Delasanta"
C: SC#83 - Condemn Automagfreek
C: SC#84 - Repeal "Liberate Islam"
C: SC#111 - Commend Krulltopia ← please forget

User avatar
Naivetry
Ambassador
 
Posts: 1294
Founded: Aug 02, 2006
Liberal Democratic Socialists

Postby Naivetry » Mon May 17, 2010 2:36 pm

A mean old man wrote:
Naivetry wrote:We can't get at their motivations if they choose to conceal them. We can (and, I think, should) make this a recommendation, but we could never really enforce it as a rule. What would you think about, instead, requiring that all Condemnations written for RP reasons be debated entirely RP-In Character? That would at least get the miserable 'yeah, he's a noob, I hate him, he's going down' posts out of the SC.


Although I can't imagine how that would be enforced. Quite a few people draw a very thin and wiggly line between IC and OOC as well. This particular idea might be a bit of a pipe dream.

For Gameplay, yes, the line can be squiggly. But for RP? There's a clear difference to me between "Yeah, he's a jerk, he made the conference not fun for anybody" and "The Betrthanuian ambassador looks to his neighbor and whispers, 'Yeah, the delegation from NOOBX screwed up that conference for everyone - did you hear about the missile strike they ordered in the middle of the opening ceremony?' "

User avatar
Snefaldia
Diplomat
 
Posts: 864
Founded: Dec 05, 2006
Inoffensive Centrist Democracy

Postby Snefaldia » Mon May 17, 2010 2:46 pm

The stench of one affiliated with the Antarctic Oasis fills the air, the pollution of the General Assembly hangs heavy, like fog...

I should point out that while, yes, in technical practice GA resolutions are automatically complied with, people still RP their disobedience, or even leave the WA so they won't have to suffer the ill-effects. Some nations even RP government bureaus whose sole purpose is to find loopholes in the law.

I see no reason, then, to have a blanket ban on mentioning any GA resolutions. An example:

Gofuckyourselfistan opposes the WA Anti-Rape treaty. The WA Anti-Rape Treaty passes. Gofuckyourselfistan leaves the WA in protest, legalising rape in the process. Can we them condemn Gofuckyourselfistan for their horrendous behaviour and support of rape in opposition to the WA?

I'm also not convinced of the argument that GA resolutions cannot be violated. No one is entirely sure how the game code writes issues or resolutions; theoretically it's possible for a nation brought into compliance with the WA Anti-Rape Treaty could get a daily issue that allows them to legalize rape. Right?

User avatar
A mean old man
Senator
 
Posts: 4444
Founded: Jun 27, 2008
Iron Fist Consumerists

Postby A mean old man » Mon May 17, 2010 2:49 pm

Naivetry wrote:-snip-


Eh; I think I've seen squigglier. Plus, like I said, imagine the tumult that would come out of enforcing it...

Though it's not a bad idea. Installing a lenient "RP proposals should be answered IC unless an OOC tag is provided" rule/guideline could be helpful.
A: SC#16 - Repeal "Liberate The Security Council"
A: SC#26 - Commend The Joint Systems Alliance
A: SC#30 - Commend 10000 Islands
A: SC#37 - Condemn NAZI EUROPE
A: SC#38 - Repeal "Condemn NAZI EUROPE"
A: GA#149 - On Expiration Dates
C: SC#58 - Repeal "Commend Sedgistan"
A: SC#62 - Repeal "Condemn Swarmlandia"
C: SC#63 - Commend Ballotonia
A: SC#65 - Condemn Punk Reloaded
C: GA#163 - Repeal "Law of the Sea"
A: SC#72 - Repeal "Commend Mikeswill"
C: SC#74 - Condemn Lone Wolves United
C: SC#76 - Repeal "Condemn Thatcherton"
A: SC#81 - Repeal "Condemn Anthony Delasanta"
C: SC#83 - Condemn Automagfreek
C: SC#84 - Repeal "Liberate Islam"
C: SC#111 - Commend Krulltopia ← please forget

User avatar
Glen-Rhodes
Powerbroker
 
Posts: 9027
Founded: Jun 25, 2008
Ex-Nation

Postby Glen-Rhodes » Mon May 17, 2010 2:51 pm

A mean old man wrote:Sure, it's possible for us to disobey WAGA legislation in roleplaying; anyone can do anything when roleplaying. But when it comes to the real game mechanics, we're not really capable of doing what we do in roleplaying. So why allow what is utterly impossible in the roleplaying of the WAGA into the roleplaying of the WASC?

First, a little disclaimer: I'm not really sure if I'm reading this right, so if the below is completely inaccurate, feel free to correct my interpretation of what you're asking for.

Erm, that's a bit unfair, dontcha think? Roleplayed noncompliance is perfectly allowable in the World Assembly. C&Cs are not solely a Gameplay mechanism; they can be used by roleplayers, as well. So, it would make sense for a roleplayer to want to condemn a nation that roleplays noncompliance with a World Assembly resolution. Whether or not the condemnation would ever come to vote is questionable, given the Gameplay-centric use of the SC. But that's no reason to ban those types of C&Cs. There is admittedly a problem when we try and condemn somebody for OOC actions based on GA resolutions; but there isn't a real problem with condemning a roleplayed nation for actions based on GA resolutions.

User avatar
Naivetry
Ambassador
 
Posts: 1294
Founded: Aug 02, 2006
Liberal Democratic Socialists

Postby Naivetry » Mon May 17, 2010 3:37 pm

A mean old man wrote:
Naivetry wrote:-snip-


Eh; I think I've seen squigglier. Plus, like I said, imagine the tumult that would come out of enforcing it...

Though it's not a bad idea. Installing a lenient "RP proposals should be answered IC unless an OOC tag is provided" rule/guideline could be helpful.

Yeah, it wasn't meant to be a particularly squiggly example.

Either way, surely it would be better than the free-for-all we have now. A lot of people aren't even trying to pretend they're IC when commenting on a resolution written IC, which just reinforces the idea that the SC exists so people can pick on someone they think is an obnoxious player, while using IC offenses as a transparent excuse.
Last edited by Naivetry on Mon May 17, 2010 3:38 pm, edited 1 time in total.

User avatar
Glen-Rhodes
Powerbroker
 
Posts: 9027
Founded: Jun 25, 2008
Ex-Nation

Postby Glen-Rhodes » Mon May 17, 2010 4:24 pm

Naivetry wrote:Either way, surely it would be better than the free-for-all we have now. A lot of people aren't even trying to pretend they're IC when commenting on a resolution written IC, which just reinforces the idea that the SC exists so people can pick on someone they think is an obnoxious player, while using IC offenses as a transparent excuse.

Oh, come on. That is a very narrow way of thinking. You (and I use the term generically) don't think that you're picking on somebody you think is an obnoxious player when you're condemning a raider? And hiding behind a facade of righteous defender authority? It's all a matter of opinion.
Last edited by Glen-Rhodes on Mon May 17, 2010 4:25 pm, edited 1 time in total.

User avatar
Urgench
Minister
 
Posts: 2375
Founded: May 21, 2008
Ex-Nation

Postby Urgench » Mon May 17, 2010 5:17 pm

So what's being proposed here is to do to IC resolutions the exact same thing which many of you (AMOM) seem to oppose being done to OOC resolutions? You advocate removing the ability of GA players and other WA players to condemn one another for non-compliance while seeming to want to continue to allow a free hand in OOC resolutions where a rule change has ben introduced to try to stop the kind of bullying which you want to stop with this proposed change.

I'm not particularly concerned either way, because I wont be authoring a condemnation for non-compliance but it seems a bit rich that you'll defend the right to speak freely in Gameplay terms while trying to stamp out freedom to speak in GA terms. No?


The whole massive flaw in Condemnations is that they can be blatantly used, and have been, as a tool of bullying and alienation. It is their very nature.
Last edited by Urgench on Mon May 17, 2010 5:35 pm, edited 3 times in total.
- Mongkha, Khan of Kashgar, Ambassador in Plenipotentiary to the World Assembly for the Federated Sublime Khanate of Urgench -

Exchange Embassies with the FSKU here - http://forum.nationstates.net/viewtopic.php?f=5&t=67

User avatar
Naivetry
Ambassador
 
Posts: 1294
Founded: Aug 02, 2006
Liberal Democratic Socialists

Postby Naivetry » Mon May 17, 2010 5:21 pm

Glen-Rhodes wrote:
Naivetry wrote:Either way, surely it would be better than the free-for-all we have now. A lot of people aren't even trying to pretend they're IC when commenting on a resolution written IC, which just reinforces the idea that the SC exists so people can pick on someone they think is an obnoxious player, while using IC offenses as a transparent excuse.

Oh, come on. That is a very narrow way of thinking. You (and I use the term generically) don't think that you're picking on somebody you think is an obnoxious player when you're condemning a raider? And hiding behind a facade of righteous defender authority? It's all a matter of opinion.

No, I don't, because no, we're not. It's not a matter of opinion; it's a matter of facts.

I have not and never will condemn someone for playing the game poorly. The only Condemnation I will ever support for a raider will be for a raider who is very, very good at what he does.

Look at the Gameplay resolutions passed - we're not C/Cing people for being noobs. If we're annoyed at noob raiders, we deal with them as we always have - by reporting them when they break the rules, and beating them when they raid. We don't come here and set out to give them shiny badges the way the latest spurt of RP-IC resolutions have done to noob RPers. If you think Gameplay C/C's are just the same kind of player-to-player OOC snarking that's been happening here lately, then by all means call us out on it when you see it happening.

EDIT: Oh, Urgench's post was so not to me.
EDIT4: ...I think.

Urgench, were you objecting to the idea of outlawing Condemnations for non-compliance, or to the idea of enforcing RP-IC standards in RP-IC Condemnation threads?
Last edited by Naivetry on Mon May 17, 2010 5:27 pm, edited 4 times in total.

User avatar
Urgench
Minister
 
Posts: 2375
Founded: May 21, 2008
Ex-Nation

Postby Urgench » Mon May 17, 2010 5:27 pm

Naivetry wrote:
EDIT: Oh, Urgench's post was so not to me. :blush:



Yeah actually sorry it wasn't that was a misquote.
- Mongkha, Khan of Kashgar, Ambassador in Plenipotentiary to the World Assembly for the Federated Sublime Khanate of Urgench -

Exchange Embassies with the FSKU here - http://forum.nationstates.net/viewtopic.php?f=5&t=67

User avatar
Urgench
Minister
 
Posts: 2375
Founded: May 21, 2008
Ex-Nation

Postby Urgench » Mon May 17, 2010 5:33 pm

Naivetry wrote:
Urgench, were you objecting to the idea of outlawing Condemnations for non-compliance, or to the idea of enforcing RP-IC standards in RP-IC Condemnation threads?



I'm not objecting to anything, I'm pointing out that strange double standard which is inherent in discussing outlawing condemnations for non-compliance while opposing outlawing OOC language in C&Cs.
Last edited by Urgench on Mon May 17, 2010 5:34 pm, edited 1 time in total.
- Mongkha, Khan of Kashgar, Ambassador in Plenipotentiary to the World Assembly for the Federated Sublime Khanate of Urgench -

Exchange Embassies with the FSKU here - http://forum.nationstates.net/viewtopic.php?f=5&t=67

User avatar
Unibot
Senator
 
Posts: 4291
Founded: May 25, 2008
Ex-Nation

Postby Unibot » Mon May 17, 2010 5:45 pm

Urgench wrote:So what's being proposed here is to do to IC resolutions the exact same thing which many of you (AMOM) seem to oppose being done to OOC resolutions? You advocate removing the ability of GA players and other WA players to condemn one another for non-compliance while seeming to want to continue to allow a free hand in OOC resolutions where a rule change has ben introduced to try to stop the kind of bullying which you want to stop with this proposed change.

I'm not particularly concerned either way, because I wont be authoring a condemnation for non-compliance but it seems a bit rich that you'll defend the right to speak freely in Gameplay terms while trying to stamp out freedom to speak in GA terms. No?


The whole massive flaw in Condemnations is that they can be blatantly used, and have been, as a tool of bullying and alienation. It is their very nature.


True. I revoke my earlier statement.

Even non-compliance without further rhetoric can be used as an argument, it's just not a very good argument. I suppose, however, one could suggest that the Security Council and the Compliance Commission are two separate entities with separate tasks, then non-compliance is only an issue for the Security Council when it threatens peace and goodwill.
Last edited by Unibot on Mon May 17, 2010 5:49 pm, edited 1 time in total.

User avatar
Glen-Rhodes
Powerbroker
 
Posts: 9027
Founded: Jun 25, 2008
Ex-Nation

Postby Glen-Rhodes » Mon May 17, 2010 5:46 pm

Naivetry wrote:I have not and never will condemn someone for playing the game poorly. The only Condemnation I will ever support for a raider will be for a raider who is very, very good at what he does.

I expect the next "let's condemn a raider for raiding" C&C to mention how good the nation is a raiding, then. Or the next Liberation to mention what a swell job the raiders did with that region.
Last edited by Glen-Rhodes on Mon May 17, 2010 5:47 pm, edited 2 times in total.

Next

Advertisement

Remove ads

Return to Security Council

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: Islandwalk, Merethin

Advertisement

Remove ads