Some of the specific resolutions I've got in mind here are (but are not limited to):
Condemn Mukkanism
Condemn Valbara
...and numerous failed proposals that have still gotten some disturbingly high approval counts in the queue.
Back while Condemn Greater Tezdrian was being drafted, I remember, very early on, QuoD having a complaint about the mention of the nation violating the terms of a certain standing WAGA resolution within the condemnation's wording. Unibot prudently removed it from the resolution.
However, we're having quite a few ugly encounters with violation of GA resolutions being cited in WASC condemnations nowadays, and it's proving to be, for proposal authors, a lazy way out of actually finding someone worthy of condemnation and a way of avoiding doing some serious work and research to discover what they have done that is truly condemnable.
I believe the argument that JURSIDICTIONS against has made against condemning nations for disobeying the terms of GA legislation in the thread for "Condemn Mukkanism" is absolutely perfect for those who like to think in a very technical fashion:
JURISDICTIONS wrote:It has been tradition that laws of the GA are automatically followed; no nation may even be capable of breaking such laws. However, I pose this question.
Can citizens of said nations break WA law? If true; Then this means that government officials can break laws. If government officials can break laws, then the nation in effect can ignore such laws. If this is true; then it brings the WA to the same fate as the "Real World United Nations" which never gets anything done.
This now makes the WAGA a mockery because laws can be put into place but ignored by governments if the question above is true.
This SC proposal should be illegal, in that... General Assembly Law cannot (meaning "totally impossible by all standards") be violated.
Sure, it's possible for us to disobey WAGA legislation in roleplaying; anyone can do anything when roleplaying. But when it comes to the real game mechanics, we're not really capable of doing what we do in roleplaying. So why allow what is utterly impossible in the roleplaying of the WAGA into the roleplaying of the WASC?
So please - before anyone writes up any more condemnations of random newbies who have defied laws set by the GA and gets their condemnations dangerously close to passing (and may I remind you that it takes little to no effort to defy GA laws - in the case of Mukkanism, with the posting of a single message, and that it takes little to no effort, apparently, to write a condemnation of these people and pull the heartstrings of proud WA delegates in order to get them to quorum ... and what the hell is a "chain-axe," anyway?), can we please think about installing a few basic rules on whether this is actually worthy of a WASC condemnation or not?
I'm all for condemning someone for evil acts in roleplaying, but citing their involvement in the WAGA and basing a proposal around their violation of a GA law seems to have an absurdly strong affect on delegates and will make them approve nearly anything, whether the condemnation is really all that deserved or not.
We could still condemn people without having to state outright in the proposal that it is for their disobedience of GA proposals, right? We could still condemn Mukkanism for cutting apart commies (though I certainly wouldn't, and I'm sure the delegates wouldn't, since they might actually notice how silly the reason for his condemnation was when it's not hidden behind an overly patriotic cry for retribution for the disrespect of GA resolutions) without having to say he was defying GA legislation, couldn't we? For all we know, Mukkanism might not have been a part of the WA when they hacked apart a few communists.
So please - consider a new rule for WASC proposals that prevents people from stating that nations were violating the terms of GA resolutions in their condemnations. From what I've seen, it's only been a detriment to the quality of WASC condemnations. Random nonentities are being condemned for utterly noobish forum posts and half-assed condemnation proposals are reaching quorum and nearly passing. All we need now is for someone with the preaching capabilities of Sedge (that was a compliment, Sedge
) to sit back for ten minutes and write one of these condemnations, and it'll sit in the WASC's history for eternity.




