NATION

PASSWORD

56% of British women say rape blame lies with the raped

For discussion and debate about anything. (Not a roleplay related forum; out-of-character commentary only.)

Advertisement

Remove ads

User avatar
AngloSaxonLand
Bureaucrat
 
Posts: 57
Founded: Feb 14, 2010
Ex-Nation

Postby AngloSaxonLand » Fri Feb 26, 2010 4:40 pm

Dyakovo wrote:No, the blame for the rape falls squarely on the shoulders of the rapist.


This thread should of been over by 2nd post.

User avatar
Ifreann
Post Overlord
 
Posts: 178531
Founded: Aug 07, 2005
Scandinavian Liberal Paradise

Postby Ifreann » Fri Feb 26, 2010 4:40 pm

Glorious Freedonia wrote:
Muravyets wrote:
Glorious Freedonia wrote:Woman A knows that Woman B would be raped because rapists are monsters that keep on raping until they are stopped. Because Woman A identified the rapist and did nothing she could have prevented Woman B from getting the raped.

You're talking about taking "Good Samaritan" laws to a whole new, crazy-ass level, because to hold a rape victim culpable for not preventing a crime would require the police to track down and investigate people who, otherwise, would never cross their radar. How do you expect them to know someone did not report a crime? They'd have to first get a rapist to confess to all the rapes he has committed, then go and investigate all those victims to see if any of them did not report it. Which means the rapist would have to be able to identify who his victims are. Then those victims get to be punished for not doing something. Of course, that would have to presume that, if they had reported the rape, their attacker would have been found and arrested, tried, and convicted anyway. At what point are you going to see just how ridiculous your argument is?

Or perhaps you just want women who have been raped to also be emotionally oppressed by the guilt of knowing they have also failed to meet your persnickety standards for how moral and righteous they should be. Of course, that runs into the problem of (a) the majority of women not even knowing you exist (which I suppose is their fault as well) and (b) the majority of women not giving a shit what you think.

I never claimed that nonreporting witnesses to rape should be punished. However, I firmly believe tha twe have a moral and civic duty to report violent crimes to the legal authorities. The fact that you do not think this was makes me a little uneasy. Are you a rapist or some other type of depraved deviant?

Have you stopped beating your wife?
He/Him
I, for one, wasn't having an affair with Jensen Huang
Saoirse don Phalaistín

User avatar
Muravyets
Postmaster-General
 
Posts: 12755
Founded: Aug 18, 2005
Ex-Nation

Postby Muravyets » Fri Feb 26, 2010 4:42 pm

Ifreann wrote:
Glorious Freedonia wrote:
Bottle wrote:
Glorious Freedonia wrote:
Dempublicents1 wrote:
Hayteria wrote:4. Even if you assume each rapist will continue raping until stopped, what if woman A doesn't agree with said assumption?


I would add to this one that rapists will often do whatever they can to convince their victims that it really is the victim's fault. The effect that has, both emotionally and psychologically, can lead a woman to believe that the rapist wouldn't hurt anyone else, because he really wasn't trying to hurt her.


This is insane. A rapist rapes a girl then tells her that she was not raped and she believes it. This is nonsense. If a woman cant trust her rapist who can she trust? Nobody thinks like that. Nobody trusts a rapist people hardly trust anybody but certainly not their rapists.

Are you kidding me?

THIS THREAD is full of people explaining all the various ways that women can be blamed for their own rapes. And this thread is just a tiny, relatively civil taste of what the rest of the world is like. (Yes, even in "civilized" countries like the USA.)

It's not just rapists telling women that they are to blame for rape. IT IS EVERYBODY ELSE TOO. It's a concerted effort, that you can see IN THIS THREAD, RIGHT IN FRONT OF YOU.

The rapist tells her, "See, you liked it, I knew you were just saying no when you meant yes." Then, when the woman goes to report the rape, the cops say, "Now, did you REALLY say no? Clearly? And you're sure you meant it, and you're sure he understood? You're really, really sure you didn't lead him on? I mean, you did go to his room, after all. You must have been expecting something. Are you really, really sure you said no?" And her friends say, "But he's a nice guy, I've hung out with him, I'm sure it's all just a misunderstanding." And his family says, "We know him, he'd never do that, she must have lead him on." And her family says, "Why were you going up to a boy's room in the first place?" And the media says, "DRUNKEN COED CRIES RAPE!"

And then concern trolls say, "Gosh, why do silly silly women think they are to blame for getting raped? Wherever would they get that silly silly idea?"


I still do not believe that women are responsible for being raped. Rape victims have a moral and civic duty to report their rapes so that the bad guys can got locked up. Police have a duty to investigate and do their best to make sure that they are arresting the right guy and if that means asking the primary rape victim what did or did not happen I do not see a problem with that. I cannot believe that truly raped people would believe a rapist or anyone else when they tell them that they deserved it or whatever. Sure there are people with guilty consciences who feel that they deserved harm because of harm they caused in the past but I am not really talking about those folks.

One person told you that you were a rapist, and you believed it. And we are to believe that if it was not one person, but a whole society, that a woman would just know she had been raped. Dude, seriously?

Well, why not? Women are responsible for everything else and expected to be better, stronger, smarter, more noble, etc, etc, than men in all things -- why not this one too? We're to blame for men getting hard-ons. We're to blame for men raping us. We're to blame for men know understanding what "no" means. Obviously, we're to blame for the mind games rapists play on us, too. A man can be misled by someone who wants to do him harm, but it's just silly to think a woman could be similarly misled because we're supposed to be the responsible ones.
Kick back at Cafe Muravyets
And check out my other RP, too. (Don't take others' word for it -- see for yourself. ;) )
I agree with Muravyets because she scares me. -- Verdigroth
However, I am still not the topic of this thread.

User avatar
Glorious Freedonia
Negotiator
 
Posts: 6137
Founded: Jun 09, 2006
Ex-Nation

Postby Glorious Freedonia » Fri Feb 26, 2010 4:42 pm

Ifreann wrote:
Glorious Freedonia wrote:
Muravyets wrote:
Glorious Freedonia wrote:Woman A knows that Woman B would be raped because rapists are monsters that keep on raping until they are stopped. Because Woman A identified the rapist and did nothing she could have prevented Woman B from getting the raped.

You're talking about taking "Good Samaritan" laws to a whole new, crazy-ass level, because to hold a rape victim culpable for not preventing a crime would require the police to track down and investigate people who, otherwise, would never cross their radar. How do you expect them to know someone did not report a crime? They'd have to first get a rapist to confess to all the rapes he has committed, then go and investigate all those victims to see if any of them did not report it. Which means the rapist would have to be able to identify who his victims are. Then those victims get to be punished for not doing something. Of course, that would have to presume that, if they had reported the rape, their attacker would have been found and arrested, tried, and convicted anyway. At what point are you going to see just how ridiculous your argument is?

Or perhaps you just want women who have been raped to also be emotionally oppressed by the guilt of knowing they have also failed to meet your persnickety standards for how moral and righteous they should be. Of course, that runs into the problem of (a) the majority of women not even knowing you exist (which I suppose is their fault as well) and (b) the majority of women not giving a shit what you think.

I never claimed that nonreporting witnesses to rape should be punished. However, I firmly believe tha twe have a moral and civic duty to report violent crimes to the legal authorities. The fact that you do not think this was makes me a little uneasy. Are you a rapist or some other type of depraved deviant?

Have you stopped beating your wife?

I love that question but I did not ask you a question like that. At least I do not think that I did.

User avatar
Glorious Freedonia
Negotiator
 
Posts: 6137
Founded: Jun 09, 2006
Ex-Nation

Postby Glorious Freedonia » Fri Feb 26, 2010 4:44 pm

Muravyets wrote:
Ifreann wrote:
Glorious Freedonia wrote:
Bottle wrote:
Glorious Freedonia wrote:
Dempublicents1 wrote:
Hayteria wrote:4. Even if you assume each rapist will continue raping until stopped, what if woman A doesn't agree with said assumption?


I would add to this one that rapists will often do whatever they can to convince their victims that it really is the victim's fault. The effect that has, both emotionally and psychologically, can lead a woman to believe that the rapist wouldn't hurt anyone else, because he really wasn't trying to hurt her.


This is insane. A rapist rapes a girl then tells her that she was not raped and she believes it. This is nonsense. If a woman cant trust her rapist who can she trust? Nobody thinks like that. Nobody trusts a rapist people hardly trust anybody but certainly not their rapists.

Are you kidding me?

THIS THREAD is full of people explaining all the various ways that women can be blamed for their own rapes. And this thread is just a tiny, relatively civil taste of what the rest of the world is like. (Yes, even in "civilized" countries like the USA.)

It's not just rapists telling women that they are to blame for rape. IT IS EVERYBODY ELSE TOO. It's a concerted effort, that you can see IN THIS THREAD, RIGHT IN FRONT OF YOU.

The rapist tells her, "See, you liked it, I knew you were just saying no when you meant yes." Then, when the woman goes to report the rape, the cops say, "Now, did you REALLY say no? Clearly? And you're sure you meant it, and you're sure he understood? You're really, really sure you didn't lead him on? I mean, you did go to his room, after all. You must have been expecting something. Are you really, really sure you said no?" And her friends say, "But he's a nice guy, I've hung out with him, I'm sure it's all just a misunderstanding." And his family says, "We know him, he'd never do that, she must have lead him on." And her family says, "Why were you going up to a boy's room in the first place?" And the media says, "DRUNKEN COED CRIES RAPE!"

And then concern trolls say, "Gosh, why do silly silly women think they are to blame for getting raped? Wherever would they get that silly silly idea?"


I still do not believe that women are responsible for being raped. Rape victims have a moral and civic duty to report their rapes so that the bad guys can got locked up. Police have a duty to investigate and do their best to make sure that they are arresting the right guy and if that means asking the primary rape victim what did or did not happen I do not see a problem with that. I cannot believe that truly raped people would believe a rapist or anyone else when they tell them that they deserved it or whatever. Sure there are people with guilty consciences who feel that they deserved harm because of harm they caused in the past but I am not really talking about those folks.

One person told you that you were a rapist, and you believed it. And we are to believe that if it was not one person, but a whole society, that a woman would just know she had been raped. Dude, seriously?

Well, why not? Women are responsible for everything else and expected to be better, stronger, smarter, more noble, etc, etc, than men in all things -- why not this one too? We're to blame for men getting hard-ons. We're to blame for men raping us. We're to blame for men know understanding what "no" means. Obviously, we're to blame for the mind games rapists play on us, too. A man can be misled by someone who wants to do him harm, but it's just silly to think a woman could be similarly misled because we're supposed to be the responsible ones.

I do not get your point and just so everyone here knows she never told me anything like "Stop I do not consent to this." She just always struggled at first.

User avatar
Muravyets
Postmaster-General
 
Posts: 12755
Founded: Aug 18, 2005
Ex-Nation

Postby Muravyets » Fri Feb 26, 2010 4:48 pm

Glorious Freedonia wrote:In fact this brings up another good point that is shameless thread drift. Why are the cute and or great in bed girls often freaking nuts?

It's not all the cute, sexy girls. It's just the ones who would be caught dead with you.




What? You were asking for snark, so I thought it would be rude not to hand you some.
Kick back at Cafe Muravyets
And check out my other RP, too. (Don't take others' word for it -- see for yourself. ;) )
I agree with Muravyets because she scares me. -- Verdigroth
However, I am still not the topic of this thread.

User avatar
Ifreann
Post Overlord
 
Posts: 178531
Founded: Aug 07, 2005
Scandinavian Liberal Paradise

Postby Ifreann » Fri Feb 26, 2010 4:51 pm

Glorious Freedonia wrote:
Ifreann wrote:
Glorious Freedonia wrote:
Muravyets wrote:
Glorious Freedonia wrote:Woman A knows that Woman B would be raped because rapists are monsters that keep on raping until they are stopped. Because Woman A identified the rapist and did nothing she could have prevented Woman B from getting the raped.

You're talking about taking "Good Samaritan" laws to a whole new, crazy-ass level, because to hold a rape victim culpable for not preventing a crime would require the police to track down and investigate people who, otherwise, would never cross their radar. How do you expect them to know someone did not report a crime? They'd have to first get a rapist to confess to all the rapes he has committed, then go and investigate all those victims to see if any of them did not report it. Which means the rapist would have to be able to identify who his victims are. Then those victims get to be punished for not doing something. Of course, that would have to presume that, if they had reported the rape, their attacker would have been found and arrested, tried, and convicted anyway. At what point are you going to see just how ridiculous your argument is?

Or perhaps you just want women who have been raped to also be emotionally oppressed by the guilt of knowing they have also failed to meet your persnickety standards for how moral and righteous they should be. Of course, that runs into the problem of (a) the majority of women not even knowing you exist (which I suppose is their fault as well) and (b) the majority of women not giving a shit what you think.

I never claimed that nonreporting witnesses to rape should be punished. However, I firmly believe tha twe have a moral and civic duty to report violent crimes to the legal authorities. The fact that you do not think this was makes me a little uneasy. Are you a rapist or some other type of depraved deviant?

Have you stopped beating your wife?

I love that question but I did not ask you a question like that. At least I do not think that I did.

Not quite. Your question is more along the lines of "Do you agree with me or are you a rapist?".
He/Him
I, for one, wasn't having an affair with Jensen Huang
Saoirse don Phalaistín

User avatar
Muravyets
Postmaster-General
 
Posts: 12755
Founded: Aug 18, 2005
Ex-Nation

Postby Muravyets » Fri Feb 26, 2010 4:55 pm

Glorious Freedonia wrote:
Muravyets wrote:
Glorious Freedonia wrote:Woman A knows that Woman B would be raped because rapists are monsters that keep on raping until they are stopped. Because Woman A identified the rapist and did nothing she could have prevented Woman B from getting the raped.

You're talking about taking "Good Samaritan" laws to a whole new, crazy-ass level, because to hold a rape victim culpable for not preventing a crime would require the police to track down and investigate people who, otherwise, would never cross their radar. How do you expect them to know someone did not report a crime? They'd have to first get a rapist to confess to all the rapes he has committed, then go and investigate all those victims to see if any of them did not report it. Which means the rapist would have to be able to identify who his victims are. Then those victims get to be punished for not doing something. Of course, that would have to presume that, if they had reported the rape, their attacker would have been found and arrested, tried, and convicted anyway. At what point are you going to see just how ridiculous your argument is?

Or perhaps you just want women who have been raped to also be emotionally oppressed by the guilt of knowing they have also failed to meet your persnickety standards for how moral and righteous they should be. Of course, that runs into the problem of (a) the majority of women not even knowing you exist (which I suppose is their fault as well) and (b) the majority of women not giving a shit what you think.

I never claimed that nonreporting witnesses to rape should be punished. However, I firmly believe tha twe have a moral and civic duty to report violent crimes to the legal authorities. The fact that you do not think this was makes me a little uneasy. Are you a rapist or some other type of depraved deviant?

No. I'm just a depraved pointer out of your illogic.
Last edited by Muravyets on Fri Feb 26, 2010 4:56 pm, edited 1 time in total.
Kick back at Cafe Muravyets
And check out my other RP, too. (Don't take others' word for it -- see for yourself. ;) )
I agree with Muravyets because she scares me. -- Verdigroth
However, I am still not the topic of this thread.

User avatar
Central Slavia
Powerbroker
 
Posts: 8463
Founded: Nov 05, 2009
Corrupt Dictatorship

Postby Central Slavia » Fri Feb 26, 2010 4:58 pm

Muravyets wrote:No. I'm just a depraved pointer out of your illogic.


A depraved pointer, or just a corrupt reference ?
(how i like programming puns)
Kosovo is Serbia!
Embassy Anthem Store Facts

Glorious Homeland wrote:
You would be wrong. There's something wrong with the Americans, the Japanese are actually insane, the Chinese don't seem capable of free-thought and just defer judgement to the most powerful strong man, the Russians are quite like that, only more aggressive and mad, and Belarus? Hah.

Omnicracy wrote:The Soviet Union did not support pro-Soviet governments, it compleatly controled them. The U.S. did not controle the corrupt regiems it set up against the Soviet Union, it just sugested things and changed leaders if they weer not takeing enough sugestions

Great Nepal wrote:Please stick to OFFICIAL numbers. Why to go to scholars,[cut]

User avatar
Ifreann
Post Overlord
 
Posts: 178531
Founded: Aug 07, 2005
Scandinavian Liberal Paradise

Postby Ifreann » Fri Feb 26, 2010 5:00 pm

Central Slavia wrote:
Muravyets wrote:No. I'm just a depraved pointer out of your illogic.


A depraved pointer, or just a corrupt reference ?
(how i like programming puns)

Don't make me throw a NullPunException at you.
He/Him
I, for one, wasn't having an affair with Jensen Huang
Saoirse don Phalaistín

User avatar
Muravyets
Postmaster-General
 
Posts: 12755
Founded: Aug 18, 2005
Ex-Nation

Postby Muravyets » Fri Feb 26, 2010 5:02 pm

Glorious Freedonia wrote:
Saint Jade IV wrote:
Muravyets wrote:
Saint Jade IV wrote:
How do you know she had no trauma? We have heard just one side of the story here for one. Furthermore, I fail to understand what is so absolutely difficult to understand about consent. If you are not sure you have it - don't have sex with the person. If the person you are trying to have sex with indicates that they "don't really want to" - then don't have sex with them.

Just how badly beaten does a woman have to be for it to be "rape" in your eyes? Do severe bruises visible on her body and face suffice, or does she need broken bones to prove that she definitely indicated she was not consenting?

There are a multiplicity of tactics that rapists use to coerce women into non-consenting sex, both before and after the fact, and multiple forms of rape that are rape under the law, but that society convinces many victims aren't because they "weren't clear enough" or "asked for it" through "dressing slutty" or drinking "too much" or a multitude of other excuses that society uses to convince women that they weren't really raped and in fact by claiming that they were they are victimising the poor male who didn't know that "No" or "Stop" or "I'm not really wanting to do this" are all ways of denying consent - that thing you need to have to not be a rapist.

This refusal to understand the concept of consent is really pissing me off. I have a very hard time believing that anyone over the age of 10 really can't grasp this. Instead, I think these arguments are raised by people looking to make excuses for bad behavior. When it gets to the point of haggling over how badly a woman has to be physically damaged before a man can be punished for raping her, I just feel the urge to tell people to grow the fuck up and quit it with that self-serving bullshit. It's grotesque.
I agree completely. I find it disgusting that people buy into the myth that men are somehow confused about a woman's (or a man's) lack of desire to engage in sex acts. I despise the idea as highly insulting to all the males I know who are able to make the distinction between consent and non-consent and control themselves accordingly.


There are exceptions to every rule. There are times when there is legitimate confusion and false accusations after the fact. I have experienced it.

So you say. I suppose it was absolutely impossible for you to not have sex with a woman who kept saying she didn't want to have sex with you. If she was just joking, then it would have been her loss until she womaned up and told you she really did want to. Until then, no means no, even if it leaves the woman frustrated.

But you keep setting yourself up as the example that proves the argument that men are too dumb to know how to behave correctly. I'm sure the men of the world will thank you for it.
Kick back at Cafe Muravyets
And check out my other RP, too. (Don't take others' word for it -- see for yourself. ;) )
I agree with Muravyets because she scares me. -- Verdigroth
However, I am still not the topic of this thread.

User avatar
Muravyets
Postmaster-General
 
Posts: 12755
Founded: Aug 18, 2005
Ex-Nation

Postby Muravyets » Fri Feb 26, 2010 5:06 pm

Glorious Freedonia";p="1569312I wrote: do not get your point and just so everyone here knows she never told me anything like "Stop I do not consent to this." She just always struggled at first.

First, I really don't care about the details of your sex stories.

Second, When "no" is accompanied by struggling, you still don't get it. You're really not doing men any favors here.
Last edited by Muravyets on Fri Feb 26, 2010 5:07 pm, edited 1 time in total.
Kick back at Cafe Muravyets
And check out my other RP, too. (Don't take others' word for it -- see for yourself. ;) )
I agree with Muravyets because she scares me. -- Verdigroth
However, I am still not the topic of this thread.

User avatar
Central Slavia
Powerbroker
 
Posts: 8463
Founded: Nov 05, 2009
Corrupt Dictatorship

Postby Central Slavia » Fri Feb 26, 2010 5:07 pm

Muravyets wrote:[quote="Glorious Freedonia";p="1569312I do not get your point and just so everyone here knows she never told me anything like "Stop I do not consent to this." She just always struggled at first.

First, I really don't care about the details of your sex stories.

Second, When "no" is accompanied by struggling, you still don't get it. You're really not doing men any favors here.[/quote]
Well the fact that she does not went away from him after the first time , kind of does her no favours either
Kosovo is Serbia!
Embassy Anthem Store Facts

Glorious Homeland wrote:
You would be wrong. There's something wrong with the Americans, the Japanese are actually insane, the Chinese don't seem capable of free-thought and just defer judgement to the most powerful strong man, the Russians are quite like that, only more aggressive and mad, and Belarus? Hah.

Omnicracy wrote:The Soviet Union did not support pro-Soviet governments, it compleatly controled them. The U.S. did not controle the corrupt regiems it set up against the Soviet Union, it just sugested things and changed leaders if they weer not takeing enough sugestions

Great Nepal wrote:Please stick to OFFICIAL numbers. Why to go to scholars,[cut]

User avatar
Glorious Freedonia
Negotiator
 
Posts: 6137
Founded: Jun 09, 2006
Ex-Nation

Postby Glorious Freedonia » Fri Feb 26, 2010 5:12 pm

Muravyets wrote:
Glorious Freedonia wrote:In fact this brings up another good point that is shameless thread drift. Why are the cute and or great in bed girls often freaking nuts?

It's not all the cute, sexy girls. It's just the ones who would be caught dead with you.




What? You were asking for snark, so I thought it would be rude not to hand you some.

:rofl: Loved it!

User avatar
Ifreann
Post Overlord
 
Posts: 178531
Founded: Aug 07, 2005
Scandinavian Liberal Paradise

Postby Ifreann » Fri Feb 26, 2010 5:14 pm

Central Slavia wrote:Well the fact that she does not went away from him after the first time , kind of does her no favours either

You'd swear that being raped could be traumatising and might get in the way of someone's reasoning abilities......
He/Him
I, for one, wasn't having an affair with Jensen Huang
Saoirse don Phalaistín

User avatar
Glorious Freedonia
Negotiator
 
Posts: 6137
Founded: Jun 09, 2006
Ex-Nation

Postby Glorious Freedonia » Fri Feb 26, 2010 5:14 pm

Muravyets wrote:
Glorious Freedonia";p="1569312I wrote: do not get your point and just so everyone here knows she never told me anything like "Stop I do not consent to this." She just always struggled at first.

First, I really don't care about the details of your sex stories.

Second, When "no" is accompanied by struggling, you still don't get it. You're really not doing men any favors here.

The point is that "no" was never accompanied by struggling. We only had the struggling. She must have been a perv to be into that struggling stuff.

User avatar
Central Slavia
Powerbroker
 
Posts: 8463
Founded: Nov 05, 2009
Corrupt Dictatorship

Postby Central Slavia » Fri Feb 26, 2010 5:20 pm

Ifreann wrote:
Central Slavia wrote:Well the fact that she does not went away from him after the first time , kind of does her no favours either

You'd swear that being raped could be traumatising and might get in the way of someone's reasoning abilities......

So if someone beats me up, and i come back to him and get some more and so on , it is perfectly reasonable course of action?
Kosovo is Serbia!
Embassy Anthem Store Facts

Glorious Homeland wrote:
You would be wrong. There's something wrong with the Americans, the Japanese are actually insane, the Chinese don't seem capable of free-thought and just defer judgement to the most powerful strong man, the Russians are quite like that, only more aggressive and mad, and Belarus? Hah.

Omnicracy wrote:The Soviet Union did not support pro-Soviet governments, it compleatly controled them. The U.S. did not controle the corrupt regiems it set up against the Soviet Union, it just sugested things and changed leaders if they weer not takeing enough sugestions

Great Nepal wrote:Please stick to OFFICIAL numbers. Why to go to scholars,[cut]

User avatar
Glorious Freedonia
Negotiator
 
Posts: 6137
Founded: Jun 09, 2006
Ex-Nation

Postby Glorious Freedonia » Fri Feb 26, 2010 5:22 pm

Central Slavia wrote:
Ifreann wrote:
Central Slavia wrote:Well the fact that she does not went away from him after the first time , kind of does her no favours either

You'd swear that being raped could be traumatising and might get in the way of someone's reasoning abilities......

So if someone beats me up, and i come back to him and get some more and so on , it is perfectly reasonable course of action?

*whine* *pout* Don't blame the victim, that's ignorant (said in a South Park-Michael Jackson voice).

User avatar
Glorious Freedonia
Negotiator
 
Posts: 6137
Founded: Jun 09, 2006
Ex-Nation

Postby Glorious Freedonia » Fri Feb 26, 2010 5:25 pm

Ifreann wrote:
Glorious Freedonia wrote:
Ifreann wrote:
Glorious Freedonia wrote:
Muravyets wrote:
Glorious Freedonia wrote:Woman A knows that Woman B would be raped because rapists are monsters that keep on raping until they are stopped. Because Woman A identified the rapist and did nothing she could have prevented Woman B from getting the raped.

You're talking about taking "Good Samaritan" laws to a whole new, crazy-ass level, because to hold a rape victim culpable for not preventing a crime would require the police to track down and investigate people who, otherwise, would never cross their radar. How do you expect them to know someone did not report a crime? They'd have to first get a rapist to confess to all the rapes he has committed, then go and investigate all those victims to see if any of them did not report it. Which means the rapist would have to be able to identify who his victims are. Then those victims get to be punished for not doing something. Of course, that would have to presume that, if they had reported the rape, their attacker would have been found and arrested, tried, and convicted anyway. At what point are you going to see just how ridiculous your argument is?

Or perhaps you just want women who have been raped to also be emotionally oppressed by the guilt of knowing they have also failed to meet your persnickety standards for how moral and righteous they should be. Of course, that runs into the problem of (a) the majority of women not even knowing you exist (which I suppose is their fault as well) and (b) the majority of women not giving a shit what you think.

I never claimed that nonreporting witnesses to rape should be punished. However, I firmly believe tha twe have a moral and civic duty to report violent crimes to the legal authorities. The fact that you do not think this was makes me a little uneasy. Are you a rapist or some other type of depraved deviant?

Have you stopped beating your wife?

I love that question but I did not ask you a question like that. At least I do not think that I did.

Not quite. Your question is more along the lines of "Do you agree with me or are you a rapist?".

Well it kinda seems that way. Either you are for good or you are for evil. There really is no middle ground. It reminds me of the saying, "The hottest places in Hell are reserved for those who remain neutral in times of moral crisis."

User avatar
Ifreann
Post Overlord
 
Posts: 178531
Founded: Aug 07, 2005
Scandinavian Liberal Paradise

Postby Ifreann » Fri Feb 26, 2010 5:33 pm

Central Slavia wrote:
Ifreann wrote:
Central Slavia wrote:Well the fact that she does not went away from him after the first time , kind of does her no favours either

You'd swear that being raped could be traumatising and might get in the way of someone's reasoning abilities......

So if someone beats me up, and i come back to him and get some more and so on , it is perfectly reasonable course of action?

Could be, depends on some other factors.
He/Him
I, for one, wasn't having an affair with Jensen Huang
Saoirse don Phalaistín

User avatar
Hamilay
Ambassador
 
Posts: 1171
Founded: Jan 23, 2006
Ex-Nation

Postby Hamilay » Fri Feb 26, 2010 5:35 pm

Glorious Freedonia";p="1569312I wrote: do not get your point and just so everyone here knows she never told me anything like "Stop I do not consent to this." She just always struggled at first.


u srs

Central Slavia wrote:
Ifreann wrote:
Central Slavia wrote:Well the fact that she does not went away from him after the first time , kind of does her no favours either

You'd swear that being raped could be traumatising and might get in the way of someone's reasoning abilities......

So if someone beats me up, and i come back to him and get some more and so on , it is perfectly reasonable course of action?


No, but I'm not sure how you can blame someone who has just been raped for acting unreasonably.

You could argue that people who return to their rapist are at fault - it seems as if it would be fairly obvious not to do that - but you may as well argue that depressed people are at fault for being injured if they try to commit suicide. It's not particularly helpful. Besides this pales in comparison to the fault the actual rapist is at unless you think 'well guys she made it really easy for me to rape her, so i'm not actually a bad guy and should get a reduced sentence' is a valid legal defence.

There are things some women could do to reduce the possibility of them being raped, just like any crime, although most rape victims could not reasonably be expected to do such things. Though retreating from other human beings seems like a good idea at some times. As Hydesland said a couple pages back it depends how you want to use the word 'blame'. However after the fact going on about this is not very helpful. Unless you think that it's somehow more ok to rape someone if it's easy to do there should be no impact on any punishment the rapist should receive regardless of the actions of the victim because they're still a rapist. Since this should make no difference in legal terms there is no reason for trying to think of ways the victim was at fault after the fact other than wanking to make the rapist seem like less of a rapist.

User avatar
Central Slavia
Powerbroker
 
Posts: 8463
Founded: Nov 05, 2009
Corrupt Dictatorship

Postby Central Slavia » Fri Feb 26, 2010 5:36 pm

Glorious Freedonia wrote:
Ifreann wrote:
Glorious Freedonia wrote:
Ifreann wrote:
Glorious Freedonia wrote:
Muravyets wrote:
Glorious Freedonia wrote:Woman A knows that Woman B would be raped because rapists are monsters that keep on raping until they are stopped. Because Woman A identified the rapist and did nothing she could have prevented Woman B from getting the raped.

You're talking about taking "Good Samaritan" laws to a whole new, crazy-ass level, because to hold a rape victim culpable for not preventing a crime would require the police to track down and investigate people who, otherwise, would never cross their radar. How do you expect them to know someone did not report a crime? They'd have to first get a rapist to confess to all the rapes he has committed, then go and investigate all those victims to see if any of them did not report it. Which means the rapist would have to be able to identify who his victims are. Then those victims get to be punished for not doing something. Of course, that would have to presume that, if they had reported the rape, their attacker would have been found and arrested, tried, and convicted anyway. At what point are you going to see just how ridiculous your argument is?

Or perhaps you just want women who have been raped to also be emotionally oppressed by the guilt of knowing they have also failed to meet your persnickety standards for how moral and righteous they should be. Of course, that runs into the problem of (a) the majority of women not even knowing you exist (which I suppose is their fault as well) and (b) the majority of women not giving a shit what you think.

I never claimed that nonreporting witnesses to rape should be punished. However, I firmly believe tha twe have a moral and civic duty to report violent crimes to the legal authorities. The fact that you do not think this was makes me a little uneasy. Are you a rapist or some other type of depraved deviant?

Have you stopped beating your wife?

I love that question but I did not ask you a question like that. At least I do not think that I did.

Not quite. Your question is more along the lines of "Do you agree with me or are you a rapist?".

Well it kinda seems that way. Either you are for good or you are for evil. There really is no middle ground. It reminds me of the saying, "The hottest places in Hell are reserved for those who remain neutral in times of moral crisis."

I do not know who said that but it is utterly right description ,or would be if Hell or Heaven existed
Kosovo is Serbia!
Embassy Anthem Store Facts

Glorious Homeland wrote:
You would be wrong. There's something wrong with the Americans, the Japanese are actually insane, the Chinese don't seem capable of free-thought and just defer judgement to the most powerful strong man, the Russians are quite like that, only more aggressive and mad, and Belarus? Hah.

Omnicracy wrote:The Soviet Union did not support pro-Soviet governments, it compleatly controled them. The U.S. did not controle the corrupt regiems it set up against the Soviet Union, it just sugested things and changed leaders if they weer not takeing enough sugestions

Great Nepal wrote:Please stick to OFFICIAL numbers. Why to go to scholars,[cut]

User avatar
Glorious Freedonia
Negotiator
 
Posts: 6137
Founded: Jun 09, 2006
Ex-Nation

Postby Glorious Freedonia » Fri Feb 26, 2010 5:38 pm

Hamilay wrote:
Glorious Freedonia";p="1569312I wrote: do not get your point and just so everyone here knows she never told me anything like "Stop I do not consent to this." She just always struggled at first.


u srs

Central Slavia wrote:
Ifreann wrote:
Central Slavia wrote:Well the fact that she does not went away from him after the first time , kind of does her no favours either

You'd swear that being raped could be traumatising and might get in the way of someone's reasoning abilities......

So if someone beats me up, and i come back to him and get some more and so on , it is perfectly reasonable course of action?


No, but I'm not sure how you can blame someone who has just been raped for acting unreasonably.

You could argue that people who return to their rapist are at fault - it seems as if it would be fairly obvious not to do that - but you may as well argue that depressed people are at fault for being injured if they try to commit suicide. It's not particularly helpful. Besides this pales in comparison to the fault the actual rapist is at unless you think 'well guys she made it really easy for me to rape her, so i'm not actually a bad guy and should get a reduced sentence' is a valid legal defence.

There are things some women could do to reduce the possibility of them being raped, just like any crime, although most rape victims could not reasonably be expected to do such things. Though retreating from other human beings seems like a good idea at some times. As Hydesland said a couple pages back it depends how you want to use the word 'blame'. However after the fact going on about this is not very helpful. Unless you think that it's somehow more ok to rape someone if it's easy to do there should be no impact on any punishment the rapist should receive regardless of the actions of the victim because they're still a rapist. Since this should make no difference in legal terms there is no reason for trying to think of ways the victim was at fault after the fact other than wanking to make the rapist seem like less of a rapist.

I do not believe that a rape occurred if this is going on and the raped is a sane adult and acting like that.

User avatar
Glorious Freedonia
Negotiator
 
Posts: 6137
Founded: Jun 09, 2006
Ex-Nation

Postby Glorious Freedonia » Fri Feb 26, 2010 5:40 pm

Ifreann wrote:
Central Slavia wrote:
Ifreann wrote:
Central Slavia wrote:Well the fact that she does not went away from him after the first time , kind of does her no favours either

You'd swear that being raped could be traumatising and might get in the way of someone's reasoning abilities......

So if someone beats me up, and i come back to him and get some more and so on , it is perfectly reasonable course of action?

Could be, depends on some other factors.

No. Fail. *awards dunce cap*

User avatar
Dempublicents1
Senator
 
Posts: 3963
Founded: Mar 28, 2005
Ex-Nation

Postby Dempublicents1 » Fri Feb 26, 2010 5:41 pm

Glorious Freedonia wrote:
Dempublicents1 wrote:...which is exactly what is implied when a woman who reports a rape will immediately be interrogated as to whether or not she was drunk, is promiscuous, dressed provocatively, was voluntarily alone with him, gave him any reason to believe she would have sex with him, etc., etc., etc. The implication is that the woman did something to bring on the rape and that, if she had just chosen not to do X, she wouldn't have been raped - thus making it her fault.

Finding out all of the facts is all there is to it. People make such a big deal about contacts with the police that they read way too much into it. You seem to be doing so as well.


For what reason do they need to know how she was dressed? For what reason do they need to know whether she is personally promiscuous? These things are just as irrelevant to the crime as they would be if she was mugged, yet they suddenly become issues if the crime being reported is rape. Your pretense that it's just the cops doing their job, rather than showing their biases, is cute.

Central Slavia wrote:
Dempublicents1 wrote:...which is exactly what is implied when a woman who reports a rape will immediately be interrogated as to whether or not she was drunk, is promiscuous, dressed provocatively, was voluntarily alone with him, gave him any reason to believe she would have sex with him, etc., etc., etc. The implication is that the woman did something to bring on the rape and that, if she had just chosen not to do X, she wouldn't have been raped - thus making it her fault.

Because if a drunk reports anything else, especially a conflict with another , he will be believed fully


If a woman was drunk at some point in time, she is "a drunk"?

If I go to a bar, have a few drinks, and then get mugged on my way home, does that mean the police should not believe me and should instantly treat me as if I'm lying?
"If I poke you with a needle, you feel pain. If I hit you repeatedly in the testicles with a brick, you feel pain. Ergo, the appropriate response to being vaccinated is to testicle-punch your doctor with a brick. It all makes perfect sense now!" -The Norwegian Blue

"In fact, the post was blended with four delicious flavors of sarcasm, then dipped in an insincerity sauce, breaded with mock seriousness, then deep fried in scalding, trans-fat-free-sarcasm oil." - Flameswroth

PreviousNext

Advertisement

Remove ads

Return to General

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: Chess Socialism, Franco-Danubian Imperium, Great Britain-and Northern Ireland, Los Einquirers, The Empire of the Fatherland, Uan aa Boa, Xechana

Advertisement

Remove ads