NATION

PASSWORD

Repeal Nuclear Testing Safety (GA #119) [DRAFT]

A record of historical World Assembly debates.
User avatar
Bergnovinaia
Negotiator
 
Posts: 7313
Founded: Jul 26, 2009
Ex-Nation

Repeal Nuclear Testing Safety (GA #119) [DRAFT]

Postby Bergnovinaia » Tue Jul 02, 2013 11:36 am

OOC: Hello everyone! I would really appreciate your feedback on this repeal effort--my second directed at nuclear matters.

Thanks!

IC:

I have drafted a replacement. It can be found here: http://forum.nationstates.net/viewtopic.php?f=9&t=249944

Image


Repeal "Nuclear Testing Safety"
A resolution to repeal previously passed legislation.

Category: Repeal | GA #119|Proposed by: Bergnovinaia

The General Assembly,

APPLAUDING the intent behind GA #119, Nuclear Testing Safety;

YET CONCERNED with the language used in the resolution--language that can easily be used to create loopholes;

NOTING that GA #119 calls for a "[Restriction of] nuclear testing to areas where the testing and its aftereffects will not directly affect surrounding populaces," yet fails to adequately define what direct and indirect effects are;

CONCERNED that in the case of this clause, nations can easily manipulate a lack of definition to disregard serious impact to public health or environmental stability as "indirect effects;"

HIGHLIGHTING some indirect effects, effects that are not necessarily considered by nations under GA #119 testing, as the following: radiation poisoning, bone marrow death, various types of cancer, perinatal mortality, and cataracts;

WORRIED that an additional clause that requires that "All tests must be thoroughly and fully supervised to ensure compliance with WA regulations" is rendered ineffective in a later clause that gives the Nuclear Testing Oversight Agency (NTOA), the body created by GA #119, the power "To supervise nuclear tests upon invitation from nuclear-testing nations;"

ALARMED that while many member states do, indeed, comply with the supervision clause of the resolution, member states that do not can dangerously conduct nuclear tests due to the lack of NTOA's supervision and power;

FURTHERMORE appalled at the language used in another clause that states that member states must work to prevent "unnecessary death or injury due to nuclear testing;"

BELIEVING that any death or injury from nuclear testing is unnecessary and CONCERNED that this clause allows debate for what is and is not "unnecessary death or injury";

HOPING that future legislation on the matter clarifies the inherent loopholes and definition errors present in GA #119, thereby truly ensuring safety during nuclear tests;

REPEALS GA #119, thereby making it completely null and void.
Last edited by Bergnovinaia on Wed Jul 03, 2013 5:18 pm, edited 6 times in total.
I am pursuing my undergraduate degree from Texas A&M University in Psychology and Spanish. My goal in life is to be a marriage and family counselor. If you have questions about me or my life, just ask!

My girlfriend and I blog about Christian & general marriage, relationship, and dating advice!

NS member since 2009. WA Resolution Author (mostly all repealed), NS sports fanatic.

User avatar
Bergnovinaia
Negotiator
 
Posts: 7313
Founded: Jul 26, 2009
Ex-Nation

Postby Bergnovinaia » Tue Jul 02, 2013 4:51 pm

I have edited the bolds and italicized words somewhat because telegrammed commentary said that the intent of the repeal got lost in excessive bolding and italics.
I am pursuing my undergraduate degree from Texas A&M University in Psychology and Spanish. My goal in life is to be a marriage and family counselor. If you have questions about me or my life, just ask!

My girlfriend and I blog about Christian & general marriage, relationship, and dating advice!

NS member since 2009. WA Resolution Author (mostly all repealed), NS sports fanatic.

User avatar
Christian Democrats
Postmaster-General
 
Posts: 10096
Founded: Jul 29, 2009
New York Times Democracy

Postby Christian Democrats » Tue Jul 02, 2013 5:47 pm

Bergnovinaia wrote:NOTING that GA #119 calls for a "[Restriction of] nuclear testing to areas where the testing and its aftereffects will not directly affect surrounding populaces," yet fails to adequately define what direct and indirect affectation are

I think you should use a word besides "affectation," possibly "effects."

affectation: n. (1) behavior intended to impress: feigned or unnatural behavior that is often meant to impress others; (2) act intended to impress: an appearance or manner assumed as a show or pretense, often to impress others.

Bergnovinaia wrote:CONCERNED that in the case of this clause, nations can easily manipulate a lack of definition to disregard serious impact to public health or environmental stability as "indirect affects;"

The word "effects" should be used instead of "affects."
Leo Tolstoy wrote:Wrong does not cease to be wrong because the majority share in it.
GA#160: Forced Marriages Ban Act (79%)
GA#175: Organ and Blood Donations Act (68%)^
SC#082: Repeal "Liberate Catholic" (80%)
GA#200: Foreign Marriage Recognition (54%)
GA#213: Privacy Protection Act (70%)
GA#231: Marital Rape Justice Act (81%)^
GA#233: Ban Profits on Workers' Deaths (80%)*
GA#249: Stopping Suicide Seeds (70%)^
GA#253: Repeal "Freedom in Medical Research" (76%)
GA#285: Assisted Suicide Act (70%)^
GA#310: Disabled Voters Act (81%)
GA#373: Repeal "Convention on Execution" (54%)
GA#468: Prohibit Private Prisons (57%)^

* denotes coauthorship
^ repealed resolution
#360: Electile Dysfunction
#452: Foetal Furore
#560: Bicameral Backlash
#570: Clerical Errors

User avatar
Bergnovinaia
Negotiator
 
Posts: 7313
Founded: Jul 26, 2009
Ex-Nation

Postby Bergnovinaia » Tue Jul 02, 2013 5:48 pm

Christian Democrats wrote:
Bergnovinaia wrote:NOTING that GA #119 calls for a "[Restriction of] nuclear testing to areas where the testing and its aftereffects will not directly affect surrounding populaces," yet fails to adequately define what direct and indirect affectation are

I think you should use a word besides "affectation," possibly "effects."

affectation: n. (1) behavior intended to impress: feigned or unnatural behavior that is often meant to impress others; (2) act intended to impress: an appearance or manner assumed as a show or pretense, often to impress others.

Bergnovinaia wrote:CONCERNED that in the case of this clause, nations can easily manipulate a lack of definition to disregard serious impact to public health or environmental stability as "indirect affects;"

The word "effects" should be used instead of "affects."


So edited.

Besides that, other thoughts? Or good to roll when ready?
Last edited by Bergnovinaia on Tue Jul 02, 2013 5:52 pm, edited 1 time in total.
I am pursuing my undergraduate degree from Texas A&M University in Psychology and Spanish. My goal in life is to be a marriage and family counselor. If you have questions about me or my life, just ask!

My girlfriend and I blog about Christian & general marriage, relationship, and dating advice!

NS member since 2009. WA Resolution Author (mostly all repealed), NS sports fanatic.

User avatar
Christian Democrats
Postmaster-General
 
Posts: 10096
Founded: Jul 29, 2009
New York Times Democracy

Postby Christian Democrats » Tue Jul 02, 2013 6:18 pm

Bergnovinaia wrote:Besides that, other thoughts? Or good to roll when ready?

It looks fine to me. You might consider adding some examples of indirect effects of nuclear testing, such as birth defects.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Effects_of_nuclear_explosions_on_human_health
Leo Tolstoy wrote:Wrong does not cease to be wrong because the majority share in it.
GA#160: Forced Marriages Ban Act (79%)
GA#175: Organ and Blood Donations Act (68%)^
SC#082: Repeal "Liberate Catholic" (80%)
GA#200: Foreign Marriage Recognition (54%)
GA#213: Privacy Protection Act (70%)
GA#231: Marital Rape Justice Act (81%)^
GA#233: Ban Profits on Workers' Deaths (80%)*
GA#249: Stopping Suicide Seeds (70%)^
GA#253: Repeal "Freedom in Medical Research" (76%)
GA#285: Assisted Suicide Act (70%)^
GA#310: Disabled Voters Act (81%)
GA#373: Repeal "Convention on Execution" (54%)
GA#468: Prohibit Private Prisons (57%)^

* denotes coauthorship
^ repealed resolution
#360: Electile Dysfunction
#452: Foetal Furore
#560: Bicameral Backlash
#570: Clerical Errors

User avatar
Bergnovinaia
Negotiator
 
Posts: 7313
Founded: Jul 26, 2009
Ex-Nation

Postby Bergnovinaia » Tue Jul 02, 2013 8:56 pm

Christian Democrats wrote:
Bergnovinaia wrote:Besides that, other thoughts? Or good to roll when ready?

It looks fine to me. You might consider adding some examples of indirect effects of nuclear testing, such as birth defects.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Effects_of_nuclear_explosions_on_human_health


So updated:

HIGHLIGHTING some indirect effects, effects that are not necessarily considered by nations under GA #119 testing, as the following: radiation poisoning, bone marrow death, various types of cancer, perinatal mortality, and cataracts;
I am pursuing my undergraduate degree from Texas A&M University in Psychology and Spanish. My goal in life is to be a marriage and family counselor. If you have questions about me or my life, just ask!

My girlfriend and I blog about Christian & general marriage, relationship, and dating advice!

NS member since 2009. WA Resolution Author (mostly all repealed), NS sports fanatic.

User avatar
United Federation of Canada
Ambassador
 
Posts: 1417
Founded: Oct 09, 2012
Ex-Nation

Postby United Federation of Canada » Tue Jul 02, 2013 9:08 pm

Please include the following clause:

Further appalled that GAR #119 Nuclear Testing Safety allows for the testing of nuclear weapons in outer space, at a distance to a planetary body, that could place such planetary body within the danger zone of damaging electromagnetic pulse effects, and such testing could cause the formation of damaging radiation belts around said planetary body,


Regards,

User avatar
Bergnovinaia
Negotiator
 
Posts: 7313
Founded: Jul 26, 2009
Ex-Nation

Postby Bergnovinaia » Tue Jul 02, 2013 9:12 pm

United Federation of Canada wrote:Please include the following clause:

Further appalled that GAR #119 Nuclear Testing Safety allows for the testing of nuclear weapons in outer space, at a distance to a planetary body, that could place such planetary body within the danger zone of damaging electromagnetic pulse effects, and such testing could cause the formation of damaging radiation belts around said planetary body,


Regards,


I don't think that specifically is an issue, as GA #119 states:

BANS nuclear testing within the area between the edge of a populated celestial body's atmosphere and twice the distance of geosychronous orbit - measured at the equator of said celestial body;
I am pursuing my undergraduate degree from Texas A&M University in Psychology and Spanish. My goal in life is to be a marriage and family counselor. If you have questions about me or my life, just ask!

My girlfriend and I blog about Christian & general marriage, relationship, and dating advice!

NS member since 2009. WA Resolution Author (mostly all repealed), NS sports fanatic.

User avatar
United Federation of Canada
Ambassador
 
Posts: 1417
Founded: Oct 09, 2012
Ex-Nation

Postby United Federation of Canada » Tue Jul 02, 2013 11:01 pm

Bergnovinaia wrote:
United Federation of Canada wrote:Please include the following clause:



Regards,


I don't think that specifically is an issue, as GA #119 states:

BANS nuclear testing within the area between the edge of a populated celestial body's atmosphere and twice the distance of geosychronous orbit - measured at the equator of said celestial body;


Which is a bunch of technical mumbo jumbo that makes no sense, has a spelling error, and should be the main argument for the repeal.

User avatar
Bergnovinaia
Negotiator
 
Posts: 7313
Founded: Jul 26, 2009
Ex-Nation

Postby Bergnovinaia » Wed Jul 03, 2013 12:12 am

United Federation of Canada wrote:
Bergnovinaia wrote:
I don't think that specifically is an issue, as GA #119 states:



Which is a bunch of technical mumbo jumbo that makes no sense, has a spelling error, and should be the main argument for the repeal.


I have to strongly disagree. The technicalities may be incorrect, but the argument is strong without this.
I am pursuing my undergraduate degree from Texas A&M University in Psychology and Spanish. My goal in life is to be a marriage and family counselor. If you have questions about me or my life, just ask!

My girlfriend and I blog about Christian & general marriage, relationship, and dating advice!

NS member since 2009. WA Resolution Author (mostly all repealed), NS sports fanatic.

User avatar
Araraukar
Post Marshal
 
Posts: 15899
Founded: May 14, 2007
Corrupt Dictatorship

Postby Araraukar » Wed Jul 03, 2013 2:03 am

Why the use of "preoccupied"? It doesn't seem to fit at all.
- ambassador miss Janis Leveret
Araraukar's RP reality is Modern Tech solarpunk. In IC in the WA.
Giovenith wrote:And sorry hun, if you were looking for a forum site where nobody argued, you've come to wrong one.
Apologies for absences, non-COVID health issues leave me with very little energy at times.

User avatar
The Akashic Records
Diplomat
 
Posts: 803
Founded: May 21, 2013
Ex-Nation

Postby The Akashic Records » Wed Jul 03, 2013 8:20 am

Comments are in blue.
Bergnovinaia wrote:NOTING that GA #119 calls for a "[Restriction of] nuclear testing to areas where the testing and its aftereffects will not directly affect surrounding populaces," yet fails to adequately define what direct and indirect effects are;

CONCERNED that in the case of this clause, nations can easily manipulate a lack of definition to disregard serious impact to public health or environmental stability as "indirect effects;"
I believe that manipulating it to such an extent would contravene the Convention Against Genocide, though that might just be me.
Genocide shall be defined as any act committed, or measure enacted, with the intent to destroy, in whole or partially, an identifiable group of persons on the basis of belief, ethnicity, nationality, culture, or a perceived innate characteristic, which for the purposes of this resolution shall include sexual orientation.
Not to mention that it might touch a bit on Clean Water Act when they were manipulating these definitions.

HIGHLIGHTING some indirect effects, effects that are not necessarily considered by nations under GA #119 testing, as the following: radiation poisoning, bone marrow death, various types of cancer, perinatal mortality, and cataracts;
We believe that the concerns laid out by the target resolution itself would rationally be adequate.
CONCERNED about the effects of nuclear tests including but not limited to: nuclear fallout, radiation, intense and deadly heatwaves and fire blasts, EMP waves and bursts, natural disasters, injury and death, and seismic activity,


WORRIED that an additional clause that requires that "All tests must be thoroughly and fully supervised to ensure compliance with WA regulations" is rendered ineffective in a later clause that gives the Nuclear Testing Oversight Agency (NTOA), the body created by GA #119, the power "To supervise nuclear tests upon invitation from nuclear-testing nations;"

PREOCCUPIED that while many member states do, indeed, comply with the supervision clause of the resolution, member states that do not can dangerously conduct nuclear tests due to the lack of NTOA's supervision and power;
Araraukar wrote:Why the use of "preoccupied"? It doesn't seem to fit at all.

FURTHERMORE appalled at the language used in another clause that states that member states must work to prevent "unnecessary death or injury due to nuclear testing;"

BELIEVING that any death or injury from nuclear testing is unnecessary and CONCERNED that this clause allows debate for what is and is not "unnecessary death or injury";

HOPING that future legislation on the matter clarifies the inherent loopholes and definition errors present in GA #119, thereby truly ensuring safety during nuclear tests;

REPEALS GA #119, thereby making it completely null and void.
I will not claim to be an expert, but in my novice opinion, I can't find too much of anything of great fault here, but do you or anyone have a replacement in the works? I have a great distaste for repeals that pulls something good out of the books, without any intention of making it better.

United Federation of Canada wrote:Which is a bunch of technical mumbo jumbo that makes no sense, has a spelling error, and should be the main argument for the repeal.
Which, your scientist(s) should be able to understand, or at least logically conclude from the following clause, unless they're too inept, in which case, they shouldn't be researching nuclear weapons in the first place.
About my posts:
Unless otherwise stated, everything I say is in character.
Coleman T. Harrison,
WA Ambassador for The Akashic Records
On Sanity - Minds are like parachutes. Just because you've lost yours doesn't mean you can borrow mine.
No, the idea behind it (free will) is that one has the option to be Good (tm) and the option to be Bad (tm). God is rather pro-choice. - The Alma Mater -

User avatar
Bergnovinaia
Negotiator
 
Posts: 7313
Founded: Jul 26, 2009
Ex-Nation

Postby Bergnovinaia » Wed Jul 03, 2013 10:05 am

Araraukar wrote:Why the use of "preoccupied"? It doesn't seem to fit at all.


Changed to ALARMED>
I am pursuing my undergraduate degree from Texas A&M University in Psychology and Spanish. My goal in life is to be a marriage and family counselor. If you have questions about me or my life, just ask!

My girlfriend and I blog about Christian & general marriage, relationship, and dating advice!

NS member since 2009. WA Resolution Author (mostly all repealed), NS sports fanatic.

User avatar
Bergnovinaia
Negotiator
 
Posts: 7313
Founded: Jul 26, 2009
Ex-Nation

Postby Bergnovinaia » Wed Jul 03, 2013 10:18 am

I believe that manipulating it to such an extent would contravene the Convention Against Genocide, though that might just be me.

"Genocide shall be defined as any act committed, or measure enacted, with the intent to destroy, in whole or partially, an identifiable group of persons on the basis of belief, ethnicity, nationality, culture, or a perceived innate characteristic, which for the purposes of this resolution shall include sexual orientation."


It's just you. As you see in the definition of genocide, it is a targeted killing or injuring of individuals based on their characteristics. The repeal effort here is concerned that the lack of defining "direct effects" can allow member states to test nuclear arms dangerously close to a population, possibly harming some individuals. This is not genocide, it's just unfortunate.

Not to mention that it might touch a bit on Clean Water Act when they were manipulating these definitions.


You can't mention past resolutions in your repeals or proposals because it would be a house of cards violation.

We believe that the concerns laid out by the target resolution itself would rationally be adequate.


Some of those items can, indeed, be seen as direct effects of nuclear tests. For example, fallout will occur after all tests. Hence, it is a direct effect. I don't think anyone will argue with that. However, whether fallout leads to cancer, cataracts, etc. is the concern of this resolution, since the target proposal only requires nations to be concerned with the direct effects of a nuclear test. The same goes for heat waves.

I will not claim to be an expert, but in my novice opinion, I can't find too much of anything of great fault here, but do you or anyone have a replacement in the works? I have a great distaste for repeals that pulls something good out of the books, without any intention of making it better.


I, personally, do not. I know United Federations Canada has something in the works here. You may not see the terrible issues in these loopholes, but I feel like the WA would be better suited with a different proposal that eliminates said issues.
I am pursuing my undergraduate degree from Texas A&M University in Psychology and Spanish. My goal in life is to be a marriage and family counselor. If you have questions about me or my life, just ask!

My girlfriend and I blog about Christian & general marriage, relationship, and dating advice!

NS member since 2009. WA Resolution Author (mostly all repealed), NS sports fanatic.

User avatar
Ceni
Senator
 
Posts: 4609
Founded: Jun 26, 2012
Left-wing Utopia

Postby Ceni » Wed Jul 03, 2013 10:35 am

Bergnovinaia wrote:
REPEALS GA #119, thereby making it completely null and void.


This last clause is redundant, as the Description at the top says "WA General Assembly Resolution #119... shall be struck out and rendered null and void."
Air Terranea | The Wanderlust Guide to Ceni | Seven Restaurants in Seven Days: Cataloging Cenian Food
Champions: Di Bradini Cup 38, U-18 World Cup 17
Runners-up: Di Bradini Cup 39, Di Bradini Cup 41
NSTT #1s: Lonus Varalin, Ardil Navsal (singles), Gyrachor Rentos, Val Korekal, Elia Xal/Fia Xal (doubles)
UICA Champions' Cup titles (1): 1860 Azoth
World Cup 76, World Cup 79
Baptism of Fire 61
Cup of Harmony 63
Copa Rushmori 41
International Basketball Championships 20
Cenian Open (Grand Slam) 1-11
<Schottia> I always think of Ceni as what it would be like if Long Island was its own nation, ran by Bernie Sanders lol.
The user behind this nation uses he/him/his pronouns.

User avatar
Bergnovinaia
Negotiator
 
Posts: 7313
Founded: Jul 26, 2009
Ex-Nation

Postby Bergnovinaia » Wed Jul 03, 2013 10:36 am

Ceni wrote:
Bergnovinaia wrote:
REPEALS GA #119, thereby making it completely null and void.


This last clause is redundant, as the Description at the top says "WA General Assembly Resolution #119... shall be struck out and rendered null and void."


It is actually required to have an operative clause in repeals.
I am pursuing my undergraduate degree from Texas A&M University in Psychology and Spanish. My goal in life is to be a marriage and family counselor. If you have questions about me or my life, just ask!

My girlfriend and I blog about Christian & general marriage, relationship, and dating advice!

NS member since 2009. WA Resolution Author (mostly all repealed), NS sports fanatic.

User avatar
Araraukar
Post Marshal
 
Posts: 15899
Founded: May 14, 2007
Corrupt Dictatorship

Postby Araraukar » Wed Jul 03, 2013 11:00 am

I think you can refer to other resolutions in a repeal, since a passed repeal can't be repealed, so the House of Cards wouldn't become an issue.
- ambassador miss Janis Leveret
Araraukar's RP reality is Modern Tech solarpunk. In IC in the WA.
Giovenith wrote:And sorry hun, if you were looking for a forum site where nobody argued, you've come to wrong one.
Apologies for absences, non-COVID health issues leave me with very little energy at times.

User avatar
Ceni
Senator
 
Posts: 4609
Founded: Jun 26, 2012
Left-wing Utopia

Postby Ceni » Wed Jul 03, 2013 11:08 am

Bergnovinaia wrote:
Ceni wrote:
This last clause is redundant, as the Description at the top says "WA General Assembly Resolution #119... shall be struck out and rendered null and void."


It is actually required to have an operative clause in repeals.


I meant " thereby making it completely null and void" that part. "REPEALS" is just fine.
Air Terranea | The Wanderlust Guide to Ceni | Seven Restaurants in Seven Days: Cataloging Cenian Food
Champions: Di Bradini Cup 38, U-18 World Cup 17
Runners-up: Di Bradini Cup 39, Di Bradini Cup 41
NSTT #1s: Lonus Varalin, Ardil Navsal (singles), Gyrachor Rentos, Val Korekal, Elia Xal/Fia Xal (doubles)
UICA Champions' Cup titles (1): 1860 Azoth
World Cup 76, World Cup 79
Baptism of Fire 61
Cup of Harmony 63
Copa Rushmori 41
International Basketball Championships 20
Cenian Open (Grand Slam) 1-11
<Schottia> I always think of Ceni as what it would be like if Long Island was its own nation, ran by Bernie Sanders lol.
The user behind this nation uses he/him/his pronouns.

User avatar
Bergnovinaia
Negotiator
 
Posts: 7313
Founded: Jul 26, 2009
Ex-Nation

Postby Bergnovinaia » Wed Jul 03, 2013 11:09 am

Araraukar wrote:I think you can refer to other resolutions in a repeal, since a passed repeal can't be repealed, so the House of Cards wouldn't become an issue.


Still, it's not necessary to quote resolutions about genocide and clean water in a repeal regarding nuclear testing safety, IMO.
I am pursuing my undergraduate degree from Texas A&M University in Psychology and Spanish. My goal in life is to be a marriage and family counselor. If you have questions about me or my life, just ask!

My girlfriend and I blog about Christian & general marriage, relationship, and dating advice!

NS member since 2009. WA Resolution Author (mostly all repealed), NS sports fanatic.

User avatar
Glen-Rhodes
Powerbroker
 
Posts: 9027
Founded: Jun 25, 2008
Ex-Nation

Postby Glen-Rhodes » Wed Jul 03, 2013 11:15 am

We can't support repealing this resolution without seeing a replacement with broad support.

On the merits of the repeal argument, we are less convinced that there is a real problem with the language on direct and indirect effects. What better language is being proposed? We do, however, agree that the NTOA should be given more authority.

- Dr. B. Castro
Last edited by Glen-Rhodes on Wed Jul 03, 2013 11:17 am, edited 1 time in total.

User avatar
Riasy
Attaché
 
Posts: 94
Founded: Dec 24, 2012
Ex-Nation

Postby Riasy » Wed Jul 03, 2013 12:06 pm

Bergnovinaia wrote:WORRIED that an additional clause that requires that "All tests must be thoroughly and fully supervised to ensure compliance with WA regulations" is rendered ineffective in a later clause that gives the Nuclear Testing Oversight Agency (NTOA), the body created by GA #119, the power "To supervise nuclear tests upon invitation from nuclear-testing nations;"

ALARMED that while many member states do, indeed, comply with the supervision clause of the resolution, member states that do not can dangerously conduct nuclear tests due to the lack of NTOA's supervision and power;

I don’t think that the second clause makes ineffective the first one. It simply means that nations have the right to use own specialists to supervise the tests and ensure that they happen in accordance with the WA regulations.

It is only reasonable to allow nations to not invite foreign specialists to supervise the tests when they want to perform them in secrecy. Mandatory presence of foreign experts at all nuclear tests in all member nations would be extreme intrusion into the national security of the member nations.

Iljas Saparitti, Ambassador
Charter Member of The Democratic Socialist Assembly

Generation 34 (The first time you see this, copy it into your sig on any forum and add 1 to the generation. Social experiment.)
98% of all Internet users would cry if Anonymous hacked Facebook. If you are part of that 2% who simply would sit back and laugh, copy and paste this into your sig.

User avatar
Lillitania
Spokesperson
 
Posts: 176
Founded: Apr 22, 2013
Ex-Nation

Postby Lillitania » Wed Jul 03, 2013 1:24 pm

I approve of this draft. I feel it points out the various flaws of the Nuclear Testing Safety Act, and therefore does it's job correctly!

By the way, I don't feel the need to replace the Nuclear Testing Safety Act, and that if the OP does plan to make one he should not have it create any World Assembly agencies that 'supervise' nuclear testing.

Jerry Greyer
General Assembly Office
Last edited by Lillitania on Wed Jul 03, 2013 1:28 pm, edited 1 time in total.
✪ Liberty, Democracy, Equality ✪
Hippostania - Unjustly deleted 30/7/2013
Napkiraly wrote:To be fair to the Americans, I've met quite a number of Europeans who also have no clue as to what communism or socialism really is. Same goes for Canada. Ignorance knows no borders.
★ AMERICAN ★
Picture of Me
Pro: United States, Patriotism, Guns, LGBT Rights, Liberation, Capitalism
Anti: Communism/Socialism, Nation-bashing, American Prejudice
CUBAN IMMIGRANT

User avatar
Araraukar
Post Marshal
 
Posts: 15899
Founded: May 14, 2007
Corrupt Dictatorship

Postby Araraukar » Wed Jul 03, 2013 1:30 pm

Lillitania wrote:I approve of this draft. I feel it points out the various flaws of the Nuclear Testing Safety Act, and therefore does it's job correctly!

And I feel the flaws it points to are not real laws and have been more or less invented for the sake of this repeal. Thus the repeal itself is flawed.
- ambassador miss Janis Leveret
Araraukar's RP reality is Modern Tech solarpunk. In IC in the WA.
Giovenith wrote:And sorry hun, if you were looking for a forum site where nobody argued, you've come to wrong one.
Apologies for absences, non-COVID health issues leave me with very little energy at times.

User avatar
Lillitania
Spokesperson
 
Posts: 176
Founded: Apr 22, 2013
Ex-Nation

Postby Lillitania » Wed Jul 03, 2013 1:39 pm

Araraukar wrote:And I feel the flaws it points to are not real laws and have been more or less invented for the sake of this repeal. Thus the repeal itself is flawed.


Bergnovinaia wrote:WORRIED that an additional clause that requires that "All tests must be thoroughly and fully supervised to ensure compliance with WA regulations" is rendered ineffective in a later clause that gives the Nuclear Testing Oversight Agency (NTOA), the body created by GA #119, the power "To supervise nuclear tests upon invitation from nuclear-testing nations;"


^ This is a pretty big wording mistake. Kind of makes the whole mandate for supervision faulty.

Jerry Greyer
General Assembly Office
✪ Liberty, Democracy, Equality ✪
Hippostania - Unjustly deleted 30/7/2013
Napkiraly wrote:To be fair to the Americans, I've met quite a number of Europeans who also have no clue as to what communism or socialism really is. Same goes for Canada. Ignorance knows no borders.
★ AMERICAN ★
Picture of Me
Pro: United States, Patriotism, Guns, LGBT Rights, Liberation, Capitalism
Anti: Communism/Socialism, Nation-bashing, American Prejudice
CUBAN IMMIGRANT

User avatar
Bergnovinaia
Negotiator
 
Posts: 7313
Founded: Jul 26, 2009
Ex-Nation

Postby Bergnovinaia » Wed Jul 03, 2013 4:42 pm

Riasy wrote:
Bergnovinaia wrote:WORRIED that an additional clause that requires that "All tests must be thoroughly and fully supervised to ensure compliance with WA regulations" is rendered ineffective in a later clause that gives the Nuclear Testing Oversight Agency (NTOA), the body created by GA #119, the power "To supervise nuclear tests upon invitation from nuclear-testing nations;"

ALARMED that while many member states do, indeed, comply with the supervision clause of the resolution, member states that do not can dangerously conduct nuclear tests due to the lack of NTOA's supervision and power;

I don’t think that the second clause makes ineffective the first one. It simply means that nations have the right to use own specialists to supervise the tests and ensure that they happen in accordance with the WA regulations.

It is only reasonable to allow nations to not invite foreign specialists to supervise the tests when they want to perform them in secrecy. Mandatory presence of foreign experts at all nuclear tests in all member nations would be extreme intrusion into the national security of the member nations.

Iljas Saparitti, Ambassador


The two clauses are pointless. The latter is completely optional and the first gives power to member states to test nuclear weapons how the wish, as long as they are, persay, "supervised." I could supervise my nation blowing up an island of natives and if they are considered "necessary death," it's all good and dandy.

We either need more transparency, or good faith that the nations of the world assembly will follow through and test safely on their own. This resolution does neither.
I am pursuing my undergraduate degree from Texas A&M University in Psychology and Spanish. My goal in life is to be a marriage and family counselor. If you have questions about me or my life, just ask!

My girlfriend and I blog about Christian & general marriage, relationship, and dating advice!

NS member since 2009. WA Resolution Author (mostly all repealed), NS sports fanatic.

Next

Advertisement

Remove ads

Return to WA Archives

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: No registered users

Advertisement

Remove ads