NATION

PASSWORD

equality of opportunity vs equality of outcome

For discussion and debate about anything. (Not a roleplay related forum; out-of-character commentary only.)

Advertisement

Remove ads

What is true equality?

equality of opportunity
52
71%
equality of outcome
21
29%
 
Total votes : 73

User avatar
JuNii
Postmaster-General
 
Posts: 13512
Founded: Aug 22, 2004
Ex-Nation

Postby JuNii » Thu Dec 03, 2009 11:11 am

Free Soviets wrote:
JuNii wrote:Sure a 'rich' family will have more opportunities...
Equality of Opportunities is more desirable for me.

and some opportunities are more equal than others!

and those that succeed pass the fruit of their labors onto their children.

Rolling squid wrote:
JuNii wrote:equality of Opportunity.

Taking what you got and making the best of what you have. Sure a 'rich' family will have more opportunities, but those 'rich families' wern't always rich. they also had to work to get to the point you have. and they passed on their success onto their children. so in the end. Equality of Opportunities is more desirable for me.


The problem with that is that it is inherently unfair and unjust. How can you justify giving someone a better quality of life, and give them more opportunities, simply because they were born in to the right families? Conversely, and more importantly, how can you justify giving someone a lower standard of education and jobs offerings simply because they were born into the wrong families?

it's not 'Being born to the right family" but it's also the fact that those families also worked hard to get where they are. if you instill the proper discipline in your children, then they will have as much opportunities as everyone else. it may not be the same TYPE of opportunities but they will have the same amount of opportunities.

Equality of outcome would negate any and all hard work, with that, it removes incentives since why try to improve your life if the lazy bum next door will have the same amount of success.
on the other hand... I have another set of fingers.

Unscramble these words...1) PNEIS. 2)HTIELR 3) NGGERI 4) BUTTSXE
1) SPINE. 2) LITHER 3)GINGER 4)SUBTEXT

User avatar
Mirkana
Ambassador
 
Posts: 1971
Founded: Oct 08, 2005
Ex-Nation

Postby Mirkana » Thu Dec 03, 2009 11:13 am

True equality of opportunity means that the only thing separating people is their ability. It's also impossible to achieve, but we should strive for it nonetheless. Equality of outcome is a path that leads to apathy and the People's Republic of Haven.

Though everyone has a right to basic survival. That is an outcome that should be guaranteed.
Impeach Ramses, Legalize Monotheism, Slavery is Theft, MOSES 1400 BCE

Pro: Democracy, Egalitarianism, Judaism, Separation of Church and State, Israel, Arab Spring, Gay Rights, Welfare, Universal Healthcare, Regulated Capitalism, Scientific Rationalism, Constitutional Monarchy
Against: Dictatorships, Racism, Nazism, Theocracy, Anti-Semitism, Sexism, Homophobia, Imperialism, Creationism, Genocide, Slavery

Alien Space Bats wrote:
Rokartian States wrote:There sure is a lot of damning and fucking going around in here. :lol:

It's the international nature of the board.

In some places, it's Saturday night; in other places, Sunday morning.


Blazedtown wrote:Because every decision ever is a secret conspiracy to keep the brothers down.

User avatar
Vault 10
Minister
 
Posts: 2471
Founded: Sep 15, 2006
Ex-Nation

Postby Vault 10 » Thu Dec 03, 2009 11:27 am

Central Slavia wrote:
Vault 10 wrote:Well, because someone has to do the simple jobs and someone has to do the complicated jobs. In any society.

That is exactly a reason why a good standard of living should be imposed on everyone.
All jobs are equally important because all are neccessary

No, they aren't. Some people are virtually irreplaceable, some are easily replaceable, some are replaceable by high-tech robots, some only take a cheap simple machine to replace, and some (e.g. politicians) are redundant altogether.
There is a line most people say they will never cross. It is usually something they have done long ago when they thought no one was watching.




User avatar
Central Slavia
Powerbroker
 
Posts: 8463
Founded: Nov 05, 2009
Corrupt Dictatorship

Postby Central Slavia » Thu Dec 03, 2009 11:34 am

No, because if all of the people decided to strike and not do the job the society would collapse. You still need robot manufacturers and repairmen to replace people with robots anyway;
Kosovo is Serbia!
Embassy Anthem Store Facts

Glorious Homeland wrote:
You would be wrong. There's something wrong with the Americans, the Japanese are actually insane, the Chinese don't seem capable of free-thought and just defer judgement to the most powerful strong man, the Russians are quite like that, only more aggressive and mad, and Belarus? Hah.

Omnicracy wrote:The Soviet Union did not support pro-Soviet governments, it compleatly controled them. The U.S. did not controle the corrupt regiems it set up against the Soviet Union, it just sugested things and changed leaders if they weer not takeing enough sugestions

Great Nepal wrote:Please stick to OFFICIAL numbers. Why to go to scholars,[cut]

User avatar
Angleter
Postmaster-General
 
Posts: 12359
Founded: Apr 27, 2008
Ex-Nation

Postby Angleter » Thu Dec 03, 2009 11:41 am

Equality of opportunity all the way. It is wrong in my opinion to extort money from the rich and middle-classes and redistribute the wealth, but we need a society where anyone can become Prime Minister, or a barrister or doctor.
[align=center]"I gotta tell you, this is just crazy, huh! This is just nuts, OK! Jeezo man."

User avatar
Free Soviets
Postmaster-General
 
Posts: 11256
Founded: Antiquity
Ex-Nation

Postby Free Soviets » Thu Dec 03, 2009 11:44 am

JuNii wrote:and those that succeed pass the fruit of their labors onto their children.

so equal opportunity for the initial set of people, and drastically unequal for all subsequent ones? why even bother with the initial equality in that case? equality would seem to be completely unimportant to justice under any such system.

User avatar
Rhodmhire
Post Marshal
 
Posts: 17421
Founded: Jun 05, 2009
Ex-Nation

Postby Rhodmhire » Thu Dec 03, 2009 11:44 am

Angleter wrote:...we need a society where anyone can become Prime Minister, or a barrister or doctor.


Anyone, really?
Last edited by Rhodmhire on Thu Dec 03, 2009 11:49 am, edited 1 time in total.
Part of me grew up here. But part of growing up is leaving parts of ourselves behind.

User avatar
Rhodmhire
Post Marshal
 
Posts: 17421
Founded: Jun 05, 2009
Ex-Nation

Postby Rhodmhire » Thu Dec 03, 2009 11:47 am

Central Slavia wrote:You still need robot manufacturers and repairmen to replace people with robots anyway;


Give me time to perfect my robot replecating repair robot replecant device.

If you give me the time, I'll be able to properly state that segment of your post as incorrect.
Part of me grew up here. But part of growing up is leaving parts of ourselves behind.

User avatar
Angleter
Postmaster-General
 
Posts: 12359
Founded: Apr 27, 2008
Ex-Nation

Postby Angleter » Thu Dec 03, 2009 12:05 pm

Rhodmhire wrote:
Angleter wrote:...we need a society where anyone can become Prime Minister, or a barrister or doctor.


Anyone, really?


By that I meant from birth. Of course if they're thick and generally fail at life, then no.
[align=center]"I gotta tell you, this is just crazy, huh! This is just nuts, OK! Jeezo man."

User avatar
JuNii
Postmaster-General
 
Posts: 13512
Founded: Aug 22, 2004
Ex-Nation

Postby JuNii » Thu Dec 03, 2009 12:06 pm

Free Soviets wrote:
JuNii wrote:and those that succeed pass the fruit of their labors onto their children.

so equal opportunity for the initial set of people, and drastically unequal for all subsequent ones? why even bother with the initial equality in that case? equality would seem to be completely unimportant to justice under any such system.

because people have the freedom to not only enjoy the fruits of their success but to also pass that on to their children.
on the other hand... I have another set of fingers.

Unscramble these words...1) PNEIS. 2)HTIELR 3) NGGERI 4) BUTTSXE
1) SPINE. 2) LITHER 3)GINGER 4)SUBTEXT

User avatar
Rhodmhire
Post Marshal
 
Posts: 17421
Founded: Jun 05, 2009
Ex-Nation

Postby Rhodmhire » Thu Dec 03, 2009 12:08 pm

Angleter wrote:
Rhodmhire wrote:
Angleter wrote:...we need a society where anyone can become Prime Minister, or a barrister or doctor.


Anyone, really?


By that I meant from birth. Of course if they're thick and generally fail at life, then no.


Oh, phew, that was a close one, I almost had to bring up the whole sooociiiety thing.

You dodged a bullet, stealth is good, keep up the good work.
Part of me grew up here. But part of growing up is leaving parts of ourselves behind.

User avatar
Free Soviets
Postmaster-General
 
Posts: 11256
Founded: Antiquity
Ex-Nation

Postby Free Soviets » Thu Dec 03, 2009 12:35 pm

JuNii wrote:
Free Soviets wrote:so equal opportunity for the initial set of people, and drastically unequal for all subsequent ones? why even bother with the initial equality in that case? equality would seem to be completely unimportant to justice under any such system.

because people have the freedom to not only enjoy the fruits of their success but to also pass that on to their children.

that doesn't really answer the question. if the right to pass on expanded opportunities to one's children trumps any obligation to provide equality of opportunity, then why would equality of opportunity ever have been important at all?

User avatar
JuNii
Postmaster-General
 
Posts: 13512
Founded: Aug 22, 2004
Ex-Nation

Postby JuNii » Thu Dec 03, 2009 12:39 pm

actually, this should've been my first question(s).

Define Equality of Opportunity

Define Equality of Outcome.
on the other hand... I have another set of fingers.

Unscramble these words...1) PNEIS. 2)HTIELR 3) NGGERI 4) BUTTSXE
1) SPINE. 2) LITHER 3)GINGER 4)SUBTEXT

User avatar
JuNii
Postmaster-General
 
Posts: 13512
Founded: Aug 22, 2004
Ex-Nation

Postby JuNii » Thu Dec 03, 2009 12:40 pm

Free Soviets wrote:
JuNii wrote:
Free Soviets wrote:so equal opportunity for the initial set of people, and drastically unequal for all subsequent ones? why even bother with the initial equality in that case? equality would seem to be completely unimportant to justice under any such system.

because people have the freedom to not only enjoy the fruits of their success but to also pass that on to their children.

that doesn't really answer the question. if the right to pass on expanded opportunities to one's children trumps any obligation to provide equality of opportunity, then why would equality of opportunity ever have been important at all?

you're not passing on Expanded Opportunities. you are only making available advantages. being rich doesn't mean automatic success in everything. same that being poor means automatic failure.
on the other hand... I have another set of fingers.

Unscramble these words...1) PNEIS. 2)HTIELR 3) NGGERI 4) BUTTSXE
1) SPINE. 2) LITHER 3)GINGER 4)SUBTEXT

User avatar
Free Soviets
Postmaster-General
 
Posts: 11256
Founded: Antiquity
Ex-Nation

Postby Free Soviets » Thu Dec 03, 2009 12:56 pm

JuNii wrote:you're not passing on Expanded Opportunities. you are only making available advantages. being rich doesn't mean automatic success in everything. same that being poor means automatic failure.

in what possible sense does having advantages not mean expanded opportunities?

User avatar
Panasean
Lobbyist
 
Posts: 17
Founded: Nov 27, 2009
Ex-Nation

Postby Panasean » Thu Dec 03, 2009 12:57 pm

JuNii wrote:
Free Soviets wrote:
JuNii wrote:Sure a 'rich' family will have more opportunities...
Equality of Opportunities is more desirable for me.

and some opportunities are more equal than others!

and those that succeed pass the fruit of their labors onto their children.

Rolling squid wrote:
JuNii wrote:equality of Opportunity.

Taking what you got and making the best of what you have. Sure a 'rich' family will have more opportunities, but those 'rich families' wern't always rich. they also had to work to get to the point you have. and they passed on their success onto their children. so in the end. Equality of Opportunities is more desirable for me.


The problem with that is that it is inherently unfair and unjust. How can you justify giving someone a better quality of life, and give them more opportunities, simply because they were born in to the right families? Conversely, and more importantly, how can you justify giving someone a lower standard of education and jobs offerings simply because they were born into the wrong families?


it's not 'Being born to the right family" but it's also the fact that those families also worked hard to get where they are. if you instill the proper discipline in your children, then they will have as much opportunities as everyone else. it may not be the same TYPE of opportunities but they will have the same amount of opportunities.

Equality of outcome would negate any and all hard work, with that, it removes incentives since why try to improve your life if the lazy bum next door will have the same amount of success.


What different types of opportunities are available to those born into a poor family that the rich do not have, beyond that of affirmative action, which is government interference which at least does provide some semblance of equal opportunity? And let's assume equal amount of proper discipline can be achieved by both the rich and the poor (not an entirely unreasonable assumption, I think). The rich still has better access to facilities be it private tutoring, better connections, etc. than the poor. And equal education only extends to K12 schools. Once you get to college, all bets are off. Certainly, there are need-based and merit-based scholarships, but the need-based scholarships can only afford average, not prestigious colleges, and the merit-based ones, if anything, are spent more on the rich, which can afford a higher level of education anyway through their extracurricular activities. One can argue that the kind of college you go into does not matter if you can show your success, but in reality this is not the case. Universities have uneven level education and people graduating from top (and usually more expensive) universities are more likely to receive high-paying jobs.

And all of this hinges on which kind of family you're born into. So yes, even assuming equal amount of proper discipline, it is still about "being born to the right family," which is something an individual cannot control.

User avatar
Central Slavia
Powerbroker
 
Posts: 8463
Founded: Nov 05, 2009
Corrupt Dictatorship

Postby Central Slavia » Thu Dec 03, 2009 1:09 pm

so-called affirmative action is bullshit.
the proper way is to have free education for everyone, that is paid from taxes.
Kosovo is Serbia!
Embassy Anthem Store Facts

Glorious Homeland wrote:
You would be wrong. There's something wrong with the Americans, the Japanese are actually insane, the Chinese don't seem capable of free-thought and just defer judgement to the most powerful strong man, the Russians are quite like that, only more aggressive and mad, and Belarus? Hah.

Omnicracy wrote:The Soviet Union did not support pro-Soviet governments, it compleatly controled them. The U.S. did not controle the corrupt regiems it set up against the Soviet Union, it just sugested things and changed leaders if they weer not takeing enough sugestions

Great Nepal wrote:Please stick to OFFICIAL numbers. Why to go to scholars,[cut]

User avatar
Andaluciae
Negotiator
 
Posts: 5766
Founded: Antiquity
Ex-Nation

Postby Andaluciae » Thu Dec 03, 2009 1:17 pm

Rhodmhire wrote:
Angleter wrote:...we need a society where anyone can become Prime Minister, or a barrister or doctor.


Anyone, really?


How about this guy?
FreeAgency wrote:Shellfish eating used to be restricted to dens of sin such as Red Lobster and Long John Silvers, but now days I cannot even take my children to a public restaurant anymore (even the supposedly "family friendly ones") without risking their having to watch some deranged individual flaunting his sin...

User avatar
Friedman and Rothbard
Bureaucrat
 
Posts: 65
Founded: Dec 03, 2009
Ex-Nation

Postby Friedman and Rothbard » Thu Dec 03, 2009 2:09 pm

Anarchic-Marxist wrote:What do the people of NS think is true equality?


Equality of outcome can only be achieved through the iron fist of government, and even then it's nothing more than artificial, feel-good equality. In the real world it is equal misery. It doesn't take into account practical economics. Only in a genuine free market -- not the nonsense Republicans talk about, but a market freed through the abolition of government -- can equality be achieved. You might mention the possibility of monopolies arising, but in an actual free market, a monopoly cannot exist. Monopolies only exist through protection by government, such as tariffs, etc.
"One of the great mistakes is to judge policies and programs by their intentions rather than their results." - Milton Friedman.

User avatar
Panasean
Lobbyist
 
Posts: 17
Founded: Nov 27, 2009
Ex-Nation

Postby Panasean » Thu Dec 03, 2009 2:43 pm

Central Slavia wrote:so-called affirmative action is bullshit.
the proper way is to have free education for everyone, that is paid from taxes.


Agreed. While it does create a semblance (dare I say even an illusion?) of leveling the playing field, it is a crappy system.

User avatar
Abdju
Minister
 
Posts: 2153
Founded: Jul 01, 2007
Ex-Nation

Postby Abdju » Thu Dec 03, 2009 2:47 pm

Neither. Equality of outcome would just end up eliminating any kind of social order and create a near-anarchic situation. Equality of opportunity just results in a self-centred entitlement "me first, me second, me third... mine mine mine" mentality with no sense of responsibility or obligation to anyone but oneself.

Left/Right -5.25 | Auth/Lib: +2.57 |
"Objectivism really is a Fountainhead of philosophical diarrhea" - derscon
"God Hates Fags But Says It's Okay to Double Dip" - Gauthier

Great Nepal - Tax supporting environment are useless, we can live without it.
Great Nepal - Lions can't fly. Therefore, eagles are superior.
Turan Cumhuriyeti - no you presented lower quality of brain
Greed and Death - Spanish was an Amerindian language.
Sungai Pusat - No, I know exactly what happened. The Titanic had left USA's shores and somewhere near the Arctic Circle
Derscon - I let Jews handle my money, not my penis.
Fevolo - i'm not talking about catholics. i'm talking about christians.

User avatar
Friedman and Rothbard
Bureaucrat
 
Posts: 65
Founded: Dec 03, 2009
Ex-Nation

Postby Friedman and Rothbard » Thu Dec 03, 2009 2:51 pm

Abdju wrote:Neither. Equality of outcome would just end up eliminating any kind of social order and create a near-anarchic situation. Equality of opportunity just results in a self-centered entitlement "me first, me second, me third... mine mine mine" mentality with no sense of responsibility or obligation to anyone but oneself.


Then what's left? In a capitalistic society, self-interest is essential. Individuals are responsible for themselves. I have no obligation to you and you have no obligation to me. In a market economy, the goal is to compete against others, to create the best product with the best price, and to convince people to use your product instead of mine. You can't cloud the debate with appeals to emotion. No just law (but of course few laws made by government are just) states I have to sacrifice myself to ensure your success.
"One of the great mistakes is to judge policies and programs by their intentions rather than their results." - Milton Friedman.

User avatar
Abdju
Minister
 
Posts: 2153
Founded: Jul 01, 2007
Ex-Nation

Postby Abdju » Thu Dec 03, 2009 2:56 pm

Friedman and Rothbard wrote:
Anarchic-Marxist wrote:What do the people of NS think is true equality?


Equality of outcome can only be achieved through the iron fist of government, and even then it's nothing more than artificial, feel-good equality. In the real world it is equal misery. It doesn't take into account practical economics. Only in a genuine free market -- not the nonsense Republicans talk about, but a market freed through the abolition of government -- can equality be achieved. You might mention the possibility of monopolies arising, but in an actual free market, a monopoly cannot exist. Monopolies only exist through protection by government, such as tariffs, etc.


BS. Monopolies exist when anyone (government or not) has the power to force someone out of business. Eg.:

Take a ferry service for example.
White Company has been in the business for years and has made a decent profit and so has some money behind it, selling tickets at £20 a throw.

Red Company is a new startup with little cash behind it. It wants to break into the market so undercuts on prices, selling tickets at £10 a throw, and is taking trade of White Company.

White company reduces it's fares to £1 a throw, way below cost price, but has plenty of cash to subsidise it's activities for months, or even years.

Red drops it's fares, but soon runs heavily into debt and is unable to meet it's commitments. It ceases trading.

White puts fares back to £20 a throw.

No government necessary for this scenario to come about.
PS: Real world scenario in a place I lived dependent on said ferry service, comapnies names are made up though.
Last edited by Abdju on Thu Dec 03, 2009 3:08 pm, edited 1 time in total.

Left/Right -5.25 | Auth/Lib: +2.57 |
"Objectivism really is a Fountainhead of philosophical diarrhea" - derscon
"God Hates Fags But Says It's Okay to Double Dip" - Gauthier

Great Nepal - Tax supporting environment are useless, we can live without it.
Great Nepal - Lions can't fly. Therefore, eagles are superior.
Turan Cumhuriyeti - no you presented lower quality of brain
Greed and Death - Spanish was an Amerindian language.
Sungai Pusat - No, I know exactly what happened. The Titanic had left USA's shores and somewhere near the Arctic Circle
Derscon - I let Jews handle my money, not my penis.
Fevolo - i'm not talking about catholics. i'm talking about christians.

User avatar
Abdju
Minister
 
Posts: 2153
Founded: Jul 01, 2007
Ex-Nation

Postby Abdju » Thu Dec 03, 2009 3:07 pm

Friedman and Rothbard wrote:
Abdju wrote:Neither. Equality of outcome would just end up eliminating any kind of social order and create a near-anarchic situation. Equality of opportunity just results in a self-centered entitlement "me first, me second, me third... mine mine mine" mentality with no sense of responsibility or obligation to anyone but oneself.


Then what's left? In a capitalistic society, self-interest is essential. Individuals are responsible for themselves. I have no obligation to you and you have no obligation to me. In a market economy, the goal is to compete against others, to create the best product with the best price, and to convince people to use your product instead of mine. You can't cloud the debate with appeals to emotion. No just law (but of course few laws made by government are just) states I have to sacrifice myself to ensure your success.


You take the position that your ethics (your "just" and "unjust" judgements of law) are universal. You may not agree with my ethics, but to accuse me of clouding the debate with emotion when yours are supposedly universal and above such things is ridiculous. Your appeal to what is just and what ins't and your desire that each competes rather than honours his obligations it no more nor no less emotional than mine.

IN either case, the talk was not of "sacrafice" but of equality. I did not say anyone "sacrifices" anything, merely that the state should not concern itself with there equality of outcome or of opportunity. Rather it should ensure that the social structure is stable and maintained, by ensuring that all levels of it understand and respect their obligations and that their rights are honoured and ensured in return. Capitalism or communism don't come into it. Frankly, I regard them both as prone to failure, but in different ways.

Left/Right -5.25 | Auth/Lib: +2.57 |
"Objectivism really is a Fountainhead of philosophical diarrhea" - derscon
"God Hates Fags But Says It's Okay to Double Dip" - Gauthier

Great Nepal - Tax supporting environment are useless, we can live without it.
Great Nepal - Lions can't fly. Therefore, eagles are superior.
Turan Cumhuriyeti - no you presented lower quality of brain
Greed and Death - Spanish was an Amerindian language.
Sungai Pusat - No, I know exactly what happened. The Titanic had left USA's shores and somewhere near the Arctic Circle
Derscon - I let Jews handle my money, not my penis.
Fevolo - i'm not talking about catholics. i'm talking about christians.

User avatar
Friedman and Rothbard
Bureaucrat
 
Posts: 65
Founded: Dec 03, 2009
Ex-Nation

Postby Friedman and Rothbard » Thu Dec 03, 2009 3:08 pm

Abdju wrote:
Friedman and Rothbard wrote:
Anarchic-Marxist wrote:What do the people of NS think is true equality?


Equality of outcome can only be achieved through the iron fist of government, and even then it's nothing more than artificial, feel-good equality. In the real world it is equal misery. It doesn't take into account practical economics. Only in a genuine free market -- not the nonsense Republicans talk about, but a market freed through the abolition of government -- can equality be achieved. You might mention the possibility of monopolies arising, but in an actual free market, a monopoly cannot exist. Monopolies only exist through protection by government, such as tariffs, etc.


BS. Monopolies exist when anyone (government or not) has the power to force someone out of business. Eg.:

Take a ferry service for example.
White Company has been in the business for years and has made a decent profit and so has some money behind it, selling tickets at £20 a throw.

Red Company is a new startup with little cash behind it. It wants to break into the market so undercuts on prices, selling tickets at £10 a throw, and is taking trade of White Company.

White company reduces it's fares to £1 a throw, way below cost price, but has plenty of cash to subsidise it's activities for months, or even years.

Red drops it's fares, but soon runs heavily into debt and is unable to meet it's commitments. It ceases trading.

White puts fares back to £20 a throw.

No government necessary for this scenario to come about.


You contradicted your thesis with your argument. The events you noted were not a result of unfair practices, but the actual mechanisms of the market. "White Company" was simply reacting to new competition. "Red Company" obviously did not conduct its business well enough to turn a profit: that's why it ran into debt. If "White Company" was a genuine monopoly, "Red Company" would not have been able to enter into the market to begin with, and if it managed to enter the market, it would have been bought out.
"One of the great mistakes is to judge policies and programs by their intentions rather than their results." - Milton Friedman.

PreviousNext

Advertisement

Remove ads

Return to General

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: Big Gav, Celritannia, Chess Socialism, Cole Whyte-Gurney, General TN, Google Adsense [Bot], Platypus Bureaucracy, Yorsa II

Advertisement

Remove ads