NATION

PASSWORD

[RESUB] Normalized Templates for Passports

A record of historical World Assembly debates.

Advertisement

Remove ads

User avatar
Voopmont
Envoy
 
Posts: 309
Founded: Dec 19, 2018
Democratic Socialists

Postby Voopmont » Fri Apr 18, 2025 8:35 pm

Eireann Fae wrote:"We appreciate both your consideration of our suggestions and the followup question, Ambassador. When we evaluate the burdens of compliance placed upon entities by World Assembly legislation, it is generally our policy to take the most pains to ameliorate individual burdens, then those placed on Member Nations, with only slight considerations being made for the World Assembly itself. However, the WA General Fund is not unlimited, and the number of languages utilised even just within Member Nations may be, so perhaps there is room for compromise here. The issue then becomes, where is the line demarcating the 'most common languages' drawn? We typically prefer to avoid hard numbers being placed in legislation, but..." Rowan furrows her brow, contemplating the problem.

"Should the threshold be drawn against the percentage of a Member Nation's population that utilises the language in question? Volume of actual requests made to OSEP to support the language? A minimum of one language per Member Nation—with the option to change that language in the future—plus some reasonable number more on request? The requesting nation could decide internally which languages they would like to see represented, either through decree or democratic process. Eireann Fae would consider this a great compromise in favour of Member Nations at the expense of their diverse residents, but could still support such a bill. Perhaps 3b could read: OSEP is responsible for translating all documentation provided by them into at least one language for each Member Nation, each of which also retaining the option to request translations for up to nine additional languages. Or based on popularity, such as ...each of which may also request translations into languages utilised by at least ten percent of their population. Thoughts?"

"We're very appreciative of these suggestions, ambassador." Silas Graygal walks into the room, taking notes over a dark purple metallic clipboard. The ambassador is of a fishy, nearly mammalian species and wearing a type of Bowalian wetsuit made to look presentable as formal wear on land. "When such a useful piece of legislation was repealed due primarily to complaints over its scope and function rather than its inherent qualities, we felt that reviving the idea could be highly beneficial to the international community in more ways than one. I already agree with most of these annotations, my team and I will take some time to look over the details this evening. As per the issue of languages to translate to, our idea was for government operations to act as a benchmark for which languages are worth translating to; if the government of Bigtopia only writes official government documentation in Bigtopian and Maxtopian, those would be the languages OSEP would be required to translate templates into. Ironically, it seems this idea may have itself been lost in translation. It must be noted that when deciding how many languages to include, many WA states are of a scale almost incomprehensible to the median country. For this reason perhaps the clause could specify a right to translations for up to five unique languages or one per 2 billion or so sentient individuals, whichever one is higher? Regardless, your suggestions have been of great help to us as nations with no experience writing for the world assembly."
Governor, The United Federations | Author of GA#804, GA#821 | Minister of World Assembly Affairs, The North Pacific | Nation of nonhumans and spacefarers

He/They

User avatar
Efel Path
Secretary
 
Posts: 33
Founded: Jan 20, 2025
Ex-Nation

Postby Efel Path » Sat Apr 19, 2025 9:14 am

"Might we suggest that rather than specifying numerical values in the text of the resolution, we defer to OSEP, and let them cooperate with member states to decide which languages to use for each member state's passport? If we provide exact values, they could be criticised as arbitrary, might not apply in specific scenarios, and could become outdated depending on the growth of the WA. Arguably that would set this up for a repeal."

"However we proceed, I'm happy that this has sparked so much discussion. Our thanks ambassador from Eireann Fae!"
Last edited by Efel Path on Sat Apr 19, 2025 9:18 am, edited 1 time in total.
Efel Path back with another BANGER of a post

''A French novel-tier idiot.''

User avatar
Eireann Fae
Senator
 
Posts: 3895
Founded: Oct 15, 2010
Ex-Nation

Postby Eireann Fae » Sat Apr 19, 2025 10:28 am

Rowan smiles and gestures appreciatively to the representative from Efel Path as they push back against specifying numerical values in the text of the legislation. She manages to contain any actual outbursts until after the ambassador had finished speaking.

"Yes! I spoke lightly before, in indicating a typical preference to avoid 'hard numbers' in the text; the Community absolutely seeks to provide beneficial legislation in the most sweeping terms at all times. If the authors, delegates, and voters can be convinced to leave it entirely up to the discretion of the neutral World Assembly body performing these duties, that would indeed be the way we would prefer to go." Her bright enthusiasm fades, just a little, as she explains her previous suggestion. "Our consideration of numerical specificity was an attempt to answer the concerns you yourself raised, and which were just reaffirmed by our Voopmontian colleague. We would absolutely support an effort to provide passports in as many languages as legally possible!"

She pauses for a moment, considering language more suitable to represent the preferences of Eireann Fae. The diminutive Emissary beside her offers a whispered suggestion, which she shares with the chamber. "If we may suggest, OSEP is responsible for translating their documentation into the languages necessary to enable travel from all populations within each Member Nation. We can leave it to OSEP to decide the parameters of a 'population', but I believe a neutral organisation representing this august body would take pains to accommodate as many residents of Member Nations as it could, without breaking their own bank."

User avatar
Eireann Fae
Senator
 
Posts: 3895
Founded: Oct 15, 2010
Ex-Nation

Postby Eireann Fae » Sun Apr 20, 2025 8:32 am

"Hey Ro, check this out," Alexandra passes her colleague the tablet they share to review and draft World Assembly legislation. While Rowan was working with the other delegates to iron out the details, she had been reviewing committees to find a suitable one for a different proposal. One of them caught her eye; Rowan reads the entry aloud.

"World Assembly Language Society..." She follows the link to the resolution that created the committee, for Protecting Minority Languages, to verify its mandate. "They survey and record existing languages, and already work with governments on their preservation and revitalisation. Alex, this is perfect!" Her eyes light up as she finishes reading the previous resolution. She rises again to address the chamber.

"Alexandra may have found something of interest," she announces, smiling warmly as she turns her attention to the delegates from Efel Path, then Voopmont. "There already exists a committee managed by this august body that documents all languages utilised in Member Nations: the World Assembly Language Society. Created for GAR#426, we believe this organisation is more than suitable for the task at hand. As such, we suggest the following for section 3(b): The World Assembly Language Society shall work with the OSEP to translate relevant documentation into the languages necessary to enable travel from all populations within each Member Nation. This could save the World Assembly General Fund copious resources as we invoke a body that's already done most of the work for this aspect of the proposed law; the WALS already enjoying a close working relationship with Member Nations could ease some of of their concerns as well. Thoughts?"

User avatar
Voopmont
Envoy
 
Posts: 309
Founded: Dec 19, 2018
Democratic Socialists

Postby Voopmont » Mon Apr 21, 2025 12:32 pm

"Brilliant!" Silas' tone shifts to excitement. "This would indeed save an enormous amount of resources. I would personally prefer something a little more airtight? But since I don't have any suggestions to replace it this will be appropriate pending criticism. The draft has just been updated with all your suggestions." He stops to take a drink. "If you have any future collaborations in mind, don't be afraid to approach us, we're eager to help in any way we can."
Governor, The United Federations | Author of GA#804, GA#821 | Minister of World Assembly Affairs, The North Pacific | Nation of nonhumans and spacefarers

He/They

User avatar
Eireann Fae
Senator
 
Posts: 3895
Founded: Oct 15, 2010
Ex-Nation

Postby Eireann Fae » Thu Apr 24, 2025 5:45 am

"Thank you, Ambassador. We fully support the proposal, and wish you luck with its submission and subsequent passage!"

User avatar
Voopmont
Envoy
 
Posts: 309
Founded: Dec 19, 2018
Democratic Socialists

Postby Voopmont » Wed Apr 30, 2025 6:35 am

LAST CALL. I will be submitting this to the queue either this weekend or next, whenever I have time to campaign for it. This is your last chance to give feedback.
Governor, The United Federations | Author of GA#804, GA#821 | Minister of World Assembly Affairs, The North Pacific | Nation of nonhumans and spacefarers

He/They

User avatar
Voopmont
Envoy
 
Posts: 309
Founded: Dec 19, 2018
Democratic Socialists

Postby Voopmont » Fri May 02, 2025 6:07 pm

Submission is postponed until at least monday to keep a clear queue
Governor, The United Federations | Author of GA#804, GA#821 | Minister of World Assembly Affairs, The North Pacific | Nation of nonhumans and spacefarers

He/They

User avatar
Barfleur
Ambassador
 
Posts: 1496
Founded: Mar 04, 2019
Ex-Nation

Postby Barfleur » Fri May 02, 2025 6:59 pm

"Support."


Ambassador to the World Assembly: Edmure Norfield
Military Attaché: Colonel Lyndon Q. Ralston
Sapient Human-Sized Rabbit: Troy of Rabbittown
Authorship

User avatar
Voopmont
Envoy
 
Posts: 309
Founded: Dec 19, 2018
Democratic Socialists

Postby Voopmont » Mon May 05, 2025 8:20 am

Eireann Fae added as co-author for significant contributions in editing the text
Last edited by Voopmont on Mon May 05, 2025 8:21 am, edited 1 time in total.
Governor, The United Federations | Author of GA#804, GA#821 | Minister of World Assembly Affairs, The North Pacific | Nation of nonhumans and spacefarers

He/They

User avatar
Eireann Fae
Senator
 
Posts: 3895
Founded: Oct 15, 2010
Ex-Nation

Postby Eireann Fae » Mon May 05, 2025 9:28 am

"We appreciate the recognition, Ambassador Graygal, and wish good luck for us all in seeing this sensible legislation come to pass."

User avatar
Cretox State
Ambassador
 
Posts: 1308
Founded: Nov 04, 2015
Liberal Democratic Socialists

Postby Cretox State » Mon May 05, 2025 9:30 am

“A fine effort!”
GA/SC/Issues author. The East Pacific Minister of World Assembly Affairs. Killer of Stats. Thought Leader. Public Servant. P20 Laureate. Delegate Emeritus of hundreds, thousands [sic] of regions.

User avatar
Voopmont
Envoy
 
Posts: 309
Founded: Dec 19, 2018
Democratic Socialists

Postby Voopmont » Sat May 10, 2025 5:50 am

Lightning round: deciding a category. I'll list below what I think are the options.

Free Trade: Mild, because it streamlines the process of international travel and therefore has an impact on ease of doing business internationally. "Free trade" is more difficult if you get stuck at the border for 2 hours waiting for someone to come along with a different type of passport reader because they're concerned you're a bad actor with a fake passport.

Regulation: Safety, because it significantly improves everyone's ability to properly identify potential bad actors. I think this is the weakest one.

Regulation: Transportation, because it is significantly affecting how international transport might be handled with more standard passports. Could mean you no longer have to show up a half hour earlier to the spaceport for your flight to Epsilon Indi just in case.

Planning to submit in about 3 hours if all goes well (should've done this last night but it's too late for that now!)
Governor, The United Federations | Author of GA#804, GA#821 | Minister of World Assembly Affairs, The North Pacific | Nation of nonhumans and spacefarers

He/They

User avatar
US Internal Revenue Service
Bureaucrat
 
Posts: 59
Founded: Jan 21, 2024
Benevolent Dictatorship

Postby US Internal Revenue Service » Sat May 10, 2025 6:23 am

Looks pretty good!
Category wise I'd probably knock Free Trade off since thats more commerce and business sorta stuff.
Regulation of Transportation makes the most sense to me, passports are mainly used for planes and other transport.
Last edited by US Internal Revenue Service on Sat May 10, 2025 6:24 am, edited 1 time in total.
"I wonder who's watching me now? WHO? THE IRS!"
A Meme Nation based out of Hell that taxes the souls of the dammed, which was previously a more serious nation, then got rebranded into a funny weeb nation, and now lies mostly dormant besides me answering issues to get the highest "Freedom from Taxation" stat as possible.
If you're reading this, you owe us money.

User avatar
Efel Path
Secretary
 
Posts: 33
Founded: Jan 20, 2025
Ex-Nation

Postby Efel Path » Sat May 10, 2025 7:59 am

US Internal Revenue Service wrote:Regulation of Transportation makes the most sense to me, passports are mainly used for planes and other transport.

OOC: Agreed :p
Efel Path back with another BANGER of a post

''A French novel-tier idiot.''

User avatar
Voopmont
Envoy
 
Posts: 309
Founded: Dec 19, 2018
Democratic Socialists

Postby Voopmont » Sat May 10, 2025 8:49 am

US Internal Revenue Service wrote:Looks pretty good!
Category wise I'd probably knock Free Trade off since thats more commerce and business sorta stuff.
Regulation of Transportation makes the most sense to me, passports are mainly used for planes and other transport.

Thanks for the feedback! I think we'll be going with that one!
Governor, The United Federations | Author of GA#804, GA#821 | Minister of World Assembly Affairs, The North Pacific | Nation of nonhumans and spacefarers

He/They

User avatar
Voopmont
Envoy
 
Posts: 309
Founded: Dec 19, 2018
Democratic Socialists

Postby Voopmont » Sat May 10, 2025 9:46 am

Governor, The United Federations | Author of GA#804, GA#821 | Minister of World Assembly Affairs, The North Pacific | Nation of nonhumans and spacefarers

He/They

User avatar
Eireann Fae
Senator
 
Posts: 3895
Founded: Oct 15, 2010
Ex-Nation

Postby Eireann Fae » Sat May 10, 2025 4:17 pm

"We would like to once again offer our gratitude to Voopmont, Simone Republic, and Efel Path for allowing us the opportunity to have positive impact with real international legislation. The deluge of repeal efforts of late has been exceedingly disheartening, and most other positive efforts are replacements accompanying repeals. We consider proposals the likes of this one to be rare diamonds among the rough stones hurled to destroy this great body, and hope to offer more such shining examples in the near future. In the meantime," Rowan steps aside to reveal that Alex had produced a bottle of Fae Honeywine and was in the process of filling several tall, narrow glasses. Rowan picks up one such glass and raises it for the chamber to see. More obscured, but no less available, are the bottles stashed below the table. "Drinks are on us!"

User avatar
Simone Republic
Minister
 
Posts: 2772
Founded: Jul 09, 2019
Capitalizt

Postby Simone Republic » Sun May 25, 2025 6:26 am

I hereby release this draft in case it is re-used in future by other authors, if it is defeated following the upcoming vote and resubmitted.

User avatar
Voopmont
Envoy
 
Posts: 309
Founded: Dec 19, 2018
Democratic Socialists

Postby Voopmont » Sun May 25, 2025 7:36 am

Proposal has been withdrawn because we strongly doubt it would pass anyway. It may be resubmitted in the near future but with how things are going now don't count on anything. Thank you to everyone who has made this possible through your comments, suggestions, and guidance. I appreciate it so much
Last edited by Voopmont on Sun May 25, 2025 7:36 am, edited 1 time in total.
Governor, The United Federations | Author of GA#804, GA#821 | Minister of World Assembly Affairs, The North Pacific | Nation of nonhumans and spacefarers

He/They

User avatar
Efel Path
Secretary
 
Posts: 33
Founded: Jan 20, 2025
Ex-Nation

Postby Efel Path » Sun May 25, 2025 7:41 am

OOC: In addition to the above, I would like to emphasise that I think it would have been inappropriate for the proposal to go to vote right now. I don't think I could campaign for people's attention in good conscience when it justifiably lies elsewhere.
Efel Path back with another BANGER of a post

''A French novel-tier idiot.''

User avatar
Eireann Fae
Senator
 
Posts: 3895
Founded: Oct 15, 2010
Ex-Nation

Postby Eireann Fae » Sun May 25, 2025 8:21 am

(OOC: Agreed. I'm probably not even going to submit Infrastructure this week like I'd originally hoped. You have my full support, Voopmont.)

User avatar
Voopmont
Envoy
 
Posts: 309
Founded: Dec 19, 2018
Democratic Socialists

Postby Voopmont » Thu Jun 19, 2025 9:19 am

Governor, The United Federations | Author of GA#804, GA#821 | Minister of World Assembly Affairs, The North Pacific | Nation of nonhumans and spacefarers

He/They

User avatar
Bisofeyr
Issues Moderator
 
Posts: 3028
Founded: Nov 26, 2023
Democratic Socialists

Postby Bisofeyr » Thu Jun 19, 2025 9:59 am

I support :)
Currently reading: The Way of Kings, Brandon Sanderson

User avatar
Voopmont
Envoy
 
Posts: 309
Founded: Dec 19, 2018
Democratic Socialists

Postby Voopmont » Sat Jun 21, 2025 12:26 pm

I'm posting here because many criticisms of this proposal were brought up on discord, some with better merits than others. I am therefore posting a new draft version and asking for commentary on this over the next two weeks, as it is literally impossible for me to campaign for another resubmission until the second week of july. The following is my understanding of the concerns posted primarily by Dilber, Excidium Planetis and Wallenburg, as well as my response to the criticism.

C: Clause 2. g. requires every WA member state recognize every other WA member as a legitimate state by recognizing their passports as legal.
R: Old clause 2. g. removed.

C: No replacement timeline is specified or referred to which therefore requires prompt replacement of all old passports and most manufacturing equipment.
R: Replacement timeline brought up in clause 2. h.

C: No sort of exemption is made for special issued or emergency passports, as well as for travel permits (such as the ones present in irl china/taiwan)
R: I have changed the definition of a passport and replaced clause 2. g.

C: The resolution requires no translation of passports to some common language and dating system (/pos), however this means passports will be illegible to most foreign states regardless. It will be impossible for the vast majority of member states to read the name and date of birth of the passport holder, to give one example.
R: I am working under the assumption that member states have worked all of this out to the point that international travel to nations even vastly disconnected from them is possible, although likely not easy. I think most people agree that requiring translation into a common language or dating system is an overreach of the world assembly's powers and just out of the question, but there are other ways to verify authenticity: for example, certain manufactured features of the passport, the individual's picture matches, some kind of chip to scan and confirm that the passport is legit. Whatever it is, that's up to the gnomes to decide which techniques to include. Creating a database of dating systems or something like that is outside the scope of the resolution and I have no plans to expand it to include that, although I am on record saying that it could realistically be managed by a couple nations of at least modern tech who care to make one.

C: (followup to the previous concern) The proposal accomplishes nothing due to the passports being indecipherable, negating any advantage of arranging information in a uniform manner. On the other hand, if member states have figured out how to read those dates and foreign language text in most circumstances, they would certainly be able to figure out where the date of birth, name, etc, are located.
R: In the second scenario there would still be an advantage because it opens up more options for automation and saves time accounting for unpredictability. In both scenarios, referring to the previous answer there is a benefit from the potential inclusion of security technology or elements that wouldn't need to be deciphered. Regardless of what the actual scenario is, the gnomes know better than you or I and have been instructed to adapt accordingly. Just to be safe I have extended clause 2. b.

Additions have been underlined. Character count is 3381.
The World Assembly,

Recognizing the benefits of standardized passport arrangements, as outlined in GA#717;

Acknowledging the criticisms brought up in GA#761; and

Hoping to reconcile these issues with the ease of travel, increased safety, and cost savings gained by standard passport arrangements;

Hereby enacts as follows;

  1. Definitions:
    1. The Passports, Nationality and Refugees Administration is hereby renamed to the "Office for the Standardization and Efficiency of Passports" (OSEP).
    2. "Passport" is a generic legal form of identification used for broad international travel.
    3. "Compliant passport" is a passport which abides by the standard templates designed and distributed by OSEP.
  2. Passport templates:
    1. OSEP is assigned the role of establishing normalized templates and arrangements for passports, by which all WA member states must abide.
    2. The use of such templates shall ensure each passport provides sufficient information to quickly, easily, and securely verify the identity of the individual to whom it has been issued. This may be done through the inclusion of various security technologies accessible to most member states.
    3. Such templates shall be designed in such a way as to incur minimal cost in their production, administration, and distribution, while maintaining a standard of quality to ensure compliant passports last the entirety of a typical renewal cycle.
    4. Such templates provide the minimum requirements for a compliant passport; additions and improvements may be made at the discretion of the issuing WA member state as long as they remain compatible with the templates designed by OSEP.
    5. Templates will be updated as necessary to reflect advancements in security technology and for other purposes at the discretion of the OSEP.
    6. Member States utilizing less common technology for passports may request modified templates from OSEP compatible with that nation's resources, or otherwise an outright exemption.
    7. Exemptions to these templates are provided to nonstandard passports or other travel documents, including but not limited to temporary passports, diplomatic passports, emergency passports, and travel permits applying only to a specific territory or list of territories.
    8. Implementation of these templates is not required immediately, Member States must transition their domestic intended passport production capacity to compliant passports at a rate which can be reasonably expected of them and no already issued passports must be recalled.
  3. Responsibilities and powers of OSEP:
    1. OSEP must provide complete manuals and style guides for the manufacture and issue of compliant passports to every WA member state.
    2. The World Assembly Language Society shall work with the OSEP to translate relevant documentation into the languages necessary to enable travel from all populations within each Member Nation.
    3. If requested by a World Assembly state, OSEP may be commissioned to issue or manufacture compliant passports on their behalf at break-even cost.
  4. Services from OSEP not related to the manufacture or distribution of physical passports are to be provided free of charge.


Special thanks to Tinhampton who has helped me (probably even more than I've helped myself) figure out the submission timeline working around my trip. Now if you'll excuse me, I have a luggage to pack.
Governor, The United Federations | Author of GA#804, GA#821 | Minister of World Assembly Affairs, The North Pacific | Nation of nonhumans and spacefarers

He/They

PreviousNext

Advertisement

Remove ads

Return to WA Archives

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: No registered users

Advertisement

Remove ads