Advertisement
by Nationalist Northumbria » Sun Jul 03, 2022 4:14 pm
by The Sarangtus Lands » Sun Jul 03, 2022 4:51 pm
Nationalist Northumbria wrote:Your Discord link is broken.
by Dentali » Sun Jul 03, 2022 5:33 pm
by Meretica » Wed Jul 06, 2022 4:26 pm
by Sao Nova Europa » Wed Jul 06, 2022 5:46 pm
by South Olpen » Wed Jul 06, 2022 7:06 pm
The Scezonian Telegram Dep. of Defense Announces Anti-Ballistic Missile Research | Election 2028; Opinions of Candidates | War Between Galapagos and Aursi... Again
by Sao Nova Europa » Wed Jul 06, 2022 7:11 pm
by Louisianan » Wed Jul 06, 2022 7:12 pm
by Sao Nova Europa » Wed Jul 06, 2022 7:15 pm
by South Olpen » Wed Jul 06, 2022 7:23 pm
Sao Nova Europa wrote:Which RL generals is William replacing? Jackson is Patton in North Africa and Sicily, and Omar Bradley in France and Germany (plus MacArthur in Korean War, but that is another story). I assume, based on the app, that William is replacing Patton during mainland European campaign?
The Scezonian Telegram Dep. of Defense Announces Anti-Ballistic Missile Research | Election 2028; Opinions of Candidates | War Between Galapagos and Aursi... Again
by Sao Nova Europa » Wed Jul 06, 2022 7:27 pm
SOUTH OLPEN wrote:Sao Nova Europa wrote:Which RL generals is William replacing? Jackson is Patton in North Africa and Sicily, and Omar Bradley in France and Germany (plus MacArthur in Korean War, but that is another story). I assume, based on the app, that William is replacing Patton during mainland European campaign?
While I believe that Bradley would be appropriate given his faceclaim, I am not a history buff, nor do I believe I know more than you, so Patton. Although then again, I personally see no reason with just having a merger of characters/having a new one take a bit of glory from some of the existing ones. But I defer to you.
by South Olpen » Wed Jul 06, 2022 7:30 pm
Sao Nova Europa wrote:SOUTH OLPEN wrote:While I believe that Bradley would be appropriate given his faceclaim, I am not a history buff, nor do I believe I know more than you, so Patton. Although then again, I personally see no reason with just having a merger of characters/having a new one take a bit of glory from some of the existing ones. But I defer to you.
Well, I've already apped as a WWII General (who combines elements of the generals I mentioned) which is why I am trying to clarify things to ensure our biographies do not contradict each other. So, I assume you are replacing Patton in European campaign? If yes, I will be changing mentions to Patton in my bio to your character.
BTW, you might want to check out my app for that reason. It's a bit extensively long but it is so to avoid any confusions about commands held: General Jonathan Jackson
The Scezonian Telegram Dep. of Defense Announces Anti-Ballistic Missile Research | Election 2028; Opinions of Candidates | War Between Galapagos and Aursi... Again
by Sao Nova Europa » Wed Jul 06, 2022 7:31 pm
SOUTH OLPEN wrote:Sao Nova Europa wrote:
Well, I've already apped as a WWII General (who combines elements of the generals I mentioned) which is why I am trying to clarify things to ensure our biographies do not contradict each other. So, I assume you are replacing Patton in European campaign? If yes, I will be changing mentions to Patton in my bio to your character.
BTW, you might want to check out my app for that reason. It's a bit extensively long but it is so to avoid any confusions about commands held: General Jonathan Jackson
Very well. I will read the parts about World War Two. I'm basically fine just slotting in Downeson in any unoccupied events in the war, so long as he commands the Battle of the Bulge on the allied side.
by South Olpen » Wed Jul 06, 2022 7:33 pm
Sao Nova Europa wrote:SOUTH OLPEN wrote:Very well. I will read the parts about World War Two. I'm basically fine just slotting in Downeson in any unoccupied events in the war, so long as he commands the Battle of the Bulge on the allied side.
I mean sure. In my app I have Jackson being sidelined from the Battle of the Bulge (as in RL with Bradley), so your character can come to the rescue (like Patton did IRL).
The Scezonian Telegram Dep. of Defense Announces Anti-Ballistic Missile Research | Election 2028; Opinions of Candidates | War Between Galapagos and Aursi... Again
by Sao Nova Europa » Wed Jul 06, 2022 7:41 pm
SOUTH OLPEN wrote:Edit: While I take no offense to the initial leading of the Battle of the Bulge, I ask you to allow Downeson to take control for most of the battle and be at least mostly responsible for the victory. As stated above, I simply want that one battle and am otherwise more than OK with being slotted in for other battles.
by Louisianan » Wed Jul 06, 2022 7:43 pm
Sao Nova Europa wrote:SOUTH OLPEN wrote:Edit: While I take no offense to the initial leading of the Battle of the Bulge, I ask you to allow Downeson to take control for most of the battle and be at least mostly responsible for the victory. As stated above, I simply want that one battle and am otherwise more than OK with being slotted in for other battles.
I mean Patton (your character in this TL) was mostly responsible for the successful defense against the Bulge offensive: "the Third Army (AKA Patton) took the lead in relieving beleaguered American troops at Bastogne during the Battle of the Bulge". So you will be the big hero of the battle and it is essentially your victory.
But nominally Montgomery is in total command since in RL he was in command (Ike in RL placed Patton's army under Monty's command: same in this TL, pissing off Jackson). That does not mean you cannot claim it was your moves that secured victory though; Patton in RL certainly claimed that.
Not sure how it would work otherwise since technically your character would be a subordinate of Jackson (your character commands an army and Jackson and Montgomery army groups).
by Sao Nova Europa » Wed Jul 06, 2022 7:45 pm
Louisianan wrote:Sao Nova Europa wrote:
I mean Patton (your character in this TL) was mostly responsible for the successful defense against the Bulge offensive: "the Third Army (AKA Patton) took the lead in relieving beleaguered American troops at Bastogne during the Battle of the Bulge". So you will be the big hero of the battle and it is essentially your victory.
But nominally Montgomery is in total command since in RL he was in command (Ike in RL placed Patton's army under Monty's command: same in this TL, pissing off Jackson). That does not mean you cannot claim it was your moves that secured victory though; Patton in RL certainly claimed that.
Not sure how it would work otherwise since technically your character would be a subordinate of Jackson (your character commands an army and Jackson and Montgomery army groups).
Ok... so if y'all apps interfere with Davis's at all don't worry about it, if it ever needs fixing ICly we'll cross that bridge when we get there lmao.
by South Olpen » Wed Jul 06, 2022 7:48 pm
Sao Nova Europa wrote:SOUTH OLPEN wrote:Edit: While I take no offense to the initial leading of the Battle of the Bulge, I ask you to allow Downeson to take control for most of the battle and be at least mostly responsible for the victory. As stated above, I simply want that one battle and am otherwise more than OK with being slotted in for other battles.
I mean Patton (your character in this TL) was mostly responsible for the successful defense against the Bulge offensive: "the Third Army (AKA Patton) took the lead in relieving beleaguered American troops at Bastogne during the Battle of the Bulge". So you will be the big hero of the battle and it is essentially your victory.
But nominally Montgomery is in total command since in RL he was in command (Ike in RL placed Patton's army under Monty's command: same in this TL, pissing off Jackson). That does not mean you cannot claim it was your moves that secured victory though; Patton in RL certainly claimed that.
Not sure how it would work otherwise since technically your character would be a subordinate of Jackson (your character commands an army and Jackson and Montgomery army groups), so you would not be nominally the overall commander. But as commander of the third army, you can claim that your actions were responsible for defeating the Germans.
The Scezonian Telegram Dep. of Defense Announces Anti-Ballistic Missile Research | Election 2028; Opinions of Candidates | War Between Galapagos and Aursi... Again
by Sao Nova Europa » Wed Jul 06, 2022 7:49 pm
SOUTH OLPEN wrote:Sao Nova Europa wrote:
I mean Patton (your character in this TL) was mostly responsible for the successful defense against the Bulge offensive: "the Third Army (AKA Patton) took the lead in relieving beleaguered American troops at Bastogne during the Battle of the Bulge". So you will be the big hero of the battle and it is essentially your victory.
But nominally Montgomery is in total command since in RL he was in command (Ike in RL placed Patton's army under Monty's command: same in this TL, pissing off Jackson). That does not mean you cannot claim it was your moves that secured victory though; Patton in RL certainly claimed that.
Not sure how it would work otherwise since technically your character would be a subordinate of Jackson (your character commands an army and Jackson and Montgomery army groups), so you would not be nominally the overall commander. But as commander of the third army, you can claim that your actions were responsible for defeating the Germans.
That's fine with me. As I said, his only other accomplishment could be glorious conqueror of Fucking Nowhere, Germany as long as he can be hailed as the mastermind behind the victory in the Battle of the Bulge. So yeah, that's fine.
by South Olpen » Wed Jul 06, 2022 7:52 pm
The Scezonian Telegram Dep. of Defense Announces Anti-Ballistic Missile Research | Election 2028; Opinions of Candidates | War Between Galapagos and Aursi... Again
by Sao Nova Europa » Wed Jul 06, 2022 7:56 pm
by South Olpen » Wed Jul 06, 2022 8:04 pm
Sao Nova Europa wrote:SOUTH OLPEN wrote:In that case, is there anything else to complete or specify?
Will be reviewing your app tomorrow probably, but I don't think so. I just needed to clarify things about WWII. So, if and when you are accepted, I'll be replacing mentions of Patton during European campaign with your character.
You could also add a line or two perhaps mentioning his relationship (if he likes or dislikes the guy) with Jackson considering the fact that Jackson was his commanding officer in WWII and both characters are Republicans, but that is up to you. It is not needed.
The Scezonian Telegram Dep. of Defense Announces Anti-Ballistic Missile Research | Election 2028; Opinions of Candidates | War Between Galapagos and Aursi... Again
by Meretica » Wed Jul 06, 2022 8:12 pm
by South Olpen » Wed Jul 06, 2022 8:32 pm
The Scezonian Telegram Dep. of Defense Announces Anti-Ballistic Missile Research | Election 2028; Opinions of Candidates | War Between Galapagos and Aursi... Again
by Louisianan » Wed Jul 06, 2022 8:35 pm
SOUTH OLPEN wrote:I'm thinking about my opening post if I get accepted tomorrow, so does anyone know whether or not the Senate is in session? If not, my guy will probably be finding donors and going to a WW2 thing.
Advertisement
Return to Portal to the Multiverse
Users browsing this forum: Britanania, Google Feedfetcher (Ancient), Newne Carriebean7, Olthenia
Advertisement