NATION

PASSWORD

[LC] Repeal "Safety and Integrity in Conflict Journalism"

A record of historical World Assembly debates.
User avatar
Honeydewistania
Senator
 
Posts: 3974
Founded: Jun 09, 2017
Capitalist Paradise

[LC] Repeal "Safety and Integrity in Conflict Journalism"

Postby Honeydewistania » Thu Dec 30, 2021 7:04 pm

Good day all. I believe that the General Assembly proposal, Repeal "Safety and Integrity in Conflict Journalism", ought to be considered illegal due to an honest mistake. Proposal's forum thread.

The General Assembly,

Respecting the intent of GAR#554 “Safety and Integrity in Conflict Journalism” to protect journalists operating in conflict zones, but

Disappointed that the resolution contains several significant and easily exploitable loopholes, and in some cases blocks further legislation to resolve these issues, rendering it inadequate for continued enforcement by this august body,

Highlighting the loopholes present due to the substandard and flawed definition of a “conflict journalist”, which:
  1. by requiring that conflict journalists be “employed in providing journalism”, can easily be interpreted as excluding journalists that do not engage in journalism due to an employment contract (for example, freelance or citizen journalists), and
  2. includes the hazy requirement that a conflict journalist must “[operate] independent of any belligerent faction”, which is so vague that member-states can easily claim that journalists nominally dependent on a belligerent faction, such as non-government news organisations headquartered in a belligerent nation during an international war, are exempt from the protections in the resolution,
Frustrated by the inadequate definition of an “act of espionage” in Clause 1c which, by requiring that a “belligerent faction” benefit from the act to be counted as an "act of espionage", excludes acts that should be considered espionage but where third parties, rather than "belligerents", benefit from said acts,

Alarmed that by legalising “any journalism” that is not considered an “act of espionage”, Clause 2b blocks future legislation, whether national, international or within this institution, to further regulate espionage that does not fit into the poor definition present in Clause 1c,

Bothered by Clause 3’s lack of protection for conflict journalists from groups other than member-states, such as armed civilians, allowing acts prohibited in Clause 3 for member-states to be perpetrated by entities that are not member-states, thus undermining the intent of Clause 3,

Troubled by the fact that while the regulations within Clause 4 restrict the “kidnapping, murder, or deliberate use of a conflict journalist as a military target”, there are no protections against the detainment, harassment, physical harm or attack of conflict journalists by non-state or non-military entities as long as this does not result in the "kidnapping [or] murder" of said journalists, thereby allowing for the legal abuse of conflict journalists, and

Concluding that, while the intent of GAR#554 is meritorious and a topic undoubtedly deserving of attention by this institution, it contains several issues and loopholes that make it too poor to remain in force,

Hereby Repeals GAR#554 “Safety and Integrity in Conflict Journalism”.


The General Assembly,

Observing that, in times of unrest, a scrutinising media provides a safety net for civilians in conflict's path, not only by keeping them apprised of dangers, but by holding leaders accountable for what atrocities might otherwise be concealed,

Recognising that, while operating in close proximity to a conflict zone is perilous, a journalist's actions may be the only mechanism by which news of happenings may be returned to international authorities,

Aware that conflict journalists face dangers beyond battlefield hazards, including being specifically targeted for arrest, kidnapping, and murder by belligerent factions or even their own government,

Resolved that it falls to the World Assembly to establish specific provisions which protect these journalists, safeguard their vital function, and assist in providing reports of non-compliance with international law,

May it be enacted that this chamber:

  1. Defines within this resolution:
    1. a "conflict zone" as a battlefield, combat area, or zone where military-grade equipment is deployed to defeat, rout, or suppress opposing forces.
    2. a "conflict journalist" as a reporter or a reporter's technical assistant, operating independent of any belligerent faction, and employed in providing journalism from an ongoing conflict zone or its immediate surrounding area.
    3. an "act of espionage" as the clandestine gathering, reporting, or delivery of information for the purposes of benefiting one or more belligerent factions, except to uphold international law.
    4. an "act of warfare" to be any of the following:
      1. The capturing or killing of combatants.
      2. The intentional damage or destruction of equipment or vehicles deployed to the conflict.
      3. The transportation of personnel or supplies for a party of the conflict.
  2. Declares that conflict journalists:
    1. are classified as civilian non-combatants of a protected status.
    2. are permitted to carry out any journalism that is not an act of espionage from or near a conflict zone.
    3. are prohibited from carrying, operating, or transporting weaponry in a conflict zone.
    4. are prohibited from hiring or otherwise soliciting the services of armed escorts and mercenaries.
    5. are prohibited from accessing military facilities, except when invited by the owner or controller of the facility.
  3. Prohibits member nations from:
    1. disallowing conflict journalists access to a conflict zone and freedom of movement within it.
    2. undertaking retaliatory action towards conflict journalists in response to unfavourable press coverage, or fear thereof.
    3. detaining conflict journalists solely to limit their access to the conflict zone, or to delay their reporting.

[*] Establishes that the kidnapping, murder, or deliberate use of a conflict journalist as a military target shall be illegal and considered a war crime.

[*] Clarifies that a conflict journalist who commits an act of espionage or proactively engages in an act of warfare will be considered a hostile combatant, exempt from the protections of this resolution, and unable to be considered a civilian in the conflict.


Repeals should address the contents of the resolution it's targeting, and not just state the reverse of the arguments given in the resolution. Embellishment, exaggeration, deceptive/weaselly-words do not constitute an 'honest mistake'. An 'honest mistake' is factual inaccuracies, misrepresentation, or content that doesn't address the resolution.


I believe the following section contains an honest mistake:

Clause 2b blocks future legislation, whether national, international or within this institution, to further regulate espionage that does not fit into the poor definition present in Clause 1c,


Clause 2b, for reference:

Declares that conflict journalists are permitted to carry out any journalism that is not an act of espionage from or near a conflict zone.


The claim here is not true. Future legislation by the World Assembly (and other institutions) can be enforced to 'regulate espionage' that does not fit into the definition. As the resolution only covers conflict journalists reporting from or near a conflict zone, the resolution only blocks future legislation to further regulate espionage committed within a conflict zone. Espionage committed anywhere else can be perfectly regulated by legislation in both nations and by the WA. As Clause 2b does not block future legislation, whether national, international or within this institution, to further regulate espionage that does not fit into the poor definition present in Clause 1c, I believe the proposal should be considered illegal for an honest mistake.
Last edited by Honeydewistania on Thu Dec 30, 2021 7:52 pm, edited 2 times in total.
Home of the first best pizza topping known to NationStates | Prolific Security Council Author (15x resolutions written) | Not that one fraud, Pineappleistania(ew) | Mouthpiece for Melons' first-rate SC takes | read this please

Alger wrote:if you have egoquotes in your signature, touch grass

User avatar
Apatosaurus
Diplomat
 
Posts: 956
Founded: Jul 17, 2020
Ex-Nation

Postby Apatosaurus » Thu Dec 30, 2021 7:11 pm

Intensely disagree with this, as the author. This is a good point in theory, that it does not block regulation of all espionage not in the 1c definition. However, I do not believe that it is enough to pass the burden of the Honest Mistake rule. The challenged section does not say that it blocks further regulation of all espionage not in the 1c definition, just "espionage" not in the 1c definition. Espionage that is done by journalists that does not fit in the 1c definition is "espionage", and #554 does indeed block regulation of that "espionage", even if not all espionage not covered by 1c.

As such, I believe that this (albeit unwittingly as this is not something that I originally considered), fits more into the category of "deceptive/weaselly-words" which "do not constitute an 'honest mistake'".
This signature stands with Palestine.

End the continued practice of bombing houses, museums, refugee camps, ambulances, and churches.

WA Ambassador: Ambrose Scott; further detail on WA delegation in factbooks. Nation overview.

User avatar
Honeydewistania
Senator
 
Posts: 3974
Founded: Jun 09, 2017
Capitalist Paradise

Postby Honeydewistania » Thu Dec 30, 2021 7:15 pm

Apatosaurus wrote:Intensely disagree with this, as the author. This is a good point in theory, that it does not block regulation of all espionage not in the 1c definition. However, I do not believe that it is enough to pass the burden of the Honest Mistake rule. The challenged section does not say that it blocks further regulation of all espionage not in the 1c definition, just "espionage" not in the 1c definition. Espionage that is done by journalists that does not fit in the 1c definition is "espionage", and #554 does indeed block regulation of that "espionage", even if not all espionage not covered by 1c.

As such, I believe that this (albeit unwittingly as this is not something that I originally considered), fits more into the category of "deceptive/weaselly-words" which "do not constitute an 'honest mistake'".


If the WA can pass a resolution right now, legally, that regulates espionage not in the definition of the resolution (which it can), it has not been 'blocked'. It is not weaselly wording. It's a straight up mistruth.
Last edited by Honeydewistania on Thu Dec 30, 2021 7:16 pm, edited 1 time in total.
Home of the first best pizza topping known to NationStates | Prolific Security Council Author (15x resolutions written) | Not that one fraud, Pineappleistania(ew) | Mouthpiece for Melons' first-rate SC takes | read this please

Alger wrote:if you have egoquotes in your signature, touch grass

User avatar
Minskiev
Minister
 
Posts: 2429
Founded: Apr 20, 2020
Ex-Nation

Postby Minskiev » Thu Dec 30, 2021 7:16 pm

TLDR: Is "2b blocks legislation to further regulate espionage" Honest Mistake if 2b only blocks further regulating espionage in journalism by conflict journalists near or in conflict zones.

(Hint: yes)

Legislation is not an individual thing, it is plural. It doesn't block one piece of legislation (which would be of espionage in journalism by conflict journalists near or in conflict zones), it blocks legislation. Laws to further regulate espionage.
Last edited by Minskiev on Thu Dec 30, 2021 7:19 pm, edited 2 times in total.
Minskiev/Walrus. Former Delegate of the Rejected Realms, 3x Officer. 15x WA author. Join the RRA here.

User avatar
Apatosaurus
Diplomat
 
Posts: 956
Founded: Jul 17, 2020
Ex-Nation

Postby Apatosaurus » Thu Dec 30, 2021 7:17 pm

Honeydewistania wrote:
Apatosaurus wrote:Intensely disagree with this, as the author. This is a good point in theory, that it does not block regulation of all espionage not in the 1c definition. However, I do not believe that it is enough to pass the burden of the Honest Mistake rule. The challenged section does not say that it blocks further regulation of all espionage not in the 1c definition, just "espionage" not in the 1c definition. Espionage that is done by journalists that does not fit in the 1c definition is "espionage", and #554 does indeed block regulation of that "espionage", even if not all espionage not covered by 1c.

As such, I believe that this (albeit unwittingly as this is not something that I originally considered), fits more into the category of "deceptive/weaselly-words" which "do not constitute an 'honest mistake'".


If the WA can pass a resolution right now, legally, that regulates espionage not in the definition of the resolution (which it can), it it not 'blocked'. It is not weaselly wording. It's a straight up mistruth.

Except, it does not say "all espionage" that does not fit into the definition of espionage in the resolution. If it is read in the context of "espionage as in specific acts", rather than "all acts of espionage", then #554 does block regulation of those specific acts of espionage.
This signature stands with Palestine.

End the continued practice of bombing houses, museums, refugee camps, ambulances, and churches.

WA Ambassador: Ambrose Scott; further detail on WA delegation in factbooks. Nation overview.

User avatar
Imperium Anglorum
Postmaster-General
 
Posts: 13180
Founded: Aug 26, 2013
Inoffensive Centrist Democracy

Postby Imperium Anglorum » Thu Dec 30, 2021 7:18 pm

I actually thought of this legality challenge when making my decision on the control panel. I took some time to think on it. Somewhat conveniently, I actually made notes on it, because it took a bit to think out.

Honeydewistania wrote:The claim here is not true. Future legislation by the World Assembly (and other institutions) can be enforced to 'regulate espionage' that does not fit into the definition. As the resolution only covers conflict journalists reporting from or near a conflict zone, the resolution only blocks future legislation to further regulate espionage committed within a conflict zone. Espionage committed anywhere else can be perfectly regulated by legislation in both nations and by the WA. As Clause 2b does not block future legislation, whether national, international or within this institution, to further regulate espionage that does not fit into the poor definition present in Clause 1c, I believe the proposal should be considered illegal for an honest mistake.

The claim is true.

Under the rule of the nearest reasonable referent (also sometimes erroneously applied as the 'last antecedent') – see eg Scalia & Garner, Reading Law (2012) 147 et seq – 'from or near a conflict zone' describes 'act of espionage', not 'journalism'. The permission applies to, using brackets for grouping, (any journalism) that is not (an act of espionage from or near a conflict zone).

The next issue I thought of was whether 'act of espionage' can be reasonably fit with the preposition 'from'; nb that nobody is questioning that 'from' can be reasonably fit with 'journalism'. It can be, after putting 'espionage from' into Google and finding a number of not-unreasonable results (phrases like 'Greek espionage from the Peloponnesian war' excepted). This establishes it is a reasonable reading and the nearest reasonable referent canon applies.

The next question is whether the descriptor in the target is correct. It says the target 'legalis[es] “any journalism” that is not considered an “act of espionage”'. This is not exactly the same as saying 'act of espionage from or near a combat zone'. However, my view is that this representation is not misrepresentation. Consider the set of all possible 'journalism'. Because 'espionage' is a strict superset of 'espionage from or near a combat zone', the claim of all espionage is still accurate. It actually understates the scope of the target's legalisation clause and is regardless not a misrepresentation of the target.
Last edited by Imperium Anglorum on Thu Dec 30, 2021 9:06 pm, edited 3 times in total.

Author: 1 SC and 59+ GA resolutions
Maintainer: GA Passed Resolutions
Developer: Communiqué and InfoEurope
GenSec (24 Dec 2021 – 25 May 2025); posts not official unless so indicated
Delegate for Europe
Publius Clodius Thrasea Paetus (previously)
Ideological Bulwark 285, WALL delegate
Twice-commended toxic villainous globalist kittehs

User avatar
Minskiev
Minister
 
Posts: 2429
Founded: Apr 20, 2020
Ex-Nation

Postby Minskiev » Thu Dec 30, 2021 7:23 pm

Imperium Anglorum wrote:snip

That isn't the point.
Minskiev/Walrus. Former Delegate of the Rejected Realms, 3x Officer. 15x WA author. Join the RRA here.

User avatar
Imperium Anglorum
Postmaster-General
 
Posts: 13180
Founded: Aug 26, 2013
Inoffensive Centrist Democracy

Postby Imperium Anglorum » Thu Dec 30, 2021 7:28 pm

I was editing my post to respond to yours, but you made an intervening post.

Minskiev wrote:
Imperium Anglorum wrote:snip

That isn't the point.
Minskiev wrote:TLDR: Is "2b blocks legislation to further regulate espionage" Honest Mistake if 2b only blocks further regulating espionage in journalism by conflict journalists near or in conflict zones.

It is the point. Your interpretation, which I don't believe is reasonable, given that it doesn't conform with the nearest reasonable referent canon, assumes that the postpositive modifier applies to 'journalism' and not 'espionage'.

Minskiev wrote:Legislation is not an individual thing, it is plural. It doesn't block one piece of legislation (which would be of espionage in journalism by conflict journalists near or in conflict zones), it blocks legislation. Laws to further regulate espionage.

This plural-vs-singular reading is not reasonable. It violates the Gender/Number canon. Scalia & Garner, Reading Law (2012) 129 et seq.
Last edited by Imperium Anglorum on Thu Dec 30, 2021 7:28 pm, edited 1 time in total.

Author: 1 SC and 59+ GA resolutions
Maintainer: GA Passed Resolutions
Developer: Communiqué and InfoEurope
GenSec (24 Dec 2021 – 25 May 2025); posts not official unless so indicated
Delegate for Europe
Publius Clodius Thrasea Paetus (previously)
Ideological Bulwark 285, WALL delegate
Twice-commended toxic villainous globalist kittehs

User avatar
Honeydewistania
Senator
 
Posts: 3974
Founded: Jun 09, 2017
Capitalist Paradise

Postby Honeydewistania » Thu Dec 30, 2021 7:29 pm

Imperium Anglorum wrote:I actually thought of this legality challenge when making my decision on the control panel. I took some time to think on it. Somewhat conveniently, I actually made notes on it, because it took a bit to think out.

Honeydewistania wrote:The claim here is not true. Future legislation by the World Assembly (and other institutions) can be enforced to 'regulate espionage' that does not fit into the definition. As the resolution only covers conflict journalists reporting from or near a conflict zone, the resolution only blocks future legislation to further regulate espionage committed within a conflict zone. Espionage committed anywhere else can be perfectly regulated by legislation in both nations and by the WA. As Clause 2b does not block future legislation, whether national, international or within this institution, to further regulate espionage that does not fit into the poor definition present in Clause 1c, I believe the proposal should be considered illegal for an honest mistake.

The claim is true.

Under the rule of the nearest reasonable referent (also sometimes erroneously applied as the 'last antecedent' in this case) – see eg Scalia & Garner, Reading Law (2012) 147 et seq – 'from or near a conflict zone' describes 'act of espionage', not 'journalism'. The permission applies to, using brackets for grouping, (any journalism) that is not (an act of espionage from or near a conflict zone).

The next issue I thought of was whether 'act of espionage' can be reasonably fit with the preposition 'from'; nb that nobody is questioning that 'from' can be reasonably fit with 'journalism'. It can be, after putting 'espionage from' into Google and finding a number of not-unreasonable results (phrases like 'Greek espionage from the Peloponnesian war' excepted). This establishes it is a reasonable reading and the nearest reasonable referent canon applies.

The next question is whether the descriptor in the target is correct. It says the target 'legalis[es] “any journalism” that is not considered an “act of espionage”'. This is not exactly the same as saying 'act of espionage from or near a combat zone'. However, my view is that this representation is not misrepresentation. Consider the set of all possible 'journalism'. Because 'espionage' is a strict superset of 'espionage from or near a combat zone', the claim of all espionage is still accurate. It actually understates the scope of the target's legalisation clause and is regardless not a misrepresentation of the target.



Espionage committed outside of journalism and not by conflict journalists simply are not covered by this resolution. They are not affected by the 'blocker', so future legislation on those can't be blocked. A resolution that prevents James Bond committing espionage outside of the definition listed in the resolution whilst drinking a martini can be passed. It isn't blocked, so I believe it's a misrepresentation.
Home of the first best pizza topping known to NationStates | Prolific Security Council Author (15x resolutions written) | Not that one fraud, Pineappleistania(ew) | Mouthpiece for Melons' first-rate SC takes | read this please

Alger wrote:if you have egoquotes in your signature, touch grass

User avatar
Imperium Anglorum
Postmaster-General
 
Posts: 13180
Founded: Aug 26, 2013
Inoffensive Centrist Democracy

Postby Imperium Anglorum » Thu Dec 30, 2021 7:48 pm

Honeydewistania wrote:Espionage committed outside of journalism and not by conflict journalists simply are not covered by this resolution. They are not affected by the 'blocker', so future legislation on those can't be blocked. A resolution that prevents James Bond committing espionage outside of the definition listed in the resolution whilst drinking a martini can be passed. It isn't blocked, so I believe it's a misrepresentation.

I feel this is a separate question from the modifier question earlier. To clarify, you're saying that—

... Clause 2b blocks future legislation, whether national, international or within this institution, to further regulate espionage that does not fit into the poor definition present in Clause 1c,

Is the thing that matters here: rather than the introductory portion?

Author: 1 SC and 59+ GA resolutions
Maintainer: GA Passed Resolutions
Developer: Communiqué and InfoEurope
GenSec (24 Dec 2021 – 25 May 2025); posts not official unless so indicated
Delegate for Europe
Publius Clodius Thrasea Paetus (previously)
Ideological Bulwark 285, WALL delegate
Twice-commended toxic villainous globalist kittehs

User avatar
Honeydewistania
Senator
 
Posts: 3974
Founded: Jun 09, 2017
Capitalist Paradise

Postby Honeydewistania » Thu Dec 30, 2021 7:52 pm

Imperium Anglorum wrote:
Honeydewistania wrote:Espionage committed outside of journalism and not by conflict journalists simply are not covered by this resolution. They are not affected by the 'blocker', so future legislation on those can't be blocked. A resolution that prevents James Bond committing espionage outside of the definition listed in the resolution whilst drinking a martini can be passed. It isn't blocked, so I believe it's a misrepresentation.

I feel this is a separate question from the modifier question earlier. To clarify, you're saying that—

... Clause 2b blocks future legislation, whether national, international or within this institution, to further regulate espionage that does not fit into the poor definition present in Clause 1c,

Is the thing that matters here: rather than the introductory portion?


Yes. Sorry if any confusion has been caused, I'll edit the OP to make things more clear.
Home of the first best pizza topping known to NationStates | Prolific Security Council Author (15x resolutions written) | Not that one fraud, Pineappleistania(ew) | Mouthpiece for Melons' first-rate SC takes | read this please

Alger wrote:if you have egoquotes in your signature, touch grass

User avatar
Sierra Lyricalia
Senator
 
Posts: 4432
Founded: Nov 29, 2008
Ex-Nation

Postby Sierra Lyricalia » Thu Dec 30, 2021 8:11 pm

Apatosaurus wrote:Espionage that is done by journalists that does not fit in the 1c definition is "espionage", and #554 does indeed block regulation of that "espionage", even if not all espionage not covered by 1c.


What?

To elaborate: how does a resolution that "Defines" [a specific term] "within this resolution", then uses that same term without any modifications once and only once, and no synonyms, adjacent meanings, etc.; to permit (and only to permit) acts falling under that specific definition... how does that resolution block legislation on similar acts that do not fall within that specific definition? Like what is the mechanism here?
My Naïve Ass, Apparently wrote:Communication and transparency are the sine-qua-non of a healthy community, including in cases where confidential processes are undertaken and only fully reported later.
and also wrote:The lesson here is that "having a good understanding of what is happening" is definitionally bad faith.

User avatar
Apatosaurus
Diplomat
 
Posts: 956
Founded: Jul 17, 2020
Ex-Nation

Postby Apatosaurus » Thu Dec 30, 2021 8:15 pm

Sierra Lyricalia wrote:
Apatosaurus wrote:Espionage that is done by journalists that does not fit in the 1c definition is "espionage", and #554 does indeed block regulation of that "espionage", even if not all espionage not covered by 1c.


What?

To elaborate: how does a resolution that "Defines" [a specific term] "within this resolution", then uses that same term without any modifications once and only once, and no synonyms, adjacent meanings, etc.; to permit (and only to permit) acts falling under that specific definition... how does that resolution block legislation on similar acts that do not fall within that specific definition? Like what is the mechanism here?

That... is not what it says? It defines an "act of espionage" and then permits "any journalism" that is not considered an "act of espionage" by that definition. However, if something fits under "any journalism" and is not an "act of espionage", then it is legalised even if it would usually be considered espionage if not for the 1c definition (which excludes acts by non-belligerents).
This signature stands with Palestine.

End the continued practice of bombing houses, museums, refugee camps, ambulances, and churches.

WA Ambassador: Ambrose Scott; further detail on WA delegation in factbooks. Nation overview.

User avatar
Minskiev
Minister
 
Posts: 2429
Founded: Apr 20, 2020
Ex-Nation

Postby Minskiev » Thu Dec 30, 2021 8:21 pm

Apatosaurus wrote:
Sierra Lyricalia wrote:
What?

To elaborate: how does a resolution that "Defines" [a specific term] "within this resolution", then uses that same term without any modifications once and only once, and no synonyms, adjacent meanings, etc.; to permit (and only to permit) acts falling under that specific definition... how does that resolution block legislation on similar acts that do not fall within that specific definition? Like what is the mechanism here?

That... is not what it says? It defines an "act of espionage" and then permits "any journalism" that is not considered an "act of espionage" by that definition. However, if something fits under "any journalism" and is not an "act of espionage", then it is legalised even if it would usually be considered espionage if not for the 1c definition (which excludes acts by non-belligerents).

Your repeal clause says "espionage", which is entirely different from what 554 doesn't cover ("acts of espionage" in journalism by "conflict journalists" from or near "conflict zones" that benefit non-belligerents).
Last edited by Minskiev on Thu Dec 30, 2021 8:24 pm, edited 1 time in total.
Minskiev/Walrus. Former Delegate of the Rejected Realms, 3x Officer. 15x WA author. Join the RRA here.

User avatar
Sierra Lyricalia
Senator
 
Posts: 4432
Founded: Nov 29, 2008
Ex-Nation

Postby Sierra Lyricalia » Thu Dec 30, 2021 8:31 pm

Apatosaurus wrote:...if something fits under "any journalism" and is not an "act of espionage", then it is legalised even if it would usually be considered espionage if not for the 1c definition (which excludes acts by non-belligerents).


Words have meanings. We permit resolutions to specify their meanings, and interpret them according to those defined specifications. You are effectively saying that if a resolution defines 'legumes' as lima beans and peanuts, it blocks legislation on lentils and black eyed peas, even though it excluded them by omission from the definition. In other words, you are claiming that the words "Defines within this resolution" basically don't exist.

At least, if you are using this argument to justify the claim in the repeal.

Do you have another mechanism to explain the alleged blocker?
My Naïve Ass, Apparently wrote:Communication and transparency are the sine-qua-non of a healthy community, including in cases where confidential processes are undertaken and only fully reported later.
and also wrote:The lesson here is that "having a good understanding of what is happening" is definitionally bad faith.

User avatar
Apatosaurus
Diplomat
 
Posts: 956
Founded: Jul 17, 2020
Ex-Nation

Postby Apatosaurus » Thu Dec 30, 2021 8:34 pm

Sierra Lyricalia wrote:
Apatosaurus wrote:...if something fits under "any journalism" and is not an "act of espionage", then it is legalised even if it would usually be considered espionage if not for the 1c definition (which excludes acts by non-belligerents).


Words have meanings. We permit resolutions to specify their meanings, and interpret them according to those defined specifications. You are effectively saying that if a resolution defines 'legumes' as lima beans and peanuts, it blocks legislation on lentils and black eyed peas, even though it excluded them by omission from the definition. In other words, you are claiming that the words "Defines within this resolution" basically don't exist.

That is.. not what I said. The situation is not about legalising things that does fit into the definition. The situation is about legalising "any journalism" that doesn't fit into the definition.
This signature stands with Palestine.

End the continued practice of bombing houses, museums, refugee camps, ambulances, and churches.

WA Ambassador: Ambrose Scott; further detail on WA delegation in factbooks. Nation overview.

User avatar
Imperium Anglorum
Postmaster-General
 
Posts: 13180
Founded: Aug 26, 2013
Inoffensive Centrist Democracy

Postby Imperium Anglorum » Thu Dec 30, 2021 8:39 pm

The issue in the new (or at least different, having re-read the OP,) question raised by Honeydewistania, is another subset question.

The actual scope of the target's de facto blocking clause is that (conflict journalists) can do (any journalism) that is not ( [clause 1c] espionage from or near a conflict zone ) (brackets for grouping; text condensed). This is because the nearest reasonable referent canon attaches 'from or near a conflict zone' to 'act of espionage' in the original. For there to be an honest mistake, I see two issues that need to be answered:

  1. What is the meaning of 'espionage' in 'Clause 2b blocks future legislation... to further regulate [non-clause 1c] espionage'? If 'espionage' is given a restrictive meaning from its context, then this isn't a material misrepresentation and there is no honest mistake.
  2. There is no actor stated in the repeal's claim: if the implied actor is something like 'most anyone', there also isn't a material misrepresentation. Thus, can 'conflict journalists' in 'conflict journalists [may do] journalism that is not... espionage from or near a conflict zone' be reasonably approximated by an implicit 'most anyone'?
'Act of espionage' in the target has a specific meaning; but I am willing to accept an abbreviation of the term as not being a material misrepresentation. The repeal draws a distinction between 'espionage' in general and 'clause 1(c) espionage': 'espionage' in the repeal refers to espionage in general. This also allows me to avoid interrogating the meaning of clause 1(c) espionage. Espionage in general need not necessarily be undertaken by a conflict journalist. This establishes both that the actors encompassed are the public writ large and also that 'any journalism' can include espionage. Reporting on matters of state security is both journalism and espionage: passing on to an enemy information that might harm the state, interests thereof, or be otherwise useful to the enemy; paraphrased from 'spying (espionage)', Oxford Dictionary of Law (5th edn, 2003).

If anyone could suddenly become a conflict journalist, I wouldn't call this a meaningful misrepresentation. But I cannot read 'conflict journalists' to be equivalent to something like 'most anyone'. If 'conflict journalists' were most anyone, as the target author has actually claimed with an extremely expansive view of 'employed', then I would lean towards that this isn't a meaningful misrepresentation: if someone becomes a conflict journalist the second they whip their phone out and start recording, spies will just strap GoPros to their heads and print cards calling themselves conflict journalists. But such a reading in the repeal can't be well taken.

This is for two reasons. First, the repeal takes a narrow reading of 'employed', which limits 'conflict journalist' internally to those under an employment contract meaningfully controlling the employee. A 'conflict journalist' can't be anyone; the presumption of consistent usage – Scalia & Garner, Reading Law (2012) 170 et seq – rules this out. Second, the more general view of 'conflict journalist' would – in my view at least – not be consistent with reasonable nation theory: nations want to preserve their freedom of action under international law and would therefore interpret 'conflict journalist' narrowly.

There is a strict contradiction test set up in Repeal "On Universal Jurisdiction" [2018] GAS 9. The standard created there is, in effect, that terms without qualifiers in a repeal should be given their broadest reading. See ibid last para; also Scalia & Garner, supra, 101 ('general terms canon'). I've been vocal in the past that I don't like this precedent, especially because it creates a tension with standard deference for repeal interpretations. But some standard like 'non-triviality' is yet to be developed to the degree that it could be predictably applied without resorting to substantial real-world evidence (eg what is the prevalence of conflict journalists conducting espionage; is it non-trivial?).

Applying the precedent, conflict journalists, who are a specific professional caste, are the only ones who are granted these extra permissions. General espionage is not permitted under the target resolution. The claim that general espionage regulations would therefore be blocked is therefore false. Resolving the two questions this way and relying on the [2018] GAS 9 precedent would force me to find the proposal illegal for materially overstating the extent of the espionage which is blocked by section 2(b) of the target. It is also not difficult to articulate an actual harm from this misrepresentation. Eg Princess Rainbow Sparkles, infra.

Some grammar and clarity edits; rearranged the points for more clarity. Expanded pre-reasoning.
Last edited by Imperium Anglorum on Fri Dec 31, 2021 2:01 am, edited 4 times in total.

Author: 1 SC and 59+ GA resolutions
Maintainer: GA Passed Resolutions
Developer: Communiqué and InfoEurope
GenSec (24 Dec 2021 – 25 May 2025); posts not official unless so indicated
Delegate for Europe
Publius Clodius Thrasea Paetus (previously)
Ideological Bulwark 285, WALL delegate
Twice-commended toxic villainous globalist kittehs

User avatar
Sierra Lyricalia
Senator
 
Posts: 4432
Founded: Nov 29, 2008
Ex-Nation

Postby Sierra Lyricalia » Thu Dec 30, 2021 9:04 pm

Apatosaurus wrote:
Sierra Lyricalia wrote:
Words have meanings. We permit resolutions to specify their meanings, and interpret them according to those defined specifications. You are effectively saying that if a resolution defines 'legumes' as lima beans and peanuts, it blocks legislation on lentils and black eyed peas, even though it excluded them by omission from the definition. In other words, you are claiming that the words "Defines within this resolution" basically don't exist.

That is.. not what I said. The situation is not about legalising things that does fit into the definition. The situation is about legalising "any journalism" that doesn't fit into the definition.


How can the statement "A is permitted where X, Y and Z are true" block legislation on things that happen where X, Y and Z are not true?
My Naïve Ass, Apparently wrote:Communication and transparency are the sine-qua-non of a healthy community, including in cases where confidential processes are undertaken and only fully reported later.
and also wrote:The lesson here is that "having a good understanding of what is happening" is definitionally bad faith.

User avatar
Imperium Anglorum
Postmaster-General
 
Posts: 13180
Founded: Aug 26, 2013
Inoffensive Centrist Democracy

Postby Imperium Anglorum » Thu Dec 30, 2021 9:05 pm

Sierra Lyricalia wrote:
Apatosaurus wrote:That is.. not what I said. The situation is not about legalising things that does fit into the definition. The situation is about legalising "any journalism" that doesn't fit into the definition.

How can the statement "A is permitted where X, Y and Z are true" block legislation on things that happen where X, Y and Z are not true?

The statement in the target is 'all A is permitted except when X'.
Last edited by Imperium Anglorum on Thu Dec 30, 2021 9:07 pm, edited 1 time in total.

Author: 1 SC and 59+ GA resolutions
Maintainer: GA Passed Resolutions
Developer: Communiqué and InfoEurope
GenSec (24 Dec 2021 – 25 May 2025); posts not official unless so indicated
Delegate for Europe
Publius Clodius Thrasea Paetus (previously)
Ideological Bulwark 285, WALL delegate
Twice-commended toxic villainous globalist kittehs

User avatar
Princess Rainbow Sparkles
Chargé d'Affaires
 
Posts: 472
Founded: Nov 08, 2021
Ex-Nation

Postby Princess Rainbow Sparkles » Thu Dec 30, 2021 9:08 pm

Princess Rainbow Sparkles, appearing as amicus curiae on behalf of the Last of the Reasonable People.

You all know by now my opinion on the Honest Mistake rule and how it should be interpreted in most cases. That said, I have seldom been more persuaded as I am right now that the proposed resolution violates the rule.

The repeal makes an extremely bold claim about what SICJ does when it says: "Alarmed that by legalising “any journalism” that is not considered an “act of espionage”, Clause 2b blocks future legislation... to further regulate espionage." (Emphasis mine).

My review of SICJ suggests that this is a mistaken representation for at least one simple reason. By its plain terms, Clause 2b applies only to the actions of "conflict journalists." It does not legalise, or even touch on, journalism practiced by any other class of persons. Even viewing the repeal proposal in its best light with all favorable inferences, the most that could possibly be said is that SICJ may block future legislation regulating espionage by conflict journalists. It is simply a misrepresentation to suggest that Clause 2b generally blocks the WA from enacting future legislation to further regulate espionage. Tomorrow, I could propose a resolution regulating espionage by requiring that all nations employ man-eating sharks in their spy corps, and it would not be prevented in any way by SICJ. (Although the Joke Proposal Rule might...)

Could it have been harmless exaggeration? I think exaggeration has to be about the RP effects of the law. You can exaggerate that people would read a provision a certain way, act a certain way, refrain from acting a certain way (all in a RP context) due to the laws provisions or implications. This repeal argument is not about RP effects. It is about game mechanics. It warns member nations that, so long as this resolution is on the books, they cannot pass any additional resolutions on the field of espionage. This sort of bare claim about game mechanics is less susceptible to fair play than RP exaggeration, and it is much more pernicious and prejudicial than RP-based arguments. If member nations truly believe that they must repeal the target in order to pursue a particular type of WA legislation, that argument will have a substantial likelihood to impact their vote: not based on the merits of repeal, but on whether or not they want people free to pitch WA proposals in that area.

For the foregoing reasons, I recommend an Honest Mistake finding as soon as possible, so the author may quickly amend the draft if they wish and take the remaining arguments to the voters.

Edit: It must also be pointed out that the repeal claims SICJ prohibits further regulation of espionage "that does not fit into the poor definition present in Clause 1c." But, SICJ's plain language states that the definition was adopted merely for use "within this resolution," and not as a comprehensive definition of espionage.
Last edited by Princess Rainbow Sparkles on Thu Dec 30, 2021 10:26 pm, edited 2 times in total.

User avatar
Apatosaurus
Diplomat
 
Posts: 956
Founded: Jul 17, 2020
Ex-Nation

Postby Apatosaurus » Thu Dec 30, 2021 9:12 pm

After consideration about this, since it seems unlikely that this will be legal at the end of the day & particularly that it is unlikely for this proposal to pass as-is, I have elected to withdraw the challenged proposal from queue. I will continue to support a repeal of the target, but it will not be me authoring the repeal.
This signature stands with Palestine.

End the continued practice of bombing houses, museums, refugee camps, ambulances, and churches.

WA Ambassador: Ambrose Scott; further detail on WA delegation in factbooks. Nation overview.

User avatar
Sierra Lyricalia
Senator
 
Posts: 4432
Founded: Nov 29, 2008
Ex-Nation

Postby Sierra Lyricalia » Thu Dec 30, 2021 9:27 pm

Ninja'd - @ IA, if my logical setup here is wrong I'm happy to continue via Discord or TGs.

Imperium Anglorum wrote:
Sierra Lyricalia wrote:How can the statement "A is permitted where X, Y and Z are true" block legislation on things that happen where X, Y and Z are not true?

The statement in the target is 'all A is permitted except X'.


"conflict journalists... are permitted to carry out any journalism that is not an act of espionage from or near a conflict zone."

A (any journalism) may be carried out if X (done by conflict journalists), Y (it is not an act of espionage as defined in the resolution), and Z (it is done from within a conflict zone) [Y and Z separate to give max benefit of the doubt to the repeal's allegation]. Even so, the repeal alleges this statement blocks legislation on actions where not-Y, regardless of X or Z.
My Naïve Ass, Apparently wrote:Communication and transparency are the sine-qua-non of a healthy community, including in cases where confidential processes are undertaken and only fully reported later.
and also wrote:The lesson here is that "having a good understanding of what is happening" is definitionally bad faith.

User avatar
Imperium Anglorum
Postmaster-General
 
Posts: 13180
Founded: Aug 26, 2013
Inoffensive Centrist Democracy

Postby Imperium Anglorum » Thu Dec 30, 2021 10:20 pm

Sierra Lyricalia wrote:
Ninja'd - @ IA, if my logical setup here is wrong I'm happy to continue via Discord or TGs.

Imperium Anglorum wrote:The statement in the target is 'all A is permitted except X'.


"conflict journalists... are permitted to carry out any journalism that is not an act of espionage from or near a conflict zone."

A (any journalism) may be carried out if X (done by conflict journalists), Y (it is not an act of espionage as defined in the resolution), and Z (it is done from within a conflict zone) [Y and Z separate to give max benefit of the doubt to the repeal's allegation]. Even so, the repeal alleges this statement blocks legislation on actions where not-Y, regardless of X or Z.

My reasoning is basically the same as what I posted above:

The next question is whether the descriptor in the target is correct. It says the target 'legalis[es] “any journalism” that is not considered an “act of espionage”'. This is not exactly the same as saying 'act of espionage from or near a combat zone'. However, my view is that this representation is not misrepresentation. Consider the set of all possible 'journalism'. Because 'espionage' is a strict superset of 'espionage from or near a combat zone', the claim of all espionage is still accurate. It actually understates the scope of the target's legalisation clause and is regardless not a misrepresentation of the target.

What the target legalises is all journalism that isn't clause 1(c) espionage near a conflict zone. The proposal claims that all journalism is legalised other than section 1(c) espionage. The proposal's claim doesn't go as far as what the target actually does. But the truth issue is just whether all journalism that is not section 1(c) espionage is legalised. Because what isn't legalised is a subset of section 1(c) espionage, the proposal claim is true.

It's like saying:

T: All numbers below 1000 are fine.
R: All numbers below 900 are fine.

This, of course and as advertised in the first paragraph, ignores the extra limitation that the target has: that the any journalism be done by conflict journalists.
Last edited by Imperium Anglorum on Thu Dec 30, 2021 10:21 pm, edited 2 times in total.

Author: 1 SC and 59+ GA resolutions
Maintainer: GA Passed Resolutions
Developer: Communiqué and InfoEurope
GenSec (24 Dec 2021 – 25 May 2025); posts not official unless so indicated
Delegate for Europe
Publius Clodius Thrasea Paetus (previously)
Ideological Bulwark 285, WALL delegate
Twice-commended toxic villainous globalist kittehs

User avatar
Imperium Anglorum
Postmaster-General
 
Posts: 13180
Founded: Aug 26, 2013
Inoffensive Centrist Democracy

Postby Imperium Anglorum » Tue Jan 11, 2022 11:33 am

*** Opinion of the Secretariat ***

We find the challenged proposal illegal on honest mistake grounds. Imperium Anglorum wrote the opinion, joined by Sierra Lyricalia, Separatist Peoples, and Bananaistan.

[1] The main issue is whether the claim in the repeal, that—

Alarmed that by legalising “any journalism” that is not considered an “act of espionage”, Clause 2b blocks future legislation, whether national, international or within this institution, to further regulate espionage that does not fit into the poor definition present in Clause 1c,

is true given that the target only—

2(b) Declares that conflict journalists are permitted to carry out any journalism that is not an act of espionage from or near a conflict zone.

[2] The claim given in the repeal is a general one. The repeal clause does not limit its scope only to journalists. We give 'espionage' an expansive reading per [2018] GAS 9; 'espionage' in the repeal cannot also take the target's definition, as it is here directly contrasted with the target's 'espionage'. Because target section 2(b) applies only to conflict journalists as defined in the target, there is no blocking of any legislation that would regulate espionage generally. What would be blocked are only laws against 'espionage' (as defined in the target) from or near a conflict zone when committed by conflict journalists. The specified actor – conflict journalists – is elided in the repeal's claim.

[3] We would be willing to overlook the oversight if we could interpret 'conflict journalists' to be almost anyone. So given, it would be an acceptable exaggeration. However, we cannot. This is for two reasons. First, the definition of conflict journalist requires that the person be 'employed in providing journalism from an ongoing conflict zone or its immediate surrounding area'. The repeal argues that the definition of 'employed' is narrow: that it refers only to persons bound by an employment contract to provide journalistic services. That reading defines a specific professional caste and, under a presumption of consistent usage, precludes interpreting conflict journalists to mean almost anyone.

[4] Second, member nations want to preserve their freedom of action under international law, especially in national security matters, and would therefore interpret 'conflict journalist' narrowly. The alternative reading would permit almost anyone to become an 'employed in' (as in 'occupied by' or 'engaged in') journalism; intelligence agencies would strap a GoPro to every agent's head and give them a legend vaguely related to blogging. Reading 'employed' in such a broad manner would be a self-detrimental interpretation that violates reasonable nation theory.

[5] Because the actor cannot be read more broadly, the general claim of blocking further regulation must fail, giving rise to factual inaccuracy under the honest mistake rule. The repeal, in this form, therefore, is illegal.

2022gas1

Author: 1 SC and 59+ GA resolutions
Maintainer: GA Passed Resolutions
Developer: Communiqué and InfoEurope
GenSec (24 Dec 2021 – 25 May 2025); posts not official unless so indicated
Delegate for Europe
Publius Clodius Thrasea Paetus (previously)
Ideological Bulwark 285, WALL delegate
Twice-commended toxic villainous globalist kittehs


Advertisement

Remove ads

Return to WA Archives

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: No registered users

Advertisement

Remove ads