Thermodolia wrote:CNN is reporting that the Taliban is in control of the Presidential Palace
Pathetic.
Advertisement

by Sundiata » Sun Aug 15, 2021 10:45 am
Thermodolia wrote:CNN is reporting that the Taliban is in control of the Presidential Palace

by Neanderthaland » Sun Aug 15, 2021 10:47 am

by Sundiata » Sun Aug 15, 2021 10:47 am
Fedel wrote:Neanderthaland wrote:This is woefully naïve.
What was probably more naïve was the nation building policies the Dems forced us to pursue these last 20 years as opposed to doing what they should've to bring about real peace.
Well, we saw how all that turned out. Unfortunate the Afghani have to suffer for our mistakes.

by The Temple of the Computer » Sun Aug 15, 2021 10:47 am
Sundiata wrote:Fedel wrote:
What was probably more naïve was the nation building policies the Dems forced us to pursue these last 20 years as opposed to doing what they should've to bring about real peace.
Well, we saw how all that turned out. Unfortunate the Afghani have to suffer for our mistakes.
We should've listened to Cheney.

by The Alma Mater » Sun Aug 15, 2021 10:48 am
Neanderthaland wrote:Fedel wrote:
What was probably more naïve was the nation building policies the Dems forced us to pursue these last 20 years as opposed to doing what they should've to bring about real peace.
Right right. It's all the Dems fault. Never mind that they haven't been in control of policy for most of that time.

by Fedel » Sun Aug 15, 2021 10:49 am
Neanderthaland wrote:Fedel wrote:
What was probably more naïve was the nation building policies the Dems forced us to pursue these last 20 years as opposed to doing what they should've to bring about real peace.
Right right. It's all the Dems fault. Never mind that they haven't been in control of policy for most of that time.

by The Temple of the Computer » Sun Aug 15, 2021 10:49 am

by Neanderthaland » Sun Aug 15, 2021 10:51 am

by The Temple of the Computer » Sun Aug 15, 2021 10:52 am

by Old Tyrannia » Sun Aug 15, 2021 10:53 am
Fedel wrote:Old Tyrannia wrote:It's clear that you have absolutely no idea what you're talking about.
This exact tactic has been used by authoritarian regimes across the world and has proved highly effective. It's even eroded democracies as strong as the U.S to the state they're in today. You can't beat systems that shape minds in their early development to be loyal and regurgitate party lines. It's a self reinforcing system.
It's simply to our detriment that the authoritarians are the only one's willing to abuse this mechanic since non-authoritarians by definition would not.

by Neanderthaland » Sun Aug 15, 2021 10:53 am
Fedel wrote:Neanderthaland wrote:Right right. It's all the Dems fault. Never mind that they haven't been in control of policy for most of that time.
Obama mainly shaped modern nation building policy in the Middle East. Trump spent his term trying to pull us out ( how wise that was given the existing conditions at that point in time is debatable but that's not what's being talked about ).

by Sundiata » Sun Aug 15, 2021 10:54 am
Neanderthaland wrote:Sundiata wrote:At a loss, there's prime opportunity in Afghanistan if we only had the nerve to finish the job.
There seems to be this fundamental belief amongst you religious conservatives that being awful equates to winning. And if you lose, it's always because you just weren't awful enough. I'm not sure where it comes from, or why you would think that.
Surely Satan would be victorious if that were the case.

by The Two Jerseys » Sun Aug 15, 2021 10:55 am

by Fedel » Sun Aug 15, 2021 10:58 am
Old Tyrannia wrote:Fedel wrote:
This exact tactic has been used by authoritarian regimes across the world and has proved highly effective. It's even eroded democracies as strong as the U.S to the state they're in today. You can't beat systems that shape minds in their early development to be loyal and regurgitate party lines. It's a self reinforcing system.
It's simply to our detriment that the authoritarians are the only one's willing to abuse this mechanic since non-authoritarians by definition would not.
Let's ignore the conspiracy talk and the dubious claims of success in other authoritarian states for a moment and focus specifically on Afghanistan. The problem you have is that Afghanistan was not an authoritarian state with a centralised government capable of the totalitarian measures you want to impose, it was an unstable state with a weak central government riven with tribalism and facing a widespread insurgency that had control over a substantial part of the country. Tell me, how are you going to persuade the rural tribal groups that you are actively at war with to send their children to be educated in your schools? You'd need to stamp out the insurgency first, which is what the US forces and their allies have been attempting and utterly failing to do for the last two decades, before you could even begin to implement the approach you've outlined- at which point the question becomes, why even bother? The communists attempted to do precisely what you are advocating and it failed miserably because they could never establish sufficient control over the rural parts of the country where the Mujahideen and the Taliban have historically drawn the bulk of their support from. There's no reason to believe that the US would be more successful with the same methods.

by Fedel » Sun Aug 15, 2021 10:59 am
Neanderthaland wrote:Fedel wrote:
Obama mainly shaped modern nation building policy in the Middle East. Trump spent his term trying to pull us out ( how wise that was given the existing conditions at that point in time is debatable but that's not what's being talked about ).
Cool cool. So 8 years is not 20. Even when you add 4 to it. Your math is a little off.

by San Lumen » Sun Aug 15, 2021 11:00 am
Sundiata wrote:Neanderthaland wrote:There seems to be this fundamental belief amongst you religious conservatives that being awful equates to winning. And if you lose, it's always because you just weren't awful enough. I'm not sure where it comes from, or why you would think that.
Surely Satan would be victorious if that were the case.
We had just cause to enter Afghanistan and just reason to finish. It's not about being awful, it's about getting a good deal for the people of Afghanistan as well as our own citizens.

by Thermodolia » Sun Aug 15, 2021 11:00 am
Fedel wrote:Neanderthaland wrote:This is woefully naïve.
What was probably more naïve was the nation building policies the Dems forced us to pursue these last 20 years as opposed to doing what they should've to bring about real peace.
Well, we saw how all that turned out. Unfortunate the Afghani have to suffer for our mistakes.

by The Temple of the Computer » Sun Aug 15, 2021 11:01 am
Thermodolia wrote:Fedel wrote:
What was probably more naïve was the nation building policies the Dems forced us to pursue these last 20 years as opposed to doing what they should've to bring about real peace.
Well, we saw how all that turned out. Unfortunate the Afghani have to suffer for our mistakes.
It wasn’t the Democrats who started the nation building nonsense, unless you think W is a democrat now

by Neanderthaland » Sun Aug 15, 2021 11:01 am

by Fedel » Sun Aug 15, 2021 11:01 am
Thermodolia wrote:Fedel wrote:
What was probably more naïve was the nation building policies the Dems forced us to pursue these last 20 years as opposed to doing what they should've to bring about real peace.
Well, we saw how all that turned out. Unfortunate the Afghani have to suffer for our mistakes.
It wasn’t the Democrats who started the nation building nonsense, unless you think W is a democrat now
Neanderthaland wrote:Fedel wrote:
I wouldn't say that the Bush administration was all that focused on "nation building" for most of its first term.
Unless the Dems were secretly engaging in nation building behind the Bush administration's back in some sort of bizarre covert Berlin airdrop type thing, your math is still off.

by Thermodolia » Sun Aug 15, 2021 11:02 am
Old Tyrannia wrote:Fedel wrote:
This exact tactic has been used by authoritarian regimes across the world and has proved highly effective. It's even eroded democracies as strong as the U.S to the state they're in today. You can't beat systems that shape minds in their early development to be loyal and regurgitate party lines. It's a self reinforcing system.
It's simply to our detriment that the authoritarians are the only one's willing to abuse this mechanic since non-authoritarians by definition would not.
Let's ignore the conspiracy talk and the dubious claims of success in other authoritarian states for a moment and focus specifically on Afghanistan. The problem you have is that Afghanistan was not an authoritarian state with a centralised government capable of the totalitarian measures you want to impose, it was an unstable state with a weak central government riven with tribalism and facing a widespread insurgency that had control over a substantial part of the country. Tell me, how are you going to persuade the rural tribal groups that you are actively at war with to send their children to be educated in your schools? You'd need to stamp out the insurgency first, which is what the US forces and their allies have been attempting and utterly failing to do for the last two decades, before you could even begin to implement the approach you've outlined- at which point the question becomes, why even bother? The communists attempted to do precisely what you are advocating and it failed miserably because they could never establish sufficient control over the rural parts of the country where the Mujahideen and the Taliban have historically drawn the bulk of their support from. There's no reason to believe that the US would be more successful with the same methods.

by Thermodolia » Sun Aug 15, 2021 11:04 am
Advertisement
Users browsing this forum: Camtropia, Google [Bot], Greater Britannian Realm, Imperial Felchah, Ruszian, The Notorious Mad Jack, Umeria, Valrifell, Washington Resistance Army, Yorsa II
Advertisement