NATION

PASSWORD

Is Sterilization For The Purpose of Eugenics Ethical?

For discussion and debate about anything. (Not a roleplay related forum; out-of-character commentary only.)
User avatar
Soyouso
Ambassador
 
Posts: 1526
Founded: May 14, 2015
Ex-Nation

Is Sterilization For The Purpose of Eugenics Ethical?

Postby Soyouso » Thu Jul 27, 2017 2:14 pm

I was in another thread and happened to mention a puppet nation of mine being planned to be practicing eugenics, then I got the idea for this thread out of curiosity.

Eugenics is the act of taking measures with the goal of eliminating unwanted genes and increasing more desirable genes in the gene pool. This can be done by sterilization or otherwise preventing people with those unwanted traits from reproducing, like people with certain mental illnesses, not being immune to certanin illnesses, STDs, basically anything that can be passed on either to someone through intimacy or by that person being their parent. This also includes not allowing certain people to reproduce because of certain behaviors in worry they'll rub off on the children they raise. There's a lot of controversy on whether or not doing this is right or if it's a violation of human rights.

Personally, I only really support sterilization for those who have committed rape (especially if it was on a child) and have either repeated their crime upon release, refuse to obey sex offender laws like staying away from children, or refuse to enter mental health program to get help to prevent it from happening again. There needs to be more mental health research on pedophiles to help them stop thinking about children, so it doesn't grow worse in silence. I believe people practicing safety and testing first would prevent STDs from spreading. I'm not exactly an advocate of eugenics. I don't really like the very thought having to resort to it except in the most serious cases where whatever would have passed on is so terrible that it would be cruel to the offspring to let them create them. I don't believe that personalities are inheritable, so preventing people from having children just because they triggered someone is stupid to me. When a child does something wrong, you have to teach them why it's wrong to get them to stop. Nurture vs Nature in mind. Kids should only be taken from them if they're abusing them or are neglectful, especially if they have attraction to children which puts the kids in danger.

Note: This can't become an argument about killing people for eugenics. Trying to advocate for that is a violation of the rule about not advocating death of [insert group].

What's your stance?

User avatar
The Land Fomerly Known as Ligerplace
Powerbroker
 
Posts: 9720
Founded: Jul 25, 2012
Ex-Nation

Postby The Land Fomerly Known as Ligerplace » Thu Jul 27, 2017 2:20 pm

For one, I don't think we understand genetics enough to do eugenics without it backfiring someday horribly. Secondly, eugenics has been a way to not so subtly get rid of unwanted populations, like Margaret Sanger and the negroes for example.

I don't exactly think its bad in itself, I just think society is almost always bad with it.
Founder of the Church of Ass.

No Homo.
TET sex chat link
Neo Art wrote:
The Land Fomerly Known as Ligerplace wrote:Ironic ain't it, now there really IS 47% of the country that feels like victims.

........fuck it, you win the internet.

User avatar
Oersae
Civilian
 
Posts: 1
Founded: Jul 22, 2017
Ex-Nation

Postby Oersae » Thu Jul 27, 2017 2:21 pm

Sterilization I think should be considered for serious inheritable diseases like cancers, chromosome disorders, AIDS, HIV, muscular or nervous system issues, heart issues, and bone deformities. It will save billions in treatment and care and prevent more people from having to suffer from it.

User avatar
Conserative Morality
Post Kaiser
 
Posts: 76569
Founded: Aug 24, 2007
Ex-Nation

Postby Conserative Morality » Thu Jul 27, 2017 2:22 pm

Sterilization for the purpose of eugenics is often poorly targeted. Eugenics cannot stop the propagation of poor practices, only poor genetics, and it's a rather imprecise tool to do so with. Theoretically it could be ethical, but practically speaking, it's like carpet bombing a whole city to kill a single rat.
On the hate train. Choo choo, bitches. Bi-Polar. Proud Crypto-Fascist and Turbo Progressive. Dirty Étatist. Lowly Humanities Major. NSG's Best Liberal.
Caesar and Imperator of RWDT
Got a blog up again. || An NS Writing Discussion

User avatar
Conserative Morality
Post Kaiser
 
Posts: 76569
Founded: Aug 24, 2007
Ex-Nation

Postby Conserative Morality » Thu Jul 27, 2017 2:24 pm

Oersae wrote:Sterilization I think should be considered for serious inheritable diseases like cancers, chromosome disorders, AIDS, HIV, muscular or nervous system issues, heart issues, and bone deformities. It will save billions in treatment and care and prevent more people from having to suffer from it.

You're losing out on a lot of good genes by doing that. With how fast technology is advancing, I'd say waiting for gene modification to become widespread is more practical.
On the hate train. Choo choo, bitches. Bi-Polar. Proud Crypto-Fascist and Turbo Progressive. Dirty Étatist. Lowly Humanities Major. NSG's Best Liberal.
Caesar and Imperator of RWDT
Got a blog up again. || An NS Writing Discussion

User avatar
Salus Maior
Postmaster of the Fleet
 
Posts: 27868
Founded: Jun 16, 2014
Iron Fist Consumerists

Postby Salus Maior » Thu Jul 27, 2017 2:24 pm

No.

Eugenics is Nazi garbage.
Traditionalist Catholic, Constitutional Monarchist, Habsburg Nostalgic, Classical Liberal with Catholic Characteristics, Disillusioned Millennial.

"In any case we clearly see....That some opportune remedy must be found quickly for the misery and wretchedness pressing so unjustly on the majority of the working class...it has come to pass that working men have been surrendered, isolated and helpless, to the hardheartedness of employers and the greed of unchecked competition." -Pope Leo XIII, Rerum Novarum

User avatar
Volkmacht
Diplomat
 
Posts: 610
Founded: Apr 18, 2017
Ex-Nation

Postby Volkmacht » Thu Jul 27, 2017 2:25 pm

Absolutely not. The idea of 'eugenics' itself is outdated and has extremely negative connotations with people trying to create a 'superior race'. Plus, who decides what is a 'desirable gene?'. What genetic trait has to be removed in order for someone to be 'perfect'? During the early days of the 20th Century, Americans could be sterilized for simply having low IQs. It would be a miracle if sterilization came back in popularity and people just let it fly by without noticing.
(UNTIL FURTHER NOTICE, IGNORE ALL NS STATS) (I AM POPULI-TERRAE)-It was deleted, now stop asking!
My Discord: https://discord.gg/FAmQCD9
TERRAEN NEWS NETWORK: Martial law to be lifted?|NYOP dominates parade|Prankster arrested|Indoctrinated teenagers began rehabilitation courses|Black sites don't exist: Ministry of Justice [/url]


"There should be no discrimination against languages people speak, skin colour, or religion",-Malala Yousafzai

User avatar
The Land Fomerly Known as Ligerplace
Powerbroker
 
Posts: 9720
Founded: Jul 25, 2012
Ex-Nation

Postby The Land Fomerly Known as Ligerplace » Thu Jul 27, 2017 2:25 pm

Salus Maior wrote:No.

Eugenics is Nazi garbage.

I think it was well before Nazis iirc.

Though it might has well have been, the way people used it...
Founder of the Church of Ass.

No Homo.
TET sex chat link
Neo Art wrote:
The Land Fomerly Known as Ligerplace wrote:Ironic ain't it, now there really IS 47% of the country that feels like victims.

........fuck it, you win the internet.

User avatar
Conserative Morality
Post Kaiser
 
Posts: 76569
Founded: Aug 24, 2007
Ex-Nation

Postby Conserative Morality » Thu Jul 27, 2017 2:26 pm

Salus Maior wrote:No.

Eugenics is Nazi garbage.

Eugenics predates Nazism. The basic idea - that some genes are less desirable than others - is sound. The exact methodologies of identifying and eliminating said genes... has a much poorer track record.
On the hate train. Choo choo, bitches. Bi-Polar. Proud Crypto-Fascist and Turbo Progressive. Dirty Étatist. Lowly Humanities Major. NSG's Best Liberal.
Caesar and Imperator of RWDT
Got a blog up again. || An NS Writing Discussion

User avatar
The Land Fomerly Known as Ligerplace
Powerbroker
 
Posts: 9720
Founded: Jul 25, 2012
Ex-Nation

Postby The Land Fomerly Known as Ligerplace » Thu Jul 27, 2017 2:29 pm

Conserative Morality wrote:
Salus Maior wrote:No.

Eugenics is Nazi garbage.

Eugenics predates Nazism. The basic idea - that some genes are less desirable than others - is sound. The exact methodologies of identifying and eliminating said genes... has a much poorer track record.

Basically hijacking natural selection and failing miserably.
Founder of the Church of Ass.

No Homo.
TET sex chat link
Neo Art wrote:
The Land Fomerly Known as Ligerplace wrote:Ironic ain't it, now there really IS 47% of the country that feels like victims.

........fuck it, you win the internet.

User avatar
AiliailiA
Postmaster of the Fleet
 
Posts: 27720
Founded: Jul 20, 2011
Ex-Nation

Postby AiliailiA » Thu Jul 27, 2017 2:31 pm

Involuntary sterilization? Or tricking/bribing people into getting sterilized? No.
My name is voiced AIL-EE-AIL-EE-AH. My time zone: UTC.

Cannot think of a name wrote:"Where's my immortality?" will be the new "Where's my jetpack?"
Maineiacs wrote:"We're going to build a canal, and we're going to make Columbia pay for it!" -- Teddy Roosevelt
Ifreann wrote:That's not a Freudian slip. A Freudian slip is when you say one thing and mean your mother.
Ethel mermania wrote:
Ifreann wrote:
DnalweN acilbupeR wrote:
: eugenics :
What are the colons meant to convey here?
In my experience Colons usually convey shit

NSG junkie. Getting good shit for free, why would I give it up?

User avatar
Gauthier
Khan of Spam
 
Posts: 52887
Founded: Antiquity
Ex-Nation

Postby Gauthier » Thu Jul 27, 2017 2:33 pm

Only if you're dealing with Genestealers.
Crimes committed by Muslims will be a pan-Islamic plot and proof of Islam's inherent evil. On the other hand crimes committed by non-Muslims will merely be the acts of loners who do not represent their belief system at all.
The probability of one's participation in homosexual acts is directly proportional to one's public disdain and disgust for homosexuals.
If a political figure makes an accusation of wrongdoing without evidence, odds are probable that the accuser or an associate thereof has in fact committed the very same act, possibly to a worse degree.
Where is your God-Emperor now?

User avatar
Serrus
Ambassador
 
Posts: 1560
Founded: Feb 06, 2017
Civil Rights Lovefest

Postby Serrus » Thu Jul 27, 2017 2:40 pm

Here is what I say to your thread question:
Long Answer: No, no no no, no, no no no no, no, no no no, no no no no, no no no, no no no, NO. NEIN! NU DRAAR. Bad. Very bad. Demagolkas that way lie.
Katganistan wrote:
Ethel mermania wrote:maybe japan wanted the zombie attack.

Possible. Zombies are cool now.

Eastern Raarothorgren wrote:News websites are good and reasonable soruces of information or they would not be on the internet if they were saying things that were incorrect.

This is why rules exist, kids!
Keshiland wrote:I am yes arguing that the 1st 4 are not binding to the states and yes I know that in most Republican states they would ban the freedom of religion and the freedom of essembally but I don't live there and I hate guns!

The Huskar Social Union wrote:
You glorifted ducking wanabe sea pheasant

Platapusses are not rel

User avatar
The Islands of Versilia
Minister
 
Posts: 2865
Founded: Feb 21, 2016
Ex-Nation

Postby The Islands of Versilia » Thu Jul 27, 2017 2:45 pm

Yes. Some people need to be sterilised and kept away from children or those they could harm.
Eugenics itself, I sort of advocate for. Though, I prefer genetic engineering than the archaic 'you can't breed with this person'.
ᛅ STÓRRIKIT ⬩ VÆRSLAND ᛘ
Factbooks⬩Themes⬩The User⬩

Palaeolithic and Bronze Age-inspired FanT-MT civilization of humans and vampiresque hominins living peacefully together in a habitable Greenland presided over by a semi-elective phylarchic monarchy with an A S C E N D E D vampiric hominin from Georgia as queen.
Rate me as Prime Minister

User avatar
Skyhooked
Senator
 
Posts: 4107
Founded: Mar 18, 2016
Ex-Nation

Postby Skyhooked » Thu Jul 27, 2017 2:48 pm

If it's purely volunteer... why not? Otherwise it's a darn slippery slope, where anyone can get stelilized, just cuz the one, who judges, what the "Genetic disorders" mean didn't like his face, race or even ideology...

Better avoid going nazi route, they met a really bad fate, which they deserved. People are smart enough to figure out on their own, should they sterilize themselves, or not. That must be up to individual, not state.
Last edited by Skyhooked on Thu Jul 27, 2017 2:54 pm, edited 6 times in total.
Skyhooked is MT/PMT with a few FT elements. Military is factbook only. NS stats are mostly non canon.
If you wanna know more about this haven of sin: https://forum.nationstates.net/viewtopic.php?f=23&t=418281&start=1

Our country offers: Alcohol, guns, cigars, weed, gambling, beaches and tons of souvenirs. And our current special: PL-74 Plasma rifle 25% discount!

Refreshing News:
Skyhooked is at war with Octavia, still holding agaisnt endless hordes of robots, vampires and traitors of humanity!/Global Defense Council was formed to help Earth hold agaisnt invasion./Luckily, we survived long enough and forces of Mandate of Humanity have arrived. (https://forum.nationstates.net/viewtopic.php?f=5&t=484352)

User avatar
Telconi
Post Czar
 
Posts: 34903
Founded: Oct 08, 2016
Ex-Nation

Postby Telconi » Thu Jul 27, 2017 2:49 pm

Short answer: No.

Longer more profane answer: Fuck no! Fuck eugenics! And fuck proponents of it with cacti!
-2.25 LEFT
-3.23 LIBERTARIAN

PRO:
-Weapons Rights
-Gender Equality
-LGBTQ Rights
-Racial Equality
-Religious Freedom
-Freedom of Speech
-Freedom of Association
-Life
-Limited Government
-Non Interventionism
-Labor Unions
-Environmental Protections
ANTI:
-Racism
-Sexism
-Bigotry In All Forms
-Government Overreach
-Government Surveillance
-Freedom For Security Social Transactions
-Unnecessary Taxes
-Excessively Specific Government Programs
-Foreign Entanglements
-Religious Extremism
-Fascists Masquerading as "Social Justice Warriors"

"The Constitution is NOT an instrument for the government to restrain the people,it is an instrument for the people to restrain the government-- lest it come to dominate our lives and interests." ~ Patrick Henry

User avatar
Vivida Vis Animi
Diplomat
 
Posts: 589
Founded: Jun 29, 2017
Ex-Nation

Postby Vivida Vis Animi » Thu Jul 27, 2017 2:52 pm

Eugenics would undoubtedly be legalised for the best intentions but it would end up being used to target minorities, especially the LGBT community where half the overly zealous folk think it's a mental disease that needs to be eradicated anyways but that's a different discussion altogether. And besides that we still don't know enough about genetics to determine if it's even worth it.
My Factbook and it's WIP
Current obsession: The Italian Wars
Telegrams always open
LOVEWHOYOUARE~<3

User avatar
Calladan
Minister
 
Posts: 3064
Founded: Jul 28, 2016
Ex-Nation

Postby Calladan » Thu Jul 27, 2017 2:53 pm

Soyouso wrote:I was in another thread and happened to mention a puppet nation of mine being planned to be practicing eugenics, then I got the idea for this thread out of curiosity.

Eugenics is the act of taking measures with the goal of eliminating unwanted genes and increasing more desirable genes in the gene pool. This can be done by sterilization or otherwise preventing people with those unwanted traits from reproducing, like people with certain mental illnesses, not being immune to certanin illnesses, STDs, basically anything that can be passed on either to someone through intimacy or by that person being their parent. This also includes not allowing certain people to reproduce because of certain behaviors in worry they'll rub off on the children they raise. There's a lot of controversy on whether or not doing this is right or if it's a violation of human rights.

Personally, I only really support sterilization for those who have committed rape (especially if it was on a child) and have either repeated their crime upon release, refuse to obey sex offender laws like staying away from children, or refuse to enter mental health program to get help to prevent it from happening again. There needs to be more mental health research on pedophiles to help them stop thinking about children, so it doesn't grow worse in silence. I believe people practicing safety and testing first would prevent STDs from spreading. I'm not exactly an advocate of eugenics. I don't really like the very thought having to resort to it except in the most serious cases where whatever would have passed on is so terrible that it would be cruel to the offspring to let them create them. I don't believe that personalities are inheritable, so preventing people from having children just because they triggered someone is stupid to me. When a child does something wrong, you have to teach them why it's wrong to get them to stop. Nurture vs Nature in mind. Kids should only be taken from them if they're abusing them or are neglectful, especially if they have attraction to children which puts the kids in danger.

Note: This can't become an argument about killing people for eugenics. Trying to advocate for that is a violation of the rule about not advocating death of [insert group].

What's your stance?


No.
Tara A McGill, Ambassador to Lucinda G Doyle III
"Always be yourself, unless you can be Zathras. Then be Zathras"
A Rough Guide To Calladan | The Seven Years of Darkness | Ambassador McGill's Facebook Page
"Give me your tired, your poor, Your huddled masses yearning to breathe free, providing they are Christian & white" - Trump

User avatar
The Land Fomerly Known as Ligerplace
Powerbroker
 
Posts: 9720
Founded: Jul 25, 2012
Ex-Nation

Postby The Land Fomerly Known as Ligerplace » Thu Jul 27, 2017 2:58 pm

Vivida Vis Animi wrote:Eugenics would undoubtedly be legalised for the best intentions but it would end up being used to target minorities, especially the LGBT community where half the overly zealous folk think it's a mental disease that needs to be eradicated anyways but that's a different discussion altogether. And besides that we still don't know enough about genetics to determine if it's even worth it.

Wait, would that even be worth it?

I mean two sticks rubbing together makes a fire, not a baby.
Founder of the Church of Ass.

No Homo.
TET sex chat link
Neo Art wrote:
The Land Fomerly Known as Ligerplace wrote:Ironic ain't it, now there really IS 47% of the country that feels like victims.

........fuck it, you win the internet.

User avatar
Ximea
Senator
 
Posts: 4797
Founded: May 28, 2004
Ex-Nation

Postby Ximea » Thu Jul 27, 2017 3:00 pm

It's worse than unethical - it's bad science, at least the way it's always been practiced. Most of the factors that were targeted are the product of a complex interaction of innumerable genes as well as environmental influences. You can't sterilize your way out of that. And attempting to enforce a particular idea of an ideal citizen is a great way to create a genetic bottleneck, which is a great way to expose your population to the risk of extinction.
"The twentieth century showed us the evil face of physics. This century will show us the evil face of biology. This will be humanity's last century." - A.X.L. Pendergast

User avatar
Telconi
Post Czar
 
Posts: 34903
Founded: Oct 08, 2016
Ex-Nation

Postby Telconi » Thu Jul 27, 2017 3:01 pm

The Land Fomerly Known as Ligerplace wrote:
Vivida Vis Animi wrote:Eugenics would undoubtedly be legalised for the best intentions but it would end up being used to target minorities, especially the LGBT community where half the overly zealous folk think it's a mental disease that needs to be eradicated anyways but that's a different discussion altogether. And besides that we still don't know enough about genetics to determine if it's even worth it.

Wait, would that even be worth it?

I mean two sticks rubbing together makes a fire, not a baby.


I don't think he's saying they would sterilize homosexuals. I think he's simply using homosexuality as an example of society oppressing a group by mis-labeling a trait of the demographic as a "defect".
-2.25 LEFT
-3.23 LIBERTARIAN

PRO:
-Weapons Rights
-Gender Equality
-LGBTQ Rights
-Racial Equality
-Religious Freedom
-Freedom of Speech
-Freedom of Association
-Life
-Limited Government
-Non Interventionism
-Labor Unions
-Environmental Protections
ANTI:
-Racism
-Sexism
-Bigotry In All Forms
-Government Overreach
-Government Surveillance
-Freedom For Security Social Transactions
-Unnecessary Taxes
-Excessively Specific Government Programs
-Foreign Entanglements
-Religious Extremism
-Fascists Masquerading as "Social Justice Warriors"

"The Constitution is NOT an instrument for the government to restrain the people,it is an instrument for the people to restrain the government-- lest it come to dominate our lives and interests." ~ Patrick Henry

User avatar
The Land Fomerly Known as Ligerplace
Powerbroker
 
Posts: 9720
Founded: Jul 25, 2012
Ex-Nation

Postby The Land Fomerly Known as Ligerplace » Thu Jul 27, 2017 3:11 pm

Telconi wrote:
The Land Fomerly Known as Ligerplace wrote:Wait, would that even be worth it?

I mean two sticks rubbing together makes a fire, not a baby.


I don't think he's saying they would sterilize homosexuals. I think he's simply using homosexuality as an example of society oppressing a group by mis-labeling a trait of the demographic as a "defect".

If it's a defect, why wouldn't you? In theory.
Founder of the Church of Ass.

No Homo.
TET sex chat link
Neo Art wrote:
The Land Fomerly Known as Ligerplace wrote:Ironic ain't it, now there really IS 47% of the country that feels like victims.

........fuck it, you win the internet.

User avatar
Telconi
Post Czar
 
Posts: 34903
Founded: Oct 08, 2016
Ex-Nation

Postby Telconi » Thu Jul 27, 2017 3:19 pm

The Land Fomerly Known as Ligerplace wrote:
Telconi wrote:
I don't think he's saying they would sterilize homosexuals. I think he's simply using homosexuality as an example of society oppressing a group by mis-labeling a trait of the demographic as a "defect".

If it's a defect, why wouldn't you? In theory.


Because it's morally wrong to deprive someone of the right to reproduce.
-2.25 LEFT
-3.23 LIBERTARIAN

PRO:
-Weapons Rights
-Gender Equality
-LGBTQ Rights
-Racial Equality
-Religious Freedom
-Freedom of Speech
-Freedom of Association
-Life
-Limited Government
-Non Interventionism
-Labor Unions
-Environmental Protections
ANTI:
-Racism
-Sexism
-Bigotry In All Forms
-Government Overreach
-Government Surveillance
-Freedom For Security Social Transactions
-Unnecessary Taxes
-Excessively Specific Government Programs
-Foreign Entanglements
-Religious Extremism
-Fascists Masquerading as "Social Justice Warriors"

"The Constitution is NOT an instrument for the government to restrain the people,it is an instrument for the people to restrain the government-- lest it come to dominate our lives and interests." ~ Patrick Henry

User avatar
The Southern Confederacy
Bureaucrat
 
Posts: 50
Founded: Jul 08, 2017
Ex-Nation

Postby The Southern Confederacy » Thu Jul 27, 2017 3:21 pm

The Land Fomerly Known as Ligerplace wrote:For one, I don't think we understand genetics enough to do eugenics without it backfiring someday horribly. Secondly, eugenics has been a way to not so subtly get rid of unwanted populations, like Margaret Sanger and the negroes for example.

I don't exactly think its bad in itself, I just think society is almost always bad with it.

Margaret Sanger didn't want to get rid of the Negroes.
Officially the Confederate States of America. Sometimes called the Southern Confederacy to distinguish it further from the United States of America.

User avatar
The Southern Confederacy
Bureaucrat
 
Posts: 50
Founded: Jul 08, 2017
Ex-Nation

Postby The Southern Confederacy » Thu Jul 27, 2017 3:22 pm

Telconi wrote:
The Land Fomerly Known as Ligerplace wrote:If it's a defect, why wouldn't you? In theory.


Because it's morally wrong to deprive someone of the right to reproduce.

Not really.
Officially the Confederate States of America. Sometimes called the Southern Confederacy to distinguish it further from the United States of America.

Next

Advertisement

Remove ads

Return to General

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: Ariddia, Google [Bot], Northern Socialist Council Republics, Owonyaania, Valrifell, Yorsa II

Advertisement

Remove ads