Lytenburgh wrote:Define "using child soldiers".
Using persons under the age of 15 in a combat or otherwise front-line capacity.
That's the only definition of "using child soldiers".
Advertisement

by The balkens » Wed Nov 26, 2014 3:38 am
Lytenburgh wrote:The balkens wrote:
I wouldn't be too surprised that you of all people said that.
I mean, why dont more Russian soldiers go on "Vacation" To east Ukraine? Its the latest Russian Excuse for sending its sons to die for a nation that doesn't exist.
The existence of Novorossiya was confirmed both by Referendum in May and elections in November. It is as real as Ukrainian desire to wipe it out.
I know, you, as Westerner, won't understand it, but a lot of Russians fighting and dying for Novorossiya wasn't "send" here. They are indeed volunteers fighting for idea and fellow slavs.

by Lytenburgh » Wed Nov 26, 2014 3:39 am
Costa Fierro wrote:Lytenburgh wrote:Define "using child soldiers".
Going by what the UN uses, so namely using those under the age of 18. The resolution passed also stated that those who aren't fighting but are underage and recruited/forced are also considered child soldiers.What, several separate reports about kids serving in support roles defending their hometown is for you the same as using the proverbial human-wave tactics.
They're still child soldiers according to international law.
Costa Fierro wrote:So what about the SPLA and it's documented use of child soldiers? They were in the same situation as Novorossiyan militias, fighting for national independence and "defending their hometowns".

by Ainin » Wed Nov 26, 2014 3:40 am
Costa Fierro wrote:Lytenburgh wrote:Define "using child soldiers".
Going by what the UN uses, so namely using those under the age of 18. The resolution passed also stated that those who aren't fighting but are underage and recruited/forced are also considered child soldiers.

by Lytenburgh » Wed Nov 26, 2014 3:40 am

by Baltenstein » Wed Nov 26, 2014 3:43 am
I know, you, as Westerner, won't understand it, but a lot of Russians fighting and dying for Novorossiya wasn't "send" here. They are indeed volunteers fighting for idea and fellow slavs.

by Lytenburgh » Wed Nov 26, 2014 3:45 am
Baltenstein wrote:I know, you, as Westerner, won't understand it, but a lot of Russians fighting and dying for Novorossiya wasn't "send" here. They are indeed volunteers fighting for idea and fellow slavs.
Also, against fellow Slavs. For all the talk about Panslavism, there has been a remarkable amount of inter-Slavic fighting going on since 1945. Soviet tanks in Prague, Croats, Serbs and Bosnians killing each other, Ukrainians versus Russians and Russophone Ukrainians...

by Baltenstein » Wed Nov 26, 2014 3:52 am
Lytenburgh wrote:Baltenstein wrote:
Also, against fellow Slavs. For all the talk about Panslavism, there has been a remarkable amount of inter-Slavic fighting going on since 1945. Soviet tanks in Prague, Croats, Serbs and Bosnians killing each other, Ukrainians versus Russians and Russophone Ukrainians...
Yeah, lets pile up all conflicts in which ethnical Russians egaged since 1945! This will make soooo much sense!
BTW - what is your point here?

by Lytenburgh » Wed Nov 26, 2014 3:53 am
Baltenstein wrote:Lytenburgh wrote:
Yeah, lets pile up all conflicts in which ethnical Russians egaged since 1945! This will make soooo much sense!
BTW - what is your point here?
That any sense of "Slavic brotherhood" is extremely artificial. Just like in Western Europe, Eastern Europeans identify with their respective nations before anything else.

by Baltenstein » Wed Nov 26, 2014 3:55 am
Lytenburgh wrote:Baltenstein wrote:
That any sense of "Slavic brotherhood" is extremely artificial. Just like in Western Europe, Eastern Europeans identify with their respective nations before anything else.
Are you specifically denying that Russians don't feel said "brotherly solidarity" with, say, Serbs and Eastern Ukrainians/Novorossiyans?


by Costa Fierro » Wed Nov 26, 2014 3:58 am
Lytenburgh wrote:Oh, I should've get used to your literal-mindeness and belief in absolutes, by now, Costa.
So, for you the world is either "black" or "white", "Good' or "Bad", "0" or "1", right?
You can't differentiate the conception of varying degrees?
For you, personally, kids who volunteered to serve their Republic and do that not on front-lines, are the same as children pressed into fighting in the fore? Can you answer this question with either "Yes" or "No"?
Who recognizes Novorossiyan militias as "terrorists" now?

by Lytenburgh » Wed Nov 26, 2014 4:01 am
Costa Fierro wrote:Lytenburgh wrote:Oh, I should've get used to your literal-mindeness and belief in absolutes, by now, Costa.
It's good to throw people a curve ball once in a while. The internet is no place for complacency.So, for you the world is either "black" or "white", "Good' or "Bad", "0" or "1", right?
I know that there are varying degrees of grey in the world. But there are instances where the world is "black" and "white".You can't differentiate the conception of varying degrees?
I don't particularly want to be seen as someone who says one thing and believes another for political purposes.For you, personally, kids who volunteered to serve their Republic and do that not on front-lines, are the same as children pressed into fighting in the fore? Can you answer this question with either "Yes" or "No"?
Yes. They're soldiers serving in whatever military organization one deems them. Do you think that the world "soldier" only applies to those who fight?Who recognizes Novorossiyan militias as "terrorists" now?
No one did. They're separatists. Same term as the SPLA were when they were fighting for independence.

by Lytenburgh » Wed Nov 26, 2014 4:03 am
Baltenstein wrote:Lytenburgh wrote:
Are you specifically denying that Russians don't feel said "brotherly solidarity" with, say, Serbs and Eastern Ukrainians/Novorossiyans?
On a national basis. If it had anything to do with Slavic identity, the same feelings should exist for Poles, Czechs etc., which clearly isn't the case.
Also, it's only natural that Russians feel solidarity with the armed forces of Novorossiya, what with a huge chunk of those being actually citizens of the Russian Federation and members of the Russian military and various secret services.

by Costa Fierro » Wed Nov 26, 2014 4:06 am
Lytenburgh wrote:Thank you for answers, Costa! I guess, for me it would be pointless to continue any further converstion with you, then...

by United Marxist Nations » Wed Nov 26, 2014 9:12 am
Ainin wrote:Costa Fierro wrote:
Going by what the UN uses, so namely using those under the age of 18. The resolution passed also stated that those who aren't fighting but are underage and recruited/forced are also considered child soldiers.
A bit nitpicky, but it's actually 15 under the Geneva Conventions and the Convention on the Rights of the Child. Enrollment of soldiers ages 16-18 is discouraged but not illegal per se, unless it was coerced/forced. Then it would be a violation of international labour laws.
The Kievan People wrote: United Marxist Nations: A prayer for every soul, a plan for every economy and a waifu for every man. Solid.
St. John Chrysostom wrote:A comprehended God is no God.

by Germanic Templars » Wed Nov 26, 2014 9:34 am

by Omorov-Nier » Wed Nov 26, 2014 9:58 am
Costa Fierro wrote:
Going by what the UN uses, so namely using those under the age of 18. The resolution passed also stated that those who aren't fighting but are underage and recruited/forced are also considered child soldiers.

by Constantinopolis » Wed Nov 26, 2014 9:59 am
The BBC wrote:But other Ukrainian TV channels have featured a pro-Kiev child soldier, without questioning whether it was right for him to be involved in the conflict.
Their reports told the story of a 17-year old who had spent two months in the conflict zone. For a week, he was a sapper at Savur Mohyla, the scene of extremely heavy fighting, one report said. Eventually, he was wounded and taken to hospital in central Ukraine.
Speaking from hospital, he told 5 Kanal that he had lied about his age to enlist in a volunteer battalion. But his commander seemed to be aware of how young he was.
"He always tried to be right at the front, he had to be kept back. It's not a person's age that matters here, but how prepared they are to fight for their country," he told Ukrayina TV, his face concealed by a balaclava.

by The Carlisle » Wed Nov 26, 2014 10:06 am
Constantinopolis wrote:Uh... in this discussion of child soldiers, are we somehow forgetting that the BBC report also mentioned 17 year olds fighting on the pro-Kiev side?The BBC wrote:But other Ukrainian TV channels have featured a pro-Kiev child soldier, without questioning whether it was right for him to be involved in the conflict.
Their reports told the story of a 17-year old who had spent two months in the conflict zone. For a week, he was a sapper at Savur Mohyla, the scene of extremely heavy fighting, one report said. Eventually, he was wounded and taken to hospital in central Ukraine.
Speaking from hospital, he told 5 Kanal that he had lied about his age to enlist in a volunteer battalion. But his commander seemed to be aware of how young he was.
"He always tried to be right at the front, he had to be kept back. It's not a person's age that matters here, but how prepared they are to fight for their country," he told Ukrayina TV, his face concealed by a balaclava.

by Omorov-Nier » Wed Nov 26, 2014 10:11 am
The Carlisle wrote:Wow. That's really stretching it.
One 17-year-old who lied about his age and it was only his commander who had an idea of it. His commander not everyone in the UA army.

by Constantinopolis » Wed Nov 26, 2014 10:15 am
The Carlisle wrote:Constantinopolis wrote:Uh... in this discussion of child soldiers, are we somehow forgetting that the BBC report also mentioned 17 year olds fighting on the pro-Kiev side?
Wow. That's really stretching it.
One 17-year-old who lied about his age and it was only his commander who had an idea of it. His commander not everyone in the UA army.

by The Carlisle » Wed Nov 26, 2014 10:20 am
Constantinopolis wrote:The Carlisle wrote:Wow. That's really stretching it.
One 17-year-old who lied about his age and it was only his commander who had an idea of it. His commander not everyone in the UA army.
Uh... yes there is only one under-18 soldier confirmed in the Ukrainian army, and there are only two of them confirmed on the Novorossiyan side, so it's not exactly a huge difference.

by Germanic Templars » Wed Nov 26, 2014 10:24 am
Omorov-Nier wrote:Costa Fierro wrote:
Going by what the UN uses, so namely using those under the age of 18. The resolution passed also stated that those who aren't fighting but are underage and recruited/forced are also considered child soldiers.
Following that definition, both the UK and the US recruit child soldiers.

by Constantinopolis » Wed Nov 26, 2014 10:26 am
The Carlisle wrote:Constantinopolis wrote:Uh... yes there is only one under-18 soldier confirmed in the Ukrainian army, and there are only two of them confirmed on the Novorossiyan side, so it's not exactly a huge difference.
Not two. Only prominent ones. In one batallion, the commander said that he had fighters as young as 16.
http://www.bbc.com/news/world-europe-30134421
There are reported cases of separatists going to schools, giving patriotic education, which implies that they are trying to recruit from schools.
Advertisement
Users browsing this forum: Ariddia, Camtropia, Gran Patria de las Antillas, Greater Britannian Realm, Greater German Confederate, Ifreann, Los Einquirers, No Freedoom, Nova Corrisia, Satreburg 2, Semi-Sentient Tumbleweed, The Crusader Kings, The Hakurei, WestSandusky, Yorsa II
Advertisement