NATION

PASSWORD

NM Supreme Court Forces Christian to Take Gay Wedding Photos

For discussion and debate about anything. (Not a roleplay related forum; out-of-character commentary only.)

Advertisement

Remove ads

Was it right for the NM Supreme Court to force Ms. Huguenin to photograph a gay wedding ceremony?

Yes
257
45%
No
308
55%
 
Total votes : 565

User avatar
Ethel mermania
Post Overlord
 
Posts: 138142
Founded: Aug 20, 2010
Ex-Nation

Postby Ethel mermania » Fri Aug 23, 2013 6:55 pm

Castille de Italia wrote:
Yumyumsuppertime wrote:
Can you give a reason why that hasn't already been shot down here time and again?

Because the owner should retain the right to refuse service. Say a man walks into my fictional barber shop wearing a green shirt. Well, I don't like the color green, so I refuse him service at my own expense. I lost potential money there but hey, it was my decision that in a free-market economy, I should be able to do.


actually you can do that. you just cant discriminate against a protected class, which in NM includes sexual orientation
https://www.hvst.com/posts/the-clash-of ... s-wl2TQBpY

The West won the world not by the superiority of its ideas or values or religion … but rather by its superiority in applying organized violence. Westerners often forget this fact; non-Westerners never do.
--S. Huntington

The most fundamental problem of politics is not the control of wickedness but the limitation of righteousness. 

--H. Kissenger

User avatar
Yumyumsuppertime
Retired Moderator
 
Posts: 28799
Founded: Jun 21, 2012
Ex-Nation

Postby Yumyumsuppertime » Fri Aug 23, 2013 6:55 pm

Ethel mermania wrote:
Farnhamia wrote:We get it. Saying it three times doesn't make it more forceful.


but it does make it true


Yeah, like when you look in a mirror and say BLOODY MARY, BLOODY MARY, BLOODY MAR--

User avatar
Castille de Italia
Minister
 
Posts: 2649
Founded: Mar 22, 2012
Father Knows Best State

Postby Castille de Italia » Fri Aug 23, 2013 6:56 pm

Yumyumsuppertime wrote:
Castille de Italia wrote:Because the owner should retain the right to refuse service. Say a man walks into my fictional barber shop wearing a green shirt. Well, I don't like the color green, so I refuse him service at my own expense. I lost potential money there but hey, it was my decision that in a free-market economy, I should be able to do.


Right.

Remind me of why you should be able to do this?

Because I own the business, and the government should not interfere. I would reserve the right to refuse service. It's not uncommon at all, really.
The Castillian Federation | La Fédération Castillia
Fraternité sous notre Fédération

M.E. | IIWiki | Dramatis Personae | CDPEC | Pan Dien | Deep Throat | Under Marianne's Banner

User avatar
Electroconvulsive Glee
Chargé d'Affaires
 
Posts: 496
Founded: Apr 20, 2013
Ex-Nation

A compelling opinion

Postby Electroconvulsive Glee » Fri Aug 23, 2013 6:58 pm

I wish I had time to comment more, but I would note that every objection raised by the OP is addressed at length by the New Mexico Supreme Court and the Court's decision is completely consistent with copious caselaw.

Regardless, I would bring attention to the follow excerpts from the special concurrence of Justice Bosson (who is selectively quoted in the OP sources):

In a constitutional form of government, personal, religious, and moral beliefs, when acted upon to the detriment of someone else’s rights, have constitutional limits. One is free to believe, think and speak as one’s conscience, or God, dictates. But when actions, even religiously inspired, conflict with other constitutionally protected rights—in [Loving v. Virginia, 388 U.S. 1 (1967),] the right to be free from invidious racial discrimination—then there must be some accommodation. Recall that [W. Va. State Bd. of Educ. v. Barnette] was all about the students; their exercise of First Amendment rights did not infringe upon anyone else. The Huguenins [who own Elane Photography] cannot make that claim. Their refusal to do business with the same-sex couple in this case, no matter how religiously inspired, was an affront to the legal rights of that couple, the right granted them under New Mexico law to engage in the commercial marketplace free from discrimination.

. . .

On a larger scale, this case provokes reflection on what this nation is all about, its promise of fairness, liberty, equality of opportunity, and justice. At its heart, this case teaches that at some point in our lives all of us must compromise, if only a little, to accommodate the contrasting values of others. A multicultural, pluralistic society, one of our nation’s strengths, demands no less. The Huguenins are free to think, to say, to believe, as they wish; they may pray to the God of their choice and follow those commandments in their personal lives wherever they lead. The Constitution protects the Huguenins in that respect and much more. But there is a price, one that we all have to pay somewhere in our civic life.

In the smaller, more focused world of the marketplace, of commerce, of public accommodation, the Huguenins have to channel their conduct, not their beliefs, so as to leave space for other Americans who believe something different. That compromise is part of the glue that holds us together as a nation, the tolerance that lubricates the varied moving parts of us as a people. That sense of respect we owe others, whether or not we believe as they do, illuminates this country, setting it apart from the discord that afflicts much of the rest of the world. In short, I would say to the Huguenins, with the utmost respect: it is the price of citizenship.
Some of the greatest satire ever, by my hero, Hammurab
  • Marcus Aurelius, The Meditations, Bk. XIII, No. LXIX: "They can all just fuck off. I'm sick of this shit and I'm going home."  
  • Butthole Surfers: "I hate cough syrup, don't you?" 
  • Socrates in Plato's Mentītus: "I can explain it to you, Dudious, but how can I understand it for you? Hmm?"

User avatar
Tubbsalot
Powerbroker
 
Posts: 9196
Founded: Oct 17, 2008
Ex-Nation

Postby Tubbsalot » Fri Aug 23, 2013 6:59 pm

Castille de Italia wrote:
Yumyumsuppertime wrote:Right.

Remind me of why you should be able to do this?

Because I own the business, and the government should not interfere.

This is not justifying discrimination, this is just saying that you should be able to discriminate. Your feelings are irrelevant. I want an explanation of why allowing discrimination is a net benefit to society.

Castille de Italia wrote:I would reserve the right to refuse service. It's not uncommon at all, really.

I don't see why you're attempting to justify discrimination with "well, a lot of people are hateful fuckers."
"Twats love flags." - Yootopia

User avatar
Yumyumsuppertime
Retired Moderator
 
Posts: 28799
Founded: Jun 21, 2012
Ex-Nation

Postby Yumyumsuppertime » Fri Aug 23, 2013 7:00 pm

Castille de Italia wrote:
Yumyumsuppertime wrote:
Right.

Remind me of why you should be able to do this?

Because I own the business, and the government should not interfere. I would reserve the right to refuse service. It's not uncommon at all, really.


Why shouldn't the government interfere? Yes, you own the business, but you don't own it within a vacuum. You're still part of a larger society, your actions and inactions affect others, and that's the government's purview. Now, it's perfectly fair to say "I don't think that the government should interfere in this aspect of my business, or that one." But to take a stand that the government has no responsibility to ensure that your business does not have a negative impact on others is ludicrous.

User avatar
Castille de Italia
Minister
 
Posts: 2649
Founded: Mar 22, 2012
Father Knows Best State

Postby Castille de Italia » Fri Aug 23, 2013 7:04 pm

Tubbsalot wrote:
Castille de Italia wrote:Because I own the business, and the government should not interfere.

This is not justifying discrimination, this is just saying that you should be able to discriminate. Your feelings are irrelevant. I want an explanation of why allowing discrimination is a net benefit to society.

Castille de Italia wrote:I would reserve the right to refuse service. It's not uncommon at all, really.

I don't see why you're attempting to justify discrimination with "well, a lot of people are hateful fuckers."

I'm not trying to justify discrimination. I am saying that you should be able to discriminate, you have that right. If she didn't want to get paid for taking pictures, then she shouldn't have had too. She should of had the right to refuse the couple service.
The Castillian Federation | La Fédération Castillia
Fraternité sous notre Fédération

M.E. | IIWiki | Dramatis Personae | CDPEC | Pan Dien | Deep Throat | Under Marianne's Banner

User avatar
Purpelia
Post Czar
 
Posts: 34243
Founded: Oct 19, 2010
Ex-Nation

Postby Purpelia » Fri Aug 23, 2013 7:05 pm

There are basically two opposing viewpoints here. And the reason for their existence is the existence of two opposing but equally emotionally valid perspectives. Not cognitively valid. But emotionally valid none the less.

On one hand, we have the customers who are wronged by virtue of being denied service. Every one of us can sympathize with that. No one would feel right about being turned down regardless of the reason. And a reason so close to heart as ones sexuality or any biological trait doubly so. And so our immediate response will be to cry out against such behavior where ever it occurs. After all if X can deny Y than tomorrow he can deny me as well.
On the other hand, we have the viewpoint of the individual who as a most basic instinct rejects being forced to do things that he or she is uncomfortable with. And when faced with such a situation the immediate emotional response is to reject any law, principal or code that has at its core the desire to compel anyone to do anything against ones will. After all if today we force X to do Y tomorrow you might force me to do Z.


Now every single one of us can without too much effort allow him self to sympathize with both sides in this argument. Our biology simply dictates that we have both a selfish and a social side in equal measure. We know that it would be very unpleasant to be denied any service. And we also know that it would be equally unpleasant to be forced to provide it. So there is an emotional struggle relating to these issues. And the eventual outcome is going to for each and every one of us depend on the individual personality and social views we hold. That is to say on our ability to put logic in front of emotions and make a rational decision in a situation where someones feelings have to be hurt either way. And our view of just what this logic leads to.

For those of us who are more social minded. This will be that people deserve access to services even if the provider is uncomfortable with it. As a communist for example, I see any and all enterprises as merely tools to provide for the happiness for the population. And thus I see a shop owner who denies service to anyone on any grounds other than the physical inability to render it as deplorable.

And yet at the same time for those on the opposite end of the spectrum things will be opposite. Those among us who are more individualistic will feel that their right to refuse is more important than someone elses right to receive on the count that he has the option of receiving from somewhere else. Even if this somewhere else is undefined or worse yet hard to reach. The fact that it exists in their minds washes away the notion of guilt validating thus the belief that the only thing anyone is entitled to is his or her own freedom to chose.


In other words. It's really just class struggle 101.
Last edited by Purpelia on Fri Aug 23, 2013 7:06 pm, edited 1 time in total.
Purpelia does not reflect my actual world views. In fact, the vast majority of Purpelian cannon is meant to shock and thus deliberately insane. I just like playing with the idea of a country of madmen utterly convinced that everyone else are the barbarians. So play along or not but don't ever think it's for real.



The above post contains hyperbole, metaphoric language, embellishment and exaggeration. It may also include badly translated figures of speech and misused idioms. Analyze accordingly.

User avatar
Electroconvulsive Glee
Chargé d'Affaires
 
Posts: 496
Founded: Apr 20, 2013
Ex-Nation

Postby Electroconvulsive Glee » Fri Aug 23, 2013 7:05 pm

Auralia wrote:
New Mexico’s highest court ruled Thursday that the owners of an Albuquerque wedding photography company violated state law when they turned away a lesbian couple who wanted to hire them to take pictures of their ceremony.

Upholding a lower-court ruling, the New Mexico Supreme Court held that the company’s refusal was an act of discrimination. They rejected the argument of the devout Christian owners of Elane Photography who claimed they had a free speech and religious right not to shoot the ceremony.

The decision comes at a time of turbulent debate over gay marriage in New Mexico, where a county clerk gained national attention this week by issuing marriage licenses to same-sex couples against the advice of the attorney general (though he’s not challenging it). As Law Blog noted earlier, gay marriage hasn’t been legalized New Mexico, though there’s a dispute over whether state law prohibits it.

Under the New Mexico Human Rights Act, it’s unlawful for a public accommodation to refuse to offer its services to someone because of the person’s sexual orientation. The same law also prohibits discrimination on the basis of race, religion, color, national origin, ancestry and gender.

“When Elane Photography refused to photograph a same-sex commitment ceremony, it violated the NMHRA in the same way as if it had refused to photograph a wedding between people of different races,” the court stated in its opinion.

“Even if the services it offers are creative or expressive, Elane Photography must offer its services to customers without regard for the customers’ race, sex, sexual orientation, or other protected classification,” the court said.

Elaine Huguenin and her husband Jonathan, the owners of the company, argued that shooting the ceremony would have conflicted with their fundamental religious tenets and given the impression that they were supportive of gay marriage.

The Alliance Defending Freedom, which represented the photographers, said the decision amounted to government-enforced coercion. “This decision is a blow to our client and every American’s right to live free,” stated the group’s senior counsel, Jordan Lorence.

The case dates back to 2006 when Vanessa Willock asked the Huguenins to photograph a “commitment ceremony” that she and her partner were planning to hold in the town of Taos.

After getting turned down, the couple accused the company of discrimination in a complaint to the New Mexico Human Rights Commission. The state body found that the company engaged in sexual orientation discrimination and ordered Elane Photography to pay thousands of dollars in attorneys’ fees.

“When you open a business, you are opening your doors to all people in your community, not just the select few who share your personal beliefs,” said Louise Melling, deputy legal director of the American Civil Liberties Union, in a statement. The ACLU filed a brief in support of Ms. Willock.

In a concurring opinion Thursday, Justice Richard C. Bosson said the case “provokes reflection on what this nation is all about.” The company’s refusal, “no matter how religiously inspired, was an affront to the legal rights of that couple,” he wrote.

“All of which, I assume, is little comfort to the Huguenins, who now are compelled by law to compromise the very religious beliefs that inspire their lives,” Justice Bosson wrote. “Though the rule of law requires it, the result is sobering. It will no doubt leave a tangible mark on the Huguenins and others of similar views.”

http://blogs.wsj.com/law/2013/08/22/photographers-discriminated-against-gay-couple-court-rules/


As a Catholic, I find this turn of events rather appalling. I would hate to be in a position where I have to choose between compromising my moral and religious beliefs or paying a heavy fine. Any law that would put me in that position is a bad law.

But even from a secular perspective, I have a couple of problems with this case. Shouldn't the First Amendment prohibit this, since it was essentially compelled speech? Shouldn't the New Mexico Religious Freedom Restoration Act (which forbids the government from substantially burdening freedom of religion unless it is the least restrictive means to accomplish a compelling governmental interest) prohibit this, since Ms. Willock was easily able to find another photographer?

After all, the purpose of anti-discrimination law is to ensure that minorities have access to essential services, not to browbeat everyone into compliance with the anti-discrimination norm. As I just said, Ms. Willock was easily able to find another photographer, so why did she and her partner feel it necessary to go after Ms. Huguenin?

So, NSG, what do you think?

EDIT: Here's the sequence of events that lead to the human rights complaint:

In 2006, Vanessa Willock e-mailed Elane Photography about photographing a “commitment ceremony” that she and her partner were planning. Willock said that this would be a “same-gender ceremony.” Elane Photography responded that it photographed “traditional weddings.” The Huguenins are Christians who, for religious reasons, disapprove of same-sex unions. Willock sent a second e-mail asking whether this meant that the company “does not offer photography services to same-sex couples.” Elane Photography responded that “you are correct.”

http://www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/george-f-will-the-tangled-web-of-conflicting-rights/2012/09/14/95b787c2-fddc-11e1-b153-218509a954e1_story.html

I do not know about NSG, but I think that you have not actually read the New Mexico Supreme Court opinion to which you object. If you had, you would find well-settled answers to your questions and objections. And you would find that most of Elane Photography's arguments were laughable.

If you choose to do public business -- particularly as a limited liability corporation (a special creation of the government), then you must abide by neutral laws of generally applicability to such public business. You have no right to violate laws merely because you disagree with them on religious grounds.
Some of the greatest satire ever, by my hero, Hammurab
  • Marcus Aurelius, The Meditations, Bk. XIII, No. LXIX: "They can all just fuck off. I'm sick of this shit and I'm going home."  
  • Butthole Surfers: "I hate cough syrup, don't you?" 
  • Socrates in Plato's Mentītus: "I can explain it to you, Dudious, but how can I understand it for you? Hmm?"

User avatar
Geilinor
Post Czar
 
Posts: 41328
Founded: Feb 20, 2010
Ex-Nation

Postby Geilinor » Fri Aug 23, 2013 7:06 pm

Castille de Italia wrote:
Yumyumsuppertime wrote:
Right.

Remind me of why you should be able to do this?

Because I own the business, and the government should not interfere. I would reserve the right to refuse service. It's not uncommon at all, really.

So you're okay with pre-Civil Rights Act of 1964 segregation being allowed? And how is such discrimination not uncommon? The last time I checked, we don't have "no blacks" or "no women" signs.
Last edited by Geilinor on Fri Aug 23, 2013 7:07 pm, edited 1 time in total.
Member of the Free Democratic Party. Not left. Not right. Forward.
Economic Left/Right: -1.13
Social Libertarian/Authoritarian: -2.41

User avatar
Tubbsalot
Powerbroker
 
Posts: 9196
Founded: Oct 17, 2008
Ex-Nation

Postby Tubbsalot » Fri Aug 23, 2013 7:07 pm

Castille de Italia wrote:I am saying that you should be able to discriminate, you have that right.

You are objectively incorrect. Are you not aware of the existence of anti-discrimination laws?

Castille de Italia wrote:If she didn't want to get paid for taking pictures, then she shouldn't have had too. She should of had the right to refuse the couple service.

Again, your feelings are irrelevant.
"Twats love flags." - Yootopia

User avatar
Wikkiwallana
Postmaster of the Fleet
 
Posts: 22500
Founded: Mar 21, 2010
Ex-Nation

Postby Wikkiwallana » Fri Aug 23, 2013 7:07 pm

Auralia wrote:
Wikkiwallana wrote:How does a wedding photographer being told to photograph a wedding constitute a substantial burden on religious rights?

If participation in a gay wedding is against the photographer's sincerely-held religious beliefs, then it is a substantial burden on freedom of religion.

I disagree.
Proud Scalawag and Statist!

Please don't confuse my country for my politics; my country is being run as a parody, my posts aren't.
Dumb Ideologies wrote:Halt!
Just because these people are stupid, wrong and highly dangerous does not mean you have the right to make them feel sad.
Xenohumanity wrote:
Nulono wrote:Snip
I'm a pro-lifer who runs a nation of dragon-men...
And even I think that's stupid.
Avenio wrote:Just so you know, the use of the term 'sheep' 'sheeple' or any other herd animal-based terminology in conjunction with an exhortation to 'think outside the box' or stop going along with groupthink generally indicates that the speaker is actually more closed-minded on the subject than the people that he/she is addressing. At least, in my experience at least.

User avatar
Castille de Italia
Minister
 
Posts: 2649
Founded: Mar 22, 2012
Father Knows Best State

Postby Castille de Italia » Fri Aug 23, 2013 7:07 pm

Yumyumsuppertime wrote:
Castille de Italia wrote:Because I own the business, and the government should not interfere. I would reserve the right to refuse service. It's not uncommon at all, really.


Why shouldn't the government interfere? Yes, you own the business, but you don't own it within a vacuum. You're still part of a larger society, your actions and inactions affect others, and that's the government's purview. Now, it's perfectly fair to say "I don't think that the government should interfere in this aspect of my business, or that one." But to take a stand that the government has no responsibility to ensure that your business does not have a negative impact on others is ludicrous.

I'm not saying the government shouldn't regulate completely, not at all. I'm just trying to get the point across that the courts shouldn't infringe on people's rights to refuse service based on race, religion, sexual orientation, etc. Plus I'm sure that there's other wedding photographers in Albuquerque that are willing to take wedding photos of LGBT couples.
The Castillian Federation | La Fédération Castillia
Fraternité sous notre Fédération

M.E. | IIWiki | Dramatis Personae | CDPEC | Pan Dien | Deep Throat | Under Marianne's Banner

User avatar
Gauthier
Khan of Spam
 
Posts: 52887
Founded: Antiquity
Ex-Nation

Postby Gauthier » Fri Aug 23, 2013 7:08 pm

Yumyumsuppertime wrote:
Ethel mermania wrote:
but it does make it true


Yeah, like when you look in a mirror and say BLOODY MARY, BLOODY MARY, BLOODY MAR--


Of course if you instead say CANDYMAN, CANDYMAN, CANDYMAN you get attacked by the angry spirit of Sammy Davis, Jr.
Crimes committed by Muslims will be a pan-Islamic plot and proof of Islam's inherent evil. On the other hand crimes committed by non-Muslims will merely be the acts of loners who do not represent their belief system at all.
The probability of one's participation in homosexual acts is directly proportional to one's public disdain and disgust for homosexuals.
If a political figure makes an accusation of wrongdoing without evidence, odds are probable that the accuser or an associate thereof has in fact committed the very same act, possibly to a worse degree.
Where is your God-Emperor now?

User avatar
Geilinor
Post Czar
 
Posts: 41328
Founded: Feb 20, 2010
Ex-Nation

Postby Geilinor » Fri Aug 23, 2013 7:09 pm

Electroconvulsive Glee wrote:
Auralia wrote:
As a Catholic, I find this turn of events rather appalling. I would hate to be in a position where I have to choose between compromising my moral and religious beliefs or paying a heavy fine. Any law that would put me in that position is a bad law.

But even from a secular perspective, I have a couple of problems with this case. Shouldn't the First Amendment prohibit this, since it was essentially compelled speech? Shouldn't the New Mexico Religious Freedom Restoration Act (which forbids the government from substantially burdening freedom of religion unless it is the least restrictive means to accomplish a compelling governmental interest) prohibit this, since Ms. Willock was easily able to find another photographer?

After all, the purpose of anti-discrimination law is to ensure that minorities have access to essential services, not to browbeat everyone into compliance with the anti-discrimination norm. As I just said, Ms. Willock was easily able to find another photographer, so why did she and her partner feel it necessary to go after Ms. Huguenin?

So, NSG, what do you think?

EDIT: Here's the sequence of events that lead to the human rights complaint:

I do not know about NSG, but I think that you have not actually read the New Mexico Supreme Court opinion to which you object. If you had, you would find well-settled answers to your questions and objections. And you would find that most of Elane Photography's arguments were laughable.

If you choose to do public business -- particularly as a limited liability corporation (a special creation of the government), then you must abide by neutral laws of generally applicability to such public business. You have no right to violate laws merely because you disagree with them on religious grounds.

This^. There are some rare cases where exceptions should be granted, and they are granted when reasonable. An example is that churches aren't required to marry same-sex couples if they are against it.
Last edited by Geilinor on Fri Aug 23, 2013 7:09 pm, edited 1 time in total.
Member of the Free Democratic Party. Not left. Not right. Forward.
Economic Left/Right: -1.13
Social Libertarian/Authoritarian: -2.41

User avatar
Tubbsalot
Powerbroker
 
Posts: 9196
Founded: Oct 17, 2008
Ex-Nation

Postby Tubbsalot » Fri Aug 23, 2013 7:09 pm

Castille de Italia wrote:I'm just trying to get the point across that the courts shouldn't infringe on people's rights to refuse service based on race, religion, sexual orientation, etc.

You can't infringe on a right which doesn't exist. Discrimination is explicitly forbidden. You might as well complain about the government infringing on the right to murder.
"Twats love flags." - Yootopia

User avatar
Castille de Italia
Minister
 
Posts: 2649
Founded: Mar 22, 2012
Father Knows Best State

Postby Castille de Italia » Fri Aug 23, 2013 7:10 pm

Tubbsalot wrote:
Castille de Italia wrote:I am saying that you should be able to discriminate, you have that right.

You are objectively incorrect. Are you not aware of the existence of anti-discrimination laws?

Castille de Italia wrote:If she didn't want to get paid for taking pictures, then she shouldn't have had too. She should of had the right to refuse the couple service.

Again, your feelings are irrelevant.

I would like you to link me to a source that isn't Wikipedia, Huff Post, or MSNBC that is related to corporate anti-discrimination laws varying by state.
The Castillian Federation | La Fédération Castillia
Fraternité sous notre Fédération

M.E. | IIWiki | Dramatis Personae | CDPEC | Pan Dien | Deep Throat | Under Marianne's Banner

User avatar
Geilinor
Post Czar
 
Posts: 41328
Founded: Feb 20, 2010
Ex-Nation

Postby Geilinor » Fri Aug 23, 2013 7:11 pm

Electroconvulsive Glee wrote:I wish I had time to comment more, but I would note that every objection raised by the OP is addressed at length by the New Mexico Supreme Court and the Court's decision is completely consistent with copious caselaw.

Regardless, I would bring attention to the follow excerpts from the special concurrence of Justice Bosson (who is selectively quoted in the OP sources):

In a constitutional form of government, personal, religious, and moral beliefs, when acted upon to the detriment of someone else’s rights, have constitutional limits. One is free to believe, think and speak as one’s conscience, or God, dictates. But when actions, even religiously inspired, conflict with other constitutionally protected rights—in [Loving v. Virginia, 388 U.S. 1 (1967),] the right to be free from invidious racial discrimination—then there must be some accommodation. Recall that [W. Va. State Bd. of Educ. v. Barnette] was all about the students; their exercise of First Amendment rights did not infringe upon anyone else. The Huguenins [who own Elane Photography] cannot make that claim. Their refusal to do business with the same-sex couple in this case, no matter how religiously inspired, was an affront to the legal rights of that couple, the right granted them under New Mexico law to engage in the commercial marketplace free from discrimination.

. . .

On a larger scale, this case provokes reflection on what this nation is all about, its promise of fairness, liberty, equality of opportunity, and justice. At its heart, this case teaches that at some point in our lives all of us must compromise, if only a little, to accommodate the contrasting values of others. A multicultural, pluralistic society, one of our nation’s strengths, demands no less. The Huguenins are free to think, to say, to believe, as they wish; they may pray to the God of their choice and follow those commandments in their personal lives wherever they lead. The Constitution protects the Huguenins in that respect and much more. But there is a price, one that we all have to pay somewhere in our civic life.

In the smaller, more focused world of the marketplace, of commerce, of public accommodation, the Huguenins have to channel their conduct, not their beliefs, so as to leave space for other Americans who believe something different. That compromise is part of the glue that holds us together as a nation, the tolerance that lubricates the varied moving parts of us as a people. That sense of respect we owe others, whether or not we believe as they do, illuminates this country, setting it apart from the discord that afflicts much of the rest of the world. In short, I would say to the Huguenins, with the utmost respect: it is the price of citizenship.

Your arguments are just great, Electroconvulsive. There should be religious freedom, but not to the extent that it violates other protected rights.
Member of the Free Democratic Party. Not left. Not right. Forward.
Economic Left/Right: -1.13
Social Libertarian/Authoritarian: -2.41

User avatar
Wisconsin9
Post Czar
 
Posts: 35747
Founded: May 18, 2012
Ex-Nation

Postby Wisconsin9 » Fri Aug 23, 2013 7:12 pm

Castille de Italia wrote:
Yumyumsuppertime wrote:
Why shouldn't the government interfere? Yes, you own the business, but you don't own it within a vacuum. You're still part of a larger society, your actions and inactions affect others, and that's the government's purview. Now, it's perfectly fair to say "I don't think that the government should interfere in this aspect of my business, or that one." But to take a stand that the government has no responsibility to ensure that your business does not have a negative impact on others is ludicrous.

I'm not saying the government shouldn't regulate completely, not at all. I'm just trying to get the point across that the courts shouldn't infringe on people's rights to refuse service based on race, religion, sexual orientation, etc. Plus I'm sure that there's other wedding photographers in Albuquerque that are willing to take wedding photos of LGBT couples.

'Cause that worked so well between 1870 and 1960.
~~~~~~~~
We are currently 33% through the Trump administration.
................................................................................................................................................................................................................
................................................................................................................................................................................................................

User avatar
Mavorpen
Khan of Spam
 
Posts: 63261
Founded: Dec 20, 2011
Ex-Nation

Postby Mavorpen » Fri Aug 23, 2013 7:12 pm

Castille de Italia wrote:I would like you to link me to a source that isn't Wikipedia

What? Why?
"The Nixon campaign in 1968, and the Nixon White House after that, had two enemies: the antiwar left and black people. You understand what I'm saying? We knew we couldn't make it illegal to be either against the war or black, but by getting the public to associate the hippies with marijuana and blacks with heroin, and then criminalizing both heavily, we could disrupt those communities. We could arrest their leaders. raid their homes, break up their meetings, and vilify them night after night on the evening news. Did we know we were lying about the drugs? Of course we did."—former Nixon domestic policy chief John Ehrlichman

User avatar
Geilinor
Post Czar
 
Posts: 41328
Founded: Feb 20, 2010
Ex-Nation

Postby Geilinor » Fri Aug 23, 2013 7:12 pm

Tubbsalot wrote:
Castille de Italia wrote:I'm just trying to get the point across that the courts shouldn't infringe on people's rights to refuse service based on race, religion, sexual orientation, etc.

You can't infringe on a right which doesn't exist. Discrimination is explicitly forbidden. You might as well complain about the government infringing on the right to murder.

Exactly. Since 1964, discrimination has not been a right in America.
Last edited by Geilinor on Fri Aug 23, 2013 7:13 pm, edited 1 time in total.
Member of the Free Democratic Party. Not left. Not right. Forward.
Economic Left/Right: -1.13
Social Libertarian/Authoritarian: -2.41

User avatar
Geilinor
Post Czar
 
Posts: 41328
Founded: Feb 20, 2010
Ex-Nation

Postby Geilinor » Fri Aug 23, 2013 7:14 pm

Wisconsin9 wrote:
Castille de Italia wrote:I'm not saying the government shouldn't regulate completely, not at all. I'm just trying to get the point across that the courts shouldn't infringe on people's rights to refuse service based on race, religion, sexual orientation, etc. Plus I'm sure that there's other wedding photographers in Albuquerque that are willing to take wedding photos of LGBT couples.

'Cause that worked so well between 1870 and 1960.

It's amazing how people don't think about the ramifications of saying "discrimination is a right".
Last edited by Geilinor on Fri Aug 23, 2013 7:14 pm, edited 1 time in total.
Member of the Free Democratic Party. Not left. Not right. Forward.
Economic Left/Right: -1.13
Social Libertarian/Authoritarian: -2.41

User avatar
Tubbsalot
Powerbroker
 
Posts: 9196
Founded: Oct 17, 2008
Ex-Nation

Postby Tubbsalot » Fri Aug 23, 2013 7:14 pm

Castille de Italia wrote:
Tubbsalot wrote:Are you not aware of the existence of anti-discrimination laws?

I would like you to link me to a source that isn't Wikipedia, Huff Post, or MSNBC that is related to corporate anti-discrimination laws varying by state.

You are rejecting the existence of anti-discrimination laws. It should be sufficient for me to provide you with evidence of the existence of such laws.

Other than that, you appear to be asking me to provide a link to literally anything which is somehow related to anti-discrimination laws. What exactly are you asking me to prove here?
"Twats love flags." - Yootopia

User avatar
Auralia
Senator
 
Posts: 4981
Founded: Dec 15, 2011
Liberal Democratic Socialists

Postby Auralia » Fri Aug 23, 2013 7:14 pm

Electroconvulsive Glee wrote:If you choose to do public business -- particularly as a limited liability corporation (a special creation of the government), then you must abide by neutral laws of generally applicability to such public business. You have no right to violate laws merely because you disagree with them on religious grounds.


Um, isn't that kind of the whole point of the Religious Freedom Restoration Act?
Catholic Commonwealth of Auralia
"Amor sequitur cognitionem."

User avatar
Geilinor
Post Czar
 
Posts: 41328
Founded: Feb 20, 2010
Ex-Nation

Postby Geilinor » Fri Aug 23, 2013 7:15 pm

Auralia wrote:
Electroconvulsive Glee wrote:If you choose to do public business -- particularly as a limited liability corporation (a special creation of the government), then you must abide by neutral laws of generally applicability to such public business. You have no right to violate laws merely because you disagree with them on religious grounds.


Um, isn't that kind of the whole point of the Religious Freedom Restoration Act?

He just posted, "you must abide by neutral laws of general applicability to such public business." Also, in my opinion, any law that's named to suggest a religious persecution complex ought to be repealed. There was no need to "restore" religious freedom in the first place. It reminds me of the thread about the Anglican who told "persecuted Christians" in the UK and US to "grow up".
Last edited by Geilinor on Fri Aug 23, 2013 7:18 pm, edited 1 time in total.
Member of the Free Democratic Party. Not left. Not right. Forward.
Economic Left/Right: -1.13
Social Libertarian/Authoritarian: -2.41

PreviousNext

Advertisement

Remove ads

Return to General

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: Cannot think of a name, Great Sappho, Jolthig, Nonconformity, Punctured Hopes, Rusozak, San Lumen, Stellar Colonies, The Lazarene Republic, The Lone Alliance, Yorsa II

Advertisement

Remove ads