NATION

PASSWORD

Most, and least, justified revolutions.

For discussion and debate about anything. (Not a roleplay related forum; out-of-character commentary only.)

Advertisement

Remove ads

User avatar
Nidaria
Senator
 
Posts: 3501
Founded: Mar 30, 2012
Ex-Nation

Postby Nidaria » Mon Jun 17, 2013 1:46 pm

The Christero revolution was undubiously the most justified. The French and Russian Revolutions were completely unjustified, as they overthrew just governments and established tyrannies.
"He who denies the existence of God has some reason for wishing that God did not exist." --St. Augustine
"There is only one difference between genius and stupidity: genius has limits." --Albert Einstein
"When statesmen forsake their own private conscience for the sake of their public duties... they lead their country by a short route to chaos." --St. Thomas More
Anti-gay, Pro-life, Traditionalist, Libertarian, Non-interventionist, Loyal Roman Catholic
Cosmopolitan/Nationalistic 25%
Secular/Fundamentalist 67%
Visionary/Reactionary 21%
Anarchistic/Authoritarian 6%
Communist/Capitalist 41%
Pacifist/Militaristic 7%
Ecological/Anthropocentric 52%


User avatar
Regnum Dominae
Postmaster-General
 
Posts: 12323
Founded: Feb 13, 2013
Ex-Nation

Postby Regnum Dominae » Mon Jun 17, 2013 1:48 pm

Nidaria wrote:The Christero revolution was undubiously the most justified. The French and Russian Revolutions were completely unjustified, as they overthrew just governments and established tyrannies.

You have a very strange idea of what a "just government" is.
I support peace in Israel and Palestine. The governments and people in power on all sides are an absolute disgrace, and their unwillingness to pursue peace is a disservice to the people they are meant to be serving. The status quo is not simply untenable; it is unquestionably unacceptable.


User avatar
Hittanryan
Powerbroker
 
Posts: 9068
Founded: Mar 10, 2011
Left-wing Utopia

Postby Hittanryan » Mon Jun 17, 2013 1:52 pm

Conscentia wrote:
Nidaria wrote:The Christero revolution was undubiously the most justified. The French and Russian Revolutions were completely unjustified, as they overthrew just governments and established tyrannies.

They overthrew tyrannies.

How does that song go? "Something something...same as the old boss"?
In-character name of the nation is "Adiron," because I like the name better.

User avatar
Nidaria
Senator
 
Posts: 3501
Founded: Mar 30, 2012
Ex-Nation

Postby Nidaria » Mon Jun 17, 2013 1:53 pm

Conscentia wrote:
Nidaria wrote:The Christero revolution was undubiously the most justified. The French and Russian Revolutions were completely unjustified, as they overthrew just governments and established tyrannies.

They overthrew tyrannies.

You apply the title where it does not belong.
"He who denies the existence of God has some reason for wishing that God did not exist." --St. Augustine
"There is only one difference between genius and stupidity: genius has limits." --Albert Einstein
"When statesmen forsake their own private conscience for the sake of their public duties... they lead their country by a short route to chaos." --St. Thomas More
Anti-gay, Pro-life, Traditionalist, Libertarian, Non-interventionist, Loyal Roman Catholic
Cosmopolitan/Nationalistic 25%
Secular/Fundamentalist 67%
Visionary/Reactionary 21%
Anarchistic/Authoritarian 6%
Communist/Capitalist 41%
Pacifist/Militaristic 7%
Ecological/Anthropocentric 52%

User avatar
Nidaria
Senator
 
Posts: 3501
Founded: Mar 30, 2012
Ex-Nation

Postby Nidaria » Mon Jun 17, 2013 1:53 pm

Regnum Dominae wrote:
Nidaria wrote:The Christero revolution was undubiously the most justified. The French and Russian Revolutions were completely unjustified, as they overthrew just governments and established tyrannies.

You have a very strange idea of what a "just government" is.

And the French and Russian monarchies were just governments.
"He who denies the existence of God has some reason for wishing that God did not exist." --St. Augustine
"There is only one difference between genius and stupidity: genius has limits." --Albert Einstein
"When statesmen forsake their own private conscience for the sake of their public duties... they lead their country by a short route to chaos." --St. Thomas More
Anti-gay, Pro-life, Traditionalist, Libertarian, Non-interventionist, Loyal Roman Catholic
Cosmopolitan/Nationalistic 25%
Secular/Fundamentalist 67%
Visionary/Reactionary 21%
Anarchistic/Authoritarian 6%
Communist/Capitalist 41%
Pacifist/Militaristic 7%
Ecological/Anthropocentric 52%

User avatar
Regnum Dominae
Postmaster-General
 
Posts: 12323
Founded: Feb 13, 2013
Ex-Nation

Postby Regnum Dominae » Mon Jun 17, 2013 1:54 pm

Hittanryan wrote:
Conscentia wrote:They overthrew tyrannies.

How does that song go? "Something something...same as the old boss"?

Except that those revolutions did not work like that. There were several periods of intermediary governments.
I support peace in Israel and Palestine. The governments and people in power on all sides are an absolute disgrace, and their unwillingness to pursue peace is a disservice to the people they are meant to be serving. The status quo is not simply untenable; it is unquestionably unacceptable.

User avatar
Hittanryan
Powerbroker
 
Posts: 9068
Founded: Mar 10, 2011
Left-wing Utopia

Postby Hittanryan » Mon Jun 17, 2013 1:55 pm

Nidaria wrote:
Regnum Dominae wrote:You have a very strange idea of what a "just government" is.

And the French and Russian monarchies were just governments.

Stagnation, food shortages for the Third Estate, and corruption in the French monarchy. Secret police, extreme military mismanagement, and corruption in the Russian monarchy.

Where did you learn your history?
In-character name of the nation is "Adiron," because I like the name better.

User avatar
Of the Free Socialist Territories
Powerbroker
 
Posts: 8370
Founded: Feb 12, 2012
Ex-Nation

Postby Of the Free Socialist Territories » Mon Jun 17, 2013 1:55 pm

Nidaria wrote:
Regnum Dominae wrote:You have a very strange idea of what a "just government" is.

And the French and Russian monarchies were just governments.


And there goes any last claims you had to being a libertarian.

"I'm a libertarian who supports extensive, intrusive, authoritarian, anti-democratic and tyrannical governments running police states and exiling or executing critics."
Last edited by Of the Free Socialist Territories on Mon Jun 17, 2013 1:56 pm, edited 1 time in total.
Don't be deceived when our Revolution has finally been stamped out and they tell you things are better now even if there's no poverty to see, because the poverty's been hidden...even if you ever got more wages and could afford to buy more of these new and useless goods which these new industries foist on you, and even if it seems to you that "you never had so much" - that is only the slogan of those who have much more than you.

Marat, "Marat/Sade"

User avatar
Regnum Dominae
Postmaster-General
 
Posts: 12323
Founded: Feb 13, 2013
Ex-Nation

Postby Regnum Dominae » Mon Jun 17, 2013 1:55 pm

Nidaria wrote:
Regnum Dominae wrote:You have a very strange idea of what a "just government" is.

And the French and Russian monarchies were just governments.

No they weren't. They were oppressive monarchic governments whose rulers had their heads in the clouds far from the concerns of the actual common people.
I support peace in Israel and Palestine. The governments and people in power on all sides are an absolute disgrace, and their unwillingness to pursue peace is a disservice to the people they are meant to be serving. The status quo is not simply untenable; it is unquestionably unacceptable.

User avatar
Nidaria
Senator
 
Posts: 3501
Founded: Mar 30, 2012
Ex-Nation

Postby Nidaria » Mon Jun 17, 2013 1:57 pm

Hittanryan wrote:
Nidaria wrote:And the French and Russian monarchies were just governments.

Stagnation, food shortages for the Third Estate, and corruption in the French monarchy. Secret police, extreme military mismanagement, and corruption in the Russian monarchy.

Where did you learn your history?

The French Monarchy did its best to eliminate corruption, stagnation, and food shortages. The Russian Tsardom is not to blame for corruption, but rather evil people like Rasputin.
"He who denies the existence of God has some reason for wishing that God did not exist." --St. Augustine
"There is only one difference between genius and stupidity: genius has limits." --Albert Einstein
"When statesmen forsake their own private conscience for the sake of their public duties... they lead their country by a short route to chaos." --St. Thomas More
Anti-gay, Pro-life, Traditionalist, Libertarian, Non-interventionist, Loyal Roman Catholic
Cosmopolitan/Nationalistic 25%
Secular/Fundamentalist 67%
Visionary/Reactionary 21%
Anarchistic/Authoritarian 6%
Communist/Capitalist 41%
Pacifist/Militaristic 7%
Ecological/Anthropocentric 52%

User avatar
Nidaria
Senator
 
Posts: 3501
Founded: Mar 30, 2012
Ex-Nation

Postby Nidaria » Mon Jun 17, 2013 1:58 pm

Regnum Dominae wrote:
Nidaria wrote:And the French and Russian monarchies were just governments.

No they weren't. They were oppressive monarchic governments whose rulers had their heads in the clouds far from the concerns of the actual common people.

What history textbook do you even follow?
"He who denies the existence of God has some reason for wishing that God did not exist." --St. Augustine
"There is only one difference between genius and stupidity: genius has limits." --Albert Einstein
"When statesmen forsake their own private conscience for the sake of their public duties... they lead their country by a short route to chaos." --St. Thomas More
Anti-gay, Pro-life, Traditionalist, Libertarian, Non-interventionist, Loyal Roman Catholic
Cosmopolitan/Nationalistic 25%
Secular/Fundamentalist 67%
Visionary/Reactionary 21%
Anarchistic/Authoritarian 6%
Communist/Capitalist 41%
Pacifist/Militaristic 7%
Ecological/Anthropocentric 52%

User avatar
Conscentia
Postmaster of the Fleet
 
Posts: 26681
Founded: Feb 04, 2011
Ex-Nation

Postby Conscentia » Mon Jun 17, 2013 1:58 pm

Nidaria wrote:
Conscentia wrote:They overthrew tyrannies.

You apply the title where it does not belong.

It applies entirely. The French & Russian aristocracies were oppressive.

Or does this (the Russian Imperial Secret Police) seem completely untyrannical to you?
Last edited by Conscentia on Mon Jun 17, 2013 2:00 pm, edited 1 time in total.

User avatar
Conscentia
Postmaster of the Fleet
 
Posts: 26681
Founded: Feb 04, 2011
Ex-Nation

Postby Conscentia » Mon Jun 17, 2013 1:59 pm

Nidaria wrote:
Regnum Dominae wrote:No they weren't. They were oppressive monarchic governments whose rulers had their heads in the clouds far from the concerns of the actual common people.

What history textbook do you even follow?

Have you ever read a history textbook?

User avatar
The UK in Exile
Postmaster-General
 
Posts: 12023
Founded: Jul 27, 2006
Ex-Nation

Postby The UK in Exile » Mon Jun 17, 2013 1:59 pm

Nidaria wrote:
Hittanryan wrote:Stagnation, food shortages for the Third Estate, and corruption in the French monarchy. Secret police, extreme military mismanagement, and corruption in the Russian monarchy.

Where did you learn your history?

The French Monarchy did its best to eliminate corruption, stagnation, and food shortages. The Russian Tsardom is not to blame for corruption, but rather evil people like Rasputin.


its best wasn't good enough, and the Tsar was to blame for Rasputin.
"We fought for the public good and would have enfranchised the people and secured the welfare of the whole groaning creation, if the nation had not more delighted in servitude than in freedom"

"My actions are as noble as my thoughts, That never relish’d of a base descent.I came unto your court for honour’s cause, And not to be a rebel to her state; And he that otherwise accounts of me, This sword shall prove he’s honour’s enemy."

"Wählte Ungnade, wo Gehorsam nicht Ehre brachte."
DEFCON 0 - not at war
DEFCON 1 - at war "go to red alert!" "are you absolutely sure sir? it does mean changing the lightbulb."

User avatar
Hittanryan
Powerbroker
 
Posts: 9068
Founded: Mar 10, 2011
Left-wing Utopia

Postby Hittanryan » Mon Jun 17, 2013 2:00 pm

Regnum Dominae wrote:
Hittanryan wrote:How does that song go? "Something something...same as the old boss"?

Except that those revolutions did not work like that. There were several periods of intermediary governments.

I forgot NSG was full of pedants. Yes, Revolutionary France had the First Republic and the Directory. Yes, Russia had the Provisional Government and the Civil War. Eventually, however, you end up with Napoleon and the Soviet Union, who bore many similarities with the governments their respective revolutions originally overthrew.
In-character name of the nation is "Adiron," because I like the name better.

User avatar
Conscentia
Postmaster of the Fleet
 
Posts: 26681
Founded: Feb 04, 2011
Ex-Nation

Postby Conscentia » Mon Jun 17, 2013 2:02 pm

Nidaria wrote:
Hittanryan wrote:Stagnation, food shortages for the Third Estate, and corruption in the French monarchy. Secret police, extreme military mismanagement, and corruption in the Russian monarchy.

Where did you learn your history?

The French Monarchy did its best to eliminate corruption, stagnation, and food shortages. The Russian Tsardom is not to blame for corruption, but rather evil people like Rasputin.

No it didn't.

As something said before, the Tsar is to blame for Rasputin.
Last edited by Conscentia on Mon Jun 17, 2013 2:03 pm, edited 2 times in total.

User avatar
Nidaria
Senator
 
Posts: 3501
Founded: Mar 30, 2012
Ex-Nation

Postby Nidaria » Mon Jun 17, 2013 2:03 pm

The UK in Exile wrote:
Nidaria wrote:The French Monarchy did its best to eliminate corruption, stagnation, and food shortages. The Russian Tsardom is not to blame for corruption, but rather evil people like Rasputin.


its best wasn't good enough, and the Tsar was to blame for Rasputin.

It was good enough, liberals did not give the king enough time. Also, the Tsar's wife was to blame for Rasputin.
"He who denies the existence of God has some reason for wishing that God did not exist." --St. Augustine
"There is only one difference between genius and stupidity: genius has limits." --Albert Einstein
"When statesmen forsake their own private conscience for the sake of their public duties... they lead their country by a short route to chaos." --St. Thomas More
Anti-gay, Pro-life, Traditionalist, Libertarian, Non-interventionist, Loyal Roman Catholic
Cosmopolitan/Nationalistic 25%
Secular/Fundamentalist 67%
Visionary/Reactionary 21%
Anarchistic/Authoritarian 6%
Communist/Capitalist 41%
Pacifist/Militaristic 7%
Ecological/Anthropocentric 52%

User avatar
Hittanryan
Powerbroker
 
Posts: 9068
Founded: Mar 10, 2011
Left-wing Utopia

Postby Hittanryan » Mon Jun 17, 2013 2:05 pm

Nidaria wrote:
Hittanryan wrote:Stagnation, food shortages for the Third Estate, and corruption in the French monarchy. Secret police, extreme military mismanagement, and corruption in the Russian monarchy.

Where did you learn your history?

The French Monarchy did its best to eliminate corruption, stagnation, and food shortages. The Russian Tsardom is not to blame for corruption, but rather evil people like Rasputin.

[CITATION NEEDED]

Especially for the claim that Rasputin was responsible for the Okhranka. Did you get all your history from Disney movies?
In-character name of the nation is "Adiron," because I like the name better.

User avatar
Conscentia
Postmaster of the Fleet
 
Posts: 26681
Founded: Feb 04, 2011
Ex-Nation

Postby Conscentia » Mon Jun 17, 2013 2:08 pm

Hittanryan wrote:
Regnum Dominae wrote:Except that those revolutions did not work like that. There were several periods of intermediary governments.

I forgot NSG was full of pedants. Yes, Revolutionary France had the First Republic and the Directory. Yes, Russia had the Provisional Government and the Civil War. Eventually, however, you end up with Napoleon and the Soviet Union, who bore many similarities with the governments their respective revolutions originally overthrew.

Similarities, yes, but they were not the same. Lenin did much to help the people of Russia, bringing industrialisation & literacy and ending feudalism, for example.

Nidaria wrote:
The UK in Exile wrote:its best wasn't good enough, and the Tsar was to blame for Rasputin.

It was good enough, liberals did not give the king enough time. Also, the Tsar's wife was to blame for Rasputin.

What liberals?
The Tsar's wife isn't part of the Russian aristocracy?
Last edited by Conscentia on Mon Jun 17, 2013 2:09 pm, edited 2 times in total.

User avatar
Priory Academy USSR
Senator
 
Posts: 4833
Founded: May 04, 2012
Ex-Nation

Postby Priory Academy USSR » Mon Jun 17, 2013 2:12 pm

Conscentia wrote:
Hittanryan wrote:I forgot NSG was full of pedants. Yes, Revolutionary France had the First Republic and the Directory. Yes, Russia had the Provisional Government and the Civil War. Eventually, however, you end up with Napoleon and the Soviet Union, who bore many similarities with the governments their respective revolutions originally overthrew.

Similarities, yes, but they were not the same. Lenin did much to help the people of Russia, bringing industrialisation & literacy and ending feudalism, for example.


I thought the Tsar abolished feudalism...

But yes, I agree that Lenin did do a great deal to try to improve the lives of the poor.
Call me what you will. Some people prefer 'Idiot'
Economic Compass
Left -7.00
Libertarian -2.67

User avatar
Nidaria
Senator
 
Posts: 3501
Founded: Mar 30, 2012
Ex-Nation

Postby Nidaria » Mon Jun 17, 2013 2:12 pm

Conscentia wrote:
Hittanryan wrote:I forgot NSG was full of pedants. Yes, Revolutionary France had the First Republic and the Directory. Yes, Russia had the Provisional Government and the Civil War. Eventually, however, you end up with Napoleon and the Soviet Union, who bore many similarities with the governments their respective revolutions originally overthrew.

Similarities, yes, but they were not the same. Lenin did much to help the people of Russia, bringing industrialisation & literacy and ending feudalism, for example.1

Nidaria wrote:It was good enough, liberals did not give the king enough time. Also, the Tsar's wife was to blame for Rasputin.

What liberals?2
The Tsar's wife isn't part of the Russian aristocracy?3

1Feudalism was ending on its own under the Tsar. The people were kept under virtual slavery, and lived under a police state.
2Know what the French Revolution is.
3She was, but as the saying goes, "one bad apple can spoil the bunch." Blaming the whole aristocracy for the actions of a few is idiotic.
"He who denies the existence of God has some reason for wishing that God did not exist." --St. Augustine
"There is only one difference between genius and stupidity: genius has limits." --Albert Einstein
"When statesmen forsake their own private conscience for the sake of their public duties... they lead their country by a short route to chaos." --St. Thomas More
Anti-gay, Pro-life, Traditionalist, Libertarian, Non-interventionist, Loyal Roman Catholic
Cosmopolitan/Nationalistic 25%
Secular/Fundamentalist 67%
Visionary/Reactionary 21%
Anarchistic/Authoritarian 6%
Communist/Capitalist 41%
Pacifist/Militaristic 7%
Ecological/Anthropocentric 52%

User avatar
The UK in Exile
Postmaster-General
 
Posts: 12023
Founded: Jul 27, 2006
Ex-Nation

Postby The UK in Exile » Mon Jun 17, 2013 2:14 pm

Nidaria wrote:
Conscentia wrote:Similarities, yes, but they were not the same. Lenin did much to help the people of Russia, bringing industrialisation & literacy and ending feudalism, for example.1


What liberals?2
The Tsar's wife isn't part of the Russian aristocracy?3

1Feudalism was ending on its own under the Tsar. The people were kept under virtual slavery, and lived under a police state.
2Know what the French Revolution is.
3She was, but as the saying goes, "one bad apple can spoil the bunch." Blaming the whole aristocracy for the actions of a few is idiotic.


not really, not when that one is the Tsar. If your going to insist on being the most important apple you can hardly be suprised when your treated as the most important bad apple.
"We fought for the public good and would have enfranchised the people and secured the welfare of the whole groaning creation, if the nation had not more delighted in servitude than in freedom"

"My actions are as noble as my thoughts, That never relish’d of a base descent.I came unto your court for honour’s cause, And not to be a rebel to her state; And he that otherwise accounts of me, This sword shall prove he’s honour’s enemy."

"Wählte Ungnade, wo Gehorsam nicht Ehre brachte."
DEFCON 0 - not at war
DEFCON 1 - at war "go to red alert!" "are you absolutely sure sir? it does mean changing the lightbulb."

User avatar
Nidaria
Senator
 
Posts: 3501
Founded: Mar 30, 2012
Ex-Nation

Postby Nidaria » Mon Jun 17, 2013 2:16 pm

The UK in Exile wrote:
Nidaria wrote:1Feudalism was ending on its own under the Tsar. The people were kept under virtual slavery, and lived under a police state.
2Know what the French Revolution is.
3She was, but as the saying goes, "one bad apple can spoil the bunch." Blaming the whole aristocracy for the actions of a few is idiotic.


not really, not when that one is the Tsar. If your going to insist on being the most important apple you can hardly be suprised when your treated as the most important bad apple.

The Tsar was not bad, he was simply weak when a strong leader was needed. He neglected to make political decisions himself and did not try to stand up to the Allies and leave the war. Although he can be criticized for this, it does not justify overthrowing him.
"He who denies the existence of God has some reason for wishing that God did not exist." --St. Augustine
"There is only one difference between genius and stupidity: genius has limits." --Albert Einstein
"When statesmen forsake their own private conscience for the sake of their public duties... they lead their country by a short route to chaos." --St. Thomas More
Anti-gay, Pro-life, Traditionalist, Libertarian, Non-interventionist, Loyal Roman Catholic
Cosmopolitan/Nationalistic 25%
Secular/Fundamentalist 67%
Visionary/Reactionary 21%
Anarchistic/Authoritarian 6%
Communist/Capitalist 41%
Pacifist/Militaristic 7%
Ecological/Anthropocentric 52%

PreviousNext

Advertisement

Remove ads

Return to General

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: Ameriganastan, Balervia, Bienenhalde, Democratic Kingdom of South India, Elejamie, Google [Bot], Greater Britannian Realm, Greater German Confederate, Grinning Dragon, Hexatanople, Israel Emirates, Legio LXI, Nilokeras, Plandistria, Platypus Bureaucracy, Serboslavonia, Slembana, The Tenth Jellian Republic, Too Opressive, Umeria, Valrifell, Valyxias, Washington Resistance Army, Yorsa II

Advertisement

Remove ads