Constructively rate the above nation's flag (8)

[Kiu Ghesik]

unfortunately, the flag waifu doesn't match the color scheme, which drops my rating of an otherwise 10/10 flag down to 8/10. very good flag with very meaningful symbolism, but light blue doesn't match up with purple and gold all that well.

[Novostia]

6.5/10, the wood texture really made it bad, it’s subtle and I don’t like it. The colors are the real problem though, wood brown and yellow don’t match together well

[Aetsveld-Aalstad]

The colors go well together and I love the symbols 7/10

[Guano]

5/10 — Green is a little too dark; blue is a little too light. The multiple blue and white blur the middle stripe and become indistinct. Not terrible, though.

[Daarwyrth]

It's a very nice flag, especially because it's a design I could see waving on a pole in the real world. The colour shades are well chosen and they match well together (more importantly they don't clash) and the star is a very nice touch conveying the overall theme of the nation. I have to admit, it's not super original, but that isn't that big of a deal. It still manages to be memorable. So, a 8.5/10 from me!

[Samonaemia]

It's a very nice flag, especially because it's a design I could see waving on a pole in the real world. The colour shades are well chosen and they match well together (more importantly they don't clash) and the star is a very nice touch conveying the overall theme of the nation. I have to admit, it's not super original, but that isn't that big of a deal. It still manages to be memorable. So, a 8.5/10 from me!

Its a realistic flag, but the shade of yellow makes it slightly dull. The coat of arms mitigates this dullness however.

6.5/10

[Random Country 453632]

Lookin at Samonaemia's flag.

The flag is distinct, has 2 colors, is very simple, yeah. Fits all of whatsitsname's Good Flag, Bad Flag rules.
I don't see any symbolism tho

Overall, 8/10

[Kentauria]

Lookin at Samonaemia's flag.

The flag is distinct, has 2 colors, is very simple, yeah. Fits all of whatsitsname's Good Flag, Bad Flag rules.
I don't see any symbolism tho

Overall, 8/10

Really like the design, as it's unique and memorable. The sun-like symbol also is adequately prominent within the overall layout. The colours fit well together, albeit perhaps the red could be slightly darker. But otherwise, a 8/10 from me!

[Valentine Z]

Very good color palette that contrasts extremely well with each other, and of course, I do like the centaur, it actually is quite a rare sight on the flags of NS.

Overall a 8.5/10 - very nice though I can see it being a bit difficult to see the centaur from a distance if you hoist it on a flagpole.

[Kalunaria]

EDIT: looking at Kentauria

Very cool, cool combination of colors, although I would use a different shade of red or maybe a lighter yellow. Very unique symbol in the center representing well the nation's name but maybe the lines underneath are a little too thin.

Other than that, very nice flag 5/7

[West Celtsridge]

Nice colours, the stripes are a nice addition as well.
The symbol looks good as well, it's the right size and the stars around it are cool.
8/10

[The Xaviet Empire]

simple colour scheme with fitting colours, looks pretty nice,

8.4/10

[Valentine Z]

EDIT: looking at Kentauria

Very cool, cool combination of colors, although I would use a different shade of red or maybe a lighter yellow. Very unique symbol in the center representing well the nation's name but maybe the lines underneath are a little too thin.

Other than that, very nice flag 5/7

It would have been helpful if you helped me out instead of just skipping me and editing that "Oh it's for the nation above you."

simple colour scheme with fitting colours, looks pretty nice,

8.4/10

It looks a little.... Atypical. The colours don't really stand out too well and yes, has that look of being slapped by a flag maker. 6/10.

[The Xaviet Empire]

EDIT: looking at Kentauria

Very cool, cool combination of colors, although I would use a different shade of red or maybe a lighter yellow. Very unique symbol in the center representing well the nation's name but maybe the lines underneath are a little too thin.

Other than that, very nice flag 5/7

It would have been helpful if you helped me out instead of just skipping me and editing that "Oh it's for the nation above you."

simple colour scheme with fitting colours, looks pretty nice,

8.4/10

It looks a little.... Atypical. The colours don't really stand out too well and yes, has that look of being slapped by a flag maker. 6/10.

angr MSpaint noises

/skip

[Japerlasa]

Even though it's probably not a serious flag, there's something I find cool about it. It's so simple and so amazing. Honestly, I don't have any criticism for your flag Val, it's an honor to rate your flag!

10/10.

[Horde of One]

8/10 The colour scheme is original, and the symbol in the center is intrincate without feeling to complex. However, the letters below the center strike me as quite unecessary and distracting, dropping my rate from an otherwise perfect 10/10.

[United Communal Burrow Republics]

4/10... Where to start with this one, hmm. Well first off, there's the obvious one I always hate, which is the combo of black and dark red. Mixing those two is almost never done well, especially if they are touching. It looks dark, it looks fuzzy, it looks messy. They fight with each other too much, if you're gonna use em in close proximity, separate them from each other. Also for lack of a better word, the design is just gross. The little tenticles on the center two lines look really nasty, not to mention they are so complicated that from a distance the fag just looks distorted. The organic looking lines all share that nasty look honestly, so I am not a fan. I keep it at a 4 because I appreciate the effort, and the fact it looks like you took time to genuinely craft it, but. It just does not look that much like a flag, and definitely not that good.

BN: I don't really care if you use my IC flag or OOC flag, ive had enough ratings in these threads to get a basic gist either way XD

[Random Country 453632]

GET THE ANIME OUT OF MY FUCKING HEAD -1/10 PLS NOTE THE HYPHEN AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA

[Cokoland]

GET THE ANIME OUT OF MY FUCKING HEAD -1/10 PLS NOTE THE HYPHEN AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA

The colors are nice, I think they managed to use them pretty well, the model itself is ok I guess, overall it's a nice flag and I don't think it needs to be improved 7/10

[Granadine]

GET THE ANIME OUT OF MY FUCKING HEAD -1/10 PLS NOTE THE HYPHEN AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA

The colors are nice, I think they managed to use them pretty well, the model itself is ok I guess, overall it's a nice flag and I don't think it needs to be improved 7/10

Uh, the flag looks like a meme so I don’t see a rating as a flag that I could give. So I’m gonna give you a 6/10 just rating the meme. Maybe you could remove the meme and only leave the symbol and then it would be a really cool and futuristic flag.

[Imperial Rifta]

The colors don’t blend well at all. I like the design itself though. Maybe if you changed the colors to a better fit. 6/10

[United Communal Burrow Republics]

Honestly I don't remember if I've rated yours before, so imma do it anyways. The star in the center looks way off, either because of colors, proportions, or it actually just being off. The colors don't mix well at all, that light of a dark grey kinda looks weird with red. And the vastly different diameters of borders and lines makes the whole thing look kinda like it was slapped together out of clip art. The design isn't awful tho, so I'd say it deserves a 5/10

[Republic of Burgundy]

Nooooooo why did you ruin your perfect flag by putting an anime girl on it.

OOC Flag: 2/10
IC Flag: 10/10

[Tsaivao]

Nooooooo why did you ruin your perfect flag by putting an anime girl on it.

OOC Flag: 2/10
IC Flag: 10/10

Part of a bet from people in my region cuz it's funny

Of course I would never put anime on my own flag, that'd be gross!

/skipme
/still Burgundy

[Valentine Z]

Nooooooo why did you ruin your perfect flag by putting an anime girl on it.

OOC Flag: 2/10
IC Flag: 10/10

A unique and bold design, I honestly don't have a lot of complaints.

9.6/10.