NationStates

Asherahan wrote:At the very least germany should have been broken up to into smaller states and not allowed to be unified like Austria Hungary.

Duhon wrote:

Asherahan wrote:At the very least germany should have been broken up to into smaller states and not allowed to be unified like Austria Hungary.

Germany got that treatment for almost 50 years.

Asherahan wrote:

Duhon wrote:
Germany got that treatment for almost 50 years.

Way smaller states and they should have lost land. And not allow them to reunify ever.

Duhon wrote:

Asherahan wrote:Way smaller states and they should have lost land. And not allow them to reunify ever.

Way to make a Poland out of Germany, with just as much justification.

Conserative Morality wrote:

The Xenopolis Confederation wrote:I do not see how that's relevant. (Although, personally I don't think anything should be a capital crime, but that's beside the point).

My point is that current law does not dictate justice; current law is simply the primary conduit for justice.

Torrocca wrote:

Jack Thomas Lang wrote:Too much damn work for too little gain.

Took a minute, tops.

See how that post OEP quoted says nothing about shooting and killing Nazis? :3

Totally Not OEP wrote:Tbh after 1968 I have more sympathy for East Germany than West.

The Xenopolis Confederation wrote:

Totally Not OEP wrote:Tbh after 1968 I have more sympathy for East Germany than West.

What happened in 1968?

Totally Not OEP wrote:

The Xenopolis Confederation wrote:What happened in 1968?

The '68 Movement.

The Xenopolis Confederation wrote:

Totally Not OEP wrote:
The '68 Movement.

What was wrong with the 68 movement that wasn't wrong with the GDR?

Totally Not OEP wrote:

The Xenopolis Confederation wrote:What was wrong with the 68 movement that wasn't wrong with the GDR?

Review the societies in question.

The Xenopolis Confederation wrote:

Totally Not OEP wrote:
Review the societies in question.

That's not really an answer.

Totally Not OEP wrote:

The Xenopolis Confederation wrote:That's not really an answer.

It is when you do as I said.

The 1968 Movement encapsulated the transformation of West Germany into a Bohemian society, as a generation of bourgeois youth far too spoiled for their own good came into power. East Germany avoided this and, for all the criticisms I as a Far Rightist could place upon them, remained fairly Nationalistic, militaristic and resistant to the social values the 1968 Revolution represented. When you delve into the writings of the East Bloc, you see they largely did maintain, at least in part, the traditionalist outlook of Slavic society with regards to social matters.

The Xenopolis Confederation wrote:

Totally Not OEP wrote:
It is when you do as I said.

The 1968 Movement encapsulated the transformation of West Germany into a Bohemian society, as a generation of bourgeois youth far too spoiled for their own good came into power. East Germany avoided this and, for all the criticisms I as a Far Rightist could place upon them, remained fairly Nationalistic, militaristic and resistant to the social values the 1968 Revolution represented. When you delve into the writings of the East Bloc, you see they largely did maintain, at least in part, the traditionalist outlook of Slavic society with regards to social matters.

I view militarism and a traditionalist slavic outlook as negatives rather than positives to be honest.

Totally Not OEP wrote:

The Xenopolis Confederation wrote:I view militarism and a traditionalist slavic outlook as negatives rather than positives to be honest.

Of course, but you did ask for my view of it right?

Totally Not OEP wrote:

The Xenopolis Confederation wrote:That's not really an answer.

It is when you do as I said.

The 1968 Movement encapsulated the transformation of West Germany into a Bohemian society, as a generation of bourgeois youth far too spoiled for their own good came into power. East Germany avoided this and, for all the criticisms I as a Far Rightist could place upon them, remained fairly Nationalistic, militaristic and resistant to the social values the 1968 Revolution represented. When you delve into the writings of the East Bloc, you see they largely did maintain, at least in part, the traditionalist outlook of Slavic society with regards to social matters.

Painisia wrote:

Totally Not OEP wrote:
It is when you do as I said.

The 1968 Movement encapsulated the transformation of West Germany into a Bohemian society, as a generation of bourgeois youth far too spoiled for their own good came into power. East Germany avoided this and, for all the criticisms I as a Far Rightist could place upon them, remained fairly Nationalistic, militaristic and resistant to the social values the 1968 Revolution represented. When you delve into the writings of the East Bloc, you see they largely did maintain, at least in part, the traditionalist outlook of Slavic society with regards to social matters.

Well, your waifu GDR became Germany`s poor fever region after the reunification in 1990. But you would find it satisfying that it is in the former lands of the GDR that the Far-Right is experiencing a surge. Alternative für Deutschland is experiencing growth there

Asherahan wrote:

Jack Thomas Lang wrote:Didn't West Germany go easy on former Nazi party members and administrators? If so, seems to have worked out fine.

Turns out Commie propaganda is just that, propaganda. Germany didn't have to initiate Stalinist repression to shut down Nazism.

*AfD exists and Right Wing Germans are still a bunch of pricks trampling over the sovereignty of other countries*

Sure it worked fine.

Asherahan wrote:

Jack Thomas Lang wrote:Didn't West Germany go easy on former Nazi party members and administrators? If so, seems to have worked out fine.

Turns out Commie propaganda is just that, propaganda. Germany didn't have to initiate Stalinist repression to shut down Nazism.

*AfD exists and Right Wing Germans are still a bunch of pricks trampling over the sovereignty of other countries*

Sure it worked fine.

North German Realm wrote:

Asherahan wrote:*AfD exists and Right Wing Germans are still a bunch of pricks trampling over the sovereignty of other countries*

Sure it worked fine.

I mean, if you take a look at the map, the AfD got most of its votes from the East, on both chambers too. One could almost say West Germany did better in expunging right-wing radicalism in its legislative form than the Easterners.

Asherahan wrote:

Duhon wrote:
Way to make a Poland out of Germany, with just as much justification.

There was less justification when we did it to austria hungary. And let me remind you they didn't murder millions.

Novus America wrote:

Asherahan wrote:*AfD exists and Right Wing Germans are still a bunch of pricks trampling over the sovereignty of other countries*

Sure it worked fine.

AFD is has some neo-Nazi members and supporters, but is not a Nazi party. Plus very few of its members were actually involved in the Nazi regime, as most people who were are dead by now.

And their stronghold is EAST Germany...

Asherahan wrote:

The Xenopolis Confederation wrote:The AfD is pretty small and not explicitly Nazi afaik. And what do you mean when you say "right-wing Germans?"

Truth be told I got a bias against right wing germans because I am a greek.

The Xenopolis Confederation wrote:

Asherahan wrote:Truth be told I got a bias against right wing germans because I am a greek.

Arguing that the EU would be less hawkish if Nazi party members were repressed harshly is a big stretch.