Dylann Roof sentenced to death

[Southerly Gentleman]

The Dallas shooter was a member of the BLM movement.

Its not really an organized movement.

Exactly, which is why I can say the Dallas shooter was part of it, based on his beliefs.

[Grenartia]

Someone like him, if he is to be executed, should ideally be drawn and quartered.

What about tar and feathered?

Dammit, you beat me to it.

[Greed and Death]

Its not really an organized movement.

Exactly, which is why I can say the Dallas shooter was part of it, based on his beliefs.

You said member which suggestion organization, membership cards, dues, and the like.

[Greed and Death]

Someone like him, if he is to be executed, should ideally be drawn and quartered.

Why not tarred and feathered?

Why not both ?

[Internationalist Bastard]

Its not really an organized movement.

Exactly, which is why I can say the Dallas shooter was part of it, based on his beliefs.

Yeah, but that doesn't mean BLM had literally any role in it.

[South East Europe]

I really don't understand the hypocrites who are against the death penalty but fully support abortion.

[Grenartia]

Give it a few decades. He'll be bawling his eyes out, wishing he had a time machine so he could stop himself.

We can do both, have him wait decades then execute him.
1-2 decades bawls his eyes out wishes to take it back
Only after 3-4 decades which he comes to terms with what he has done that we kill him.

That way the execution is merciful.

No execution. Why should we waste the money on him?

[Novus America]

Before. AND after. The standard should apply for the the death penalty to be given before it is first handed down. Then it would be subject to review de novo on appeal.

Sounds good to me. But how many appeals should they get?

A good question. At least once. The district court tries orginally and then you appeal to the circuit court/appeals court for federal. Plus you have the ability to appeal to the Supreme Court but they do not have to hear every appeal. Possibly create some sort of independent review court just for the death penalty between the circuit and supreme courts.

I think it should be available as a tool otherwise what do you do with people in prison for life who still commit crimes in prison? But it should be when there is no doubt and they cannot be safely kept as a prisoner. Not used often.

Dylan Roof meets the first test. He does not even contest his guilt, he just argued the death penalty is unconstitutional.

Does he met the cannot be safely imprisoned test though?

[Farnhamia]

Or go to classic techniques - hanging, firing squad, the good ole' French guillotine...

Dropped from a helicopter is another choice

I disagree with the Death Penalty, i think he should get a life sentence instead. This is not based on the race of the offender, just my belief on the death penalty.

That being said, his crime was both aggravated and horrific. He certainly deserved the conviction he got, though not the final judgment of death.

He's not better than a member of ISIS as far as i'm concerned.

I'm a strong supporter of the death penalty, I think we should definitely cut down the amount of time you are allowed to spend on death row before you are executed. And I'm perfectly fine with making them suffer.

Someone like him, if he is to be executed, should ideally be drawn and quartered.

What about tar and feathered?

Someone like him, if he is to be executed, should ideally be drawn and quartered.

Why not tarred and feathered?

Or go to classic techniques - hanging, firing squad, the good ole' French guillotine...

Someone like him, if he is to be executed, should ideally be drawn and quartered.

Life sentence him instead. A ruined and wasted life is worse than a short one.

Maybe torture him for the next 6 decades.

Why not tarred and feathered?

Why not both ?

Engleberg, Grenartia, The Princes of the Universe: *** Warned for trolling (gloating over the manner of an execution). ***

Thermodolia: *** 1 day ban for trolling (gloating over the manner of an execution). ***

greed and death: *** 7 day ban for trolling (gloating over the manner of an execution). ***

Debate the usefulness of the death penalty, fine, but no more gleeful suggestions about the method of Roof's execution.

[Ethel mermania]

He deserves it, hopefully sooner rather than later.

It'll be later. Automatic appeal.

indeed,

[Prybourne]

http://www.cnn.com/2017/01/10/us/dylann-roof-trial/index.html

Dylann roof has today been sentenced to death for his activities towards blacks. I personally believe his death penalty should be immediately reversed. the Jury should be ashamed of themselves. The death penalty is not appropriate.

Regardless, he has purportedly admitted some sort of guilt for this accused activity, and so the Jury subsequently found him guilty and sentenced him to death today.

Do you think Dylann Roof should have his sentence pardoned? How do you think this bodes for White-Black relations? How do you feel about his purported activities and subsequent retaliation?

Can you give further speculation onto why you deem the punishment inappropriate?

[Ethel mermania]

Dropped from a helicopter is another choice

I'm a strong supporter of the death penalty, I think we should definitely cut down the amount of time you are allowed to spend on death row before you are executed. And I'm perfectly fine with making them suffer.

What about tar and feathered?

Why not tarred and feathered?

Someone like him, if he is to be executed, should ideally be drawn and quartered.

Maybe torture him for the next 6 decades.

Why not both ?

Engleberg, Grenartia, The Princes of the Universe: *** Warned for trolling (gloating over the manner of an execution). ***

Thermodolia: *** 1 day ban for trolling (gloating over the manner of an execution). ***

greed and death: *** 7 day ban for trolling (gloating over the manner of an execution). ***

Debate the usefulness of the death penalty, fine, but no more gleeful suggestions about the method of Roof's execution.

tbf tarring and feathering is not intended to be fatal.

[Farnhamia]

Engleberg, Grenartia, The Princes of the Universe: *** Warned for trolling (gloating over the manner of an execution). ***

Thermodolia: *** 1 day ban for trolling (gloating over the manner of an execution). ***

greed and death: *** 7 day ban for trolling (gloating over the manner of an execution). ***

Debate the usefulness of the death penalty, fine, but no more gleeful suggestions about the method of Roof's execution.

tbf tarring and feathering is not intended to be fatal.

TBF, I don't care. It contributed to the trolling and I won't have it.

[Fartsniffage]

tbf tarring and feathering is not intended to be fatal.

TBF, I don't care. It contributed to the trolling and I won't have it.

I'm amused that you didn't see that as sarcasm.

[Ethel mermania]

tbf tarring and feathering is not intended to be fatal.

TBF, I don't care. It contributed to the trolling and I won't have it.

now that is fair enough. (not that my definition of fair enough counts for a lot).

[Ethel mermania]

TBF, I don't care. It contributed to the trolling and I won't have it.

I'm amused that you didn't see that as sarcasm.

i think she did, but i think the argument that even so, it contributed to the trolling is reasonable.

[Ethel mermania]

Between dismissing his lawyers, refusing the insanity defense, and saying that he has no remorse, it's clear that this is what he wanted.

i dont think he is smart enough to use it to make "incompetent defense" as part of the appeal process.

A question, as the appeal is automatic, does he still get to represent himself?

[Farnhamia]

OP being edgy again? Why, does he want to switch places with Roof?

Anyway, killing him is a start, but ultimately it's not enough. Dylann Roof, sentenced to a quick and painful death, a mercy he dare not give to those he killed?

Fuck that. He should be killed in the slowest and most painful way possible, then for his body to be dragged from one end of Florida to the other.

*** Warned for trolling. ***

[Arlenton]

Good. Justice is served.

[The Shining Purple Light]

Was he found guilty on charges against the State of South Carolina or the Federal Government?
I assume South Carolina but idk.

[Republic of Tacos]

I heard this, and I went.

"He did? I kind of saw it coming."

[Farnhamia]

Was he found guilty on charges against the State of South Carolina or the Federal Government?
I assume South Carolina but idk.

This is the verdict and sentencing on his Federal charges. He hasn't stood trial on the South Carolina murder charges.

[Blakk Metal]

Between dismissing his lawyers, refusing the insanity defense, and saying that he has no remorse, it's clear that this is what he wanted.

i dont think he is smart enough to use it to make "incompetent defense" as part of the appeal process.

You can't do that if you represent yourself.

[Blakk Metal]

Was he found guilty on charges against the State of South Carolina or the Federal Government?
I assume South Carolina but idk.

This is the verdict and sentencing on his Federal charges. He hasn't stood trial on the South Carolina murder charges.

South Carolina should get on that then. The feds can't execute shit.

[Farnhamia]

This is the verdict and sentencing on his Federal charges. He hasn't stood trial on the South Carolina murder charges.

South Carolina should get on that then. The feds can't execute shit.

It was supposed to start next week but it's been delayed again.