New site!

[Thenium]

at the moment I have Authoritarianism what stats would change from it?

Concentrated executive power with little tolerance for dissent.

Beh it would have even less civil rights, even less political freedom, few economic freedom anyway and little governement.
Probably also traditionalist.

I don't want to look rude so please take this discussion as in fact a discussion, I think these things are alr covered by authoritarianism

[Lipizia]

Beh it would have even less civil rights, even less political freedom, few economic freedom anyway and little governement.
Probably also traditionalist.

I don't want to look rude so please take this discussion as in fact a discussion, I think these things are alr covered by authoritarianism

Ok ok but you should create authoritarian communism so. Because only "Communism" in a total dictatorship is not correct, at least for me.

[Thenium]

I have a question regarding to the website. Why is State Atheism classified as an "ideology"? Auth-left to be exact?
And in the world census explorer, why is law enforcement not in the safety and security category?

It references to past "communist" nations who imposed atheism, im changing the place of law enforcment rn thanks for the feedback

[Thenium]

I don't want to look rude so please take this discussion as in fact a discussion, I think these things are alr covered by authoritarianism

Ok ok but you should create authoritarian communism so. Because only "Communism" in a total dictatorship is not correct, at least for me.

Yup indeed, Puff Mains also noted this, I'm gonna wait for her/his/their response on the matter since it looked like he/she/they knew better than me, I'd also like to note my site is politically neutral, if you think that one ideology has a too "straw-manned" description suggest another one and I'll probably change it.

[Kuromistan]

Ok ok but you should create authoritarian communism so. Because only "Communism" in a total dictatorship is not correct, at least for me.

Yup indeed, Puff Mains also noted this, I'm gonna wait for her/his/their response on the matter since it looked like he/she/they knew better than me, I'd also like to note my site is politically neutral, if you think that one ideology has a too "straw-manned" description suggest another one and I'll probably change it.

You might need to have a team of people to consult with regarding proper (and perhaps more) nation classifications, but PLEASE DON'T SCRAP IT!!!

[Lipizia]

Ok ok but you should create authoritarian communism so. Because only "Communism" in a total dictatorship is not correct, at least for me.

I'd also like to note my site is politically neutral.

Who said it wasn't?

[Thenium]

Yup indeed, Puff Mains also noted this, I'm gonna wait for her/his/their response on the matter since it looked like he/she/they knew better than me, I'd also like to note my site is politically neutral, if you think that one ideology has a too "straw-manned" description suggest another one and I'll probably change it.

You might need to have a team of people to consult with regarding proper (and perhaps more) nation classifications, but PLEASE DON'T SCRAP IT!!!

hehe don't worry I won't scrap it I just need some help with the descriptions and some suggestion on what data to take into account, im also updating the how the data is calculated to be more clear in what data I'm using at the moment, I just pushed it tell me if it is more clear now

[Thenium]

I'd also like to note my site is politically neutral.

Who said it wasn't?

No one it's just that I may have involuntarily made it not-so-neutral so I'd like if someone told me where things are too "straw-manned"

[The Republic of the United Marble Tribes]

cool website

https://nationstates-dossier-explorer.vercel.app/

My ideology is religious socialism. (HOW?)

Also, my people are called Marblelanians, you may want to correct on that. Thank you!

[Kuromistan]

cool website

https://nationstates-dossier-explorer.vercel.app/

My ideology is religious socialism. (HOW?)

Also, my people are called Marblelanians, you may want to correct on that. Thank you!

Yeah, the demonym field seems to not get fetched

[Thenium]

cool website

https://nationstates-dossier-explorer.vercel.app/

My ideology is religious socialism. (HOW?)

Also, my people are called Marblelanians, you may want to correct on that. Thank you!

Yeah, the demonym field seems to not get fetched

Thanks I will look into this asap
The Republic of the United Marble Tribes yup indeed I'm looking into this now

[New Lanous]

I didn't expect to be Conservative Right, oh well.

[Lipizia]

Who said it wasn't?

No one it's just that I may have involuntarily made it not-so-neutral so I'd like if someone told me where things are too "straw-manned"

Eh oh bruh It happens to everyone.
But di you ready this?

Anarcho-Primitism

Guys this would be the third time I try to fix Anarcho-Primitism, Puff Mains suggested taking into account the ban on cars and airplanes, while this suggetion would pretty much fix the entire issue it looks like NS doesn't store this information so A-P would never appear in the ideological history of your nation, I'm open to some suggestions on what stats to consider for A-P, and what expected traditionalism for it would you suggest? Rn it is at 44/100 — Mixed which I think could even be lowered but umh I'm gonna wait for you to tell me what to change reguarding this ideology.

For me personally, anarcho-primitism is ok how it's now. Maybe in effect it should be only for nation with at least... 20? (In the Big Number Scale)

[CAEDALPE]

Excellent!

[Valentine Z]

I have tried it out as well. It is VERY cool, I love it! Not just the data itself, but the visuals / GUI is very eye-pleasing too. ♥

[Fhaengshia]

I know my nation is weird, and even NS doesn't get anarchies quite right, but I was surprised to find my nation described as having an Anarcho-Capitalism ideology.
I am aiming for pure 100/100 scores in each of the freedoms (Civil rights, Political freedom, Economic freedom) which is the extreme point of anarchies on NS, but my nation has extremely robust civil services and a whopping 92.5% tax rate. Quite the opposite of the stateless capitalism of ancap.

Is it possible to take taxation, government size, or something else into account or is my setup just too niche?

[Meraud]

"and a whopping 92.5% tax rate. Quite the opposite of the stateless capitalism of ancap."

I have a functional military, police, courts and have managed to reduce my taxation to 0% by relying on non-theft sources of income.

[Enimero]

Oooooooh!!! This site is very nice
I did get Social Liberalism! Though I'd much prefer a more progressive type than just 'liberalism'.

[Kuromistan]

Oooooooh!!! This site is very nice
I did get Social Liberalism! Though I'd much prefer a more progressive type than just 'liberalism'.

I find it interesting that we could have different classifications here and the same classification there, and some nations could have the same classification here and different classifications there

[Grenartia]

Anarcho-Primitism

Guys this would be the third time I try to fix Anarcho-Primitism, Puff Mains suggested taking into account the ban on cars and airplanes, while this suggetion would pretty much fix the entire issue it looks like NS doesn't store this information so A-P would never appear in the ideological history of your nation, I'm open to some suggestions on what stats to consider for A-P, and what expected traditionalism for it would you suggest? Rn it is at 44/100 — Mixed which I think could even be lowered but umh I'm gonna wait for you to tell me what to change reguarding this ideology.

I'd suggest just taking into account the following stats:

Scientific Advancement, Primitiveness, Ignorance, Intelligence, and Human Development Index. Obviously, Scienctific Advancement, Intelligence, and Human Development Index should have an inverse effect on the A-P score while Primitiveness and Ignorance should have a positive effect on it.

[Kombinita Socialisma Demokratio]

Nope, it is vibe coded. I thought the typo indicated otherwise. Stay away.

Edit count is mostly because of repeatedly listing bugs.

[Thenium]

I know my nation is weird, and even NS doesn't get anarchies quite right, but I was surprised to find my nation described as having an Anarcho-Capitalism ideology.
I am aiming for pure 100/100 scores in each of the freedoms (Civil rights, Political freedom, Economic freedom) which is the extreme point of anarchies on NS, but my nation has extremely robust civil services and a whopping 92.5% tax rate. Quite the opposite of the stateless capitalism of ancap.

Is it possible to take taxation, government size, or something else into account or is my setup just too niche?

I'm pushing a BIG update on the compass yo may want to check it again in a few hours

[King Sam of House of Buca]

I know my nation is weird, and even NS doesn't get anarchies quite right, but I was surprised to find my nation described as having an Anarcho-Capitalism ideology.
I am aiming for pure 100/100 scores in each of the freedoms (Civil rights, Political freedom, Economic freedom) which is the extreme point of anarchies on NS, but my nation has extremely robust civil services and a whopping 92.5% tax rate. Quite the opposite of the stateless capitalism of ancap.

Is it possible to take taxation, government size, or something else into account or is my setup just too niche?

I'm pushing a BIG update on the compass yo may want to check it again in a few hours

well done

[Thenium]

BIG UPDATE TO THE COMPASS
It almost certainly still needs some adjustments,

Now there are 60 ideologies not 63

Guild Socialism merged into Market Socialism

Techno-Utopianism merged into Ecomodernism

Radical Centrism was remove

(These ideologies were too niche)

Maoism is now defined by agrarian economy + mobilised, politicised society + extreme radicality.

Trotskyism is defined as far-left economics under libertarian conditions with maximal radicality.

Monarchy labels are now directly anchored to the game's official category. (Absolute monarchism, unfortunately NS doesn't store past categories)

New Statistics Used by the Classifier
It now fetchs 28 census scales per classification (up from 21).Previous scales retained: Civil Rights, Economy, Political Freedom, Social Conservatism, Government Size, Welfare, Public Healthcare, Religiousness, Income Equality, Ideological Radicality, Defence Forces, Pacifism, Economic Freedom, Authoritarianism, Weaponization, Secularism, Primitiveness, Scientific Advancement, Public Education, Patriotism, and Economic Output.
Eight new scales added:

Agriculture : Grounds Maoism's peasant-centred focus.
Intelligence : Acts as a hard gate for Technocracy.
Political Apathy : Provides mobilisation evidence for Maoism, Jacobinism, Trotskyism, Luxemburgism, and both Populisms.
Taxation : Grounds Fiscal Conservatism (low-tax requirement).
Youth Rebelliousness : Evidence of a revolutionary generation (Jacobinism, Trotskyism).
Average Income : Powers the Degrowth per-capita check.
Compliance & Safety : Fetched for law-and-order corroboration.

Two New Evidence Channels

Government budget shares (GOVT shard): Spirituality gates Theocracy/Clerical Fascism (requiring actual state funding for religion); Defence grounds Neoconservatism; Environment supports the green family; Welfare/Healthcare anchor Social Democracy; Administration supports Technocracy and State Capitalism; Commerce grounds Plutocracy.

Game category: Serves as the sole authority on the head of state. Constitutional and Absolute Monarchism now strictly require their matching game category, catching details census numbers miss.

What "— (Definitional label only)" Means

In "how the data is calculated", the Census requirement column highlights mandatory traits an ideology demands (for example, Anarcho-Pacifism must actually have pacifism).

Most ideologies do not have these hard requirements since I couldn't think of what NS stat to use; their labels are defined purely by their compass position and expected traditionalism or radicality.

To make this clear, the column now reads — (definitional label only).

Hard gates: Only 12 ideologies carry strict census requirements.

Definitional labels: The other 48 simply define a region of the map (the compass), with softer supporting evidence found in the neighbouring "Preferred profile" column.

Big thanks to Puff Mains, most of this update is inspired to the things he/she/they noted (what pronouns do you go by Puff?), mainly how there aren't ways of making sure the ideological description actually reflects a nation, from now it is specified if there is no way we can calculate via NS if that description fits your nation. (look in how the data is calculated)

The example nations are almost all wrong for a bit it should fix itself with time.
I still haven't fixed the denonym bug have patience please <3

[Thenium]

BIG UPDATE TO THE COMPASS
It almost certainly still needs some adjustments,

Now there are 60 ideologies not 63

Guild Socialism merged into Market Socialism

Techno-Utopianism merged into Ecomodernism

Radical Centrism was remove

(These ideologies were too niche)

Maoism is now defined by agrarian economy + mobilised, politicised society + extreme radicality.

Trotskyism is defined as far-left economics under libertarian conditions with maximal radicality.

Monarchy labels are now directly anchored to the game's official category. (Absolute monarchism, unfortunately NS doesn't store past categories)

New Statistics Used by the Classifier
It now fetchs 28 census scales per classification (up from 21).Previous scales retained: Civil Rights, Economy, Political Freedom, Social Conservatism, Government Size, Welfare, Public Healthcare, Religiousness, Income Equality, Ideological Radicality, Defence Forces, Pacifism, Economic Freedom, Authoritarianism, Weaponization, Secularism, Primitiveness, Scientific Advancement, Public Education, Patriotism, and Economic Output.
Eight new scales added:

Agriculture : Grounds Maoism's peasant-centred focus.
Intelligence : Acts as a hard gate for Technocracy.
Political Apathy : Provides mobilisation evidence for Maoism, Jacobinism, Trotskyism, Luxemburgism, and both Populisms.
Taxation : Grounds Fiscal Conservatism (low-tax requirement).
Youth Rebelliousness : Evidence of a revolutionary generation (Jacobinism, Trotskyism).
Average Income : Powers the Degrowth per-capita check.
Compliance & Safety : Fetched for law-and-order corroboration.

Two New Evidence Channels

Government budget shares (GOVT shard): Spirituality gates Theocracy/Clerical Fascism (requiring actual state funding for religion); Defence grounds Neoconservatism; Environment supports the green family; Welfare/Healthcare anchor Social Democracy; Administration supports Technocracy and State Capitalism; Commerce grounds Plutocracy.

Game category: Serves as the sole authority on the head of state. Constitutional and Absolute Monarchism now strictly require their matching game category, catching details census numbers miss.

What "— (Definitional label only)" Means

In "how the data is calculated", the Census requirement column highlights mandatory traits an ideology demands (for example, Anarcho-Pacifism must actually have pacifism).

Most ideologies do not have these hard requirements since I couldn't think of what NS stat to use; their labels are defined purely by their compass position and expected traditionalism or radicality.

To make this clear, the column now reads — (definitional label only).

Hard gates: Only 12 ideologies carry strict census requirements.

Definitional labels: The other 48 simply define a region of the map (the compass), with softer supporting evidence found in the neighbouring "Preferred profile" column.

Big thanks to Puff Mains, most of this update is inspired to the things he/she/they noted (what pronouns do you go by Puff?), mainly how there aren't ways of making sure the ideological description actually reflects a nation, from now it is specified if there is no way we can calculate via NS if that description fits your nation. (look in how the data is calculated)

The example nations are almost all wrong for a bit it should fix itself with time.
I still haven't fixed the denonym bug have patience please <3

The world being slighty right wing could be a bug, I will look into it in a few days