Constructively rate the above nation's flag (8)

[Centriana]

I like the design and layout of the flag, easy on the eyes and neutral, I dont like the colours however, a bit too overlapping. 7.5 out of 10.

[Lothria]

I actually really like this. It's nice and simple, and the symbol with the tridents is really cool - complex enough to be interesting, but not so complex as to be hard to draw. Blue isn't my favourite colour, but that's really my only criticism. It's a really nice flag. 9/10

[Centriana]

I actually really like this. It's nice and simple, and the symbol with the tridents is really cool - complex enough to be interesting, but not so complex as to be hard to draw. Blue isn't my favourite colour, but that's really my only criticism. It's a really nice flag. 9/10

Thanks, the Three Tridents reference or countries Politics, Culture and Defence, they intersect to represent the people, the blue colour represents our pride in our sea-going culture and navy. (Notice how the political and defence tridents are lower than our cultural trident and are 'peripheral' tridents.

[Ineva]

Going to assume there should've been a /skipme in the above response, so /stillLothria.

[The Children of Mercy]

8/10 I like it a lot, but the bird looks a little goofy and out of place.

[Skavenholm]

6/10, Good layering and coloring; the bars could be a bit larger to make them more visible from a distance.

[ImSaLiA]

It's... beautiful!
0/0

[BLACKGRUE]

Not very vexological, too many uses of gradients/photoelements and it has words and cartoons on it.

1/10

[Lothria]

I'm not sure I like the skull. On the one hand, it is a cool design in concept and represents a steampunk-ish nation quite well. But, at least in my eyes, I don't think the art style of the skull fits with the wrenches. I also think the flag could do without the wrench and hammer. One symbol is usually enough, especially when one, like the skull, is already pretty complex. I'm also not a huge fan of how wide it is, but all that said it's definitely not a bad flag. Can't go wrong with a black and red colour scheme. 7/10, maybe a 6.5 but probably not.

[Skilles]

I am a big fan of yellow/black combinations, I don't like the bird as an idea, but it has strong cultural ties to your nation so I can dig it, the little box features help the piece evolve as you get closer without becoming muddled at distance. I've sat here for a little bit trying to think of an improvement and I really can't so i must conclude this is 10/10 flag

[Russila]

I am a big fan of yellow/black combinations, I don't like the bird as an idea, but it has strong cultural ties to your nation so I can dig it, the little box features help the piece evolve as you get closer without becoming muddled at distance. I've sat here for a little bit trying to think of an improvement and I really can't so i must conclude this is 10/10 flag

10/10 I really love the design of your flag

[Reactorland]

I am a big fan of yellow/black combinations, I don't like the bird as an idea, but it has strong cultural ties to your nation so I can dig it, the little box features help the piece evolve as you get closer without becoming muddled at distance. I've sat here for a little bit trying to think of an improvement and I really can't so i must conclude this is 10/10 flag

10/10 I really love the design of your flag

Almost perfect flag. 9/10. Probably just remove the black part of the flag.

[Russila]

10/10 I really love the design of your flag

Almost perfect flag. 9/10. Probably just remove the black part of the flag.

/Skip me

The black part of the flag is supposed to represent the night sky surrounding the Bethlehem star which is why it's there and it would be hard to see the actual star if I removed it but thanks for the criticism.

[Rhanukhan]

Ooh - there's some garish colours, though that does make it pop as it scrolls by on the thread. The red and orange are a little too similar to each other and might be well-served by giving the triangle a white trim. I'm not sure what the charge is - it looks like a paintbrush - but the drab browns clash with the bold cyan and red of the cog. The star could probably be a little larger and higher also. Overall - 6/10

[New Eestiball]

the only flag that works with purple & orange
nevertheless the colors don't go great together and the octopus symbol is a bit overcomplex
8/10

[Zancostan]

the only flag that works with purple & orange
nevertheless the colors don't go great together and the octopus symbol is a bit overcomplex
8/10

The Ying Yang motif works. I'm curious as to what the blue represents.

8/10

[BLACKGRUE]

Overall, it's complex but not bad. Ruined somewhat by the flutter filter. 6/10

[Varsemia]

8/10 I like how you used cogs, gears and spanners to make a skull and crossbones plus the colour scheme is pretty cool.

[La Montilla]

9/10 The colors compliment each other really well, I also really like the sun symbol

[Bozarkia 2]

I like it a lot! However, it is kinda basic. I like how you incorporated the stars! 7.5 (Or possibly even / 10

[New Eestiball]

the only flag that works with purple & orange
nevertheless the colors don't go great together and the octopus symbol is a bit overcomplex
8/10

The Ying Yang motif works. I'm curious as to what the blue represents.

8/10

this was originally an estonia-themed nation ergo blue black white
AN: 7/10
why ripple, and symbol a bit overcomplex but makes sense given canon
other than that good

[Nu Elysium]

very neat and memorable 9/10

[Pelzer]

i respect it. simple and basic. nothing complicated. simple flag. i feel like it's a 9/10.

[Taiqar]

8/10 color scheme is great, but the bird in the middle is way too detailed.

[Fragrancia]

Dare I ask, is that a Qing Dragon in on the style of Nauru, but the orange-white stripes are replaced by the five races' flag; and the pacific star is replaced by a KMT Sun?

Ignoring that, 4/10 since it's a bit busy

[For AN: This is my temporary neon war flag]