Illegal SC proposals - post them here

[Bhang Bhang Duc]

SECURITY COUNCIL PROPOSAL
ID: the_dankest_and_zestiest_memes_1461085512

Liberate Confederation of Autonomous States

A resolution to strike down Delegate-imposed barriers to free entry in a region.


Category: Liberation

Nominee (region): Confederation of Autonomous States

Proposed by: The Dankest and Zestiest Memes

Description: The Confederation of Autonomous States is run by the fascist dictator Ficklovia he needs to be stopped! Any word spoken against him leads to an ejection and ban. The leaders made an intricate plot to become the permanent leaders. They might call our region a democracy but do not be misled it is clearly a dictatorship. Please my fellow WA members I ask you to help the people of The CAS for we are being led to our downfall. Just take a look at The CAS's constitution please fellow members I beg of you! We need help and only you can save us.

R3 and some R4b.

[Kaboomlandia]

SECURITY COUNCIL PROPOSAL
ID: blabaria_1461105521

Condemn Lenyo

A resolution to express shock and dismay at a nation or region.


Category: Condemnation

Nominee: Lenyo

Proposed by: Blabaria

Description: Here we have The Socialist Republic of
Lenyo, a nation infamous for editing and approving some of NationStates worst Dilemmas and issues.

Known for it's extremely far-left biased issues that tend to be based off REAL controversial events and, rather than making it absurd and Ridiculous, Lenyo makes the issues into Pretentious agenda-pushing disasters.

these issues tend to villainize Democratic and Right wing views and be in favor for Communist and extreme libertarian views, The likes seen flooding colleges, online blog and social media sites, and other places.

The most infamous of which is the so called "bigtopian Lives Matter"
To Quote:

I just got an issue called "Bigtopian Lives Matter." The issue is obviously based on the recent killing of Michael Brown in Ferguson, USA. The issue states that an eighteen year old Bigtopian "boy" is killed by one of your police officers "despite video footage showing him with his hands up," which thus leads to racial division in your country. From what I understand of the real life case, however, Brown was high on drugs at the time and attacked the police officer, which is why the officer shot and killed him. This issue thus portrays an extremely biased take on what happened in real life. Furthermore, the three options you have to choose from are basically to either "do the right thing" by punishing the officer and regulating the police more, justify whatever police do on the job, or attack the protesters akin to the attacks on civil rights protesters in 1960s America.

From what I've garnered about NS, issues are supposed to be zany and lead to unexpected results, but they're not supposed to support anyone's political agenda, i.e. make communism look great as opposed to capitalism, or vice versa; if anything, most issues make everyone in the situation look bad, which I guess is sort of fair. This issue seems unfair, though, as it seems to support the Black Lives Matter movement's version of an event, while not considering the data and facts that oppose their claims.

I think that the issue should be edited so that it is unclear if the "boy" was innocent, or acted violently against the police officer, which would make the the issue more realistic and complicated as opposed to "this side obviously good, this side obviously bad." Also I think that the second response should be something like arming your cops with head cameras as a sort of compromise between giving in to protester demands and flat out attacking them. What do you think, NSG? Is the issue fair? Should it be changed the way I pointed out, another way, or not at all?

P.S. I apologize if I didn't post this in the right forum; this is my first forum post since I started NS.

this level of bias should not be permitted on NationStates' issues and I hereby request the THE CONDEMNATION OF LENYO

Approvals: 3 (Vancouvia, Ancient Free and Accepted Masons, CGI)

Status: Lacking Support (requires 119 more approvals)

Voting Ends: in 3 days 1 hour

R1, R2c, R3, and all four clauses of R4. I don't think I've ever seen an SC proposal as illegal as this.

[John Turner]

SECURITY COUNCIL PROPOSAL
ID: blabaria_1461105521

Condemn Lenyo

A resolution to express shock and dismay at a nation or region.


Category: Condemnation

Nominee: Lenyo

Proposed by: Blabaria

Description: Here we have The Socialist Republic of
Lenyo, a nation infamous for editing and approving some of NationStates worst Dilemmas and issues.

Known for it's extremely far-left biased issues that tend to be based off REAL controversial events and, rather than making it absurd and Ridiculous, Lenyo makes the issues into Pretentious agenda-pushing disasters.

these issues tend to villainize Democratic and Right wing views and be in favor for Communist and extreme libertarian views, The likes seen flooding colleges, online blog and social media sites, and other places.

The most infamous of which is the so called "bigtopian Lives Matter"
To Quote:

I just got an issue called "Bigtopian Lives Matter." The issue is obviously based on the recent killing of Michael Brown in Ferguson, USA. The issue states that an eighteen year old Bigtopian "boy" is killed by one of your police officers "despite video footage showing him with his hands up," which thus leads to racial division in your country. From what I understand of the real life case, however, Brown was high on drugs at the time and attacked the police officer, which is why the officer shot and killed him. This issue thus portrays an extremely biased take on what happened in real life. Furthermore, the three options you have to choose from are basically to either "do the right thing" by punishing the officer and regulating the police more, justify whatever police do on the job, or attack the protesters akin to the attacks on civil rights protesters in 1960s America.

From what I've garnered about NS, issues are supposed to be zany and lead to unexpected results, but they're not supposed to support anyone's political agenda, i.e. make communism look great as opposed to capitalism, or vice versa; if anything, most issues make everyone in the situation look bad, which I guess is sort of fair. This issue seems unfair, though, as it seems to support the Black Lives Matter movement's version of an event, while not considering the data and facts that oppose their claims.

I think that the issue should be edited so that it is unclear if the "boy" was innocent, or acted violently against the police officer, which would make the the issue more realistic and complicated as opposed to "this side obviously good, this side obviously bad." Also I think that the second response should be something like arming your cops with head cameras as a sort of compromise between giving in to protester demands and flat out attacking them. What do you think, NSG? Is the issue fair? Should it be changed the way I pointed out, another way, or not at all?

P.S. I apologize if I didn't post this in the right forum; this is my first forum post since I started NS.

this level of bias should not be permitted on NationStates' issues and I hereby request the THE CONDEMNATION OF LENYO

Approvals: 3 (Vancouvia, Ancient Free and Accepted Masons, CGI)

Status: Lacking Support (requires 119 more approvals)

Voting Ends: in 3 days 1 hour

R1, R2c, R3, and all four clauses of R4. I don't think I've ever seen an SC proposal as illegal as this.

That one really ought to be framed as the example of what not to do.

[Dark Robes]

Of course Vancouvia approves it.

[Sedgistan]

Wow. That was officially the most illegal SC proposal ever. We can all retire and go home now.

[We Are Not the NSA]

Wow. That was officially the most illegal SC proposal ever. We can all retire and go home now.

Seems like a pretty easy record to break. All one would need to is copy and paste this proposal and submit it. Slap an R2a violation on as well. Of course, that person would then be banned from the WA for plagiarism, so people shouldn't try that.

[We Are Not the NSA]

SECURITY COUNCIL PROPOSAL
ID: blasee_1461586743

Repeal "Commend Dyr Nasad"

A resolution to repeal previously passed legislation.


Category: Repeal

Resolution: SC#196

Proposed by: Blasee

Description: WA Security Council Resolution #196: Commend Dyr Nasad shall be struck out and rendered null and void.

Argument: This bitch is middle eastern
Hes part of the fucking taliban
He should be executed and tortured and raped and excommunicated for the following reasons:
Hes a piece of shi'ite
Hes a terrorists
He liberalized regions that didnt want to be liberated

Please excuse any formatting errors, I hate posting from mobile. Several R4s and the whole thing is trolling and/or flaming.

[Sedgistan]

Yep, calling for another user to be "executed and tortured and raped" gets your nation deleted.

[We Are Not the NSA]

Commend Drawkland

A resolution to recognize outstanding contribution by a nation or region.


Category: Commendation

Nominee: Drawkland

Proposed by: Xhayparia

Description: RECOGNISING The Interstellar Empire of Drawkland's activity to run his region Sonnel for over three years,

NOTING his friendly competition on the NS Sports forum,

KNOWING his creation of a small Drum Corps xkorinate file that became a huge hit with other band geeks within NationStates,

OUTSTANDED by his creation of a massive canon of the entirety of Sonnel, including myself.

SHOWING his devotion to the game by creating extremely detailed systems of anything and everything you can think of for Sonnel.

Hereby commends The Interstellar Empire of Drawkland

Basically all of the R4s.

[Drawkland]

Commend Drawkland

A resolution to recognize outstanding contribution by a nation or region.


Category: Commendation

Nominee: Drawkland

Proposed by: Xhayparia

Description: RECOGNISING The Interstellar Empire of Drawkland's activity to run his region Sonnel for over three years,

NOTING his friendly competition on the NS Sports forum,

KNOWING his creation of a small Drum Corps xkorinate file that became a huge hit with other band geeks within NationStates,

OUTSTANDED by his creation of a massive canon of the entirety of Sonnel, including myself.

SHOWING his devotion to the game by creating extremely detailed systems of anything and everything you can think of for Sonnel.

Hereby commends The Interstellar Empire of Drawkland

Basically all of the R4s.

I'd like to apologize on Xhay's behalf. He doesn't really know what he's doing.

[We Are Not the NSA]

I'd like to apologize on Xhay's behalf. He doesn't really know what he's doing.

That's totally acceptable. All he has to do is file a GHR to have the proposal removed, then post it to the forum for others to review.

[Bhang Bhang Duc]

SECURITY COUNCIL PROPOSAL
ID: the_commonwealth_of_new_states_1461601651

Condemn Cormactopia II

A resolution to express shock and dismay at a nation or region.


Category: Condemnation

Nominee: Cormactopia II

Proposed by: The Commonwealth Of New States

Description: Description: Condemning The Most Serene Republic of Cormactopia II for abusing their power as a leader of a region

SHOCKED: That The Most Serene Republic of Cormactopia II is suppressing messages in Osiris to stay in power.

KNOWING: That they ban anyone who apposes them.

ACCEPTING: the fact that they will continue to hurt others in Osiris.

RELEASING: this to the council so that they may see the true colors of this nation and its illegal coup.

CONDEMNING: The Most Serene Republic of Cormactopia II for illegal use of power and suppression of people in Osiris.

Reference to suppressing "messages" (as in posts) makes it an R4 violation?

[Drawkland]

I'd like to apologize on Xhay's behalf. He doesn't really know what he's doing.

That's totally acceptable. All he has to do is file a GHR to have the proposal removed, then post it to the forum for others to review.

That's the problem, see, he doesn't much want to post on the forums. He's too lazy.

I don't mind either. I don't need a commendation.

[Xhayparia]

Well I'm sorry. I didn't know that there were rules to this. I was just trying to be nice.

[John Turner]

Well I'm sorry. I didn't know that there were rules to this. I was just trying to be nice.

Been around for two and a half years and doesn't realize there are rules?

[Xhayparia]

Well I'm sorry. I didn't know that there were rules to this. I was just trying to be nice.

Been around for two and a half years and doesn't realize there are rules?

Never bothered doing the whole "WA" thing until now. Mainly RP'd on the International Incidents thread.

[We Are Not the NSA]

Commend the South Pacific

A resolution to recognize outstanding contribution by a nation or region.


Category: Commendation

Nominee: the South Pacific

Proposed by: The Commonwealth Of New States

Description: Description: The South Pacific has become one the largest regions recently and still continues to show strong leadership and friendly help to anyone who needs it

ACKNOWLEDGING: The South Pacific nations who are active and always helping any and all nations who ask for assistance

NOTING: The South Pacific's ability to prevent violent altercations with in its Regional borders and outside as wel.

PRAISING: Nations that provide this help are included but not limited to WA Delegate
The Swiftly Tilting Land of Tsunamy, The Drunken Irish Nation of Drugged Monkeys, The Presidential Republic of The Solar System Scope The Republic of Curlyhoward, The United Kingdom of Punchwood, The Technocracy of Farengeto The Republic of Kringalia, The Vote For Salaxalans of SJS Republic and The Catholic Commonwealth of Railana.

BELIEVING: That The South Pacific will not only continue to help each other but anyone who asks for help or is in desperate need of help.

PROUD: To be apart of a region with a strong democratic process and all nations alike willing to have a voice in government.

INSPIRED: By the regions ability to handle the large amount of new nations with respect and showing them how to help one another.

Hereby Commends The South Pacific

R4d

[Leppikania]

SECURITY COUNCIL PROPOSAL
ID: uretia_1461792611

Commend Commonwealth of Liberty

A resolution to recognize outstanding contribution by a nation or region.


Category: Commendation

Nominee: Commonwealth of Liberty

Proposed by: Uretia

Description: Commending:Commonwealth of Liberty for equally viewing and allowing to participate, members of every race, ancestry, and political belief that he or she chooses WITHOUT discretion.

Approvals: 2 (Vancouvia, Clion)

Status: Lacking Support (requires 122 more approvals)

Voting Ends: in 3 days 1 hour

R4

[Crazy girl]

Reference to suppressing "messages" (as in posts) makes it an R4 violation?

I think messages in this case is ambiguous enough. Where posts very clearly refer to the online posting, messages could be anything. Even poor carrier pigeons being shot

R4

While he or she often is a rule 4 violation, it always depends on context. In this case, it isn't referring to a nation (player) and within this sentence I believe it is fine.

[Bhang Bhang Duc]

Reference to suppressing "messages" (as in posts) makes it an R4 violation?

I think messages in this case is ambiguous enough. Where posts very clearly refer to the online posting, messages could be anything. Even poor carrier pigeons being shot

Who told you about my hobby?

Appreciate the feedback CG.

[Bhang Bhang Duc]

SECURITY COUNCIL PROPOSAL
ID: yokans_island_nation_of_facism_1461936532

Condemn Wa

A resolution to express shock and dismay at a nation or region.


Category: Condemnation

Nominee: Wa

Proposed by: Yokans Island Nation of Facism

Description: I propose that we condemn Wacka flocka islands. With their below average civil rights, unheard of political freedom, and oppressive police force. Their compulsory gun ownership leads to Wacka Flocka Islands becoming a ticking time bomb, which will eventually snap. The nation has an abusive leader, who has sent numerous telegrams bullying and defaming other nations, including cursing their leaders and making fun of them. I urge you to vote to condemn The Armed Republic of Wacka Flocka Islands, as it may lead him to check what he is doing and realize that his actions are borderline abusive. Thank you for your consideration.

R2c, R3, R4b and R4d

SECURITY COUNCIL PROPOSAL
ID: yokans_island_nation_of_facism_1461937299

Condemn Waka Flocka Islands

A resolution to express shock and dismay at a nation or region.


Category: Condemnation

Nominee: Waka Flocka Islands

Proposed by: Yokans Island Nation of Facism

Description: I accidentally wrote the wrong nation in the nation field. I apologize, and this is the correct proposal. I apologize to The Protectorate of Wa for incorrectly submitting a proposal to condemn them.

I propose that we condemn The Armed Republic of Waka Flocka Islands. With their below average civil rights, unheard of political freedom, and oppressive police force. Their compulsory gun ownership leads to Waka Flocka Islands becoming a ticking time bomb, which will eventually snap. The nation has an abusive leader, who has sent numerous telegrams bullying and defaming other nations, including cursing their leaders and making fun of them. I urge you to vote to condemn The Armed Republic of Wacka Flocka Islands, as it may lead him to check what he is doing and realize that his actions are borderline abusive. Thank you for your consideration.

Corrected the name, but still the same faults: R2c, R3, R4b and R4d

SECURITY COUNCIL PROPOSAL
ID: the_fallout_reincarnation_1461939352

Liberate New York

A resolution to strike down Delegate-imposed barriers to free entry in a region.


Category: Liberation

Nominee (region): New York

Proposed by: The fallout reincarnation

Description: The region of New York has been home to a regional community for many players for most of Nation States history holding a strong firm of democracy , and respecting all of it's nations as equals .

After a visit from WA Klopstock the history of the region held within the nations message board was erased from the public eye . WA Klopstock then proceeded to eject locals for no reason even those who had endorsed him . Those who survived his act of terror where soon met with another unfortunate turn of events as a new Raiding region going by the name Roadside Detroit quickly striped the remaining morales of the region and tarnished the regional ways . The region is still being watched by Roadside Detroit to this day and are still under there oppressive rule .

Therefore, the World Assembly hereby lifts the forced control of New York from Roadside Detroit so that they run there region as they please .

R3, R4b and numerous spelling errors.

[We Are Not the NSA]

Commend the South Pacific

A resolution to recognize outstanding contribution by a nation or region.


Category: Commendation

Nominee: the South Pacific

Proposed by: The fallout reincarnation

Description:

RECOGNIZING. That the The South Pacific has been a safe heaven for new players in nationstates since the beginning .

IMPRESSED. By how orgaized the region is with keeping WA endorsement to a minimum whilealso holding equal elections.

PRAISING. The tolerance and respect that each and every nation shows each other .

ACKNOWLEDGING. The hard working leaders to keep all nations safe and respectful while also making sure free speech is up held .

COMMENDS. The South Pacific for it's contributions to nationstates as a whole

R4c violation

[Bhang Bhang Duc]

Commend the South Pacific

A resolution to recognize outstanding contribution by a nation or region.


Category: Commendation

Nominee: the South Pacific

Proposed by: The fallout reincarnation

Description:

RECOGNIZING. That the The South Pacific has been a safe heaven for new players in nationstates since the beginning .

IMPRESSED. By how orgaized the region is with keeping WA endorsement to a minimum whilealso holding equal elections.

PRAISING. The tolerance and respect that each and every nation shows each other .

ACKNOWLEDGING. The hard working leaders to keep all nations safe and respectful while also making sure free speech is up held .

COMMENDS. The South Pacific for it's contributions to nationstates as a whole

R4c violation

I was looking and looking for an illegality in this one, just couldn't see it. I actually thought it might be plagiarised because some of the clauses seemed familiar.

[Bhang Bhang Duc]

SECURITY COUNCIL PROPOSAL
ID: the_fallout_reincarnation_1461948453

Commend the South Pacific

A resolution to recognize outstanding contribution by a nation or region.


Category: Commendation

Nominee: the South Pacific

Proposed by: The fallout reincarnation

Description:

Recognizing that The South Pacific is still one of the most active , largest ,and respected Regions in the world . Also that the The South Pacific has been a safe heaven for new players in nationstates since the beginning and for veterans of nationstates

IMPRESSED. By how orgaized the region is with keeping WA endorsement to a minimum while also holding equal elections.

PRAISING. That they are willing to adjust there system to fit the players needs

ACKNOWLEDGING. The hard working leaders to keep all nations safe and respectful while also making sure free speech is up held .

Therefore the World assembly here by commends The South Pacific for it's contributions to nationstates by severing a starting point for new nations

He's decided to resubmit the same Commend - slightly different but still the same R4c violations.

[Leppikania]

SECURITY COUNCIL PROPOSAL
ID: new_caladonea_1462054753

Liberate Commonwealth of Free Nations

A resolution to strike down Delegate-imposed barriers to free entry in a region.


Category: Liberation

Nominee (region): Commonwealth of Free Nations

Proposed by: New Caladonea

Description: A PROPOSAL TO SEND SECURITY COUNCIL MILITARY FORCES INTO THE REGION OF THE COMMONWEALTH OF FREE NATIONS IN ORDER TO LIBERATE THE TERRITORIES FROM THE TOTALITARIAN COUP THAT SUCCEEDED IN OVERTHROWING THE PEACEFUL, DEMOCRATIC GOVERNMENT

Approvals: 0

Status: Lacking Support (requires 125 more approvals)

Voting Ends: in 3 days 5 hours

R3