Is Banning Circumcision Xenophobic?

[Totally Not Leningrad Union]

Is it xenophobic when countries like Germany ban circumcision?

I think it is because it spits on the values, culture and tradition of many non-European immigrants. It enforces European values on non-Europeans or Europeans who want to do it. My belief is that the problem lies in the fact that many of these countries do not understand circumcision because they never tried it.

What do you guys think, NATIONSTATES?

[Frazers]

Culture isn't an excuse against everything.

[Lunatic Goofballs]

Is it xenophobic when countries like Germany ban circumcision?

I think it is because it spits on the values, culture and tradition of many non-European immigrants. It enforces European values on non-Europeans or Europeans who want to do it. My belief is that the problem lies in the fact that many of these countries do not understand circumcision because they never tried it.

What do you guys think, NATIONSTATES?

It's a ring of dick skin. Seriously. I don't know what's worse, referring to a little snip of dick skin as 'mutilation', or being so religiously dogmatic that the loss of the ability to snip dick skin is seen as an attack on that whole religion.

I wish we could ban drama instead.

[Sun Wukong]

Only in the sense that laws against animal cruelty are anti-voodoo.

[Stagnant Axon Terminal]

Ritual Infant Circumcision is a violation of human rights just as much as involuntary female genital mutilation.
Human rights trump tradition.

[Geilinor]

Is it xenophobic when countries like Germany ban circumcision?

I think it is because it spits on the values, culture and tradition of many non-European immigrants. It enforces European values on non-Europeans or Europeans who want to do it. My belief is that the problem lies in the fact that many of these countries do not understand circumcision because they never tried it.

What do you guys think, NATIONSTATES?

I don't see why those countries should try circumcision. It isn't a problem and their non-practice of it is not their fault. Banning circumcision is more than about European or non-European values. It brings up issues of parental rights, how far religious liberties should go, and bodily autonomy.

[DesAnges]

Is it xenophobic when countries like Germany ban circumcision?

I think it is because it spits on the values, culture and tradition of many non-European immigrants. It enforces European values on non-Europeans or Europeans who want to do it. My belief is that the problem lies in the fact that many of these countries do not understand circumcision because they never tried it.

What do you guys think, NATIONSTATES?

It's a ring of dick skin. Seriously. I don't know what's worse, referring to a little snip of dick skin as 'mutilation', or being so religiously dogmatic that the loss of the ability to snip dick skin is seen as an attack on that whole religion.

I wish we could ban drama instead.

I could sum up my thoughts more succinctly but with swearing far reaching past the PG-13. So I'll just agree with the clown to the left of me.

[Pandeeria]

No.

[Totally Not Leningrad Union]

Is it xenophobic when countries like Germany ban circumcision?

I think it is because it spits on the values, culture and tradition of many non-European immigrants. It enforces European values on non-Europeans or Europeans who want to do it. My belief is that the problem lies in the fact that many of these countries do not understand circumcision because they never tried it.

What do you guys think, NATIONSTATES?

It's a ring of dick skin. Seriously. I don't know what's worse, referring to a little snip of dick skin as 'mutilation', or being so religiously dogmatic that the loss of the ability to snip dick skin is seen as an attack on that whole religion.

I wish we could ban drama instead.

Probably the ridiculous who call it mutilation.

Ritual Infant Circumcision is a violation of human rights just as much as involuntary female genital mutilation.
Human rights trump tradition.

I thought you were Islamic.

[Tubbsalot]

My belief is that the problem lies in the fact that many of these countries do not understand circumcision because they never tried it.

hahahahaha oh my god

[Totally Not Leningrad Union]

Is it xenophobic when countries like Germany ban circumcision?

I think it is because it spits on the values, culture and tradition of many non-European immigrants. It enforces European values on non-Europeans or Europeans who want to do it. My belief is that the problem lies in the fact that many of these countries do not understand circumcision because they never tried it.

What do you guys think, NATIONSTATES?

I don't see why those countries should try circumcision. It isn't a problem and their non-practice of it is not their fault.

They shouldn't, but they shouldn't discriminate because of it. I don't drink so I don't say every alcoholic should be arrested.

[Geilinor]

It's a ring of dick skin. Seriously. I don't know what's worse, referring to a little snip of dick skin as 'mutilation', or being so religiously dogmatic that the loss of the ability to snip dick skin is seen as an attack on that whole religion.

I wish we could ban drama instead.

Probably the ridiculous who call it mutilation.

Or the ridiculous who say that they're being persecuted because of the loss of the ability to circumcise.

[Ancient Magmia]

It's a ring of dick skin. Seriously. I don't know what's worse, referring to a little snip of dick skin as 'mutilation', or being so religiously dogmatic that the loss of the ability to snip dick skin is seen as an attack on that whole religion.

I wish we could ban drama instead.

^This.

[Stagnant Axon Terminal]

It's a ring of dick skin. Seriously. I don't know what's worse, referring to a little snip of dick skin as 'mutilation', or being so religiously dogmatic that the loss of the ability to snip dick skin is seen as an attack on that whole religion.

I wish we could ban drama instead.

Probably the ridiculous who call it mutilation.

Ritual Infant Circumcision is a violation of human rights just as much as involuntary female genital mutilation.
Human rights trump tradition.

I thought you were Islamic.

My religion does not give me a right to mutilate my son. When he becomes a man, he can choose for himself whether he wants to be circumcised or not.

[Pandeeria]

I don't see why those countries should try circumcision. It isn't a problem and their non-practice of it is not their fault.

They shouldn't, but they shouldn't discriminate because of it. I don't drink so I don't say every alcoholic should be arrested.

They force unnecessary surgery on a child. Circumcision is a violation of basic human rights.

[America Libertaria]

Obviously it's an anti-Semitic revival in Germany which is attacking Jews' rights of cutting up babies' little peepee's.

[Totally Not Leningrad Union]

Probably the ridiculous who call it mutilation.

Or the ridiculous who say that they're being persecuted because of the loss of the ability to circumcise.

Well we are because it's an ancient tradition that was given to us by our creator in a covenant.

[Kyuji]

Is it xenophobic when countries like Germany ban circumcision?

I think it is because it spits on the values, culture and tradition of many non-European immigrants. It enforces European values on non-Europeans or Europeans who want to do it. My belief is that the problem lies in the fact that many of these countries do not understand circumcision because they never tried it.

What do you guys think, NATIONSTATES?

It's a ring of dick skin. Seriously. I don't know what's worse, referring to a little snip of dick skin as 'mutilation', or being so religiously dogmatic that the loss of the ability to snip dick skin is seen as an attack on that whole religion.

I wish we could ban drama instead.

Its the removal of a part of a CHILDS PENIS!!!

[Tubbsalot]

referring to a little snip of dick skin as 'mutilation'

Leaving aside the fact that which word we use is irrelevant to a ban on the actual practice, that's perfectly reasonable. If I sliced a little line down the centre of your forehead, you'd be left with a great fucking scar for the rest of your life. I wouldn't even be removing anything. Does that not qualify as mutilation?

[Alcase]

Well banning circumcision would be, in a sense, anti-religion seeing as how Judaism requires a baby to be circumcised.

[Totally Not Leningrad Union]

Obviously it's an anti-Semitic revival in Germany which is attacking Jews' rights of cutting up babies' little peepee's.

No, the fourth reich is here for other reasons. And circumcision isn't cutting it up. A tiny flap of skin is removed.

[The New World Oceania]

There are these strange questions that are asked on NSG and unfortunately I've gotten used to seeing and asking them.

"Would you like eggs for breakfast?"
"That's a little xenophobic, don't you think? Not to mention the slut shaming."

[Fluerian]

Nations really ban circumcision? I am circumcised and am surprised nations banned it.

[Frazers]

Or the ridiculous who say that they're being persecuted because of the loss of the ability to circumcise.

Well we are because it's an ancient tradition that was given to us by our creator in a covenant.

If someone advised me to go around nipping off kids foreskins as an important way to get close to them I'd probably think twice about following any of their advice

[Olivaero]

When something a relegion does falls outside of secular ethics the religious practice should take a back seat not the other way around.