[PASSED] Freedom of the Press

[Domeshka]

Despite knowing the greater intention behind this legislation, and seeing that this resolution has outstanding support- the nation of Domeshka has decided to vote against the Freedom of the Press Resolution.

While intended to allow freedom for all people to know of major news stories, free of government corruption, while maintaining national security, this resolution has the previous flaws mentioned by our nation- of defining a genuine threat to national security.

In addition, viewing arguments of other nations, our nation has noticed other flaws, such as loopholes to the "freedoms" trying to be guaranteed in this legislation.

With attention paid to these facts, Domeshka votes against this resolution, as it sees problems arising that will eventually lead to a repeal. Despite it's overwhelming support, Domeshka still stands against this resolution.

We do hope, however, if it is repealed, that a revised edition of this resolution is brought to the floor- as these freedoms of the news media are valued rather highly in our country.

[Daynor]

I cast The South Pacific's vote FOR the region. The polls on our forum are still close though, so, it is possible this will change.

[Alsaveria]

I do not wish to support this resolution. I simply do not agree with some the terms. For example, no one can be banned for reading, listening, or watching news from other countries. No way. My Communist Utopia will not stand for this.

[Lordieth]

Section I; Clause 5 is so ambiguous that it serves as a serious loophole to restrict freedom of the press, contradicting the entire point of this resolution. AGAINST.

[Chalskanaka]

Do to the fact that this doesn't really get anything done. Chalskanaka votes against this resolution.

[Calaloo]

The nation of Calaloo is very much in favor of freedom of the press, however we must vote against this legislation due to Section 2 Clause 5. Specifically, Calaloo is against allowing censorship of the press due to "national security". We might consider legislation that included a very narrow and specific definition of what constitutes "national security", and also included the requirement of specific means and procedures to ensure that it was not abused, but even then Calaloo would be somewhat hesitiant. Allowing censorship of any kind creates a huge risk of abuse. Therefore, in this legislation's current form, the nation of Calaloo must vote against it.

[Cobdenia]

Whilst the Cobdenian delegation has voted against this resolution (I don't want the dratted natives from getting ideas above their station and demanding the British out of Cobdenia or other such rot), we will not be overly upset if it passes.

In anticipation of it passing, we have decided to illegalise the act of remembering what you've read in a foreign news publication

[Flibbleites]

Whilst the Cobdenian delegation has voted against this resolution (I don't want the dratted natives from getting ideas above their station and demanding the British out of Cobdenia or other such rot), we will not be overly upset if it passes.

The Rogue Nation of Flibbleites echoes the sentiments of the Cobdenian ambassador, except our reason for voting against is NatSov related (as in, we don't care if other nations have a free press).

Bob Flibble
WA Representative

[Ventienza]

Transcript of Article 2, section X of the code of Ventienza,

Under article 2, in Section X, it is described that no news organization (News paper, Radio, or otherwise.) is held back by what they show, regardless of the content. Show whatever you wish, as long as it does not go against the "Socialist Documents of Ventienza".

Transcript ended.

As seen in accordance with this code of this nation, we vote for this act. We find it a disgrace, and very distasteful, to vote against this. We hope to see all follow in accordance.

Freedom for all.

And for those nay-sayers,

Transcript of Article 3, Section X of the code,

In accordance with Article 2, we declare that it will not be the news channel that is responsible for the actions and ideals of people, but the people themselves.

Transcript ended.

Enough said.

[Tikania]

For

[Sanitaristan]

The Sanitaristan Chamber of Commerce, Sanitation, and Governance welcomes the loophole introduced by Section I(2) of the legislation up for vote (re: permission required for operation of international news organizations within country). Sanitaristan votes FOR.

[The Altani Confederacy]

This thing has more holes in it than a piece of Swiss cheese. Against.

-Sophie Fournier etc.

[Broughdom]

Well, passed with 9,290 for votes to 3,670 against.

Thanks to everyone in support of this and those who voted for it, and I have a great deal of thanks to those who helped during the drafting phrase (first 3 pages of this topic). All comments were taken on board and hopefully I didn't do too bad of a job for my first resolution.

If the repeal which appears to be in the works goes through I may revisit this at a later to date, but for now I'm happy with what I've done so will take a break.

*pulls armchair by the fire, pours a glass of whisky, lights a cuban cigar, and chills out*

[Aetrina]

OOC: Great job and congrats !!

[Flibbleites]

Well, passed with 9,290 for votes to 3,670 against.

Thanks to everyone in support of this and those who voted for it, and I have a great deal of thanks to those who helped during the drafting phrase (first 3 pages of this topic). All comments were taken on board and hopefully I didn't do too bad of a job for my first resolution.

If the repeal which appears to be in the works goes through I may revisit this at a later to date, but for now I'm happy with what I've done so will take a break.

*pulls armchair by the fire, pours a glass of whisky, lights a cuban cigar, and chills out*

Considering the way the voting turned out, I doubt you'll have to worry much about the repeal.

Bob Flibble
WA Representative