What would you think of a new Soviet country with these borders ?The Archregimancy wrote:
You would have come closest in the period 1918-1924, when the modern Central Asian republics were mostly divided between the Turkestan ASSR and the Kirgiz ASSR, with two smaller 'People's Socialist Republics' around Bukhara and Khiva, so the map looked like this:
However, these were ASSRs of the main Russian Republic, not full Soviet Republics; that came later.
Just to confuse matters, the Kirgiz ASSR is essentially the territory of modern Kazakhstan, not modern Kyrgyzstan. It took the Soviets until the 1930s to decide that the 'Kirghiz-Kazaks' should be called Kazakhs, and the Kara-Kirghiz should be called 'Kyrgyz'; which helps to show the extent to which the modern nation states in that region are not just artificial constructs in terms of their state boundaries, but also in terms of the formulation of their ethnic identities. Though since everyone more or less accepts the Soviet-era ethnic designations and boundaries (to the extent that they cause occasional inter-ethnic flare-ups in the Fergana Valley), there's no real harm done. Not currently, anyway.