Syberis wrote:Brief Paragraph of Addendum to address Unibot's point (He posted while I was.) You realize that me admitting this mistake is terrible politically because it puts me on a side opposite my own allies, right? You realize that the best political decision for me would have been to not do what I am doing, right? You realize that this is an objectively bad move if I was going from a pure political standpoint, and we killed an alliance with LWU over this? That when it comes to the established stance of the OFO, it would have been better from a pure, pragmatic political standpoint for me to stand by a failing operation and go down with the ship than it would have been to meet TRR, TSP, and the NPO at the table? This whole thing, tactically, was a terrible idea. It was optimism, but not in the way you articulate it.
I think you misunderstood my post, the pragmatism was a reference to Tim/Roavin - GR had accused them of 'rosy optimism.' I've praised your conduct here and I suggested that Osiris may have supported UDoL and opposed the Khanate in part because of the history of the Osiran Imperium War; Osiris has been under foreign occupation (Gatesville) and required regime change to overcome its instability.
(My apologies if I wasn't clear.)
However to respond to your concerns: I think there's a possibility that in the future, this crisis could end as a sinkerite success story. Three sinker regions may move forward from this crisis with a stronger sense of mutual respect, the foundation of any good working relationship. I think the only political loser in this story will end up being Balder for their short-sightedness and lack of appreciation for autonomous government.
(You can now promptly accuse me of rosy optimism. )
Cormactopia Prime wrote:TL;DR: This is actually in large part your fault, Glen-Rhodes. Shame on you. I'm glad the South Pacific's external affairs are now in more capable hands.
This seems deeply unfair to GR. If GR had shut his trap I don't think it'd have changed your stance or any of the reasoning you explained in that post. He was one of many individuals, including those 'capable hands,' voicing the same indictment of the UDoL verbatim. A call for reconciliation and a moratorium on recriminations is indeed appropriate, but it's a two-way street - it includes GR as much as you.