Defeated Security Council Proposals

[Indo-Malaysia]

Defeated Security Council Proposals

Welcome to the index of defeated Security Council Proposals! This contain Proposals that were defeated in the Security Council Voting Quorum. If you were looking for Proposals that have passed, please see this wonderful thread courtesy of Tim-Opolis.

The purpose of this thread is to serve as a place where you can view failed proposals with ease and links to the relevant discussion areas.

---

Liberate Femdom Empire
Commend The North Pacific
Commend The Rejected Realms
Condemn The Order of the Grey Wardens
Repeal "Liberate Dank Memes"

Condemn Wrektopia

[Indo-Malaysia]

Liberate Femdom Empire

A resolution to strike down Delegate-imposed barriers to free entry in a region.

Category: Liberation | Nominee: Femdom Empire | Proposed by: The Rejected Realms

Description: The Security Council,

Defines the term Authoritarianism as an ideology that favors a concentration of power in a leader or an elite that tends to lead to oppression and tyranny and the term Fascism as an ideology that favors region over nation and stands for a centralized autocratic government that is led by a dictatorial leader, maintains strict social regimentation, and wipes out opposition;

Mortified by Femdom Empire's collaboration with Fascist regions, or more specifically Nazi Europa, The Iron Guard, and The Iron Order, to help defend against The CAIN through suspicious methods in a recent conflict to capture Femdom Empire;

Further Disturbed by Femdom Empire’s collaboration with Authoritarian regions, or more specifically Federation of Greater German Republics, Great Empire of Great Cyan, KAISERREICH, Krumpelburg, Order of the Southern North, and Psychotic Dictatorships in the aforementioned conflict;

Observing that Femdom Empire is enforcing border control, presumably to secure the region fully by refounding it;

Seeing that one of the mentioned Fascist regions is connected to Nazi Europa, which has recently already almost destroyed The Arab League;

Generally Annoyed by Femdom Empire’s willingness to cooperate with Authoritarian and Fascist regions,

Acknowledging the presence of military forces who seek to eradicate Authoritarianism and Fascism;

Aware that these forces may only act on an unique opportunity for their goals if the border controls of Femdom Empire are struck down;

Hereby Liberates Femdom Empire.

Votes For: 2,608
Votes Against: 14,862

Defeated March 15th 2017
[Official Debate Topic]

[Indo-Malaysia]

Commend The North Pacific

A resolution to recognize outstanding contribution by a nation or region.

Category: Commendation | Nominee: The North Pacific | Proposed by: Tinhampton

Description: The Security Council,

THE SECURITY COUNCIL:

BELIEVING that the largest of the world's five feeders, the North Pacific (TNP), is a shining example to the world, especially in the art of combining freedom with security;

NOTING that, after the various coups d'état it suffered in its early years – inflicted by the likes of Great Bight, Pixiedance, The Crimson Order, Shoeless Joe and Durkadurkiranistan I & II (many of which are cited by past Security Council resolutions*) – TNP have endeavored after each liberation to recover and prevent future coups in a manner consistent with its democratic heritage, such as:

• The creation of a Bill of Rights which recognises national sovereignty;
• A regional constitution, which has changed over the years but which has consistently ensured that TNP remains a free, democratic and open region;
• Upholding the rule of law and the supremacy of the legislature;
• Establishing a Security Council of trusted and influential residents (responsible to TNP and its constitution) which oversee the region's security and respond to threats as they arise;
• A contemporary endorsement trading scheme which encourages (rather than discourages) endorsement trading between WA nations; ultimately aiding in TNP's retention of newcomers and its overall regional security, in addition to the average nation in TNP amassing 16 endorsements;

*: See SC#33, 34, 49, 63, 129, 168, and 169.

REALISING that TNP's delegate endorsement counts are double that of regular contemporary counts for feeders, currently standing at over 1,250 (one catalyst of which may have been a mass campaign to endorse then-delegate HMS Unicorn at the end of 2014; momentum which once saw an 85% delegate endorsement rate amongst TNP's WA nations, as well as a rise in endorsements from 490 to over 600);

NOTICING that TNP is now home to many Commended nations (or puppets thereof), including: Astarial, Flemingovia, McMasterdonia, Renaissancistic People, Eluvatar, Mousebumples, Evil Wolf, and Sanctaria;

OBSERVING that TNP is unusual in having a voluntary, official regional religion: Flemingovianism, which requires its observants to worship the nation of Flemingovia as a god;

PRAISING TNP's efforts to keep its resident nations up to date with regional events, through the many dispatches (including regional census results and WA vote recommendations) put out by The Northern Light, and formerly by the North Pacific Wire; and

REMEMBERING how the North Pacific Army (NPA) have helped their Feeder and Sinker allies in times of crisis:

• April 2015: During the occupation of Lazarus by the New Lazarene Order (backed by the Pacific), the NPA provided material and tactical support for the Lazarene Underground State;
• Summer 2013: TNP opposed the rogue delegacy of the Dourian Embassy in Osiris, and the subsequent Gatesville occupation; and
• April 2013: The NPA supplied key military aid to its allies, the Coalition of the South Pacific, in its fight against the South Pacific People's Republic (SPPR). Thus, the Security Council:

HEREBY COMMENDS the North Pacific.

Votes For: 6,564
Votes Against: 9,055

Defeated March 20th 2017
[Official Debate Topic]

[Indo-Malaysia]

Commend The Rejected Realms

A resolution to recognise outstanding contribution by a nation or region.

Category: Commendation | Nominee: the Rejected Realms | Proposed by: Cepcecic Diplomacy

Description: CONGRATULATING The Rejected Realms on achieving a stable and safe democracy without being able to issue bans and ejections, and for accepting nations with open arms.

RECOGNISING The Rejected Realms on having the oldest army of any region, the RRA (Rejected Realms Army). This army is a defender army and strives for interregional peace and prosperity.

ACKNOWLEDGING that The Rejected Realms is a diplomatic ally with many regions who works towards international peace. Without The Rejected Realms's efforts, progress towards international peace would have slowed down significantly.

THANKING The Rejected Realms for their assistance and leadership of several missions to liberate regions in distress including but not limited to:
- Japan, a small region with high influence.
- The South Pacific, one of the largest feeder regions.
- Hogwarts, another small region with high influence.
- Lazarus, a fellow defender region with extremely high influence.

APPLAUDING The Rejected Realms's successful defence of 10000 Islands in 2003. Despite 10000 Islands not being a defender region at the time, it's successful defence would eventually lead to it becoming one of the largest and most influential Defender regions in the world.

MOVED by The Rejected Realms's outstanding cultural diversity, with no limits to its endless array of different nations. This cultural diversity allows nations unfamiliar or new to the The Rejected Realms to participate in a vast plethora of activities, discussions, and the inclusion that many regions lack.

ESTABLISHING The Rejected Realms as a unique region due to its periodic regional newspaper (The Rejected Times), which documents and records events across Nationstates for everyone to read.

DISTINGUISHING The Rejected Realms for being a founder member of the ADN, and later being an influential member of the FRA. Their contributions kept the FRA running for many years after, with many of the Arch Chancellors of the FRA coming from The Rejected Realms.

APPALLED that The Rejected Realms has been underappreciated for so long, and has failed thus far to be noticed by the esteemed members of the World Assembly for its outstanding performance and resolve.

KNOWING that with the passage of this resolution that The Rejected Realms can only continue to strive for international peace and success.

HEREBY Commends The Rejected Realms for outstanding performance, resolve, diversity, and courage

Votes For: 6,279
Votes Against: 10,680

Defeated April 24th 2017
[Official Debate Topic]

[Indo-Malaysia]

Condemn The Order of the Grey Wardens

A resolution to express shock and dismay at a nation or region.

Category: Condemnation | Nominee: The Order of the Grey Wardens | Proposed by: Cresenthia

Description: The Security Council,

Concerned by the actions of The Order of the Grey Wardens, also known as The Grey Wardens and TGW, a supposedly defender group, that has undertaken seemingly hypocritical actions in recent history, part of a pattern dating back to the occupation of Madrigal, including the following,

• The attempted invasion of Femdom Empire, and the attempted displacement of its natives.
• The invasion of Super Reich I.
• The numerous unprovoked actions against Kaiserreich, in particular, the puppeteering of Kurnugia.
• The invasion of Warzone Europe, starting a wholly unwarranted conflict with its protector, Equilism.

Furthermore concerned that The Grey Wardens frequently poach nations from the raider and invader regions they publicly decry.

Shocked that when these actions were pointed out, The Grey Wardens denied such claims, calling them “fake news.”

Noting that as a member of CAIN, The Grey Wardens have abused the organization as a tool to take absurd positions, for the sole purpose of mislabeling their enemies as members of an extreme ideology under the guise of interregional cooperation to gain more raiding targets.

Observing the possibility of other such, and even more depraved and hypocritical actions.

Hereby Condemns The Order of The Grey Wardens.

Votes For: 2,517
Votes Against: 14,247

Defeated May 19th 2017
[Official Debate Topic]

[Indo-Malaysia]

Repeal "Liberate Dank Memes"

A resolution to repeal previously passed legislation.

Category: Repeal | Resolution: #SC 205 | Proposed by: Tim-Opolis

Description: The Security Council,

Acknowledging that Security Council Resolution #205 was passed for the purposes of preventing Dank Memes from being refounded while being invaded,

Noting that the aforementioned resolution only had to be passed due to naive carelessness by the native delegate La Navasse,

Observing that the region Dank Memes is now under the control of Captain Woodhouse, formerly of Nazi Europa,

Recognizing that this situation came about as a result of numerous blunders by former delegate La Navasse and the region's invader occupants HYDRA Command,

Illuminating the fact that La Navasse subsequently released a dispatch to the world in which they claimed Nazi Europa would allegedly help refound Dank Memes,

Emphasizing a specific part of the statement which said "Dank Memes shall become a fascist state and provide military assistance to Nazi Europa eternally",

Hugely Amused by the fact that Dank Memes was never returned to La Navasse, and is still held by Captain Woodhouse,

Believing that since the region of Dank Memes has been permanently refounded there is little value for a Liberation continuing to exist,

Hereby Repeals Security Council Resolution #205 "Liberate Dank Memes".

Votes For: 5,069
Votes Against: 9,265

Defeated June 10th 2017
[Official Debate Topic]

[Indo-Malaysia]

Condemn Wrektopia

A resolution to express shock and dismay at a nation or region.

Category: Condemnation | Nominee: Wrektopia | Proposed by: Adytus

Description: Noting that The Trash King of Wrektopia is absolutely replete with garbage, and that this irresponsible hoarding of refuse (which has covered each and every square foot of available land within the country) has caused severe and irreversible damage to the nation's natural ecosystem and economy, if not utterly destroyed them altogether.

Acknowledging the Wrektopian nation as being ruled by a self-proclaimed "Trash King.”

Bemoaning the smug, confrontational demeanor of the Wrektopian leader, Curly Eayler, towards this problem, and denouncing his disdain for the well-being of the Wrektopian people, for the health of the nation's environment, and for the repeated requests of neighboring governments to refrain from hoarding detritus.

Observing that the Wrektopian litter crisis has negatively impacted dozens of surrounding nations within Wrektopia's native region of Osiris, including but not limited to Adytus, Jamil Federations, Syberis, Yunoa, North Aurelia, and Weast Jurmany.

Further Noting that the Wrektopian condition was determined to be directly responsible for the extinction of at least 247 unique species of terrestrial and aquatic wildlife and flora, including the orange-crested gannet (formerly the national bird of Adytus), the brown-speckled North Kervoskian hamster, the beautiful, big-eyed Altinian raptor, the great Pelicanese walrus seal, the Johnny Cash-faced impala of Weast Jurmany, and, most notably, the birdlike hyena dogfish rabbit, and that Wrektopia's rubbish-related endeavors have brought more than 500 other species close to extinction.

Recognizing that the Wrektopian government's reaction to an international conference attempting to address this situation, as well as to sanctions levied against it, is simply to send crassly-worded telegrams and taped recordings of indiscernible screeching to the conference member governments, and to continue to senselessly produce, ascertain, and stockpile waste.

Further Recognizing that within the last month large rafts of festering offal mixed with sewage have begun to float against the current with an almost animal-like sense of direction out of Wrektopian bays and into the shorelines of its neighbors, and

Believing this to be a new stage in the development of the Wrektopian menace that could pose a more long-distance threat to its neighbors and even to the world.

Determining the trash-filled condition of Wrektopia to be a deplorable affront to the environment and a blatant and deliberate disrespect of its neighbors, and

Fearing the outcome of this situation if it is not firmly addressed on an international scale.

Hereby Condemns The Trash King of Wrektopia.

Votes For: 4,030
Votes Against: 9,872

Defeated July 7th 2017
[Official Debate Topic]