[PASSED] Commend The NationStates Community

by **New Conglomerate** » Tue Apr 10, 2012 1:57 pm

Eist wrote:I will be voting AGAINST this commendation, because NS Community has not done anything worthwhile (let alone commendation worthy) in NS.

The IPO was fun, and that's about it. To commend this NS Community cheapens the commendations that have been issued to the more deserving nations before it.

I disagree with your assumption that bringing together many of the nations on NationStates in order to gain more shares in the IPO then Max Barry wasn't "anything worthwhile."

The fact that we did this in a democratic fashion absent of serious infighting is significant as well.

by **Danatova** » Tue Apr 10, 2012 2:05 pm

Firmly against.

The NationStates Community, and all who aided it, are damned traitors to His Eternal Majesty, Our Lord and Master, Max Barry. Indeed, to vote for such a proposal would be an overt act of treason!

by **Wamitoria** » Tue Apr 10, 2012 2:12 pm

Danatova wrote:Firmly against.

The NationStates Community, and all who aided it, are damned traitors to His Eternal Majesty, Our Lord and Master, Max Barry. Indeed, to vote for such a proposal would be an overt act of treason!

Max Barry gave The NationStates Community his shares...

by **Ora Amaris** » Tue Apr 10, 2012 3:04 pm

The Ambassador has indicated his vote FOR.
The experience definitely deserves commendation.
The NationStates Community by extension includes all that was involved, and the effort that it took.
Its quite a unique resolution, that's for sure. But I don't think because of that it deserves to get defeated.

By looking at the events that happened, it was quite an impressive display and coordinated event.
Just like any other event that deserves commendation, this one definitely deserves it.

by **Tibberiria** » Tue Apr 10, 2012 3:58 pm

A mean old man wrote:Meh. April Fools was fun, but nah.

This.

by **Ora Amaris** » Tue Apr 10, 2012 4:01 pm

Tibberiria wrote:
A mean old man wrote:Meh. April Fools was fun, but nah.

This.

But... why not? I think what they did was pretty exceptional.

by **Weed** » Tue Apr 10, 2012 4:07 pm

Voted against, I gave my shares, but this wasn't earned. Fun day, but not commendation worthy. They got recognition from Max on a news story most of NS will at least glance at (to make the (1) go away

) isn't that good enough?

by **Ora Amaris** » Tue Apr 10, 2012 4:14 pm

Weed wrote:Voted against, I gave my shares, but this wasn't earned. Fun day, but not commendation worthy. They got recognition from Max on a news story most of NS will at least glance at (to make the (1) go away ) isn't that good enough?

Could be argued.
Although it was mentioned by Max, the entire action could be given in-character commendation and recognition.
It was definitely one for the history books.

by **Triganor** » Tue Apr 10, 2012 5:41 pm

as last contributor to the NationsStates Community and after sending a message to them to realize a merging with Texas ... and considering that Texas has misllead us all by his greedy behavior to achieve the goal, i strongly commends and support the NationStates community who understand well the goals of the I.P.O. and promote it democraticaly all along the day ... well done NationStates Community and all the contributors ! :clap:

by **Weed** » Tue Apr 10, 2012 6:02 pm

Triganor wrote:as last contributor to the NationsStates Community and after sending a message to them to realize a merging with Texas ... and considering that Texas has misllead us all by his greedy behavior to achieve the goal, i strongly commends and support the NationStates community who understand well the goals of the I.P.O. and promote it democraticaly all along the day ... well done NationStates Community and all the contributors !

The grammar and spelling in this post is absolutely horrible. Anyway, Texas did not mislead anyone. Your poorly worded statement is completely baseless.

Topid

by **Far Rayeal** » Tue Apr 10, 2012 6:07 pm

by **Ruzan** » Tue Apr 10, 2012 6:18 pm

For! Getting that many nations to work for a common goal has never happened before, and might never happen again. IMO, it's worth a commendation.

by **A mean old man** » Tue Apr 10, 2012 7:39 pm

It was an example of mob mentality. People felt like beating Max's 25 million shares and dumped their own into the highest holder. The fact that its name was eventually "The NationStates Community" certainly helped. We all knew it was an April 1 event and that the stocks would go away when the day was over and figured "what the fuck, why not?" It wasn't that amazing.

by **Unibot II** » Tue Apr 10, 2012 7:44 pm

A mean old man wrote:It was an example of mob mentality. People felt like beating Max's 25 million shares and dumped their own into the highest holder. The fact that its name was eventually "The NationStates Community" certainly helped. We all knew it was an April 1 event and that the stocks would go away when the day was over and figured "what the fuck, why not?" It wasn't that amazing.

There was a lot of drama in the IPO that revolved around individuals coming to terms with sacrificing their shares on an individual's basis, far removed from just mindless mob mentalities.

by **Crushing Our Enemies** » Tue Apr 10, 2012 7:45 pm

I agree the unified purpose was not as grand as many make it out to be. But in a community where there are so many factions that want so little to do with each other (raiders, defenders, intfeds, natsovs, conservatives, liberals, etc) I was a bit surprised that personal conflicts and ideological boundaries didn't get in the way much.

by **A mean old man** » Tue Apr 10, 2012 8:06 pm

Unibot II wrote:There was a lot of drama in the IPO that revolved around individuals coming to terms with sacrificing their shares on an individual's basis, far removed from just mindless mob mentalities.

So are we commending "The NationStates Community" or back-patting the comparatively few individuals who could get over themselves and toss in their shares?

by **Ora Amaris** » Tue Apr 10, 2012 8:41 pm

A mean old man wrote:
Unibot II wrote:There was a lot of drama in the IPO that revolved around individuals coming to terms with sacrificing their shares on an individual's basis, far removed from just mindless mob mentalities.

So are we commending "The NationStates Community" or back-patting the comparatively few individuals who could get over themselves and toss in their shares?

But that's just it, the individual became part of a greater whole. Like the actual NationStates community, a bunch of diverse people came under one banner collectively to contribute to a pretty awesome thing. Its certainly a unique event that one can't compare to traditional commend or condemn events in the Security Council, but I definitely think that the actions of those that got involved with this is worth commending.

by **Jaggeria** » Tue Apr 10, 2012 10:58 pm

The main reason we, the people from Jaggeria, approve of this is mainly in hopes to sway Max into making it a new permanent feature, adding an economic dynamic to this game will revitalize this game in a way that would help drive up activity levels across Nationstates, and have more impact on regions directly so not everything is done off-site and usually done in a complicated fashion that discourages activity.

by **Crushing Our Enemies** » Tue Apr 10, 2012 11:01 pm

Jaggeria wrote:The main reason we, the people from Jaggeria, approve of this is mainly in hopes to sway Max into making it a new permanent feature, adding an economic dynamic to this game will revitalize this game in a way that would help drive up activity levels across Nationstates, and have more impact on regions directly so not everything is done off-site and usually done in a complicated fashion that discourages activity.

Yeahh, somehow I don't think that's how he would interpret the passing of this proposal...but hey, go for it.

by **Improving Wordiness** » Tue Apr 10, 2012 11:25 pm

Out of curiosity.....what was The Nationstates Community doing in Corporate Profit Alliance 95 days ago?

by **Mallorea and Riva** » Tue Apr 10, 2012 11:30 pm

Improving Wordiness wrote:Out of curiosity.....what was The Nationstates Community doing in Corporate Profit Alliance 95 days ago?

That coincides precisely with the liberation of CPA from... Damn what was his name... really nice guy... Anyways UDL liberation. Probably Mahaj's puppet.

EDIT: Yeah I just remembered. That was a weird one. Raiders moved in really early, Mahaj dumped his puppet in there and we moved in and endo'd him. He had to go, but the next morning he never came online to boot the raiders. They reinforced, and took the region at the minor update. UDL forces including myself (Although probably not Mahaj) then responded by liberating the region at the major update. So the NS Community may very well have been part of a successful turned failed defense

DOUBLE EDIT: TBH was uninvolved in the situation as far as I remember, the lead was from... Democratium? Maybe? So Mahaj must have plunked him down in TBH main region just to have a nation there for whatever reason.

by **Major Recruitment** » Tue Apr 10, 2012 11:55 pm

Mallorea and Riva wrote:
Improving Wordiness wrote:Out of curiosity.....what was The Nationstates Community doing in Corporate Profit Alliance 95 days ago?

That coincides precisely with the liberation of CPA from... Damn what was his name... really nice guy... Anyways UDL liberation. Probably Mahaj's puppet.

Switz, who was quite nice and joined #udl to congratulate us on the liberation.

- Unibot

by **Improving Wordiness** » Wed Apr 11, 2012 12:10 am

So it is a UDL controlled nation?

by **Mallorea and Riva** » Wed Apr 11, 2012 12:15 am

Improving Wordiness wrote:So it is a UDL controlled nation?

Presumably it was controlled by Mahaj at one point. Whether he maintains control over it now is something I'm not sure of. I would assume that Earth has control over the nation now. Either way, controlled by a UDL member, but obviously not active currently in military action.

Major Recruitment wrote:
Mallorea and Riva wrote:That coincides precisely with the liberation of CPA from... Damn what was his name... really nice guy... Anyways UDL liberation. Probably Mahaj's puppet.

Switz, who was quite nice and joined #udl to congratulate us on the liberation.

- Unibot

Ahhhh yes, Switz.

by **Crushing Our Enemies** » Wed Apr 11, 2012 12:16 am

It is currently under the exclusive control of Lyanna Stark. In the past, it has been used by Mahaj for whatever he wanted to do with it. Looks like that includes at least one liberation, and a brief visit to TBH. Regardless, it has changed hands and purposes since then, and both of those occurrences are irrelevant to the proposal.

[PASSED] Commend The NationStates Community

Who is online