Bhang Bhang Duc wrote:Westinor wrote:Hellooooo! Going to put this on last call for any comments and feedback
Hi West - I do have some comments, nothing major. This is another epic draft, phenomenal research into the history of a much storied nation.
Okay, criticisms. When I read a draft or even (especially) my own reports for work I am on the lookout for repetition of words or phrases used in relatively quick succession. I find it jarring and disruptive to the flow of the text.
“Foundation” or “foundational” seems to me a bit overused in your draft. “Regional” is as well. I would highlight them but I’m on my phone with a small screen and with my eyesight…..
Not expecting you to be a walking thesaurus, but a little judicial editing wouldn’t come amiss.
In terms of the cards, well I think what you have is sufficient - even without the cards there seems to almost enough material for two Commendations. Almost.
There were a couple of very minor grammar edits but they’ll have to wait until I’m on a bigger screen tomorrow.
Many thanks, BBD! Have been edited to cut down on or replace those repetitions; admittedly that's a bit of a pet peeve for me too but I seem to be doing quite more of it as of late. Thanks for helping me catch those!
WRT cards I'm in agreement with you in that the current status of Riemst's work in that community is sufficient, though it wouldn't hurt to add more if he gets there in time. I've checked the cards he's missing, and they are among the most rare; unless he's likely to get those rather soon, I'm not feeling currently inclined to wait for that to occur. A similar point was raised to wait for WS to get AoCI before his commendation is passed, and several months after the commendation has passed WS' collection is unfortunately still lacking on that front.