North Washington Republic wrote:Ansarullah wrote:I just explained what makes you a Muslim and why they're not Muslim. You're grasping at straws.
What authority do you have to determine if someone is a Muslim or not? I understand the Quran states that they’re are those that say that they’re believers but are actually not(Al-Baqara Ayah 8. ). However, doesn’t that judgment only belong to Allah?
Yes, that's correct as far as my understanding goes.
(Sorry but I corrected the "ayah" part a bit )
Jolthig wrote:And yes, El-Amin was a legitimate Muslim. Ive said this before: Anyone who observes the 5 daily prayers, faces Kaaba, slaughters animals in a Halal way. Etc. Are Muslim.
This.