[DEFEATED] Commend LadyRebels

[Sedgistan]

If the criticism is too much filler, isn't the solution just to redraft to try to get rid of the "filler"? Lol

Your proposal had filler in it because it needed filling out. Your writing was good enough, it's just that the nominee you picked hasn't really got the significance, breadth or longevity of achievements that people expect to award a Commendation. Every author gets misses as well as hits - occasionally there's something you can improve on, or it's a case of bad timing, but most often you chalk them up to experience and move on.

[Honeydewistania]

Sad to see this defeated

Anyway, I'll likely be attempting this again in the future (6? or so months).

Dude, just take this L and move on.

[The Python]

Sad to see this defeated :(

Anyway, I'll likely be attempting this again in the future (6? or so months).

Dude, just take this L and move on.

What's wrong with attempting it again not in any time soon xD

[Andusre]

Dude, just take this L and move on.

What's wrong with attempting it again not in any time soon xD

In the context where many SC regulars viewed your conduct in this thread as hard-headed and stubborn, pressing ahead - even if it's a few months down the line - suggests a lack of self-reflection on why this did not pass.

[WayNeacTia]

Dude, just take this L and move on.

What's wrong with attempting it again not in any time soon xD

If the criticism is too much filler, isn't the solution just to redraft to try to get rid of the "filler"? Lol

Your proposal had filler in it because it needed filling out. Your writing was good enough, it's just that the nominee you picked hasn't really got the significance, breadth or longevity of achievements that people expect to award a Commendation. Every author gets misses as well as hits - occasionally there's something you can improve on, or it's a case of bad timing, but most often you chalk them up to experience and move on.

I bolded the important parts for you, in case you somehow missed it.

[Outer Sparta]

Dude, just take this L and move on.

What's wrong with attempting it again not in any time soon xD

If LadyRebels becomes more commendable in the future, then maybe you have more material to work with. However, I don't think that would ever happen since they haven't seem to have done much as indicated by the responses in the thread.

[Varanius]

Dude, just take this L and move on.

What's wrong with attempting it again not in any time soon xD

Not being commendable is not being commendable. And given I doubt LR is planning on coming back and furthering commendable efforts, time isn’t some magic cure that’ll suddenly make them commendable.