Should the State of Israel have a right to exist?

[Qazaq Persia]

Why is this a question? Of course the State of Israel has a right to exist, just as much of a right as the State of Palestine does.

[Boomhaueristan]

This is bait.

[Alcala-Cordel]

Using the idea that everyone should be safe from oppression is an extremely ironic way to defend a militaristic apartheid state.

[Praetoriius]

It has the right to exist, but that right can and should be revoked if it continues to be so pugnacious towards Palestine.

[Ifreann]

Course it fricking should. I dont like the shit they do to the Palestinians but Israel should continue to exist as a country, ideally alongside with Palestine but fat chance of that happening.

Both Israel and Palestine are true Ulm clay.

[Great Algerstonia]

Course it fricking should. I dont like the shit they do to the Palestinians but Israel should continue to exist as a country, ideally alongside with Palestine but fat chance of that happening.

Both Israel and Palestine are true Ulm clay.

The Ulminati is real!

[Deacarsia]

I have said it many times and I will say this again—the ethnostate of Israel has no 'right' to exist. Building on this clause you should answer, "for what reason?" I have long disdained the 'two-state solution' as it more likely gives a lot of chances for Zionists and sympathizers to continue with their settler colonialist expansions and their war crimes.


And be replaced with a Crusader State that treats Muslims as second-class citizens?

Ironically the Crusader States treated Muslims rather well (bad form to oppress the locals that outnumber you), leaving them alone as long as they paid their taxes. Muslims preferred Crusader rule to that of the neighboring Muslim rulers. This is why there were never any Muslim rebellions in the Crusader States. I imagine they were quite disappointed when the Crusaders ended up getting the boot.

Yea, exactly. I support the establishment of a Crusader State along these lines.

[Algebra and Geometry]

the middle east should be a part of brazil

How? The Middle East and Brazil have nothing in common and are on opposite parts of the world.

That is more like relating potatoes with Apples.

[Algebra and Geometry]

Why is this a question? Of course the State of Israel has a right to exist, just as much of a right as the State of Palestine does.

Israel is good , Palestine bad, I support Israel.

[Vassenor]

Why is this a question? Of course the State of Israel has a right to exist, just as much of a right as the State of Palestine does.

Israel is good , Palestine bad, I support Israel.

So ethnic cleansing against Palestinian settlements is OK then?

[Deacarsia]

Israel is good , Palestine bad, I support Israel.

So ethnic cleansing against Palestinian settlements is OK then?

Apparently so, if you believe this nonsense.

[The Holy Therns]

It's been there a good long while, I think it's a bit of a moot point to ask if it should or should not. Should the sun rise in the morning? Doesn't matter, it's going to anyway.

[Algebra and Geometry]

So ethnic cleansing against Palestinian settlements is OK then?

Apparently so, if you believe this nonsense.

It's rightfully Israel's ancestral land , these Palestinian s are recent immigrants from Iraq or Jordan , they settled there barely a few hundred years ago.

[Etheral Babylon]

It's a country, it exists whether you like it or not. So yes, obviously.

[Luziyca]

Both Israel and Palestine have the right to exist, even if I do think that it would make the most sense to have a Bosnia and Herzegovina-esque/Belgium-esque federation in the region instead of having two states, of which one can never be truly viable as a sovereign state, and the other oppresses those residing in the former.

[Washington Resistance Army]

Apparently so, if you believe this nonsense.

It's rightfully Israel's ancestral land , these Palestinian s are recent immigrants from Iraq or Jordan , they settled there barely a few hundred years ago.

This isn't true at all.

[-Ra-]

Speaking on purely Lockean terms, the State of Israel has a right to exist because its citizens broadly consent to its existence, and freely bind themselves to its laws and customs, for the purpose of securing their collective weal and protection.

Israel is good , Palestine bad, I support Israel.

So ethnic cleansing against Palestinian settlements is OK then?

What does this have to do with Israel's right to exist?

[Vassenor]

Apparently so, if you believe this nonsense.

It's rightfully Israel's ancestral land , these Palestinian s are recent immigrants from Iraq or Jordan , they settled there barely a few hundred years ago.

So you agree that it's time for all the Europeans to leave the Americas?

[Andretopia]

No, not even palestine. None of them

[The A Empire]

No, Cause fuck 'em

[Turk Cumhuriyeti]

Yes, if it respects the rights of every citizen.

[Helidan]

No states should exist.

A united humanity is a much better option but people apparently don't like each other.

Like orange Fanta united humanity, or true communism united humanity?

[Deblar]

No states should exist.

A united humanity is a much better option but people apparently don't like each other.

Like orange Fanta united humanity, or true communism united humanity?

Y E S

[Alcala-Cordel]

Apparently so, if you believe this nonsense.

It's rightfully Israel's ancestral land , these Palestinian s are recent immigrants from Iraq or Jordan , they settled there barely a few hundred years ago.

Ancient empires don't give anyone the right to drive people who live in a place out. Land is land, and it's the rightful home of whichever individual lives there.

[Deacarsia]

It's rightfully Israel's ancestral land , these Palestinian s are recent immigrants from Iraq or Jordan , they settled there barely a few hundred years ago.

This isn't true at all.

You are right; it is not remotely true. This is insanity.