Constructively rate the above nation's flag (8)

[Apiary One]

Continued from viewtopic.php?f=25&t=453730

The objective of this thread is to rate the above nation's flag out of 10. But don't just rate it; explain in a sentence or two why you liked it or disliked it. The feedback must be constructive which means no lazy remarks, e.g. "It's great!" or "It's terrible!", absent a reason. Please do not rate the same nation more than once unless their flag has changed.

Really nice flag. It’s easy on the eyes, unique and interesting. No problems. Easy 9 or 10/10

8/10. The level of intricate detail on the owl is excellent. However, with the black background it does not look very flaglike.

[Drew Durrnil]

Nice design especially with the yellow converging in the middle and the wasp on the hexagon, 9/10

[Nooooooooooooooo]

7/10

Love the colors, love the symbolism, I just think it's a bit complex. Your other flag would get a 10, though.

[National Capitalist United States]

Simple desing and ok colors. 5/10

[Apiary One]

7/10. Simple memorable design; slightly unoriginal.

[New Solaurora]

10/10 good flag. Good colors. Consistent design.

[Valentine Z]

Ahh, new thread smell! Snifffffffffff.

Anyway, good design and colors! Kinda looks a bit like what I would see in a F1 race, or some motorsports event, which makes it cooler. 9.5 / 10.

[United Communal Burrow Republics]

7/10.

I like the colors on this flag, but they are a little bit blended together, and the design is overalltoo simplistic for my tastes. Not bad in any way though, and definately a good flag!

[Frangaulf]

This flag could come with the motto:

Bunny Nation under Construction - Strength through fluffiness.

And even when it has nothing to do with bunnies, it still tantalises the imagination. I like it a lot!

Only suggestion: one big orange band instead of one thicker and one thinner.

9/10

[Utopian States of America]

Nice colors but the design is horrible. 4/10

[Lagonza]

1: in what world is the word "horrible" constructive criticism?

2. Red, green and black brings Afghanistan to mind. Is that supposed to be the case?

3. flowy leaf: sort of original, but reminiscent of New Zealand's fern (the alternative flag)

0.0/3.0 for attitude + 2.5/3.0 for colors + 1.5/3.0 for not highly original composition + 1/1 because nobody deserves a zero.

= 5/10 in all.

[Valentine Z]

There's a bit of color clashing and I don't think this can be avoided, unfortunately. Stripes with the emblem/logo on top is a bit difficult to pull off in terms of contrast.

With that said, I still like it! The wolf/lion (forgive me, I think I see a wolf+lion combo) animal is pretty awesome, and the stripes' colours are pretty nice though a little normal.

I wonder if it will look better with a thicker outline, or a shield emblem.

Overall, 7.5/10.

[Lagonza]

There's a bit of color clashing and I don't think this can be avoided, unfortunately. Stripes with the emblem/logo on top is a bit difficult to pull off in terms of contrast.

With that said, I still like it! The wolf/lion (forgive me, I think I see a wolf+lion combo) animal is pretty awesome, and the stripes' colours are pretty nice though a little normal.

I wonder if it will look better with a thicker outline, or a shield emblem.

Overall, 7.5/10.

SKIP ME

That bit about the wolf/lion combo made my heart sing - I had tried to base it on the old Venetian flag - which had a winged lion in it!

[Paeyrus]

Valentine Z:

Clean, geometric forms for one central emblem. Good composition - easy to remember, and unique.

The colour contrast could be improved. Have you considered a different (shade of) primary colour?

6/10

[Peoples shara]

Valentine Z:

Clean, geometric forms for one central emblem. Good composition - easy to remember, and unique.

The colour contrast could be improved. Have you considered a different (shade of) primary colour?

6/10

scary, 2/10

[Paeyrus]

Valentine Z:

Clean, geometric forms for one central emblem. Good composition - easy to remember, and unique.

The colour contrast could be improved. Have you considered a different (shade of) primary colour?

6/10

scary, 2/10

Bland and unoriginal.

1/10

[Peoples shara]

scary, 2/10

Bland and unoriginal.

1/10

[Roegerland]

scary, 2/10

Bland and unoriginal.

1/10

5/10

It looks nice but the design is too complex for use on a national flag in my opinion.

Bland and unoriginal.

1/10

5/10

It's fine as a flag however it lacks creativity and originality, being very similar to some Iberian flags I've seen. Also the image seems to be of a low quality, it would be really easy to fix that.

[United Communal Burrow Republics]

9/10. Honestly, I love a flag trying to look like an IRL flag, and succeeding so greatly. Your flag has nice colors, nice structures, and just all around looks very solid. The use of existing common symbols is always great when it's done in a way that leaves your flag looking unique, and yours nails it. I don't have too much to really comment on improving, it just looks nice.

[Goraria]

Very good. I already rated your flag. 9.3/10

[Tsaivao]

8/10 - Pretty decent flag with good colors, but not really something I'd write home about

[Yeet Nationss]

9/10
Great colors and I really like the design.

[Saloniana]

9/10 Good style, nice clors, but the symbol does seem very complex for a flag

[Yeet Nationss]

9/10 Good style, nice clors, but the symbol does seem very complex for a flag

Mine or his???
/do me again
Edit: /skip

[Saloniana]

9/10 Good style, nice clors, but the symbol does seem very complex for a flag

Mine or his???
/do me again

No, i ment yours?/Skip