Valrifell wrote:Andsed wrote:If that it was it I could give it a pass. But then having Luke completely give up? That is what really breaks his character for me. Luke is the type to make mistakes, but he does not just give up like that. Especially when his loved ones are in danger. If it had been Luke had traveled to Ach-To to learn from his mistake and the ancient Jedi and consider what to do and he actually trained Rey and helped the resistance then it would sit a lot better with me.
Yeah, I agree. Having him meditate on looking to the past for solutions (instead of outright giving up) could also jive with the pre-existing themes of the movie. Plus it would make the scene with Yoda burning the sacred Jedi texts from beyond the grave and Luke's reaction... make a little more sense?
As for helping the Resistance? I don't think that would have ever been in the cards, meta/production-wise. Part of the overarching themes of the first two movies (haven't seen RoS) is handing stuff to a new generation. I think having him go out as a tricksy force-hologram was probably the best it was going to get for his final ending.
Fair enough, though I still think he should have at the least trained Rey.
Anyways, after re watching some Fallen Order things on Youtube I was reminded on another reason I love the game. The inquisitors are just so much better in the game. In Rebels they were just your average villain and pretty eh. In Fallen Order I was actively dreading fighting them for the first time(which is partially due to how I was still learning the game but the atmosphere of their first apprentices definitely contributed as well.) Not to mention the game really did emphasize their pretty tragic lives. Not surprisingly Trilla stood out but even the Ninth Sister got a line that emphasized how fucked up the Inquisitors backstories are. Some pretty good writing from Respawn imo.