NATION

PASSWORD

"Rock ‘N’ Roll Suicide", add additional options?

A place to spoil daily issues for those who haven't had them yet, snigger at typos, and discuss ideas for new ones.
User avatar
Romance and Reverie
Secretary
 
Posts: 40
Founded: Jun 13, 2020
Psychotic Dictatorship

"Rock ‘N’ Roll Suicide", add additional options?

Postby Romance and Reverie » Sun Jul 05, 2020 1:50 am

The Issue

The nation is in mourning after beloved cultural icon Johnny Brazeau was found dead of apparent suicide in his Tasmanian beachhouse. New details have emerged that his eccentric and happy-go-lucky public persona was masking chronic depression, thrusting mental illness into the public spotlight.

The Debate

1. “Clearly, Mr. Brazeau was suffering from severe depression,” says world-renowned psychiatrist Dr. Marlon Rubin. “This is symptomatic of a deep-seated epidemic of unreported mental illness across Arab League. Mental health services have been underfunded for decades, and it is about time that the government stepped in to provide proper mental healthcare for the nation. We desperately need evidence based CBT, more psychiatrists, and proper education to finally rid ourselves of this stigma surrounding mental health. You can’t put a price on the nation’s wellbeing.”

2. “Johnny Brazeau’s death is a tragedy, but we all know his songs contained subliminal pro-suicide messages,” says moral crusader Sierra Allen, who is well known for egging blasphemers and burning effigies of politicians. “People across Al Hiwariyya al oula now know that an idolized national treasure selfishly took his own life. What kind of message does that send, especially to kids? This shameless act is only going to convince them that suicide is cool. Suicide must be made illegal, and only the ultimate punishment will deter people from this sin. We need to teach our children that life, regardless of how much you’re suffering, is always the answer.”

3. “Haha, the freak finally did himself in. That’s very droll,” laughs insensitive city worker Ashley Fraser, who was recently laid off for making countless inappropriate jokes on the job. “Yes, of course people are down in this nation, but if you want to cheer us up, give the people a tax cut. Stop wasting money on welfare and all this mental health rubbish. Give us our money back, and we’ll make ourselves happy.”

4. “It’s a tragedy of course, but also an opportunity,” suggests professional spin doctor Elmo McDuck, handing you a bottle of fake tears. “If we play our cards right, we can create a distraction from hard-to-sell government policies. Make a speech with a single tear rolling down your cheek and visit the widow to bring a wreath and a spontaneous hug. We can make bad news work to improve your public image.”

5. Dismiss Issue

-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Dismissing issues feels worse than answering them, and I've probably only dismissed a handful so far. Up till now, the dismissals felt natural enough, as if I didn't care to make a decision, since I didn't care about the issue too much. So cool, dismissed. Encountering this one was different. I care very much about suicide, but none of the options align. Option One is for people who care, but not everyone puts stock in psychotherapy, not everyone has new age inclinations. The options make it so you either care, and want to help through psychotherapy, or you don't care, are rude/prude, and want to further your own goals.

Perhaps an option which wants frames the nation as sympathetic, and wants a solution to suicide indirectly. Create more parks, lessen workplace related stresses, create more opportunities for communal bonding like investing in festivities, strengthening national pride through whatever avenues, etc. I believe that if a person genuinely feels loved, feels like he belongs/is needed, and has purpose, he won't suicide even in hellish conditions. He'd have something to live for. It's more important to create such a condition than to try to (often falsely) convince a man that the world is sunshine and rainbows, just look it at a different way, and/or take these pills. That, and a bit of old-fashioned grit. I'm not the greatest wordsmith, so I don't know what an additional option ought to look like, I just think it'd be cool if there was one. I'll write one, since I'm asking for it, but I'm not advocating for it in particular, just something.

My option:

6. "Johnny Brazeau’s death is a tragedy. We'll never know exactly what led him to take such a drastic action, but if someone with such wealth and adulation commits suicide, maybe the deep-seated epidemic isn't unreported mental illness, but the structure of our society. All this mumbo jumbo about "Mental Health" and "Psychotherapy" is just Ivory Tower geezers and virtue-signaling teens driveling on. We need to create an environment where every [X]ian feels loved, needed, and appreciated. I'm not sure how exactly we'd go about this, but for starters, why not create a Department For Suicide Prevention By Making The Nation Awesomer. Sure it'll cost he taxpayers a pretty penny, but it's worth it.

EDIT

Looks like this is a pervasive problem at NationStates. Either you spend money on psychotherapy bullshit, or you don't care about depression. Got another issue which has the same problem with choices.

https://nsindex.net/wiki/NationStates_Issue_No._62
Last edited by Romance and Reverie on Mon Jul 06, 2020 6:57 am, edited 1 time in total.

User avatar
Candlewhisper Archive
Senior Issues Editor
 
Posts: 21767
Founded: Aug 28, 2015
Anarchy

Postby Candlewhisper Archive » Tue Jul 07, 2020 1:06 am

Nice thought process, though rather than add length to an existing issue I'd suggest you create a separate issue addressing exactly that question -- is mental healthcare the best way to address depression?

It sounds like you've thought about it, and if you can find some other approaches and viewpoints, I think you could have a good issue there.
editors like linguistic ambiguity more than most people

User avatar
Trotterdam
Powerbroker
 
Posts: 8848
Founded: Jan 12, 2012
Left-Leaning College State

Postby Trotterdam » Tue Jul 07, 2020 3:01 am

Candlewhisper Archive wrote:Nice thought process, though rather than add length to an existing issue I'd suggest you create a separate issue addressing exactly that question -- is mental healthcare the best way to address depression?

It sounds like you've thought about it, and if you can find some other approaches and viewpoints, I think you could have a good issue there.
Indeed. We already have several issues about depression (#62, #352, #496, #510, #576) and they pretty much always assume that it's a choice between "psychiatric care" and "let them kill themselves", so it seems arbitrary to single out #496 as the one to complain about (except that, presumably, it's the first one this player received).

#394 even points out problems with psychiatric care, but the only proposed solution (that isn't "ignore the problem to save money" or "corruptly cover it up") is more psychiatric care. If any of these issues warrants an update, that one should probably take priority.

Personally I'm of the attitude that if people are depressed, it's because their life is depressing. Proper care should involve figuring out what circumstances in their life they're depressed about and helping them fix it. (Or occasionally helping them come to terms with it and find something else worth living for, but that's definitely a plan B.) Telling them that their feelings are wrong (by calling them a "mental illness") is condescending.

That does seem pretty close to the option Romance and Reverie is suggesting. Though if it's going to be the subject of an entirely new issue, we probably want more than one not-covered-in-previous-issues approach.


Return to Got Issues?

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: Cain EH v0

Advertisement

Remove ads