Illegal GA Proposals 2nd edition

[Bears Armed]

Recognize Yangtianian Sovreignty

A resolution to restrict civil freedoms in the interest of moral decency.

Category: Moral Decency

Strength: Mild

Proposed by: Yangtian

A resolution to fullly recognise territorial sovreignty of the Empire of Yangtian and its right to exist containing the following guidelines:

1: The empire of Yangtian has full and undisputed territorial sovreignty on ALL of its territories also, no nation has the right to interfere in its internal affairs

2: Yangtian has the right to defend itself if treatened by using its armed forces at its own discretion and military action will not be taken against Yangtian UNLESS a resolution for it is approved BY A MAJORITY in both the general assembly and the security council in exchange Yangtian promises not to use any nuclear weapons AS LONG as this condition is respected including guideline 3

3: any military action taken against Yangtian after being voted for by a majority (SEE GUIDELINE 2) must be done with CONVENTIONAL WARFARE ONLY to ensure preservation and safety of all nations in the resulting conflict no chemical, biological or nuclear weapons are allowed in these interventions

Ummm ... branding

... and Category incorrect, Meta-gaming (mention of the SC in a GA proposal), and Game Mechanics (giving the GA and SC the ability to pass [joint?] resolutions about military activity involving a specific nation).

[The New California Republic]

Let Halander Help Developing Countries Advance Tech

A resolution to develop industry around the world.

Category: Advancement of Industry

Area of Effect: Commercial Enterprise

Proposed by: Halander

Halander has one of the biggest information Technology sectors in the South Pacific if not the world. We want to help struggling third world countries improve there technological advances because it is almost a necessity in the 21st century.
Let us do our part in contributing to the global stage and ensuring peace.

It's actually quite funny, as the claim that Halander makes about having one of the biggest information technology sectors in their region and the world is a complete and utter lie, being ranked 25,255th in the world and 783rd in their region: https://www.nationstates.net/nation=hal ... ensusid=13

[Araraukar]

*snip*

Roleplayed claim, maybe? I mean, GA proposals are RP creations...

[The New California Republic]

*snip*

Roleplayed claim, maybe? I mean, GA proposals are RP creations...

Could be I suppose. Just seemed oddly specific.

[Grays Harbor]

Repeal: “Defending The Rights Of Sexual And Gender Minorities”

A resolution to repeal previously passed legislation.

Category: Repeal

Resolution: GA#457

Proposed by: Sinyal

General Assembly Resolution #457 “defending the rights of sexual and gender minorities” (Category: Civil Rights; Strength: Significant) shall be struck out and rendered null and void.

This is unfair to countries want same-sex marriage to be banned. This one man cannot order us around.

natsov only

[Grays Harbor]

Plastic Prevention

A resolution to enact uniform standards that protect workers, consumers, and the general public.

Category: Regulation

Area of Effect: Energy

Proposed by: East Morey

The amount of of plastic in our oceans is on the rise. This is due to, littering on beaches and sewage. This policy would make all WA Nations use paper bags, paper straws and paper cups. This would also make all member nations to have at least one recycling plant within it's borders. Any stores that are within 5 miles of a beach would have to be forced to use the paper items listed earlier.
The above policies hereby implement plastic prevention.

How is this “regulation-energy”?

[The New Nordic Union]

General Assembly Proposal
ID: furballland_1560269580

Repeal: “World Assembly Justice Accord”
A resolution to repeal previously passed legislation.

Category: Repeal

Resolution: GA#466

Proposed by: Furballland

General Assembly Resolution #466 “World Assembly Justice Accord” (Category: Civil Rights; Strength: Strong) shall be struck out and rendered null and void.

Water Problem is Worsen , Save The Earth ad Stop Water Pollution to Stop Killing Animals!

Does not adress the target

General Assembly Proposal
ID: furballland_1560269751

Repeal: “World Assembly Justice Accord”
A resolution to repeal previously passed legislation.

Category: Repeal

Resolution: GA#466

Proposed by: Furballland

General Assembly Resolution #466 “World Assembly Justice Accord” (Category: Civil Rights; Strength: Strong) shall be struck out and rendered null and void.

Presidency of The World and The President of The Assembly

Neither does this

[Bears Armed]

Plastic Prevention

A resolution to enact uniform standards that protect workers, consumers, and the general public.

Category: Regulation

Area of Effect: Energy

Proposed by: East Morey

The amount of of plastic in our oceans is on the rise. This is due to, littering on beaches and sewage. This policy would make all WA Nations use paper bags, paper straws and paper cups. This would also make all member nations to have at least one recycling plant within it's borders. Any stores that are within 5 miles of a beach would have to be forced to use the paper items listed earlier.
The above policies hereby implement plastic prevention.

How is this “regulation-energy”?

It isn't.
Also, of course, "This _ would" doesn't.

General Assembly Proposal
ID: furballland_1560269580

Repeal: “World Assembly Justice Accord”
A resolution to repeal previously passed legislation.

Category: Repeal

Resolution: GA#466

Proposed by: Furballland

General Assembly Resolution #466 “World Assembly Justice Accord” (Category: Civil Rights; Strength: Strong) shall be struck out and rendered null and void.

Water Problem is Worsen , Save The Earth ad Stop Water Pollution to Stop Killing Animals!

Does not adress the target

General Assembly Proposal
ID: furballland_1560269751

Repeal: “World Assembly Justice Accord”
A resolution to repeal previously passed legislation.

Category: Repeal

Resolution: GA#466

Proposed by: Furballland

General Assembly Resolution #466 “World Assembly Justice Accord” (Category: Civil Rights; Strength: Strong) shall be struck out and rendered null and void.

Presidency of The World and The President of The Assembly

Neither does this

Right both times... and if the second one's author actually held the titles they're claiming then it would be Branding as well.

[Grays Harbor]

LGBT Parent Rights

A resolution to improve worldwide human and civil rights.

Category: Civil Rights

Strength: Mild

Proposed by: Ofasval

The World Assembly,

Protecting the rights of LGBT Parents to adopt children.

Noting that, discrimination against LGBT parents, as well as the allowance of LGBT parents to adopt children, is completely banned in several nationstates, it is to be resolved whether LGBT parents shall, or shall not be allowed to adopt children.

Concerned about lack of LGBT freedoms and non-discrimination laws,

The World Assembly Hereby:

1. Recognises all LGBT parents are legally allowed to adopt children of any age.

2. Requires all member states to allow LGBT parents to adopt children

3. Renders disallowance of adoption from any one person(s), illegal and resulting in punishment to be determined by the individual nationstate.

Wouldn’t the majority of this already be covered by 297?

[Araraukar]

LGBT Parent Rights

A resolution to improve worldwide human and civil rights.

Category: Civil Rights

Strength: Mild

Proposed by: Ofasval

The World Assembly,

Protecting the rights of LGBT Parents to adopt children.

Noting that, discrimination against LGBT parents, as well as the allowance of LGBT parents to adopt children, is completely banned in several nationstates, it is to be resolved whether LGBT parents shall, or shall not be allowed to adopt children.

Concerned about lack of LGBT freedoms and non-discrimination laws,

The World Assembly Hereby:

1. Recognises all LGBT parents are legally allowed to adopt children of any age.

2. Requires all member states to allow LGBT parents to adopt children

3. Renders disallowance of adoption from any one person(s), illegal and resulting in punishment to be determined by the individual nationstate.

Wouldn’t the majority of this already be covered by 297?

And CoCR.

[BlackLight Covenant]

Repeal: “World Assembly Justice Accord”
A resolution to repeal previously passed legislation.

Category: Repeal

Resolution: GA#466

Proposed by: Beikou

General Assembly Resolution #466 “World Assembly Justice Accord” (Category: Civil Rights; Strength: Strong) shall be struck out and rendered null and void.

Countries should be able to treat their citizens how they like.

NatSov-only repeal.

[Grays Harbor]

Prohibition Of Anti-Religious Bias

A resolution to improve worldwide human and civil rights.

Category: Civil Rights

Strength: Strong

Proposed by: The Fun Kingdom of Kawhi Leonard

The World Assembly,

RECOGNISING that "issues" are a key part of NationStates including the formation of nations and their respective policies.

AWARE that nations' policies and data are created through these issues.

UNDERSTANDING that the WA and NationStates attempt to allow freedom of choice when it comes to policies such as but not limited to; Financial Systems (Capitalism, Communism), Political Motives (Conservative, Liberal), and/or War strategy.

CONCERNED that the choices of leader(s), particularly ones of Conservative mindsets, tend to induce negative effects upon their nations.

FURTHER CONCERNED that NationStates is beginning to favour democratic, capitalist, and liberal leaders.

HEREBY,

1. Demands The WA and NationStates shall revitalise issues so Conservative ideals don't intersect with generally positive aspects of a nation. (e.g. Lower Taxes shouldn't equal lower HDI)

2. Demands The WA and NationStates shall not have Pro-Religious choices negatively effect Intelligence.

3. Enforces The WA shall not be permitted to pass further anti-religious legislation.

4. Prohibits the WA Security Council from passing legislation condemning preemptive self-defence.

5. Encourages NationStates to quickly amend issues and/or options which contain negative bias to Pro-Religious and/or Pro-Conservative leaning nations.

Metagaming, Game Mechanics

[Grays Harbor]

Prohibition Of Anti-Religious Bias II

A resolution to improve worldwide human and civil rights.

Category: Civil Rights

Strength: Significant

Proposed by: The Fun Kingdom of Kawhi Leonard

The World Assembly,

RECOGNISING that Gensec plays a key role in the prevention of illegal proposals getting to the public.

AWARE that Gensec's members attempt to stay unbiased.

UNDERSTANDING that the WA and NationStates attempt to allow freedom of choice when it comes to policies such as but not limited to; Financial Systems (Capitalism, Communism), Political Motives (Conservative, Liberal), and/or War strategy.

CONCERNED that the proposals of leader(s), particularly ones of Conservative mindsets, tend to become illegal.

FURTHER CONCERNED that NationStates is beginning to favour democratic, capitalist, and liberal leaders.

HEREBY,

1. Demands The WA creates legislation to uphold religious freedoms.

2. Demands The WA shall not have Pro-Religious nations be unfairly treated.

3. Enforces The WA shall not be permitted to pass further anti-religious legislation.

4. Prohibits the WA Security Council from passing legislation condemning preemptive self-defence.

5. Encourages the WA to quickly review whether or not Gensec members are truly unbiased towards Conservative and/or religious nations.

Looks like a pile of metagaming

[Araraukar]

Looks like a pile of metagaming

And the bits that aren't, are duplication and a blocker.

[BlackLight Covenant]

Proposal For Prevention Of Economic Monopolies
A resolution to enact uniform standards that protect workers, consumers, and the general public.

Category: Regulation

Area of Effect: Legal Reform

Proposed by: United States of America and West Europe

The World Assembly,

Aware that bureaucratic elites hold a near monopoly on the media and banking.

Believing that their influence is dangerous and unlawful.

Acknowledging that efforts have been made to prevent this in the past.

Further Acknowledging that vast majority of these attempts has failed.

Concerned that World Assembly member nations are being controlled by undemocratic, bureaucrats without regard to personal freedom or the democratic process.

Believing that, for our betterment of all nations and securing the democratic process, steps should be made to end this.

Understanding that many of these bureaucrats have already risen to power within select member nations.

Hereby,

Defines a monopoly as any entity with sole control over the productions and distribution of goods or services.

Further Defines a bureaucrat as any person who participates in monopolies on political power while subverting the democratic process.

Urges the member-states of the World Assembly to place restrictions on companies to disallow them from influencing politics and prevent monopolies.

Encourages members of the World Assembly to forcibly shut down these companies if necessary.

Allows that force be used if said companies harbour a pseudo-military force,

Urges member-states to not allow companies to own monopolies on production and distribution of goods and services.

Prohibits governments from taking direct control of companies, thereby subverting the ideals of capitalism.

Grants the World Assembly to become involved if necessary.

Encourages the World Assembly to use further preventative measures to keep monopolies out of the hands of companies

Requires the World Assembly allow the capitalistic process to take place without subverting it.

Might be an ideology ban, seeing how it aims to force capitalism upon all members. Not sure, tho.

[Bears Armed]

Proposal For Prevention Of Economic Monopolies
A resolution to enact uniform standards that protect workers, consumers, and the general public.

Category: Regulation

Area of Effect: Legal Reform

Proposed by: United States of America and West Europe

The World Assembly,

Aware that bureaucratic elites hold a near monopoly on the media and banking.

Believing that their influence is dangerous and unlawful.

Acknowledging that efforts have been made to prevent this in the past.

Further Acknowledging that vast majority of these attempts has failed.

Concerned that World Assembly member nations are being controlled by undemocratic, bureaucrats without regard to personal freedom or the democratic process.

Believing that, for our betterment of all nations and securing the democratic process, steps should be made to end this.

Understanding that many of these bureaucrats have already risen to power within select member nations.

Hereby,

Defines a monopoly as any entity with sole control over the productions and distribution of goods or services.

Further Defines a bureaucrat as any person who participates in monopolies on political power while subverting the democratic process.

Urges the member-states of the World Assembly to place restrictions on companies to disallow them from influencing politics and prevent monopolies.

Encourages members of the World Assembly to forcibly shut down these companies if necessary.

Allows that force be used if said companies harbour a pseudo-military force,

Urges member-states to not allow companies to own monopolies on production and distribution of goods and services.

Prohibits governments from taking direct control of companies, thereby subverting the ideals of capitalism.

Grants the World Assembly to become involved if necessary.

Encourages the World Assembly to use further preventative measures to keep monopolies out of the hands of companies

Requires the World Assembly allow the capitalistic process to take place without subverting it.

Might be an ideology ban, seeing how it aims to force capitalism upon all members. Not sure, tho.

No.
"Urges" and "Ecnourages" aren't strong enough to ban anything, and although the "Prohibits" clause keeps governments from "taking direct control of" existing companies it could reasonably be read as applying only to companies that somebody else has already set up and not banning the governments from setting up such organisations themselves. Also, it's possible to have forms of communism in which it isn't the government that controls industries... In fact, in Marxism that 's actually supposed to be the end-result of the process.
What this is illegal for however, is Incorrect Category.

[BlackLight Covenant]

Might be an ideology ban, seeing how it aims to force capitalism upon all members. Not sure, tho.

No.
"Urges" and "Ecnourages" aren't strong enough to ban anything, and although the "Prohibits" clause keeps governments from "taking direct control of" existing companies it could reasonably be read as applying only to companies that somebody else has already set up and not banning the governments from setting up such organisations themselves. Also, it's possible to have forms of communism in which it isn't the government that controls industries... In fact, in Marxism that 's actually supposed to be the end-result of the process.
What this is illegal for however, is Incorrect Category.

Ah, fair enough. My apologies for that one.

[Araraukar]

So a proposal that only encouraged and urged complete secularism of the government and legislation, would not be ideological ban of theocracies? Good to know.

[Grays Harbor]

Debates Should Take Place

A resolution to increase democratic freedoms.

Category: Furtherment of Democracy

Strength: Significant

Proposed by: Erdenhalk

Debates should be held in battle for board roles. This will help because the voters could decide more surely what to choose. Also, these debates will advance our democracy much more than before.

Not quite sure what they are talking about. The forum? Anyhow, not written as law.

[Grays Harbor]

SECURITY REFORM BILL

A resolution to improve world security by boosting police and military budgets.

Category: International Security

Strength: Strong

Proposed by: NEALVILLA

We need to focus on the security of our people by building a stronger military and focus on law and order. Our people safety is very important and would hate for any terroristic attack on anyone. Manufacturing more weapons would be a tremendous help.

Does nothing

[Bears Armed]

Debates Should Take Place

A resolution to increase democratic freedoms.

Category: Furtherment of Democracy

Strength: Significant

Proposed by: Erdenhalk

Debates should be held in battle for board roles. This will help because the voters could decide more surely what to choose. Also, these debates will advance our democracy much more than before.

Not quite sure what they are talking about. The forum? Anyhow, not written as law.

Raiding?

[Grays Harbor]

The International Green Deal

A resolution to increase the quality of the world's environment, at the expense of industry.

Category: Environmental

Industry Affected: All Businesses - Mild

Proposed by: Otrait

Recently, throughout most Nations there have been alarmingly increasing/decreasing temperature rates. This environmental/climate change has forced our nation, the Holy Kingdom of Otrait to talk up about the current situation and to declare this as an environmental crisis. Our nation suggests the Green Deal. A deal aiming to terminate climate change and all effects of global warming. This deal consists of several points which require global unity and cooperation, in order to achieve our ultimate goal which is the termination of global warming. The main points of the deal are:
• All nations shall come together and unite their efforts in the protection of our planet, leaving behind all current feuds and affairs that might threaten our cause.
• All nations are required to provide funding for our efforts which include research, cleanups and other activities.
• Nations that depend on resources or activities that harm the environment will receive a specific amount of money in order to cover all fees. Additionally, all counties should keep their harmful activities to a minimum or put an end to them.
• All countries are required to introduce changes to the harmful lifestyles of their civilians including solar panel energy instead of burning fossil fuels, turbines and other means.
• All nations that are willing to show corporation will join an ecological union of some sorts that protects all actions made by other nations and to insure harmony.
• Lastly, all civilians’ rights will be protected especially the ones that have any type of connection to the mining industry, fossil fuels industry and etc. The individuals that lose their jobs due to this deal will be trained in special centres within the country that focuses on environmental change of every kind and later on they will be assigned to facilities that they will work at.
This deal requires all countries to show willingness and cooperation. Time is running out and we have to act now before it’s too late.

The branding renders this automatically illegal. Everything else is just icing.

[Araraukar]

The individuals that lose their jobs due to this deal will be trained in special centres within the country that focuses on environmental change of every kind and later on they will be assigned to facilities that they will work at.

The branding renders this automatically illegal. Everything else is just icing.[/quote]
Well, the icing is contradiction with a side dish of slavery, so I'm not sure I want to lick the bowl.

[Grays Harbor]

The individuals that lose their jobs due to this deal will be trained in special centres within the country that focuses on environmental change of every kind and later on they will be assigned to facilities that they will work at.

The branding renders this automatically illegal. Everything else is just icing.

Well, the icing is contradiction with a side dish of slavery, so I'm not sure I want to lick the bowl. [/quote]
It has to be baked first.

[Araraukar]

It has to be baked first.

You don't bake icing! ...not that I think I'd like the taste of slavery, whether baked or not...