Constructively Rate the flag above you: VII

[Robosia]

#6 is at 500, so here we go.

No one above me.

[Gowinia]

The Sixth Thread has now reached page 500, which means it is time for the Seventh Iteration of this game.
Rate the AN's flag out of ten, and reason your rating.

[Arkhadiam]

8/10

Great color combination and noice dragon, but it doesn't appeal to me all that much for some reason. Still neat tough.

[Maisiestan]

8/10

Great color combination and noice dragon, but it doesn't appeal to me all that much for some reason. Still neat tough.

6/10. colors go well together and the animal looks good, but the text is kind of bland and awful.

[Greater Free Oceania]

6/10

The lizard is weird and overcomplicated

[Arkhadiam]

6/10

The lizard is weird and overcomplicated

Commie lizard deserves better than that

/skip

[Priobalslavia]

6/10

The lizard is weird and overcomplicated

8/10, unusual colors for a flag, but, they work well.

[New United States of Columbia]

7/10
A tad generic Eastern Bloc design but still a nice use of colors

[Whiiteria]

9/10

The design is simple, yet the colors are very appealing.

[Republic of Altos and Stratis]

8/10 Your design is a bit complicated but good use of colors, except the black is a tad hard to see on the blue.

[Draos]

8/10 Your design is a bit complicated but good use of colors, except the black is a tad hard to see on the blue.

Simple design but a tad too many colors most you should really use is 3 plus the Coat of Arms is kinda small and hard to see 5/10

[Aaaaaa]

Video game made fictional countries have been on a roll lately with their national flags, and Arma 3 is no different, I've always liked the Altis flag, and putting the armed forces flag crest on what you're using looks really good IMO, 9/10.

DAMMIT NINJADSUDSUDSIDBSID

8/10 Your design is a bit complicated but good use of colors, except the black is a tad hard to see on the blue.

Simple design but a tad too many colors most you should really use is 3 plus the Coat of Arms is kinda small and hard to see 5/10

I really like the green-black combo, and the shield intersecting the quadrilaterals is very unique, the lion-thing on the other hand... looks absolutely ridiculous. 7/10.

[Draos]

Video game made fictional countries have been on a roll lately with their national flags, and Arma 3 is no different, I've always liked the Altis flag, and putting the armed forces flag crest on what you're using looks really good IMO, 9/10.

DAMMIT NINJADSUDSUDSIDBSID

Simple design but a tad too many colors most you should really use is 3 plus the Coat of Arms is kinda small and hard to see 5/10

I really like the green-black combo, and the shield intersecting the quadrilaterals is very unique, the lion-thing on the other hand... looks absolutely ridiculous. 7/10.

it's a manticore a creature from Persian and Greek Mythologies
/skip

[Arkhadiam]

Video game made fictional countries have been on a roll lately with their national flags, and Arma 3 is no different, I've always liked the Altis flag, and putting the armed forces flag crest on what you're using looks really good IMO, 9/10.

DAMMIT NINJADSUDSUDSIDBSID

Simple design but a tad too many colors most you should really use is 3 plus the Coat of Arms is kinda small and hard to see 5/10

I really like the green-black combo, and the shield intersecting the quadrilaterals is very unique, the lion-thing on the other hand... looks absolutely ridiculous. 7/10.

Not at all like an actual nation flag. Too nonsense.

10/10

[Broader Confederate States]

It's very intricate, which is a huge no-no in vexillological circles.

Doesn't stop it from not looking too bad, though, so I'll hand it a 6.5/10.

[Broader Confederate States]

Stop with the words 3/10

[Arkhadiam]

Stop with the words 3/10

Words on flags are awful indeed, but I took "a bit" of inspiration on the flag of the Free Territory of Ukraine (the one with the skull), so I just went with words like they did

/skip

[Valehart]

Stop with the words 3/10

I like it, personally the colours are pretty appealing to me.

8.5/10

[Vadterland]

Broader Confederate States:
8/10. Good use of contrasting colors and patternry, and a good design in general. However, the canton feels almost a bit too large.

Valehart:
8/10. Weird design, but I kinda like it. The colors are good, you can never go wrong with black and white, and despite the general asymmetry and odd placement of the stars it has a good aesthetic.

Here's my flag without the nazi loli, in case anyone decides to complain about that like usual.

[The Allied Andromeda Systems]

Broader Confederate States:
8/10. Good use of contrasting colors and patternry, and a good design in general. However, the canton feels almost a bit too large.

Valehart:
8/10. Weird design, but I kinda like it. The colors are good, you can never go wrong with black and white, and despite the general asymmetry and odd placement of the stars it has a good aesthetic.

Here's my flag without the nazi loli, in case anyone decides to complain about that like usual.

4.5/10 it's okay-ish. Bit too much going on on the flag overall, though.

[Arkhadiam]

7.5/10

Looks good, but I think simpler would be better.

[Gowinia]

7/10 - It looks good and simplistic, but putting text in a flag is a sin.

[The Burke Islands]

I really, really like it, but the overlay is a bit unnecessary. 8/10

[Frievolk]

The red banner with two stars makes it look better than it normally would. While ethically... questionable, the flag is still pretty nice. I'd give it 8/10

[Astoriya]

7/10