Cormactopia Prime wrote:I do agree with you though that some of these nominations have not been nearly detailed enough, and my hope is that the judges will just not even consider nominations that don't meet the rule they made very clear, which is that nominations must include detailed reasons.
All nominations are considered (public as well as ones judges make among themselves) regardless of how detailed of an explanation was provided. It is just helpful to have reasons for the judges to review and gives the nominee more of an advantage in the consideration.