[Draft]Against Enemies of the World Assembly

[First Nightmare]

Knowing that member states face many threats,
Unwilling to form a full defensive pact between its members, due to national security concerns, bad financing incentives and national sovereignity issues,
Aware, however, of threats that transcend ordinary threats,
Yearning to prevent member states from financing enemies of the World Assembly,

the World Assembly resolves:

1. Any state willingly supporting or performing an armed attack in or on the World Assembly Headquarters is a permanent enemy of the World Assembly.
2. Any state declaring war against the World Assembly is an enemy of the World Assembly.
3. Any state that attempts to, or succeeds in, making uninhabitable or destroying planets including (destroyed) World Assembly nation is an enemy of the World Assembly.
4. Any state that continues to develop, or uses, uncontrollable biological weapons aimed at destroying species vital for the health of a planet or nation, or sapient species, is a permanent enemy of the World Assembly. Member states are urged and allowed to perform any action necessary to prevent the usage of these biological weapons. The apparent necessity of such an action is a total defense against any criminal or civil proceedings, but whoever willingly engages in deception aimed at simulating such necessity is guilty of all offenses resulting of this deception.
5. Any state declared to be an enemy of the World Assembly is at war with every nation in the World Assembly.
6. The state of war against a permanent enemy of the World Assembly ends when that state ceases to exist, or is defeated by a member state and its territory is subsequently integrated in that member state and/or other states who are not enemies of the World Assembly.
7. The World Assembly General Committee shall be created. It shall be staffed by one delegated person for each member state adopting this resolution who share decision-making power per majority vote, and necessary staff not having final decision-making power.
   
   1. The World Assembly General Committee shall be tasked with any duties of the World Assembly not delegated to another World Assembly organ, such as committees or courts.
   2. The World Assembly General Committee shall be tasked with making peace treaties(upon request) with enemies of the World Assembly who are not permanent enemies. Such peace treaties shall demand restitution by the offending state, including an additional fine, and political changes that reduce the chances of it happening again. A successful peace treaty ends the status as enemy of the World Assembly.
8. Other WA member states and organs of the World Assembly are banned from allowing trade with, and giving aid to, enemies of the World Assembly(This does not include making peace treaties).
9. Being a World Assembly member nation does not prevent that nation from being an enemy of the World Assembly.

Knowing that member states face many threats,
Unwilling to form a full defensive pact between its members, due to national security concerns, bad financing incentives and national sovereignity issues,
Aware, however, of threats that transcend ordinary threats,
Yearning to prevent member states from financing enemies of the World Assembly,

the World Assembly resolves:

1. Any state willingly supporting or performing an armed attack in or on the World Assembly Headquarters is a permanent enemy of the World Assembly.
2. Any state declaring war against the World Assembly is an enemy of the World Assembly.
3. Any state that attempts to, or succeeds in, making inhabitable or destroying planets including (destroyed) World Assembly nation is an enemy of the World Assembly.
4. Any state that continues to develop, or uses, uncontrollable biological weapons aimed at destroying species vital for the health of a planet or nation, or sapient species, is a permanent enemy of the World Assembly. Member states are urged and allowed to perform any action necessary to prevent the usage of these biological weapons. The apparent necessity of such an action is a total defense against any criminal or civil proceedings, but whoever willingly engages in deception aimed at simulating such necessity is guilty of all offenses resulting of this deception.
5. The state of war against a permanent enemy of the World Assembly ends when that state ceases to exist, or is defeated by a member state and its territory is subsequently integrated in that member state and/or other states who are not enemies of the World Assembly.
6. The World Assembly General Committee shall be created. It shall be staffed by one delegated person for each member state adopting this resolution who share decision-making power per majority vote, and necessary staff not having final decision-making power.
   
   1. The World Assembly General Committee shall be tasked with any duties of the World Assembly not delegated to another World Assembly organ, such as committees or courts.
   2. The World Assembly General Committee shall be tasked with making peace treaties(upon request) with enemies of the World Assembly who are not permanent enemies. Such peace treaties shall demand restitution by the offending state, including an additional fine, and political changes that reduce the chances of it happening again. A successful peace treaty ends the status as enemy of the World Assembly.
7. Other WA member states and organs of the World Assembly are banned from allowing trade with, and giving aid to, enemies of the World Assembly(This does not include the World Assembly General Committee making peace treaties).
8. Being a World Assembly member nation does not prevent that nation from being an enemy of the World Assembly.

Knowing that member states face many threats,
Unwilling to form a full defensive pact between its members, due to national security concerns, bad financing incentives and national sovereignity issues,
Aware, however, of threats that transcend ordinary threats,
Yearning to prevent member states from financing enemies of the World Assembly,

the World Assembly resolves:

1. Any state willingly supporting or performing an armed attack in or on the World Assembly Headquarters is an enemy of the World Assembly.
2. Any state declaring war against the World Assembly is an enemy of the World Assembly.
3. Any state that attempts to, or succeeds in, making uninhabitable or destroying planets including (destroyed) World Assembly nation is an enemy of the World Assembly.
4. Any state that continues to develop, or uses, uncontrollable biological weapons aimed at destroying species vital for the health of a planet or nation, or sapient species, is a permanent enemy of the World Assembly. Member states are urged and allowed to perform any action necessary to prevent the usage of these biological weapons. The apparent necessity of such an action is a total defense against any criminal or civil proceedings, but whoever willingly engages in deception aimed at simulating such necessity is guilty of all offenses resulting of this deception.
5. The state of war against a permanent enemy of the World Assembly ends when that state ceases to exist, or is defeated by a member state and its territory is subsequently integrated in that member state and/or other states who are not enemies of the World Assembly; or if it is defeated by a member state, and subsequently administered temporarily by a member state or member states until the enemy state is very unlikely to engage in any of the acts leading to a state becoming an enemy of the World Assembly.
6. The World Assembly General Committee shall be created. It shall be staffed by one delegated person for each member state adopting this resolution who share decision-making power per majority vote, and necessary staff not having final decision-making power.
   
   1. The World Assembly General Committee shall be tasked with any duties of the World Assembly not delegated to another World Assembly organ, such as committees or courts.
   2. The World Assembly General Committee shall be tasked with making peace treaties(upon request) with enemies of the World Assembly who are not permanent enemies. Such peace treaties shall demand restitution by the offending state, including an additional fine, and political changes that reduce the chances of it happening again. A successful peace treaty ends the status as enemy of the World Assembly.
7. Other WA member states and organs of the World Assembly are banned from allowing trade with, and giving aid to, enemies of the World Assembly(This does not include the World Assembly General Committee making peace treaties).
8. Being a World Assembly member nation does not prevent that nation from being an enemy of the World Assembly, however, World Assembly nations are prohibited from trying to become an enemy of the World Assembly.

Knowing that member states face many threats,
Unwilling to form a full defensive pact between its members, due to national security concerns, bad financing incentives and national sovereignity issues,
Aware, however, of threats that transcend ordinary threats,
Yearning to prevent member states from financing enemies of the World Assembly,

the World Assembly resolves:

1. Any state willingly supporting or performing an armed attack in or on the World Assembly Headquarters is an enemy of the World Assembly.
2. Any state declaring war against the World Assembly is an enemy of the World Assembly.
3. Any state that attempts to, or succeeds in, making uninhabitable or destroying planets including (destroyed) World Assembly nation is an enemy of the World Assembly.
4. Any state that continues to develop, or uses, uncontrollable biological weapons aimed at destroying species vital for the health of a planet or nation, or sapient species, is a permanent enemy of the World Assembly. Member states are urged and allowed to perform any action necessary to prevent the usage of these biological weapons. The credibly apparent necessity of such an action is a total defense against any criminal or civil proceedings, but whoever willingly engages in deception aimed at simulating such necessity is guilty of all criminal offenses resulting of this deception, and cannot claim credibly apparent necessity as a defense.
5. The World Assembly is at war with nations who are enemies of the World Assembly. This does not necessarily extend to individual member nations.
6. The state of war against a permanent enemy of the World Assembly ends when that state ceases to exist, or is defeated by a member state and its territory is subsequently integrated in that member state and/or other states who are not enemies of the World Assembly; or if it is defeated by a member state, and subsequently administered temporarily by a member state or member states until the enemy state is very unlikely to engage in any of the acts leading to a state becoming an enemy of the World Assembly.
7. The World Assembly General Committee shall be created. It shall be staffed by one delegated person for each member state adopting this resolution who share decision-making power per majority vote, and necessary staff not having final decision-making power.
   
   1. The World Assembly General Committee shall be tasked with any duties of the World Assembly not delegated to another World Assembly organ, such as committees or courts.
   2. The World Assembly General Committee shall be tasked with making peace treaties(upon request) with enemies of the World Assembly who are not permanent enemies. Such peace treaties shall demand restitution by the offending state, including an additional fine, and political changes that reduce the chances of it happening again. A successful peace treaty ends the status as enemy of the World Assembly.
8. Other WA member states and organs of the World Assembly are banned from allowing trade with, and giving aid to, enemies of the World Assembly(This does not include the World Assembly General Committee making peace treaties).
9. Being a World Assembly member nation does not prevent that nation from being an enemy of the World Assembly, however, World Assembly nations are prohibited from trying to become an enemy of the World Assembly.

[Bhang Bhang Duc]

I mean I’ve seen you come up with some shit but this takes the biscuit.

[First Nightmare]

I mean I’ve seen you come up with some shit but this takes the biscuit.

The following statement is as supported by arguments as yours:
This draft is absolutely perfect and has no flaws whatsoever, and will be very popular.

[Lipizia]

Please stop making ******
Anyway, in clause 3 there Is "everyone that succeeds in making inhabitable planets Is and enemy of the WA."
What sence has this?!?!
In clause 5 "Enemies of WA are in war with every WA nation"
An enormous violation of national sovereignty. Why should I fight with enemies cause of a stupid resolutions and make people DIE for It? Why should I spend money for it?
Obviously Strongly against .

[First Nightmare]

Please stop making ******
Anyway, in clause 3 there Is "everyone that succeeds in making inhabitable planets Is and enemy of the WA."
What sence has this?!?!
In clause 5 "Enemies of WA are in war with every WA nation"
An enormous violation of national sovereignty. Why should I fight with enemies cause of a stupid resolutions and make people DIE for It? Why should I spend money for it?
Obviously Strongly against .

We have removed this clause. You are still prohibited from giving them aid.

[Bonderovia]

4-Allow nukes on bioweapon users?Clarify
5-Forced land integration?
8-Makes the proposal ineffective

[First Nightmare]

4-Allow nukes on bioweapon users?Clarify
5-Forced land integration?
8-Makes the proposal ineffective

4-IF it is necessary.
5-Good point, will change slightly.
8-Changing that a bit.

[Chum Chum]

Joke proposals go in here please

[First Nightmare]

Joke proposals go in here please

OOC: What makes you think this is a joke proposal?

[Lipizia]

Joke proposals go in here please

No, he/She is serious. First Nightmare (or Old Hope) always makes madness.

[First Nightmare]

Please stop making ******
Anyway, in clause 3 there Is "everyone that succeeds in making inhabitable planets Is and enemy of the WA."
What sence has this?!?!
In clause 5 "Enemies of WA are in war with every WA nation"
An enormous violation of national sovereignty. Why should I fight with enemies cause of a stupid resolutions and make people DIE for It? Why should I spend money for it?
Obviously Strongly against .

Have your concerns been alleviated or are there further issues in need to be sorted out?

[Lipizia]

snip

Have your concerns been alleviated or are there further issues in need to be sorted out?

Clause 8 is strange, and the thing of permanent enemies puzzles me, but I admit you improved a lot.
Neutral.

[Kshemarashtram]

This is definitely not as fun as your previous proposal

A comment:

(clause 4)
The apparent necessity of such an action is a total defense against any criminal or civil proceedings, but whoever willingly engages in deception aimed at simulating such necessity is guilty of all offenses resulting of this deception.

The fact that it says "apparent necessity ... is a total defense against any criminal or civil proceedings" may contradict the following part of "deception aimed at simulating such necessity is guilty&c.". "Apparent" means that it may not be real, so any member state can dodge accountability by saying the threat seemed apparent at the moment even though it wasn't an actual threat. Who decides deceitful intent, and in what manner?

Also, it isn't clarified what "all offenses resulting of this deception" refers to.

[First Nightmare]

This is definitely not as fun as your previous proposal

A comment:

(clause 4)
The apparent necessity of such an action is a total defense against any criminal or civil proceedings, but whoever willingly engages in deception aimed at simulating such necessity is guilty of all offenses resulting of this deception.

The fact that it says "apparent necessity ... is a total defense against any criminal or civil proceedings" may contradict the following part of "deception aimed at simulating such necessity is guilty&c.". "Apparent" means that it may not be real, so any member state can dodge accountability by saying the threat seemed apparent at the moment even though it wasn't an actual threat. Who decides deceitful intent, and in what manner?

Also, it isn't clarified what "all offenses resulting of this deception" refers to.

Yes, true.... maybe...
would

credible apparent necessity

be better? The problem with strict liability is that, well, we do not want member states be hindered in preventing mass extinction events. The other one could be changed as well, thanks for feedback.

Have your concerns been alleviated or are there further issues in need to be sorted out?

Clause 8 is strange, and the thing of permanent enemies puzzles me, but I admit you improved a lot.
Neutral.

Clause 8 takes into account that states may become member states at any time, and the World Assembly cannot hinder them from becoming one. Member states must not try to become an enemy of the World Assembly, but they could already be one when they join.

[Fachumonn]

Every time I think it can't get worse, it does.

I don't know how you can take yourself serious.

[First Nightmare]

We have received constructive criticism which we could - mostly - address.
However, we have also received multiple negative comments with no substance whatsoever.
Like...

Every time I think it can't get worse, it does.

I don't know how you can take yourself serious.

Are there additional issues with this draft or are those nations not willing to share their reasons because those might be unpopular?

[Kshemarashtram]

Yes, true.... maybe...
would

credible apparent necessity

be better?

Hmm, would be better. Who determines credibility though? Some WA branch? Who would be the members of those branch, and how will any possible bias be prevented? It is quite possible that one member state (which is a part of such a panel that determines "credibility") may leverage its influence against another member state and deliberately give wrong decisions on "credibility" so as to declare them an "enemy of the WA" or whatever.

The other one could be changed as well, thanks for feedback.

Yeah, please clarify what offenses are being referred to.

Also, for the sake of my eyes, please use some line breaks

Edit: Sorry, I see that "line breaks" may be interpreted as simply going to the next line. What I meant is, leave a blank line between any two distinct clauses so that it doesn't appear a giant wall of text.