OOC: As submitted:
In response to the recently legislated resolution "Affordable Transgender Hormone Therapy" some points as to why this resolution should be immediately repealed are presented to the World Assembly member-nations:
I. It demands that all World Assembly member-nations have as written:" easy-to-access way for its transgender population to access hormone therapy" without any regard of the financial state some World Assembly members may be in. In order for the nations to carry into effect this resolution, they must set aside from their national fund or increase taxes on their citizens so that the required facilities are built, the requested medications are bought and professionals in this sphere are recruited, trained or sent for specialization. These actions will, in no doubt, prove very costly to some nations.
II. The proposed as fact №3 statement: "Their first-hand accounts of this understanding are real; each person is in the best position to understand and discern their own gender identity." cannot be accepted as one as there are many cases of people with autism, schizophrenia or dissociative identity disorder (which are undeniably classified as mental illnesses), who under the impact of their illness identify themselves as a member of the opposite sex or something in-between and demand that their bodies be altered . The proposed and accepted resolution will force medical persons to perform a hormone therapy on patients, who have not made this choice of their own sanity. And the fact alone that they identify themselves as transgender people will be enough to tie the hands of both medical specialists and jurists because of this resolution, which so formulated, allows it.
III. This resolution does not take into account the various cultures, religions and scientific development of all the World Assembly member-nations. It demands that all nations recognize transgender people as sain or existing, which may contradict their official religion, to which
98% of the populace may belong. Furthermore enforcing the legislation of such a resolution can be seen as a threat to the national sovereignty of certain nations as it will also force governments to change the laws, which govern such cases. This may result in protests and riots from citizens, who feel betrayed because the government they have democratically chosen, accepts laws controversial to the ideals it was chosen to represent and defend.
IV. The required laws cannot be enforced if the judiciary of a certain state deems them unconstitutional, thus making the legislation of this resolution both impractical and impossible without violating the law of a certain nation.
Broken into parts for feedback:
without any regard of the financial state some World Assembly members may be in
Which goes for the vast majority of resolutions.
they must set aside from their national fund or increase taxes on their citizens so that the required facilities are built
Outright lying means Honest Mistake, funny as it sounds. The target does not require any building of facilities. Like, I can't even imagine where you pulled this one out of. Also, no taxes were mentioned, and the WA literally cannot directly affect member nations' tax policies to begin with, because of NEF.
the requested medications are bought and professionals in this sphere are recruited, trained or sent for specialization
Again, what the fuck are you talking about? It only requires hormones to be affordable to the individual, it doesn't require the nation to buy them. Also, again, what "professionals in this sphere"? You should already have endocrinologists (people specialized in hormones) just for your normal healthcare needs, as well as pharmacists (people specialized in handing out/selling the medications), again for your normal healthcare needs. Estrogen exists in simple pill form and testosterone in a salve you spread on the skin and let it be absorbed from there. Both are ways of taking the medication that the individual can do themselves.
The proposed as fact №3 statement:
You have broken code there. The submission form doesn't understand macros.
"Their first-hand accounts of this understanding are real; each person is in the best position to understand and discern their own gender identity." cannot be accepted as one as there are many cases of people with autism, schizophrenia or dissociative identity disorder (which are undeniably classified as mental illnesses)
Whether you want to accept it or not, the target proposal does not assert that, it's simply repeating it to be in compliance with a previous resolution. So trying to use your inability to deal with facts as a reason, runs into the problem of there now being TWO resolutions that say it's not a mental illness and cannot be classified as such.
Also,
autism is a developmental disorder, not mental illness.
Dissociate identity disorder and
schizophrenia are, but have literally nothing to do with gender dysphoria or being transgender. It's like complaining that
chickens are proof that
apples don't exist.
who under the impact of their illness identify themselves as a member of the opposite sex or something in-between
Transgender people
can have the abovementioned issues, just like cisgender people can. They are not related conditions, and trying to claim they are, is frankly speaking insulting to everyone, including yourself (for framing yourself to appear completely ignorant of what the words you used, mean).
and demand that their bodies be altered
This has nothing to do with the target resolution, nor do all transgender people demand or even want that.
will force medical persons to perform a hormone therapy on patients
Again, target resolution doesn't force anyone to do anything, simply that the treatment is available and affordable. And as I already said, the hormones exist in self-administrable form in RL, so it's not that difficult to imagine they do so in imaginary worlds as well.
who have not made this choice of their own sanity
This, frankly speaking, just makes you look stupid. Do you know what
dissociation means? Your "facts" reek of it.
And the fact alone that they identify themselves as transgender people will be enough to tie the hands of both medical specialists and jurists because of this resolution, which so formulated, allows it.
...this literally makes no sense as a sentence. What are you trying to say?
This resolution does not take into account the various cultures, religions and scientific development of all the World Assembly member-nations. It demands that all nations recognize transgender people as sain or existing, which may contradict their official religion, to which
98% of the populace may belong.
Neither do any of the other human rights resolutions. Slavery is still banned even if your society had totally depended on it. Maltreatment of prisoners of war is still forbidden, even if your cultural practice had been to torture them. Human sacrifice is still banned, even if it had been the central tenet of your state religion.
Also, you have a random enter press there.
Furthermore enforcing the legislation of such a resolution can be seen as a threat to the national sovereignty
Duh. That's what WA does. Nobody's forcing the nations to remain in the WA.
This may result in protests and riots from citizens, who feel betrayed because the government they have democratically chosen, accepts laws controversial to the ideals it was chosen to represent and defend.
This has nothing to do with the target resolution, and what I said about human rights resolutions still applies. Tell me, how did your people cope with resolution CoCR?
The required laws cannot be enforced if the judiciary of a certain state deems them unconstitutional, thus making the legislation of this resolution both impractical and impossible without violating the law of a certain nation.
Again, duh, that's what WA does. If your national law conflicts with WA resolutions, your national law is ignored until you have changed it to agree with the resolutions. This is a fight you cannot win, because of how the WA works.
All in all your proposal can be broken down into Honest Mistake and NatSov, which both make it illegal.