Manticore Reborn wrote:Aabceef wrote:2. Establishes the following immunities for any sex worker participating in the trade legally as defined under their member nation's laws,
a) No sex workers shall be levied any unfairly targeted tax on their income solely because of their profession.
The representative from the Kingdom of Manticore Reborn objects to this section. This clause infringes upon our right to tax and raise revenue as our sovereign sees fit. Additionally, unlike spirituous beverages or other tangible substances there is no practical way to tax the service that is rendered; therefore an additional tax on the providers may be the best way for independent nations to regulate the trade.
OOC: I object to anything in the forum being listed as a "Final" draft. I don't think the draft should be considered final until it is actually in the proposal queue.
OCC: Fix'd
IC: The exact goal of this provision is to prevent nations from effecting a de facto ban on prostitution by exerting unfair or excessive taxes on the profession. This would force sex workers in a nation in which prostitution is de jure legal to move their services into the black market in which the trade would be unregulated and they would not benefit from the rights and protections of this resolution therefore defeating the purpose of this resolution entirely. The ambassador of Aabceef humbly queries the representative from the Kingdom of Manticore Reborn as to how specifically we can add provisions that address your concerns without creating a loophole that could be used to undermine the rights of sex workers?