[DRAFT] Ban on Judicial Murder

[Araraukar]

Besides, I won't kill you, I shall Judge you.

Good luck with that, my soul ain't bound to you.

OOC EDIT: And can we now stop the threadjack or whatever?

[Wallenburg]

OoC: My main account never posted in this thread.

OOC: My apologies, it's usually Wallenburg who makes those kinds of accounts.

Hey I'm not the only ass on this forum!

[Araraukar]

OOC: My apologies, it's usually Wallenburg who makes those kinds of accounts.

Hey I'm not the only ass on this forum!

OOC: Are you the new hammer one? I think you were one of the previous two. And a landmine. And I forget what all else.

[Kyoki Chudoku]

“No matter what supposed deities might say,” said Tokiko, glaring contemptuously at the so-called god, “I still believe that a total ban on execution is an idiotic decision, and furthermore, the fact that we have to contend with this being illegal due to duplication is an embarrassment to the World Assembly, as it implies that the previous resolution totally bans execution- I can assure you now that the Supreme Ultimate Country values its ability to permanently eliminate guilty traitors more than it values the absence of sanctions. Resolutions such as these greatly impede the ability to overcome chaos, and mitigate any efforts to combat crime by enforcing expensive, temporary solutions over practical and permanent ones.”

[Sapient Hammers United]

OOC: Are you the new hammer one? I think you were one of the previous two. And a landmine. And I forget what all else.

Hey now, we're a free-actor, independent-like, you see?

[Wallenburg]

Hey I'm not the only ass on this forum!

OOC: Are you the new hammer one? I think you were one of the previous two. And a landmine. And I forget what all else.

I can't claim Sapient Hammers, but I do own one of the 2 or 3 landmine puppets.

[The Galactic Liberal Democracy]

This entire proposal is a smear on a practice that can be legitimate.

[Araraukar]

OOC: Are you the new hammer one? I think you were one of the previous two. And a landmine. And I forget what all else.

I can't claim Sapient Hammers, but I do own one of the 2 or 3 landmine puppets.

OOC: I meant Cosmopolitan Hammers (spoiler in my siggy has quotes from that thread).

[Kenmoria]

OOC: I love how when I propose a wildly controversial resolution, y'all find this to be the most interesting aspect of it.

OOC: It's a fight over your current proposal's legality. If I'm right, your proposal's basic idea is legal - still a bad idea, IMO, but legal - and if they're right, it's illegal for duplication. If the rest of GenSec agrees with Wally and BA, then this is illegal, but the legality decision won't affect my RP anyway for the reasons I already explained. So... this will likely get ruled illegal, and whether you want to fight the decision, is up to you.

Edit because I can't type. Need to go eat something...

(OOC: I think it could be legal either way, independent of the months vs years debate. For the record, I agree with Wallenburg here, not that I think it matters. If you are right, and six months can be less than half a year, then executions may take place between the passage of twelve months and that of a year.

If Wally and BA are correct, then executions must be done on the exact day twelve months after sentencing, so that more than a year is not elapsed, but the serial six-month periods for evidence re-examination are correct. Either way, UM is still banning only a fraction of possible cases, so it could be that this is enough for Gensec to mark it illegal anyway.)

[Attempted Socialism]

OOC: I admit I haven't been following that closely, but I haven't seen that claim, no.

OOC: See posts by Wallenburg on this thread. Pages 1 and 2.

The effect is the same de facto, but not de jure.

And yet Wallenburg (and possibly BA) argue that this proposal is illegal for duplication.

With my rephrasing of your point in the other thread and now, I think I should get my eyesight checked. Or my memory.