[DRAFT]

[Bosnie]

--

[Grays Harbor]

This is not compulsory.

Optionality is not an option. WA resolutions either do or don’t. There is no maybe. This, as long as it is there, renders this illegal.

(Also, NS =/= Earth.)

[Kenmoria]

This is not compulsory.

Optionality is not an option. WA resolutions either do or don’t. There is no maybe. This, as long as it is there, renders this illegal.

(Also, NS =/= Earth.)

(OOC: I thought the optionality rule only applied if the whole proposal is optional; since the line you quote is a subclause or clause 5, it looks to me as though all of the other clauses are still mandatory.)

[East Meranopirus]

Regardless of what's optional or not, the topic has already been legislated on here. Before you submit a proposal always check this thread (use the search function for keywords that relate to your proposal).

[Grays Harbor]

Optionality is not an option. WA resolutions either do or don’t. There is no maybe. This, as long as it is there, renders this illegal.

(Also, NS =/= Earth.)

(OOC: I thought the optionality rule only applied if the whole proposal is optional; since the line you quote is a subclause or clause 5, it looks to me as though all of the other clauses are still mandatory.)

No, it can’t be both ways. That one clause makes all of them optional.

[Aclion]

(OOC: I thought the optionality rule only applied if the whole proposal is optional; since the line you quote is a subclause or clause 5, it looks to me as though all of the other clauses are still mandatory.)

No, it can’t be both ways. That one clause makes all of them optional.

Do you have any evidence that sub-clauses are interpreted that way?

[Araraukar]

2. All member states to impose an ecotax. (Tax specifications granted to the government's.)
a. An ecotax is a taxation imposed by government's on activities that harm the enviornment.

OOC: Contradicts NEF.

[Borovan entered the region as he]

Why do ppl even edit their proposals to nothing

[Kenmoria]

--

(OOC: Nuking the draft, by deleting all of it, is generally a bad idea. Although, since the idea has already been done before it doesn’t have much chance of passing, the draft can still be learned from for the future.)