[Draft] Repeal GA#453: Intersystem Space Stations Programme

[Veniyerris]

Seeing as the current GA proposal is a close vote which is currently leaning for, I have been working on a repeal for it. Feedback is appreciated

Repeal GA#453: Intersystem Space Stations Programme

The World Assembly,

Acknowledging that the intention to foster scientific advancement in space is laudable;

Believing that the target resolution to be poorly written, convoluted, and unclear in its intent;

Shocked that the target lacks defined goals, while requiring unlimited and ongoing funding, all for an undefined “scientific benefit”;

Noting the vague definition of distance in the proposal, especially in the context of nations with differing tech levels;

Concerned that the target does not take into account the desires of member nations when requiring support for the construction of space stations

Additionally concerned that the target requires nations to contribute to and fund the construction and planning of Space Stations without considering nations’ level of technical achievement or economic position;

Alarmed that the resolution would benefit nations with high levels of technological advancement, while taking precious funding away from nations with low levels of technological advancement;

Concluding that this resolution is aimed at discriminating against less wealthy and technologically advanced societies, an aim unbecoming of this esteemed Assembly;

Hereby repeals GA#453: Intersystem Space Stations Programme

[Bobberino]

Should this pass, I'm couping TNP just so I can approve this one.

[Kenmoria]

“I would add that member nations must fund space stations, through the WA general fund, even when they do not wish to explore the cosmos, possibly for religious or sociological reasons. I’m currently neutral on a repeal; although Kenmoria has a strong interest in exploring space through the WA Mission, a replacement could accomplish this far better.”

[Kranostav]

I have some potential edits coming, but full support. Hopefully this is a quick instarepeal.

[Veniyerris]

“I would add that member nations must fund space stations, through the WA general fund, even when they do not wish to explore the cosmos, possibly for religious or sociological reasons. I’m currently neutral on a repeal; although Kenmoria has a strong interest in exploring space through the WA Mission, a replacement could accomplish this far better.”

"The WA general fund assesses donations based on 'donors' national wealth and ability to give'. The target requires member nations to indefinitely fund space stations (even ones they cannot afford) regardless of the national wealth or ability to give of the member nation."

Should this pass, I'm couping TNP just so I can approve this one.

I have some potential edits coming, but full support. Hopefully this is a quick instarepeal.

Thank you for your support!

[Aenglaland]

Full support. It's disappointing to see #453 on the verge of being approved, so hopefully, and like Kranostav said, this is a quick instarepeal.

[Aclion]

Full support.

[Fecaw]

Support.

[Ivory Rhodes]

Seeing as the current GA proposal is a close vote which is currently leaning for, I have been working on a repeal for it. Feedback is appreciated

Concerned that the target does not take into account the desires of member nations when requiring support for the construction of space stations

Additionally concerned that the target requires nations to contribute to and fund the construction and planning of Space Stations without considering nations’ level of technical achievement or economic position;

Perhaps a mention that the author called this a "glaring error" in their own resolution?

[Nagatar Karumuttu Chettiar]

The resolution is going to fail, so there isn't anything to repeal, Joscopor changed his vote