Illegal GA Proposals 2nd edition

[Republic Of Ludwigsburg]

https://www.nationstates.net/page=UN_vi ... 1645945365

Repeal: “Access To Euthanasia Services”

A resolution to repeal previously passed legislation.

Category: Repeal

Resolution: GA#598

Proposed by: The Republic of Spacelandia

General Assembly Resolution #598 “Access To Euthanasia Services” (Category: Health; Area of Effect: Healthcare) shall be struck out and rendered null and void.

Humans do not have a right to decide when they die. God in Heaven rules that. He decides when people will be born, and when it is a person's time to die. If some of you who vote on this say you are a Christian and you vote against this Repeal, then you are not a true Christain.

NS not a blog, RL references

[Bears Armed]

26 minutes ago: Bears Armed: Illegal — RL Reference ("Neoliberalism"); Proposal Basics (Proposals must be written as the laws that they would become if passed, and from the viewpoint of the WA as a whole); Branding (in this case, use of the first person singular "I"); No Operative Clause.

I always just go for the first thing I see. Glad you point out all of it!

If we only tell the authors about one illegality then they might try fixing just that alone and re-submit it still with all of the other problems... potentially meaning more work, in the long term, for GenSec.
I've got a file collecting the answers that I use most frequently, to cut-&-paste from.

[Republic Of Ludwigsburg]

https://www.nationstates.net/page=UN_vi ... 1646272718
https://www.nationstates.net/page=UN_vi ... 1646272717

Ban revolvers

A resolution to slash worldwide military spending.

Category: Global Disarmament

Strength: Mild

Proposed by: Bing bongians

This is 2022 it won’t change a thing. So just approve .

Approvals: 0
GenSec Status: LEGAL
Info

Status: Lacking Support (requires 60 more approvals)

Voting Ends: in 2 days 18 hours

[Bears Armed]

Anti Killer Movement
A resolution to slash worldwide military spending.

Category: Global Disarmament
Strength: Significant
Proposed by: Estaind

Private industry rules the world, some governments do not see the consequences of ence or fighting, if the rights of your country are great congratulations! But here comes my proposal.

Civilians can punish criminals through death, sounds crazy? I know! But that way crime will cease to prosper - the crossfire has consequences. But still let criminals go free, allow this law if you want to balance peace and security.

Resources run out but in some cases the work, the will of others can save millions of lives

Please give permission to civilians to kill criminals and the world could be safer

Disculpen si me equivoque soy Méxicano pero hize mi esfuerzo por traducir esto a el idioma de la mayoría de jugadores de nationstates

Approvals: 0
Voting Ends: in 3 days 3 hours
Status: Lacking Support (requires 62 more approvals)

=>

GenSec Status: ILLEGAL — HELD
Illegal (1): Bears Armed
Seconds ago: Bears Armed: Illegal — Category incorrect; Proposal Basics(Proposals must be written as the laws that they would become if already passed, from the viewpoint of the W.A. as a whole, and entirely in English); Branding (in this case, use of the first person singular "my"); RL Reference ("Mexicano"); Contradiction of existing G.A. legislation.

[Outer Sparta]

https://www.nationstates.net/page=UN_vi ... 1651217015

Repeal: “Read The Resolution Act”
A resolution to repeal previously passed legislation.

Category: Repeal

Resolution: GA#122

Proposed by: Banana rule

General Assembly Resolution #122 “Read the Resolution Act” (Category: Furtherment of Democracy; Strength: Mild) shall be struck out and rendered null and void.

REALISING that nations may use misleading language in their resolutions the justify their wrong choices. and also, i forgot how to write anything other than a repeal and on that note, THANKING early nations for coming up with great resolutions as i scrolled through 121 resolutions before this looking for something worthy of a repeal, by only using the title and it would all be pointless. and many bad nations may be wanting to destroy our great website with silly rules under bad reasons. ADDING another sentence so people don’t complain about too much of this resolution being me, sad because because i wasted my time.

Branding, repeal basics, referring to NS as a website

[Juansonia]

https://www.nationstates.net/page=UN_view_proposal/id=dead_warrior_daddy_1651405986

Dissolve The WA
A resolution to improve worldwide human and civil rights.

Category: Civil Rights

Strength: Strong

Proposed by: Dead Warrior Daddy

Understand that the WA is toxic and destroys many nations individuality
Know that a world without the WA can be safer and better
Realize how good it is to take power out of the proposal inspectors and make them one of us
Here by propose to resolve the WA in its complete entirety

Contradicts existing legislation (GAR 001), branding ("make them one of us") incorrect strength ("Proposes to ... " is not strong), fails to do targeted action (dissolve ... resolve), several grammar errors.

edit: How does it have 10 approvals already?

[Imperium Anglorum]

https://www.nationstates.net/page=UN_view_proposal/id=dead_warrior_daddy_1651405986

Dissolve The WA
A resolution to improve worldwide human and civil rights.

Category: Civil Rights

Strength: Strong

Proposed by: Dead Warrior Daddy

Understand that the WA is toxic and destroys many nations individuality
Know that a world without the WA can be safer and better
Realize how good it is to take power out of the proposal inspectors and make them one of us
Here by propose to resolve the WA in its complete entirety

Contradicts existing legislation (GAR 001)

edit: How does it have 10 approvals already?

The issue isn't that it contradicts GA 1, it's that it can't be effected via the game code. Passage would not in fact dissolve the GA. It's a game mechanics violation.

[Juansonia]

General Assembly Proposal
ID: danielanza_1651842922

Make Education Compulsory Up 24 Age
A resolution to promote funding and the development of education and the arts.

Category: Education and Creativity

Area of Effect: Educational

Proposed by: Danielanza

It is well known that the University, considering both the bachelor's and master's degrees, leads students to devote themselves to training (understood as the phase preceding access to the world of work) until they reach the age of 24. The proposal of my country (or mine) is to extend the obligation of education and training up to the age of 24. Although it is already in force in my country, I would like this obligation to be extended to the other countries of the World Assembly as well.
The reason is very simple: a student who has a broad and multidisciplinary education (up to high school), makes our citizens of the future more aware and with greater attention to the world of culture.
Thanks for the attention

Danielanza (President Daniele Romano).

Branding, not from WA perspective, no binding clause

[Bears Armed]

General Assembly Proposal
ID: danielanza_1651842922

Make Education Compulsory Up 24 Age
A resolution to promote funding and the development of education and the arts.

Category: Education and Creativity

Area of Effect: Educational

Proposed by: Danielanza

It is well known that the University, considering both the bachelor's and master's degrees, leads students to devote themselves to training (understood as the phase preceding access to the world of work) until they reach the age of 24. The proposal of my country (or mine) is to extend the obligation of education and training up to the age of 24. Although it is already in force in my country, I would like this obligation to be extended to the other countries of the World Assembly as well.
The reason is very simple: a student who has a broad and multidisciplinary education (up to high school), makes our citizens of the future more aware and with greater attention to the world of culture.
Thanks for the attention

Danielanza (President Daniele Romano).

Branding, not from WA perspective, no binding clause

All of those, yes, and also 'Contradiction of existing G.A. legislation' (because GA Resolution #299 'Legal Competence' includes a clause that blocks the G.A. from setting any one-size-fits-all age thresholds) as well.

[Attempted Socialism]

General Assembly Proposal
ID: danielanza_1651842922

Make Education Compulsory Up 24 Age
A resolution to promote funding and the development of education and the arts.

Category: Education and Creativity

Area of Effect: Educational

Proposed by: Danielanza

It is well known that the University, considering both the bachelor's and master's degrees, leads students to devote themselves to training (understood as the phase preceding access to the world of work) until they reach the age of 24. The proposal of my country (or mine) is to extend the obligation of education and training up to the age of 24. Although it is already in force in my country, I would like this obligation to be extended to the other countries of the World Assembly as well.
The reason is very simple: a student who has a broad and multidisciplinary education (up to high school), makes our citizens of the future more aware and with greater attention to the world of culture.
Thanks for the attention

Danielanza (President Daniele Romano).

Branding, not from WA perspective, no binding clause

All of those, yes, and also 'Contradiction of existing G.A. legislation' (because GA Resolution #299 'Legal Competence' includes a clause that blocks the G.A. from setting any one-size-fits-all age thresholds) as well.

It's back in the same form:

https://www.nationstates.net/page=UN_view_proposal/id=danielanza_1651922430
General Assembly Proposal
ID: danielanza_1651922430
Make education compulsory up 24 age

A resolution to promote funding and the development of education and the arts.

Category: Education and Creativity

Area of Effect: Educational

Proposed by: Danielanza

It is known that the University, considering both the bachelor's and master's degrees, leads students to devote themselves to training (understood as the phase that precedes access to the world of work) until they reach the age of 24. The proposal from my country (or mine) is that we have a civic duty to extend the obligation of education and training up to the age of 24. Although it is already in force in my country, I would like this obligation to be extended to the other countries of the World Assembly as well.
The reason is very simple: a student who has a broad and multidisciplinary education (up to high school), makes our citizens of the future more aware and with greater attention to the world of culture. Thanks for the attention

Danielanza (President Daniele Romano).

[Juansonia]

General Assembly Proposal
ID: dead_warrior_daddy_1651959736

Kill All Speds
A resolution to improve worldwide human and civil rights.

Category: Civil Rights

Strength: Strong

Proposed by: Dead Warrior Daddy

The speds is very mean and gives me bad news

They so dumb

No friends

no active clause, not WA perspective, likely contradicts previous legislation (if speds means what Urban Dictionary says it means, the proposal probably contradicts something about genocide)

[Bears Armed]

General Assembly Proposal
ID: dead_warrior_daddy_1651959736

Kill All Speds
A resolution to improve worldwide human and civil rights.

Category: Civil Rights

Strength: Strong

Proposed by: Dead Warrior Daddy

The speds is very mean and gives me bad news

They so dumb

No friends

no active clause, not WA perspective, likely contradicts previous legislation (if speds means what Urban Dictionary says it means, the proposal probably contradicts something about genocide)

It was already Mod-deleted before I got there.

[Juansonia]

ID: harveykingdoms_1652457557
Decentralized Autonomous Government Act
A resolution to increase democratic freedoms.

Category: Furtherment of Democracy

Strength: Strong

Proposed by: HarveyKingdoms

Whereas, there is no real democracy in the world!

Regardless of dictatorship theocracy or democratically elected political parties, all countries are monopolized by a small group of people who cannot bear the losses of the whole country.

Also, the fewer the number of people involved in decision-making, the easier for them to join forces to commit corruption and electoral fraud.
Also, all wars are initiated by a small group of dictators who manipulate countries!

As the main contributor, the grassroots people not only have no right to make decisions, but also take responsibility and suffer for wrong policy which general by dictator, also exploited by the elite related with the dictator, so reform of constitution is necessary as below policies:-

A. Politically Policy:
1. In order to ensure efficiency, prevent fraud, and avoid the never-ending struggle for power, stop the system of authorize parliament to make decision for the peoples (prone to corruption), lets return the final decision-making power of major affairs, laws and personnel appointments to the entire people (*peoples make decision together for their own city and country through a one-person, one-vote referendum, every city also highly autonomous)…
…using an open-source blockchain mobile voting application (*a public media and news platform mixed with the functions of toutiao, FB, Twitter and nationstates.net, together with voting analysis classify by different nationalities, genders, occupations, religious and ages)…
…exams can be attached to make sure that voters carefully analyze the motion…
…users who do not have time to vote can set delegated votes (*same as authorize parliament to make decision for them).
2. Everyone has the right to propose proposals, run for elections and organize executive committees.
3. Member of Parliament, experts and government officials are responsible for optimizing of various proposals and analyze the pros and cons of them for the people to make the final decision.
4. The head of state and parliament are responsible for monitoring implementation.
5. Members of Parliament, government officials, the military and the police swear to the death allegiance to the entire people and are responsible for protecting everyone's human rights, freedom of speech and democracy.

B. National property rights corporatization:
The state has been changed to a joint-stock company, everyone holds state shares, and jointly owns permanent land property rights (value-added tax), charitable funds and public properties across the country, sharing operating benefits, and sharing decision-making responsibilities... The bundling of interests prompts everyone to vote earnestly to help increase income and reduce expenditure.

C. Economically Policy:
The central bank prints money to subscribe for the “National Venture Capital Fund” zero-coupon bonds that everyone owns. → Supports grassroots collective entrepreneurship, scientific research, infrastructure, environmental protection and AI automatic production lines, and the whole people share production materials and passive income → Constantly generate new Enterprises support the value of currency, promote economic growth, generate profits and taxes, and avoid chaebol monopoly on the political economy.

Propose the about policy to your government now, whoever implements the above plan first will become a global democratic leader who will last forever!

As long as all countries can implement the above policies, there will be no more wars between countries (because it is the people who really go to the battlefield to die, and it is the people who will always suffer in any war, not the dictator)

Come to visit our Region for detail information.

Branding (come to visit our region), not WA perspective, RL references(toutiao, FB, Twitter and nationstates.net), no binding clause, probably contradicts previous legislation

Edit: this is a near-duplicate of a resolution marked illegal.

[Bears Armed]

ID: harveykingdoms_1652457557
Decentralized Autonomous Government Act
A resolution to increase democratic freedoms.

Category: Furtherment of Democracy

Strength: Strong

Proposed by: HarveyKingdoms

Whereas, there is no real democracy in the world!

Regardless of dictatorship theocracy or democratically elected political parties, all countries are monopolized by a small group of people who cannot bear the losses of the whole country.

Also, the fewer the number of people involved in decision-making, the easier for them to join forces to commit corruption and electoral fraud.
Also, all wars are initiated by a small group of dictators who manipulate countries!

As the main contributor, the grassroots people not only have no right to make decisions, but also take responsibility and suffer for wrong policy which general by dictator, also exploited by the elite related with the dictator, so reform of constitution is necessary as below policies:-

A. Politically Policy:
1. In order to ensure efficiency, prevent fraud, and avoid the never-ending struggle for power, stop the system of authorize parliament to make decision for the peoples (prone to corruption), lets return the final decision-making power of major affairs, laws and personnel appointments to the entire people (*peoples make decision together for their own city and country through a one-person, one-vote referendum, every city also highly autonomous)…
…using an open-source blockchain mobile voting application (*a public media and news platform mixed with the functions of toutiao, FB, Twitter and nationstates.net, together with voting analysis classify by different nationalities, genders, occupations, religious and ages)…
…exams can be attached to make sure that voters carefully analyze the motion…
…users who do not have time to vote can set delegated votes (*same as authorize parliament to make decision for them).
2. Everyone has the right to propose proposals, run for elections and organize executive committees.
3. Member of Parliament, experts and government officials are responsible for optimizing of various proposals and analyze the pros and cons of them for the people to make the final decision.
4. The head of state and parliament are responsible for monitoring implementation.
5. Members of Parliament, government officials, the military and the police swear to the death allegiance to the entire people and are responsible for protecting everyone's human rights, freedom of speech and democracy.

B. National property rights corporatization:
The state has been changed to a joint-stock company, everyone holds state shares, and jointly owns permanent land property rights (value-added tax), charitable funds and public properties across the country, sharing operating benefits, and sharing decision-making responsibilities... The bundling of interests prompts everyone to vote earnestly to help increase income and reduce expenditure.

C. Economically Policy:
The central bank prints money to subscribe for the “National Venture Capital Fund” zero-coupon bonds that everyone owns. → Supports grassroots collective entrepreneurship, scientific research, infrastructure, environmental protection and AI automatic production lines, and the whole people share production materials and passive income → Constantly generate new Enterprises support the value of currency, promote economic growth, generate profits and taxes, and avoid chaebol monopoly on the political economy.

Propose the about policy to your government now, whoever implements the above plan first will become a global democratic leader who will last forever!

As long as all countries can implement the above policies, there will be no more wars between countries (because it is the people who really go to the battlefield to die, and it is the people who will always suffer in any war, not the dictator)

Come to visit our Region for detail information.

Branding (come to visit our region), not WA perspective, RL references(toutiao, FB, Twitter and nationstates.net), no binding clause, probably contradicts previous legislation

Edit: this is a near-duplicate of a resolution marked illegal.

I'm not sure about the Contradiction off-forepaw (as I found so many other problems so easily that I didn't bother to analyse it in detail for that as well), but certainly all of the others that you list... Also "Not written as the law that it would become if passed", Ideological Ban (as we haven't abolished [i]that[i] rule yet), and Meta-gaming (the mention of nationstates.net, and use of the word "region" in what was clearly the game's sense).

[Juansonia]

snip.

I'm not sure about the Contradiction off-forepaw (as I found so many other problems so easily that I didn't bother to analyse it in detail for that as well), but certainly all of the others that you list... Also "Not written as the law that it would become if passed", Ideological Ban (as we haven't abolished [i]that[i] rule yet), and Meta-gaming (the mention of nationstates.net, and use of the word "region" in what was clearly the game's sense).

Yet another version: This time, mention of regions was removed in exchange for a "Don't mark this illegal" plea.

General Assembly Proposal
ID: harveykingdoms_1652500767

Decentralized Autonomous Government Act
A resolution to improve worldwide human and civil rights.

Category: Civil Rights

Strength: Strong

Proposed by: HarveyKingdoms

Whereas, there is no real democracy in the world!

Regardless of dictatorship theocracy or democratically elected political parties, all countries are monopolized by a small group of people who cannot bear the losses of the whole country.
Also, the fewer the number of people involved in decision-making, the easier for them to join forces to commit corruption and electoral fraud.
Also, all wars are initiated by a small group of dictators who manipulate countries!

As the main contributor, the grassroots people not only have no right to make decisions, but also take responsibility and suffer for wrong policy which general by dictator, also exploited by the elite related with the dictator, so reform of constitution is necessary as below policies:-

A. Politically Policy:
1. In order to ensure efficiency, prevent fraud, and avoid the never-ending struggle for power, stop the system of authorize parliament to make decision for the peoples (prone to corruption), lets return the final decision-making power of major affairs, laws and personnel appointments to the entire people (*peoples make decision together for their own city and country through a one-person, one-vote referendum, every city also highly autonomous)…
…using an open-source blockchain mobile voting application (*a public media and news platform mixed with the functions of toutiao, FB, Twitter and nationstates.net, together with voting analysis classify by different nationalities, genders, occupations, religious and ages)…
…exams can be attached to make sure that voters carefully analyze the motion…
…users who do not have time to vote can set delegated votes (*same as authorize parliament to make decision for them).
2. Everyone has the right to propose proposals, run for elections and organize executive committees.
3. Member of Parliament, experts and government officials are responsible for optimizing of various proposals and analyze the pros and cons of them for the people to make the final decision.
4. The head of state and parliament are responsible for monitoring implementation.
5. Members of Parliament, government officials, the military and the police swear to the death allegiance to the entire people and are responsible for protecting everyone's human rights, freedom of speech and democracy.

B. National property rights corporatization:
The state has been changed to a joint-stock company, everyone holds state shares, and jointly owns permanent land property rights (value-added tax), charitable funds and public properties across the country, sharing operating benefits, and sharing decision-making responsibilities... The bundling of interests prompts everyone to vote earnestly to help increase income and reduce expenditure.

C. Economically Policy:
The central bank prints money to subscribe for the “National Venture Capital Fund” zero-coupon bonds that everyone owns. → Supports grassroots collective entrepreneurship, scientific research, infrastructure, environmental protection and AI automatic production lines, and the whole people share production materials and passive income → Constantly generate new Enterprises support the value of currency, promote economic growth, generate profits and taxes, and avoid chaebol monopoly on the political economy.

Propose the about policy to your government now, whoever implements the above plan first will become a global democratic leader who will last forever!

As long as all countries can implement the above policies, there will be no more wars between countries (because it is the people who really go to the battlefield to die, and it is the people who will always suffer in any war, not the dictator)

Pls let my proposal go, dont put it to illegal! DONT DELETE IT! Pls promote this proposal to your government, it can help improve civil right and stop the war that come from dictators forever!!

[Bears Armed]

Yet another version: This time, mention of regions was removed in exchange for a "Don't mark this illegal" plea.

I've seen it.

Illegal (1): Bears Armed

38 minutes ago: Bears Armed: Illegal — SAME AS THE LAST TWO TIMES, BASICALLY.

[Juansonia]

ID: harveykingdoms_1652801517

Intelligent Education Reform
A resolution to promote funding and the development of education and the arts.

Category: Education and Creativity

Area of Effect: Educational

Proposed by: HarveyKingdoms

To increase efficiency and save expenses, reduce the chance of child and elder abuse, reduce the chance of corrupted on Education, Childcare and Elderly Services, the following reforms are advocated.

Part One
Decentralized Autonomous Management System:
All Parents, students, teachers and volunteers are invited to participate in voting to jointly decide school rules and various major decisions and then organize students to implement school management under the guidance of teachers and volunteers.

System management: anyone can provide proposal, discuss and vote through the open source blockchain mobile application, all proposal will randomly invite 99 current online users to participate in the evaluation through voting (prevent a decision-making committee composed of a small group of people from monopolizing decision-making power) , anyone can provide suggestion to improve it.

Benefits:
1. Save the cost of salary of management team,
2. Reduce opportunities for officials to shield each other from common corruption and child abuse.
3. Enhance students' independent thinking, awareness of the rule of law, teamwork and management skills.

Part Two
1. Setup the Mutual Aid Base for the Elderly and Children that integrates nurseries, boarding schools, nursing homes, shelters for the disabled, apprenticeship hospitals and modern agricultural bases, facilitate the integration of resources to save the land and expenses.

2. Setup the Social Contribution Points System to encourage all recipients (include their family member and Volunteer) to look after each other, caring for young children, farming (adopting AI in Organic Farming to Improve Food Security and efficiency) and maintain the public area, all recipients will be allocated different levels of housing, food and medical services according to their social contribution points, senior class students are responsible for guiding junior class students.

3. Compulsory military training since kindergarten, cultivate students' ability to survive in the wild, self-care ability, medical work and strong perseverance.
[i]Let students get used to high-intensity exercise and a balanced diet since childhood, and strengthen the labor ability, mental strength, body resistance and healthy vitality of all people. Reduce medical expenses and various social crises.

4. Co-organize apprenticeship courses with corporations and charity hospitals to cultivate students' diverse skills from primary school, including 3D graphic and programming for the construction of metaverse.

5. Attract children to self-study through gamified intelligent metaverse apps to complete college courses, introduce training courses on memory improvement, psychology, financial ability, interpersonal communication and sexual skills to enhance everyone's affinity, expression ability, learning ability and influence, more adaptable to future social needs.

Benefits:
1. All parents will no longer need to place time and money (supported by Mutual Fund) in caring for children and the elderly, which will help improve the overall productivity, sense of security and happiness index for all.
2. Let group of elderly live with children of different ages, let them feel younger, no longer lonely, have more people to take care of each other and reduce the chance of them being bullied by the staff and domestic violence.
3. Encourage Child and Elderly take care each others, can save >80% salary expenses, cultivate the good habit of students of helping others from an early age, let all recipient have a sustenance in their lives.

Part Three
All People's Mutual Fund
Setup the Education, Venture Capital and Pension Mutual Fund that owned and managed by all people.

Details:
1. All shareholders make decision together, apply seed capital for projects and provide idea via the Decentralized Autonomous Management System.

2. Central bank will buy the 100 years zero rate bonds that issued by the fund, and will serve as the basis for money printing, all people share the loss caused by inflation as their investment.
[i]The Fund will invest on the Research and Entrepreneurship Projects, support currency value and reduce inflation by supporting the real economy and artificial intelligence automated production lines to increase production capacity and push GDP.

3. The fund will invest on "Mutual Aid Base for the Elderly and Children", all sponsored students are responsible for repaying the principal in installments within 30 years, and 5% of their lifetime income and assets will be used as investment dividends to the fund.

Benefits:
1. Everyone is also more focused on help to nurturing talent, sponsoring children and supporting entrepreneurs because they have a share of dividends.
2. The educational curriculum is decided by all the people to prevent the dictator's brainwashing education.

Not written as legislation, no active clause, might violate ideological ban, possibly conflicts with existing legislation on education, compulsory military training could be construed as violating GAR:002. (Would blockchain and metaverse be RL references?)

[Juansonia]

ID: krisward_1652905597

Proposal To Implement New Leadership In A Region
A resolution to increase democratic freedoms.

Category: Furtherment of Democracy

Strength: Mild

Proposed by: KrisWard

Dear General Assembly,

I feel NOW is the time to act on a pressing matter currently affecting 1 Region, but if left unchecked this corruption, political brutality cound spread across our World and affect all of us. Members of the General Assembly I ask you to vote for this proposal to put pressure of The Democratic Republic of Crimsoland to sign over Emergency Powers to The Republic of KrisWard to set the Region of Massachusettss on a Democracitic form of Governing. The Democratic Republic of Crimsoland has not appointed a Delegate to the World Assembly, has not formed Embassy’s with other Regions forcing Members of the Region to have no Diplomatic Ties, and has made the Regions banner read, Quote “Gamer Gamer gamer”. These issues are tragedies that should be resolved. Many Nations May question why The Republic of KrisWard chooses to remain and the answer is that this Nation has set out to improve the world doing anything possible. Esteemed Members of the General Assembly The Republic of KrisWard pledges that with support that The Republic of KrisWard can make the World a greater place, 1 region at a time

Sincerely,
The Republic of KrisWard State Governor of Massachusettss.

Proposals cannot target individual region, Not written as legislation, branding, even the security council can't do what he's asking for.

[Bears Armed]

ID: krisward_1652905597

Proposal To Implement New Leadership In A Region
A resolution to increase democratic freedoms.

Category: Furtherment of Democracy

Strength: Mild

Proposed by: KrisWard

Dear General Assembly,

I feel NOW is the time to act on a pressing matter currently affecting 1 Region, but if left unchecked this corruption, political brutality cound spread across our World and affect all of us. Members of the General Assembly I ask you to vote for this proposal to put pressure of The Democratic Republic of Crimsoland to sign over Emergency Powers to The Republic of KrisWard to set the Region of Massachusettss on a Democracitic form of Governing. The Democratic Republic of Crimsoland has not appointed a Delegate to the World Assembly, has not formed Embassy’s with other Regions forcing Members of the Region to have no Diplomatic Ties, and has made the Regions banner read, Quote “Gamer Gamer gamer”. These issues are tragedies that should be resolved. Many Nations May question why The Republic of KrisWard chooses to remain and the answer is that this Nation has set out to improve the world doing anything possible. Esteemed Members of the General Assembly The Republic of KrisWard pledges that with support that The Republic of KrisWard can make the World a greater place, 1 region at a time

Sincerely,
The Republic of KrisWard State Governor of Massachusettss.

Proposals cannot target individual region, Not written as legislation, branding, even the security council can't do what he's asking for.

Already got it, but thank you posting it here. My ruling was:

Illegal — Proposal Basics (Proposals must be written as the laws that they would become if passed, must be written from the viewpoint of the WA as a whole, and must apply -- at least in theory -- to all of the W.A.'s member nations); Category incorrect (There is NO correct Category for this); Branding (multiple cases); Meta-gaming (use of the terms "Region[s]" & "banner" in what are clearly the game's OOC context).

[Juansonia]

General Assembly Proposal
ID: crimsoland_1652973563

The Problem On Our Hands
A resolution to restrict civil freedoms in the interest of moral decency.

Category: Moral Decency

Strength: Strong

Proposed by: Crimsoland

Dear Members of the General Assembly,

We have a large problem on our hands. The world is being taken over, slowly but surely, by an evil enemy. This enemy goes by the name of "The Republic of KrisWard". They have submitted a joke proposal to this council, as well as tried to get many innocent members of the community punished and banned. I believe that something must be put in place. I think that this member should immediately be permanently banned from the game, and have it made impossible to make a new account. We must joust them from their position! Stand with democracy!

Not from WA perspective, not written as legislation, GA resolutions cannot target individual nation, Meta-gaming(calls NS a game), World assembly cannot ban nations from existing, no active clause.

edit: it's already discarded. Thanks

[Umbratellus]

https://www.nationstates.net/page=UN_view_proposal/id=arkkine_1653157757
The World Assembly,

Taxes have been too high for too many nations, there have been few to none issues to be able to fix the problem as well. We need reform in the taxation parts of NS. Either to create more taxation issues allowing nations to lower their taxes if they want, or to lower all government funding around the NS world. NS has suffered from the taxation problem for way to long, it has screwed up our nations look, caused unwanted oppressive government looks, and has ruined our currency worth in NS. I say we increase taxation issues and give nations the chance to fix their taxation issue. Because every issue I happen to do it always increases my taxes which has been slowly suffocating my nation and many other nations.

Branding, metagaming, not written as a proposal.

[Bears Armed]

https://www.nationstates.net/page=UN_view_proposal/id=arkkine_1653157757
The World Assembly,

Taxes have been too high for too many nations, there have been few to none issues to be able to fix the problem as well. We need reform in the taxation parts of NS. Either to create more taxation issues allowing nations to lower their taxes if they want, or to lower all government funding around the NS world. NS has suffered from the taxation problem for way to long, it has screwed up our nations look, caused unwanted oppressive government looks, and has ruined our currency worth in NS. I say we increase taxation issues and give nations the chance to fix their taxation issue. Because every issue I happen to do it always increases my taxes which has been slowly suffocating my nation and many other nations.

Branding, metagaming, not written as a proposal.

Right. I hit it on the way here.

[Juansonia]

General Assembly Proposal
ID: kalebop_1653317081

All Men And Women Of Every Race Are Created Equal
A resolution to improve worldwide human and civil rights.

Category: Civil Rights

Strength: Significant

Proposed by: Kalebop

All Men And Women Of Every Race Are Created Equal. So they should all have equal rights. From now on all people in your country have equal rights, and racism is now illegal.

duplicates/contradicts existing legislation, not written as law

[Umbratellus]

https://www.nationstates.net/page=UN_view_proposal/id=antarctic_empire2_1653328791
People in Ellbella have been reported to be overall oppressed and due to her decisions she needs to be checked and overturned in favor of this nations prosperous continuation in this world.

Seems like a matter for the security council, so wrong category, not written as a law.

https://www.nationstates.net/page=UN_view_proposal/id=murderisfun_1653331226
These kids keep trying to do Tiktok stunts, an example is the spinning water bottle challenge which could be really dangerous because if its spinning fast enough you could fall from impact or damage your brain or something so we should ban These dangerous Tiktok Stunts.

RL references, not written as a law.

[Bears Armed]

General Assembly Proposal
ID: kalebop_1653317081

All Men And Women Of Every Race Are Created Equal
A resolution to improve worldwide human and civil rights.

Category: Civil Rights

Strength: Significant

Proposed by: Kalebop

All Men And Women Of Every Race Are Created Equal. So they should all have equal rights. From now on all people in your country have equal rights, and racism is now illegal.

duplicates/contradicts existing legislation, not written as law

I just said Duplication for this one: It might not be in the usual format for a "law", but its illegality on Agrethat point is arguably borderline.

https://www.nationstates.net/page=UN_view_proposal/id=antarctic_empire2_1653328791
People in Ellbella have been reported to be overall oppressed and due to her decisions she needs to be checked and overturned in favor of this nations prosperous continuation in this world.

Seems like a matter for the security council, so wrong category, not written as a law.

https://www.nationstates.net/page=UN_view_proposal/id=murderisfun_1653331226
These kids keep trying to do Tiktok stunts, an example is the spinning water bottle challenge which could be really dangerous because if its spinning fast enough you could fall from impact or damage your brain or something so we should ban These dangerous Tiktok Stunts.

RL references, not written as a law.

Agreed on both of them...
And for the first one, also Proposal Basics (Proposals must, at least in theory, affect ALL of the W.A.'s member nations) & Branding (in this case, use of a nation's name in the title & text);
And for the 'Tiktok' one, also No Operative Clause (because "should" actually doesn't DO anything).